Public Scientific Reviews

Contact owners and managers

1–30 of 89

This group includes scientific reviews that are shared publicly with the reviewers name un-blinded. The reviewer posting to this group is therefore responsible for the review - unlike a blind reviewer who is unaccountable to some degree. The reviewed material comes from multiple sources - some pre-publication, and some post publication. Feel free to join the public non-blind review process.

0 selected

10/2/23

Simulation 2023: Enabling massively parallel, ad-hoc exploration of the design space for simulation models.- Reviewer Jacob Barhak

A second review round results in the following: Title: Enabling massively parallel, ad-hoc

unread,

Simulation 2023: Enabling massively parallel, ad-hoc exploration of the design space for simulation models.- Reviewer Jacob Barhak

A second review round results in the following: Title: Enabling massively parallel, ad-hoc

10/2/23

6/27/17

SummerSim 2017: The Reference Model Models ClinicalTrials.Gov - Response for Reviewers

################################################################## Reply to reviewer: Dan Zelterman #

unread,

SummerSim 2017: The Reference Model Models ClinicalTrials.Gov - Response for Reviewers

################################################################## Reply to reviewer: Dan Zelterman #

6/27/17

6/12/17

SummerSim 2017: Microsimulation Models for Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: a Review and Introduction to CEAM - Response for Reviewers

Below is the corrected version of response for reviewers: Reed Sorensen May 31, 2017 Unformatted text

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Microsimulation Models for Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: a Review and Introduction to CEAM - Response for Reviewers

Below is the corrected version of response for reviewers: Reed Sorensen May 31, 2017 Unformatted text

6/12/17

6/12/17

SummerSim 2017: Microsimulation Models for Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: a Review and Introduction to CEAM - Reviewer Jacob Barhak

Following the final upload by the corresponding author, Jacob Barhak wrote this additional supplement

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Microsimulation Models for Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: a Review and Introduction to CEAM - Reviewer Jacob Barhak

Following the final upload by the corresponding author, Jacob Barhak wrote this additional supplement

6/12/17

6/10/17

SummerSim 2017: Untangling Uncertainty With Common Random Numbers: A Simulation Study - Response for Reviewers

Third Response to Reviewers for Untangling uncertainty with common random numbers: a simulation study

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Untangling Uncertainty With Common Random Numbers: A Simulation Study - Response for Reviewers

Third Response to Reviewers for Untangling uncertainty with common random numbers: a simulation study

6/10/17

6/10/17

SummerSim 2017: Towards an Anatomical Modeling Pipeline for Neurosurgical Simulation and Shift-Corrected Navigation - Reviewer Jacob Barhak

Since this review process was unusual it was decided to upload the entire communication between the

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Towards an Anatomical Modeling Pipeline for Neurosurgical Simulation and Shift-Corrected Navigation - Reviewer Jacob Barhak

Since this review process was unusual it was decided to upload the entire communication between the

6/10/17

6/6/17

SummerSim 2017: Untangling Uncertainty With Common Random Numbers: A Simulation Study - Reviewer Mohammad Abdullah Al-Mamun

Below is final response from Mohammad Abdullah Al-Mamun Hi Jacob, I think, I agree with you, the

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Untangling Uncertainty With Common Random Numbers: A Simulation Study - Reviewer Mohammad Abdullah Al-Mamun

Below is final response from Mohammad Abdullah Al-Mamun Hi Jacob, I think, I agree with you, the

6/6/17

6/5/17

SummerSim 2017: Towards an Anatomical Modeling Pipeline for Neurosurgical Simulation and Shift-Corrected Navigation - Reviewer Johannes Sametinger

The authors provided another version Below are the responses to that second revision. ########

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Towards an Anatomical Modeling Pipeline for Neurosurgical Simulation and Shift-Corrected Navigation - Reviewer Johannes Sametinger

The authors provided another version Below are the responses to that second revision. ########

6/5/17

6/4/17

SummerSim 2017: Population Modeling by Examples III - Response for Reviewers

Response to Review for SummerSim 2017 paper #42 – Population Modeling by Examples III The response is

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Population Modeling by Examples III - Response for Reviewers

Response to Review for SummerSim 2017 paper #42 – Population Modeling by Examples III The response is

6/4/17

6/3/17

SummerSim 2017: Untangling Uncertainty With Common Random Numbers: A Simulation Study - Reviewer Jacob Barhak

Below is the Response by Jacob Barhak to the changes made by the authors The authors did address the

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Untangling Uncertainty With Common Random Numbers: A Simulation Study - Reviewer Jacob Barhak

Below is the Response by Jacob Barhak to the changes made by the authors The authors did address the

6/3/17

6/3/17

SummerSim 2017: Untangling Uncertainty With Common Random Numbers: A Simulation Study - Reviewer Karel Van den Bosch

Below is the Response by Karel Van den Bosch and an email exchange with Jacob Barhak regarding the

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Untangling Uncertainty With Common Random Numbers: A Simulation Study - Reviewer Karel Van den Bosch

Below is the Response by Karel Van den Bosch and an email exchange with Jacob Barhak regarding the

6/3/17

5/29/17

SummerSim 2017: The Reference Model Models ClinicalTrials.Gov - Reviewer Dan Zelterman

Final response from Dan Zelterman: Robert – This is fine. Thanks for sharing it with me. Best, Dan On

unread,

SummerSim 2017: The Reference Model Models ClinicalTrials.Gov - Reviewer Dan Zelterman

Final response from Dan Zelterman: Robert – This is fine. Thanks for sharing it with me. Best, Dan On

5/29/17

5/26/17

SummerSim 2017: The Reference Model Models ClinicalTrials.Gov - Reviewer Robert Smith?

Response from Robert Smith? I find the paper acceptable; however, my outstanding concern is still

unread,

SummerSim 2017: The Reference Model Models ClinicalTrials.Gov - Reviewer Robert Smith?

Response from Robert Smith? I find the paper acceptable; however, my outstanding concern is still

5/26/17

5/26/17

SummerSim 2017: The Reference Model Models ClinicalTrials.Gov - Reviewer Ann Jolly

Final response from Ann Jolly: I just reviewed Jakob's changes and its all good to go!! Can you

unread,

SummerSim 2017: The Reference Model Models ClinicalTrials.Gov - Reviewer Ann Jolly

Final response from Ann Jolly: I just reviewed Jakob's changes and its all good to go!! Can you

5/26/17

5/19/17

SummerSim 2017: Using Sensitivity analysis to examine the effects of an Ebola vaccine - Reviewer Jacob Barhak

Final review record: ( disregard scores as those were not in the original form so numbers are set to

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Using Sensitivity analysis to examine the effects of an Ebola vaccine - Reviewer Jacob Barhak

Final review record: ( disregard scores as those were not in the original form so numbers are set to

5/19/17

5/19/17

SummerSim 2017: Using Sensitivity analysis to examine the effects of an Ebola vaccine - Reviewer Zvi Roth

Third review round: Dear Jacob, Everything is satisfactory now. I deem the paper Acceptable. Regards,

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Using Sensitivity analysis to examine the effects of an Ebola vaccine - Reviewer Zvi Roth

Third review round: Dear Jacob, Everything is satisfactory now. I deem the paper Acceptable. Regards,

5/19/17

5/19/17

SummerSim 2017: Using Sensitivity analysis to examine the effects of an Ebola vaccine - Reviewer Mike Famulare

Third Review round: I agree with Zvi. Also, I like this review process. Thank you for organizing, --

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Using Sensitivity analysis to examine the effects of an Ebola vaccine - Reviewer Mike Famulare

Third Review round: I agree with Zvi. Also, I like this review process. Thank you for organizing, --

5/19/17

5/19/17

SummerSim 2017: Using Sensitivity analysis to examine the effects of an Ebola vaccine - Response for Reviewers

Below is response after the second review round: ################### I think the revised paper is

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Using Sensitivity analysis to examine the effects of an Ebola vaccine - Response for Reviewers

Below is response after the second review round: ################### I think the revised paper is

5/19/17

5/19/17

SummerSim 2017: Population Modeling by Examples III - Reviewers: Thomas Woolly, Jane Heffernan, Robert Smith?

This is the updated review page from 19 May 2017, after response for reviewers was posted, Submission

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Population Modeling by Examples III - Reviewers: Thomas Woolly, Jane Heffernan, Robert Smith?

This is the updated review page from 19 May 2017, after response for reviewers was posted, Submission

5/19/17

4/30/17

SummerSim 2017: Microsimulation Models for Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: a Review and Introduction to CEAM - Reviewer Chris Kypridemos

Thank you for giving the opportunity to review this interesting paper presenting a new

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Microsimulation Models for Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: a Review and Introduction to CEAM - Reviewer Chris Kypridemos

Thank you for giving the opportunity to review this interesting paper presenting a new

4/30/17

4/25/17

SummerSim 2017: Microsimulation Models for Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: a Review and Introduction to CEAM - Reviewer Wojciech (Al) Chrosny

################## Review by : Wojciech (Al) Chrosny Here is my review of the paper #43: 1.

unread,

SummerSim 2017: Microsimulation Models for Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: a Review and Introduction to CEAM - Reviewer Wojciech (Al) Chrosny

################## Review by : Wojciech (Al) Chrosny Here is my review of the paper #43: 1.

4/25/17

7/7/16

SummerSim 2016: Theoretical considerations on creating populations with partnerships for large-scale agent-based models - Response for Reviewers

At final stages of preparation it was discovered an author was added to the paper author list. The

unread,

SummerSim 2016: Theoretical considerations on creating populations with partnerships for large-scale agent-based models - Response for Reviewers

At final stages of preparation it was discovered an author was added to the paper author list. The

7/7/16

6/10/16

SummerSim 2016: Investigating the Fidelity of an Improvement-Assessment Tool After One Vacuum Bell Treatment Session - Response for Reviewers

In Addition to my review, the following conversation took place between the author and the second

unread,

SummerSim 2016: Investigating the Fidelity of an Improvement-Assessment Tool After One Vacuum Bell Treatment Session - Response for Reviewers

In Addition to my review, the following conversation took place between the author and the second

6/10/16

6/10/16

SummerSim 2016: Investigating the Fidelity of an Improvement-Assessment Tool After One Vacuum Bell Treatment Session - Reviewer Matthew Jacobson

Submission #99 Investigating the Fidelity of an Improvement-Assessment Tool After One Vacuum Bell

unread,

SummerSim 2016: Investigating the Fidelity of an Improvement-Assessment Tool After One Vacuum Bell Treatment Session - Reviewer Matthew Jacobson

Submission #99 Investigating the Fidelity of an Improvement-Assessment Tool After One Vacuum Bell

6/10/16

6/8/16

SummerSim 2016: Investigating the Fidelity of an Improvement-Assessment Tool After One Vacuum Bell Treatment Session - Reviewer Jacob Barhak

Submission #99 Investigating the Fidelity of an Improvement-Assessment Tool After One Vacuum Bell

unread,

SummerSim 2016: Investigating the Fidelity of an Improvement-Assessment Tool After One Vacuum Bell Treatment Session - Reviewer Jacob Barhak

Submission #99 Investigating the Fidelity of an Improvement-Assessment Tool After One Vacuum Bell

6/8/16

6/2/16

SummerSim 2016: The Kidney Transplant Process Model (KTPM): Simulation Tool for the Transplant Process - Reviewer Jacob Barhak

This conversation took place upon submission of the final manuscript and includes additional review

unread,

SummerSim 2016: The Kidney Transplant Process Model (KTPM): Simulation Tool for the Transplant Process - Reviewer Jacob Barhak

This conversation took place upon submission of the final manuscript and includes additional review

6/2/16

5/30/16

SummerSim 2016: Smart wearable device for health monitoring in the Internet of Things domain - Response for Reviewers

Below is the Response for reviewers submitted as part of the camera ready manuscript ##########

unread,

SummerSim 2016: Smart wearable device for health monitoring in the Internet of Things domain - Response for Reviewers

Below is the Response for reviewers submitted as part of the camera ready manuscript ##########

5/30/16

5/30/16

SummerSim 2016: The Kidney Transplant Process Model (KTPM): Simulation Tool for the Transplant Process - Response for Reviewers

Below s the Response for reviewers submitted as part of the camera ready manuscript ########## Review

unread,

SummerSim 2016: The Kidney Transplant Process Model (KTPM): Simulation Tool for the Transplant Process - Response for Reviewers

Below s the Response for reviewers submitted as part of the camera ready manuscript ########## Review

5/30/16

5/22/16

SummerSim 2016: Simulation of Tumor Necrosis in Primary Melanoma - Response for Reviewers

Below s the Response for reviewers submitted as part of the camera ready manuscript ##########

unread,

SummerSim 2016: Simulation of Tumor Necrosis in Primary Melanoma - Response for Reviewers

Below s the Response for reviewers submitted as part of the camera ready manuscript ##########

5/22/16

5/20/16

SummerSim 2016: Disease Model Sharing Formats - Response for Reviewers

Below s the Response for reviewers submitted as part of the camera ready manuscript ########## Reply

unread,

SummerSim 2016: Disease Model Sharing Formats - Response for Reviewers

Below s the Response for reviewers submitted as part of the camera ready manuscript ########## Reply

5/20/16

Search

Clear search

Close search

Google apps

Main menu