Explanation: Just as there are reasons for the revelation of some chapters and verses of the Quran so too are there reasons for the utterance of some hadiths of the Messenger of Allah (pbuh).
It is possible to understand the reason why this hadith, which we are trying to explain, was uttered from the following narration of Abu Hurairah:
The Messenger of Allah addressed us and said,
- “O Muslims! Hajj has been rendered for you; so, perform hajj”. A man asked:
- O Messenger of Allah! Every year?
The Messenger of Allah did not answer and kept silent. The man repeated his question three times. Thereupon, the Prophet said:
“If I had said ‘yes’, it would definitely have been fard for you; you would naturally not be able to perform hajj every year” (Muslim, Hajj 412). Then, he uttered the hadith in question.
The Companion that asked the Prophet the question above was Aqra’ Ibn Habis. Since he knew that prayers, zakah and fasting were performed repeatedly, he asked that question by comparing hajj (pilgrimage) to them. He could not imagine the difficulty or even the impossibility of performing this worship by the Muslims every year. The Prophet did not answer his question first because keeping silent is an answer to an ignorant person. It is stated that the useful and good question is half of knowledge.
The Prophet did not keep silent about an issue that needed to be explained to the ummah and that people needed. If the question that was asked had been caused by such a need, he would definitely have answered it very clearly. However, we see that the Prophet did not regard Aqra’s question like that; on the contrary, he did not answer Aqra’s question even though he asked it again and again. However, when he saw that his silence was not regarded as an answer, he answered that question clearly too. It is understood from the way of answering the question by the Messenger of Allah that he did not welcome the person asking the question. For, Aqra Ibn Habis may have asked that question before the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) completed his statement and made the relevant explanations. As a matter of fact, Allah informed the believers about the good manners regarding the issue as follows:
“O Ye who believe! Put not yourselves forward before Allah and His Messenger” [al-Hujurat (49), 1].
The Prophet advised the Companions to be content with what he declared about the issues determined through revelation like especially belief, fard deeds of worship, and halal and haram, not to scrutinize them, and to refrain from asking too many and unnecessary questions. Therefore, he said: “Leave me as I leave you related to the issues of your understanding.” He explained why it should be done like that by showing the destruction of the past ummahs, Jews and Christians as an example because they asked their prophets many and unnecessary questions. In addition, instead of accepting the answer given by their prophet, they would quarrel and disagree about it. This characteristic of theirs, that is, asking many and unnecessary questions, caused their destruction because of quarreling about the answers and falling into disagreement. For, conflict brings about divisions and groupings. Consequently, the unity and solidarity of society will disappear. Nations and ummahs that cannot ensure unity and solidarity within their own bodies will be destroyed. All this shows that it is forbidden to ask questions without necessity and to disagree on matters whose decrees are specified by Allah and His Messenger. For, if the end of something is destruction, it is obvious that it is haram or a major sin. In particular, conflicts cause hearts to split and the religion to weaken. Just as they are haram so too are the reasons that lead to them are haram.
It is necessary to avoid and keep away from the things that the religion prohibits. There is no tolerance in this regard. Excuses such as “I cannot do” or “I cannot quit because I am used to it” are not valid. Obligatory situations called darurah (absolute necessity) are always regarded as exception. That is an issue that varies according to time, place and individuals, and requires extensive explanations. The piety and taqwa of a person are evaluated by the prohibitions he keeps away from rather than his worship. For, keeping away from prohibitions cannot be something related to hypocrisy, show off and pleasing others. As for deeds of worship, they can exist in them to a certain extent.
Prohibitions need absolute avoidance but the commands of the religion need to be fulfilled by everyone as much as they can because there are various conditions and reasons of doing something. Those conditions and reasons may not exist at the same degree in everybody or may not exist at all. Therefore, everybody is held responsible to the extent that they can afford because Allah does not place a burden on anyone greater than they can bear [al-Baqara (2), 286]. Some people can do a certain deed while others cannot. Responsibility is based on the power of people. God Almighty states the following in the Quran: “So fear Allah as much as ye can; listen and obey and spend in charity for the benefit of your own soul and those saved from the covetousness of their own souls,- they are the ones that achieve prosperity” [at-Taghabun (64), 16].
Everyone has the same responsibility related to performing fard deeds of worship. As it was mentioned before, supererogatory prayers are limited to the power of each individual and they are optional. This rule is valid not only in deeds of worship but also in all commands of the religion.