CronTrigger misfire instruction DoNothing not working

[Krzysztof Zegzuła]

Hello everyone
I encountered a problem with MisfireInstruction.CronTrigger.DoNothing (basicaly it is not working). My scenario:

I run my app at 10:00 pm, so my scheduler (and a listener) is initialized:

ISchedulerFactory schedFact = new StdSchedulerFactory();

sched = schedFact.GetScheduler();

listener = new MyListener(); 
sched.ListenerManager.AddSchedulerListener(listener);

Then I schedule some jobs using this code:

IJobDetail job = JobBuilder.Create<SwitchJob>()
   .WithIdentity(jobName, "jobGroup")
   .Build();

ITrigger trigger = TriggerBuilder.Create()
   .WithIdentity(triggerName, "jobGroup")
   .WithCronSchedule(cronPhrase, x => x
       .WithMisfireHandlingInstructionDoNothing())
   .UsingJobData("sourceId", sourceId)
   .UsingJobData("transitionType", transitionType)
   .ForJob(jobName, "jobGroup")
   .Build();

sched.ScheduleJob(job, trigger);

Some of the cronPhrases will say to execute for example everyday at 10:10 pm (so first execution would happen short time after being scheduled). 

Then at 10:20 pm I call

sched.Start();

And all misfired jobs that were scheduled and had their first execution time when Scheduler was in stand by, are triggered immediately even though they had the misfire policy set to MisfireInstruction.CronTrigger.DoNothing. According to the documentation they should not be fired untill the next time for example the next day 10:10 pm if the Scheduler was still on.

I researched on this topic and found peoples concerns about this unwanted behaviour even with the java implementation:

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/32075128/avoiding-misfires-with-quartz

http://stackoverflow.com/questions/30298977/quartz-crontrigger-ignores-misfire-policies-and-reschedules-every-misfire

[David Gràcia i Llobet]

Hi,

We are having the same issue, it has the same behaviour as the MisfireInstructions.CronTrigger.IgnoreMisfirePolicy...

We haven't been able to successfully do this with a SimpleSchedule either...

El dimarts, 15 setembre de 2015 18:09:57 UTC+2, Krzysztof Zegzuła va escriure: