Samar Minallah: On whose agenda is trying to sabotage peace accord?
By: Earthman, International Professor
Why a five six month old incidence of flogging a woman has been publicized by Samar Minallah, and later widely circulated around the world. It is learnt that recording from a phone camera of above event was sold to international brokers, a lottery for Samar Minallah to earn hundred thousand dollars and free publicity.
Punishment to woman was Islamic or non-Islamic; it is duty of courts and clergy to comment on the matter. Distribution and publicity of above event on such a large scale around the world have political ambitions rather human rights or women protection concerns. If you may pick today’s newspaper the statements of a particular group is witness that this political drama is based on sectarian abhorrence.
Minallah family is known crony of Mush and poses as die heart lover of Bhutto and Peoples Party. In the present circumstances when Athar Minallah played a role in restoration of Chief Justice, there he and Aitzaz Ahsan were responsible for sending CJ to the Zardari house, which was widely criticized throughout Pakistan. It is presumed that Hamid Mir of GEO TV is aware of whole conspiracy to sabotage Swat peace agreement, and he widely publicized such matter on Capital talk TV show.
It is assumed that some peoples want to disrupt peace agreement of Swat area, as it is in final course of action and lying on the table of Zardari for signature. Moreover since American’s have announcement 1.5 billion annual stipends; briskness of expected beneficiaries is on highest altitude to pose them warriors or crusaders, who are dictating Pak army to rejoin civil war.
In the last few months and in recent days a lot of human rights abuses have been reported by media but Samar Minallah did not bothered to came forward and comment on any of events such as:
1. Israr ullah Zehri appointed as minister in PPP’s government
2. Mir Hazar Khan Bajarani appointed as Minister of Education by PPP.
3. Abdul Qayyum Jatoi was caught red handed at Cat House Islamabad, later appointed as minister by PPP.
4. Altaf Hussain kicked out his wife from his home; later goons of MQM deprived her from rights and legal proceedings.
5. Legislation has been passed in Afghanistan denying right of Shia women by Hamid Karazai.
6. Pak army has brutally murdered hundred of women and children’s with the help of air strikes and canons at Swat and FATA areas.
7. NATO is regularly killing women and children’s with the help of drone attacks.
8. Hundreds of girls of Jamia Hafsa were brutally murdered, kidnapped and humiliated by Pakistan army.
9. Pak army, Frontier Forces still have occupied dozens of schools in war torn areas, but no one has courage to point out that why security forces are sitting in schools. And whenever Taliban attacks on those schools then a different picture is presented.
10. At Peshawar today anybody can visit and see “Heera Mandi Street”, no Taliban or Al Qaida ever attacked there nor did Samar Minallah ever help prostitutes to adopt any other profession. NWFP has largest market of male Prostitutes as well; titles of some of the sex business are so vulgar that peoples avoid quoting them. Crying on the name of Women protection is a political drama or means to receive aid from overseas countries.
11. There are so many hue and cries for polio vaccination, question is why Mush awarded such contracts to Agha Khanis, and same as whole education system was handed over to Agha Khan School Board. All privatized tourism hotels have been awarded to them and even 99.9% five star hotels is owned by that group. On other hand Karakoram State and Agha Khan State is in pipe line. That was the only reason that Idi Amin kicked them out from Uganda.
All above are a few examples excluding Aafia Siddiqui case and many women who have been involved in terrorism related cases by agencies? In the month of March Zardari was involved in allowing security agencies to jump in to homes with the help of ladders to crush lawyer’s movement. It is on record that security agencies brutally humiliated protesters including women during entire movement of restoration of justice.
Athar Minallah who was crony of Mush and minister in his cabinet want to fail ANP government for the sake of making room for PPP, question is why Minallah family now abruptly started to broadcast on TV channels that Swat peace agreement has been failed and condition is for worst then civil war times? Additionally Army should continue to fight in those areas and so many other pessimistic theories could be witnessed on TV channels and papers.
Nasr Minallah who served Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto as a civil servant later he was ill-treated by General Zia ul Haq due to his contacts with Bhutto. After death his wife Bilqis became MNA. Both have four children’s Athar, Fauzia, Akmal and Samar. Their close relatives, justice Safdar Shah was the Supreme Court judge who wrote a judgment declaring Bhutto innocent of the crime for which he was ultimately hanged (a 4 to 3 majority vote in the Supreme Court).
Athar Minallah poses that he is a lover of Z A Bhutto but why he worked as a Minister in Mush Government. His storey of participation in lawyer’s movement is well known. Samar Minallah is his sister who claimed to be living at Swat since last two years but neither Taliban touched her or Al Qaeda.
There is a strong group of Afghan Northern alliance at Islamabad, who has established an Aryana Institute for Regional Research and Advocacy (AIRRA) at Islamabad funded by anti-Pakistan quarters. Their major aims and ambitions include keeping busy Pakistan army in civil war. Majority of communists and cronies of India and Russia are sitting at Islamabad for spying on Pakistan. Its office is established in a large palace at a posh area of Islamabad. Farhat Taj Andersen is their spokes person, who is a Christian convert and based at Oslo. She is a great friend of Jang group and Salman Taseer media group who usually publish her poisonous sermons based on hatred and fascist theories.
Peoples are watching helplessly to observe manoeuvres of politicians, army and bureaucracy. Those were asked to pray for peace during civil war. Now when peace has returned to the area anarchists, fascists and groups surviving on the stipend of imperialists are trying hard to interrupt whole peace process. Restoration of judiciary which left a soft impression on global level has now been tactfully sabotaged by Samar Minallah. The video she has sold to overseas agencies is continuously running on all leading channels around globe.
It is certainly move of Mush or Zardari, who are behind Samar Minallah.
Dear Dr Qureshi, Please do not try to distract attention from the issue. Whatever your gripe with Samar Minallah, please keep it between yourselves. For whatever reason Samar Minallah did or did not draw attention to other HR issues you have referred to does not, in any way mitigate the gravity of the outrage of flogging a girl. It is not just for the court and the clergy to comment on the matter. Every one has a right and duty to condemn a barbaric act. Ehtisham Dr. Syed Ehtisham (607) 776-3336 Blog syedehtisham.blogspot.com Feudalism, militarism, fundamentalism and bureaucrats constitute the evil Quad in Pakistan. --- On Sat, 4/4/09, Dr Shahid Qureshi <ukcorre...@hotmail.com> wrote: |
From: Dr Shahid Qureshi <ukcorre...@hotmail.com> |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Dear Mr. Syed,
This is not my write-up. I would have put my name on it. I received email and shared with others. Is that a problem? The number of collaborators and traitors in Pakistan is in thousands unfortunately most of them are 'mummy dady' English speaking class? When US Senator said, ‘Pakistanis would sell their mothers for few $'. He was talking about them and not about 170 million honourable, proud Pakistanis because they don't have $ accounts.
Please reply to the email address:. internation...@hotmail.com
many thanks
Dr Shahid Qureshi
London
|
The question that naturally creeps in ones mind after viewing this is why the world kept silent when this women tortured horrendously in OHIO in
2006 by non other then police officers, and why the news of women flogging
was all over the news, all over the globe
The point to note is that if this video were to be shown 24/7 on channels
all across the world, and the propagators' own people were to stage paid
demonstrations in streets across cities, then this would have been a crime of
equal magnitude. This is called Media Warfare
Dear Farzana, We are more concerned with what happens in Pakistan, because we are from there. And there is a degree of rule of law, though it could be improved, in the USA, much higher than in Pakistan. Even if one grants that Samar is following some one's agenda, whose agenda, is it Taliban's or is it Jamaat e Islami, that you are following? |
Dr. Syed Ehtisham (607) 776-3336 Blog syedehtisham.blogspot.com Feudalism, militarism, fundamentalism and bureaucrats constitute the evil Quad in Pakistan. |
--- On Mon, 4/6/09, Farzana Shah <jana...@gmail.com> wrote: |
I think we should think twice before we get into the blame-game as it is very easy to just jump to a conclusion and then start an entire campaign.
Samar Minallah is not a hired hand of any political party or anti-Islamic organization. She has been a journalist for twenty years and now a documentary film maker focusing on the issues upon which we are not willing to speak out against and which are the stigma on our country and its traditions. She works purely for Pakistan and is helping to empower the women folk under the Muslim Context.
If we really want to know about hired/paid/ATM or Chequebook journalism then go back in history, particularly the Afghan War Era, when millions and millions of dollars were drawn by the “rightist” journalists and newspaper editors-cum-owners, they were on the payroll of the ISI and other such sources.
I read the article carefully and realized that the writer, Earthman or whatever his name is, doesn’t bring many things she did do for the sake of humanity. Like, for instance, due to Samar's efforts, in December 2005 a three-member bench comprising Chief Justice of Pakistan Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhry, Justice Faqir Khokhar and Justice Shakirullah Jan gave police orders to protect women against Swara (a tradition in which the daughter or a female of the family is given away to the enemy to end old rivalry, it is practised in all parts ot Pakistan with different names) by registering any complaints for women who came forward. Her petition requested the court to declare the handing over of a woman as compensation in any form of settlement illegal, and to declare that marriage under the custom of Sawara did not constitute legal marriage. She also requested the court to declare that Jirga decisions in such cases hold no legal value as it violates fundamental rights besides section 310(1) (compounding of Qisas) of the Pakistan Penal Code, and that Sawara customs should be banned immediately and the victims be released to lead a new life in accordance with the constitution.
And surely that Video of a girl being whip lashed by the “non-mehram” men amid so many other ‘non-mehram’ men is not Islamic. Even if it were a fake, then it is an undeniable fact that the extremists have been doing a lot of callous acts, including the violence on women in those regions. Islam is the religion in which there are no compulsions but the extremists are misusing the teachings of Islam and trying to spread it through guns, severe punishments and they do all this: in the name of God.
It is a shame that we just jump to a conclusion and start blaming people without having any concrete evidence. All due to the lack of right professional approach. Please put your emotions aside and be impartial to all this just for once and see the entire matter as a human being, you cannot even be a good Muslim unless you are a good human being.
-Zanobia
From:
PressP...@googlegroups.com [mailto:PressP...@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of Farzana Shah
Sent: Sunday, April 05, 2009 11:25
PM
To: ual...@hotmail.com
Cc: ukcorre...@hotmail.com;
sye...@yahoo.com; abidul...@gmail.com; paka...@googlegroups.com;
pakistanpe...@yahoogroups.com; paka...@gmail.com;
pakm...@yahoogroups.com; paf_op...@yahoogroups.com;
kashmiraf...@yahoogroups.com; pakpot...@googlegroups.com;
muslims...@yahoogroups.com; ansar....@gmail.com;
saeeda...@gmail.com; asif...@gmail.com; pressme...@gmail.com;
pressp...@googlegroups.com; aisha.f...@phclondon.org;
azhar...@geo.tv; faisa...@yahoo.com; b.sh...@mopa.gov.sy;
bush...@yahoo.com; bhcl...@btconnect.com; iqbalsa...@yahoo.co.uk;
hami...@geo.tv; li...@presstv.ir; infor...@alhayat.com;
hesh...@presstv.ir; sou...@btconnect.com
Subject: Re: Samar
Minallah: On whose agenda is trying to sabotage peace accord?
I wonder why on earth no political party had ever announced to stage a protest over killing of women in Balochistan recently? WHY NO ONE the likes of MQM had ever staged protest over Afia case??
<br
Dear Farzana,
We are more concerned with what happens in Pakistan, because we are from there. And there is a degree of rule of law, though it could be improved, in the USA, much higher than in Pakistan.
Even if one grants that Samar is following some one's agenda, whose agenda, is it Taliban's or is it Jamaat e Islami, that you are following?
Dr. Syed Ehtisham
(607) 776-3336
Blog syedehtisham.blogspot.com
Feudalism, militarism, fundamentalism and bureaucrats constitute the evil Quad in Pakistan.
--- On Mon, 4/6/09, Farzana Shah <jana...@gmail.com> wrote:
From: Farzana Shah <jana...@gmail.com>
Subject: Re: Samar Minallah: On whose agenda is trying to sabotage peace accord?
Date: Sun, 5 Apr 2009 11:24:56 -0700
Subject: Re: Samar Minallah: On whose agenda is trying to sabotage peace accord?
From: jana...@gmail.com
Get news, entertainment and everything you care about at Live.com. Check it out!
blank" href="http://www.live.com/getstarted.aspx">Check it out!
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You are receiving this email because you are member of PressPakistan Googlegroup, a mailing list of about 4,000 Pakistani and international journalists. To subscribe/unsubscribe, please visit: http://PressPakistan.co.cc
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
--
Its very shocking that the so-called civil society organizations could take a step just for the sake of earning dollars. The video which is clearly indicating as fake that the way the girl left the scene so calmly is the clear evidence.
Just asked to that so-called civil society activist to just take at least five flogs and then show how u can be able to go easily.
Its again very shocking because it not only give bad name to our society but also opened another chapter of criticism on Islam. I am not a fundamentalist but not a secular to such an extent as these so-called civil society activists are doing for the sake of earning “green backs”.
Being journalists all of us know very well that what these elements are doing in the name of civil society and non-governmental organizations.
Ali Hussain
Reporter
The Frontier Post, Islamabad
& PPI
Cell # 0345-5911734
I dont know why you guys send me this trash. Cant you guys do something productive than this bickering about a non-issue |
--- On Mon, 6/4/09, Farzana Shah <jana...@gmail.com> wrote: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
<br
Dear All,
It is astonishing, how some people are still alleging and counter-alleging each other and Ms. Minallah’s possible motive.
Folks:
1. Instead of slandering each other, how about we focus on why this video has riled emotions of many (both pro and con)? Could it be, because some of us are afraid that soon they or their loved ones also may have to face the pervasive version of justice of the self-righteous? On the other hand, some people are on defensive, because they fear it falsely depicts their culture and their traditions.
2. So far, there is a video (authentic or engineered) that shows blatant violations of women rights, and then we have purely speculative allegations that it’s an engineered video. This reminds me of how Maulana Fazal-ur-Rehman chose to attack Ansar Abassi, despite the availability of physical proof and eye witness accounts. So how about we debate the subject and refrain from slandering each other and that too, purely on speculative bases?
3. Regardless, whether this video is authentic or not, in this day and age of readily available camera equipped cell-phones, its only matter of time when another such video will make its début.
p.s. here is another video of Taliban abusing another woman, who didn’t cover her ankles to the satisfaction of a Talib. Can someone please translate the audio and make a guess about the dialect in this video? Thanks.
Sincerely,
Adnan Gill
Los Angeles
Subject: RE: Samar Minallah: On whose agenda is trying to sabotage peace accord?
Date: Mon, 6 Apr 2009 18:18:55 +0500
From: zanobi...@CNBCPakistan.com
To: Jana...@gmail.com; ual...@hotmail.com
CC: ukcorre...@hotmail.com; sye...@yahoo.com; abidul...@gmail.com; paka...@googlegroups.com; pakistanpe...@yahoogroups.com; paka...@gmail.com; pakm...@yahoogroups.com; paf_op...@yahoogroups.com; kashmiraf...@yahoogroups.com; pakpot...@googlegroups.com; muslims...@yahoogroups.com; ansar....@gmail.com; saeeda...@gmail.com; asif...@gmail.com; pressme...@gmail.com; pressp...@googlegroups.com; aisha.f...@phclondon.org; azhar...@geo.tv; faisa...@yahoo.com; b.sh...@mopa.gov.sy; bush...@yahoo.com; bhcl...@btconnect.com; iqbalsa...@yahoo.co.uk; hami...@geo.tv; li...@presstv.ir; infor...@alhayat.com; hesh...@presstv.ir; sou...@btconnect.com
Subject: RE: Samar Minallah: On whose agenda is trying to sabotage peace accord?
Date: Mon, 6 Apr 2009 18:18:55 +0500
From: zanobi...@CNBCPakistan.com
To: Jana...@gmail.com; ual...@hotmail.com
CC: ukcorre...@hotmail.com; sye...@yahoo.com; abidul...@gmail.com; paka...@googlegroups.com; pakistanpe...@yahoogroups.com; paka...@gmail.com; pakm...@yahoogroups.com; paf_op...@yahoogroups.com; kashmiraf...@yahoogroups.com; pakpot...@googlegroups.com; muslims...@yahoogroups.com; ansar....@gmail.com; saeeda...@gmail.com; asif...@gmail.com; pressme...@gmail.com; pressp...@googlegroups.com; aisha.f...@phclondon.org; azhar...@geo.tv; faisa...@yahoo.com; b.sh...@mopa.gov.sy; bush...@yahoo.com; bhcl...@btconnect.com; iqbalsa...@yahoo.co.uk; hami...@geo.tv; li...@presstv.ir; infor...@alhayat.com; hesh...@presstv.ir; sou...@btconnect.com
*** This Message Has Been Sent Using BlackBerry Internet Service from Mobilink ***
*** This Message Has Been Sent Using BlackBerry Internet Service from Mobilink ***
Hot n SourWhere are you Farzana Bari???
Makhdoom Mukhtar
Last Friday a young girl finished her classes at the Quaid e Azam University campus and headed for her relatives on the weekend. She reached the University main gate and waited for taxi. A taxi arrived on the scene but she did not waved her hand to attract the attention of the driver as two men were already sitting in the cab. But still the taxi stopped beside her. Before she could understand the situation, one man came out of the taxi, grabbed the girl and pushed her inside the vehicle. Some onlookers were present on the scene but no body raised an alarm and no body even tried to record the number plate of the car. The incident was reported in the press in detail. It was told that parents of the poor girl were seen rushing here and there in search of their daughter. The University administration refused to take up the case with the police and police never did it on their own. Where the hell are you Farzana Bari?
Farzana Bari is an internationally acclaimed gender rights activist who heads the department of Gender Studies at the prestigious Quaid e Azam University in Islamabad. She remains busy in reading research papers on gender injustices done to poor women in functions held at air conditioned five star venues. Half her days are spent abroad enlightening the world about the struggle she has done on improving the quality of life of women in Pakistan. And when one of her colleagues asked her to do something for the poor abducted girl, she snubbed her as the matter did not specifically concern her department. In her own department where she rules like Aristotle, an unfortunate incident occurred only last month. One of her brilliant student was raped by another student and the unfortunate girl had to leave not only the university but the city where this international university has its distinguished premises.
Quaid e Azam University is in the grip of sexual harassment cases and gender related crimes these days. Since the post of Vice Chancellor in Pakistan is bureaucratically tailored in this country, he would never feel the need to visit around to sense the pulse at the campus. There have been no Student Counseling Facilities in this university whereas Dr.Farzana Bari and all her crew members have been studying abroad and they very well know what Student Counseling means. According to a survey made by the students themselves 100 percent of the female students are subject to harassment at the hands of males at the campus. The incidents reported in the earlier passages are not the only happenings in this academic institution stationed in a jungle.
The vast and boundary less area of the university is covered by trees and bushes and hideouts. The place becomes haunted after the classes are over but there is no check on entrance or exits of the visitors who continue to roam in the campus in search of a glimpse of girls. The functions at the university are arranged by the students in the night and no secure best practices have been introduced to monitor the activities of the students. A couple of years back, corpse of a young girl was found in the bushes right after the night of a function. The matter was never probed.
The male students have made it an established custom to pass comments on the passer-by female students. More horrible is the fact that girl students have now accepted the occurring of these remarks as a routine feature of the university. However this has increased the sense of insecurity among the girl students at a large level. They take refuge in the company of their male class fellows in the hope that their proximity would stop the students of other departments from harassing them. The male class fellows don’t allow their female class fellows to even stand alone at the bus stop as they know the threats posed by the male species at the campus. Rows and fights featuring over protective and jealous boys are on the rise. What are the management and faculty waiting for? What do they want to happen next?
But who can blame the students when teachers themselves are on the forefront in creating a rampage against the fair sex. Those who have studied at the Quaid e Azam University know the names of those professors very well who demand special favors from their female students in exchange of good grades. One feels like hating this rendezvous. One feels like asking are we really humans? Are we really the students and are we really the teachers for that matter? Is it a horror movie being screened by a Hollywood Film Maker or is it a slide show of our inner brutes that rule the roost in the garb of education?
Where are all the researchers gone who have devoted their skills to explore the reasons of acid throwing incidents on young innocent girls in remote areas of Pakistan? Don’t they see that something terrible is happening to the girls going to University in the heart of the capital Islamabad? Why Farzana Bari has not conducted a survey to find out the reasons of harassment in one of the leading university of the country? And why on earth has she not until now in all along her magnificent career even once tried to create awareness among the male students of the university against sexual harassment. May be Government of Pakistan can fund a consultancy or may be another foreign tour can be arranged for her so that she can go abroad and find out the reasons of criminal sex offences happening right under her nose?
All the efforts of women right activists have been for blind compliance of western feminism movements. Would any body define and design Gender Studies in Pakistani context? Please join your hands to save our culture that used to give respect to the women and girls. Please do something to save the young girls going to their Alma Maters from indecent threats at the hands of the males. Please save the repute of this wonderful institution that we know as Quaid e Azam International University. Dr.Farzana Bari; Please do something.
The writer is a freelance columnist
With all due respect Mr Mohammad Boota, I really feel sorry for your loss. Its very common now from indian side that they treat Pakistani's like this. I also remember a kid who went to watch a cricket match & then his dead body was sent. Indians are insane. Honestly Pakistani media will/can never say against indian brutality. They always stick to their ego's/money & didn't give a single min of coverage to the 2008 Kashmir peaceful revolution. Now that CJ is reinstated & Pakistani media has given every Pakistani Justice then you can go & ask CJ to do something for which I know he won't.
again sorry for ur loss...Allah usko jald hee bhejay....IlahiAmin
WasSalam
Dear Ali,
Thanks for providing insight information about D. Farzan Bri and one of the leading institution of this county. I strongly agree with the first and part of the passage that people like Farzana Bari are the “So called Champions of the Human rights who exploited the poor people in the name of Human rights. I have personally seen the media persons who are invited to take Dr. Bari's pictures during the protest and even directed to catch the special events like police is beating the women, people, or catching Dr. Bari during the demonstration.
This sort of people is doing these activities just for fame or to become a celebrity. What about those media persons who are the part of Dr. Bari’s drama????????
I have spent five years of my life Quaid-e-Azam university. In second part, the picture of Quaid-e-Azam university you have portrayed it’s not real. As you are saying that female students are harassed or grabbed by the male students of the university.
I haven’t heard any story as you stated “A couple of years back, corpse of a young girl was found in the bushes right after the night of a function. The matter was never probed”
I agree that few teachers are committing this sort of activities that, exploiting the female students. But I don’t think that this is one way traffic at all, some times students are too involved in these cases.
I am afraid, the picture you are creating is not as worse as you are saying. The students who are studying in the university are grown people they are not kids. They can understand and think what is good or bad.
What I conclude from your statements that Qauid-e-Azam University is a place axis of evil rather than an academic institution so be careful to pass this sort of emails or statements.
Be realistic and don’t say anything that does not exist
|
|
|
|
|
|
<br
Dear all,
Whether the videotape was fake or real but the frequently changing statements of the Taliban spokesmen have proved that such incident were happened in Swat.
Regards,
Tehseen Khan
Mr. Singh,
you might be right that Swat should not be equated with Pakistan but the northwest should not be ignored at all. Pakistan doesn't mean just Punjab. People are worried because the northwest is burning. The fire has crossed into settled parts of NWFP. look Peshawar, capital of NWFP, kidnappings for ransom are on rise (police say criminals have joined Taliban and they're doing for making funds for "jihad" in Pakistan), everyday militants set fire container trucks carrying supplies for western forces, and sufi shrines are attacked. Nexst door in Khyber region, militants are charging tax from traders and shopkeepers and there is clear order from Mr. Mangal Bagh, a man who has two children has to donate for his force. In D.I. Khan, you can witnessed violence in sectarian lines. Hangu, Kohat, mardan, you name it and one tell you how Taliban are operating there.
Sadly on the part government there's no resistence.
we are either saying Hanoos Delhi Door Hast (Delhi is still far away) or we're trying to justfy terrorism and terrorists' brutal acts by dubbing then reactionary acts to what Western forces have been doing in Afghanistan or conspiracy of "infidels".
I know many of you might be considering me "the bloody westernise pakistani" or "Pakistani journalist" but my point is let's not push shit under the carpet or turn your back to reality n facts. Take them boldly and fight them back.
For Mr. Razi: what i know a little bit about history of Pakistan: Mr. Jinnah was at first stage didn't want a separate state. he wanted a confideration. But he was forced to raise voice for separate land - thanks to Mr. Nehru and Patal.
And unfortunately, those who opposed Pakistan (Islamist parties) became protectors and masters of this land.
chrz
kamran
+92 300 8560 944
|
From: bishwajeet singh <rbish...@gmail.com> |
Dear All
I always hear a word ‘independent media’ but not really know what independent media means,,,,,,,,,,, being journalists you all might be very known about the situation in Kurram Agency, located in West of the country with Afghan border also known “Durand Line” and is an important and strategic part of the country.
But unfortunately, the part is being ignored not only by the rulers but also by the so-called independent media of which I am also a part, just only the region is predominating by a particular sect.
Kurram Agency had been the scene for bloody violence with the recent deadliest one that started in April 2007 and continued till November 2008 that left hundreds killed, wounded and thousands other homeless. Now after the peace accord was signed by the rival tribes, peace was restored a little but soon was violated by the militants who again started kidnapping and targeting people of the particular tribe.
The only road—Thall-Parachinar road, that links Kurram Agency with the rest of the country has been closed for more than two months after the series of killing a kidnapping was started again by the militants. Ironically, when a single person is killed in Swat or else where in the country, the country’s electronic media starting to disseminate the news with its Breaking News,,,, (I am not happy with the killing of these innocent people but I am just trying to bring the issue in your kind notice). Some 2500 people including women and children have been killed sine 2007 in these deadliest fighting but nether the rulers paid their due heeds to comfort the locals nor the media highlighted miseries of these people.
You will be shocked to hear that locals of Parachinar, the headquarters of Kurram Agency, when want to go rest of the cities of Pakistan they use Afghanistan’s four to five provinces to travel to Peshawar, which in normal days one can reach only in 5 hours.
Now a day too, the locals of Parachinar and rest of the areas are again the worst victim of economic blackout by the armed militants for more than two months who have occupied the singe gateway passing through the areas of the other sect.
The people of the areas have their history of loyalty to the country but these days the strange behaviour by the rulers and the media are questionable for them. You will feel these miseries of the people when you himself pass through these.
I myself wanted to join my family on the last Eid-ul-Azha after a year and went via Afghanistan to Parachinar. It was very strange to see those Afghanis who when came in our villages after the Russian War in 1979, we serve them like real brothers, even gave them rooms in our own house for residing and divided edibles with them but were very arrogant on us when we were arrested briefly in Gardaiz Province of Afghanistan because we were non Afghans. We were locked for the reason in small room for sometime and were released after through investigations. Every one was interrogated as there should not be any Urdu speaker.
Hammm--- we were subjected to the interrogations by those Afghanis due to which our own country is in a war like situation where they are moving as freely as Pakistan is their grand father’s home.
Independent media,,,, I am still confused as what does it mean, my own news story to highlight these miseries is not being published. The children of the areas are worst victim of mental torture and our so-called civil society activists and champions of human rights are silent. Whether children residing in Kurram Agency are not human beings or whether they are not Pakistanis, whether they don’t have the right of basic needs like health facilities or they don’t have the right to go to school or they are not the human beings to provide with the necessary food items.
Sorry if anybody does not agree with me and received any problem.
Regards
Ali
for latest news always click
www.vofp.pk
to know about us, aim & objectives please click
http://www.vofp.pk/cms/?page_id=2
to meet our team click
http://www.vofp.pk/cms/?page_id=45
Team Voice of People
---------------------------------------
Love it Mr. Sajaad wht you said! you have just proved truth wht point I tried to make. You tried to justified Taliban's brutality and actions. Look, two wrongs don't make one right. I'm not supporting or neglecting wht MQM or others have been doing. My point is that we should open our eyes and don't take everybody clean and commander or protector of a religion who use the name of it. Trust me, MQM or any other criminal are not defaming Islam BUT Taliban do becaue they're using Islam to impose their agenda. Taliban are hardcore criminal, not holy fighters.
I'm not at all against talks/peace deals with Taliban but these must stop radicalisation and Talibanisation of society instead they give a room to radicals to become more powerful and spread its agenda through terror. Everybody has right to propogate what he believes is right but don't try to impose it on others. tell me how many people in Pakistan or world are cursing or abusing Tableegi jamaat or people? they travel everywhere. Tell me, how many times Prophet Mohammad Peace Be Upon Him carried sword to impose Shariah (offensive)?
I think you have never been to northwest of Pakistan. please visit Peshawar and then Lahore or any city big of Punjab and talk to people. you could see the difference and draw a good picture. you'll feel insecurity among masses in peshawar. And for your info, I was born in Peshawar, grew up there, roamed around. I'm proud i belong to that land but at the same time, I'm sad what has happened to it and what they're doing to it (no offence, just to make my point dear).
And Kashmir is neither part Pakistan nor India. It's Kashmiris to decide their destination. so please ignore such impressions that kashmir is part of any these two countries.
About the video or the girl - dear that's you're observation or opnion, which could be wrong or right. You didn't investigat it so one should take it as any opnion, not a statement backed by athentic probe.
Journalists reported that incident happened. It was Samar Minallah or Taliban who could accept it or deny it. At first stage, Mr. Muslim Khan chose to take responsibility but later denied it (you can see his statement in my early email). Residents of Swat said this footage is available on mobiles as well as on CDs which are sold in Mingora.
chrz
|
|
dear sajjad,
if you read your previous email again, you'll find you did try to jutify or ask a third person to make a comment on tht (anyway it is not the case)
look when i say brutality, it is my expression/opinion but listen I as journalist never used that in my report. that's what journalism demands. don't put your bias in your report and since it's discussion so I enjoy liberty to express what i feel (but in limits and a decent way).
Dear, please address contradictions in your thought (no offense). you're wiiling to give liberty to Taliban that they do it what they want but impose your willing on Kashmiris that they accept Pakistan. if we admit they want Pakistan and accept all polls true, even then let them vote and then count how many votes are bagged in your favour. Kashmir is a part of Pakistan that is your willing and everyone should respect that but that doesn't mean Kashmiris go by your willing.
Dear, again there's talk of enemies. Look in Swat case, there're two parties - Taliban and army or govt. You select who is enemy. Who is toeing the policy of Pakistan's enemy?
chrz
kamran |
9/11 Cover Story Demolished? | |
| |
| |
|
|
|
The London Post | |
By Dr Shahid Qureshi | |
| |
|
|
|
PAKISTANI MEDIA MAFIA’S ABUSES
By Dr Shahid Qureshi
Mafia groups have invested in media and hired shining journalist/media persons. By doing that they are using their network to influence the authorities and also rubbing shoulders with the so called elite of Pakistan. By doing that some of them are getting away with their basic responsibilities as employers. The government need publicity so mostly it side with the owners of the press and media groups.
Pakistani media evolved in the past few years as a result of realization that no war and no peace could be won without it? A society where level of respect is measured with nuisance value journalists are at the centre. In past rich and famous use to keep close links/friendships with poor middle or working class journalists both to avoid bad publicity and get good one. Some university/college lecturers choose to keep on foot in journalism and one in education.
The verbal abuse by Nazir Naji of a junior reporter Mohammad Ahem Noorani of The News Islamabad is just a tip of the iceberg of the plight of media in Pakistan. A senior drunk with arrogance and power scolded a new comer for just asking legitimate questions. These old gurus blew trumpets of who ever in power are now enjoying the perks and those young like Ansar Abbasi, Ahmed Noorani, and Kashif Abbasi and others who say what they mean and not the otherwise are being criticised for their principle stands?
The access/powers a journalist has with empty pockets in Pakistan is open to abuse? This access attracts people to become journalists even work free with the view that these losses would be recovered in future. I am not sure medic cum anchor Dr Shahid Masood has recovered his losses of his voluntary/free work at ARY TV in London? The gold dealers are close to President Zardari and believe in live and let live at all cost…
According to senior journalist those who arrived with a ‘trunk’ (suitcase made with iron) in Lahore, Karachi and Islamabad are millionaires and own big media groups. These poverty stricken gurus never did anything for the new comers and become abusers themselves?
In December 2008 a young Pakistani TV journalist committed suicide due to the non payment of his salary for months and rude behaviour of Imtinan Shahid of Channel5 of Khabrain Group. The suicide of Mohammed Azam a Pakistani TV Channel-5 journalist shows the amount of pressures and constant war of survival in the journalistic community in Pakistan. They are mostly being abused by their own former colleagues who become of owners of media groups after working for others. Obviously they know the ticks of the trade?
Media in Pakistan has become like family business where sons, daughters and daughter in laws can have fast track promotions as editors or chief editors, CEOs and a place in higher media bodies. That is how abuse of media and journalism starts? Those who have spent years studying media in the universities are being criticised or assessed by these people who don’t have a clue about the profession? It’s like direct appointment without training as General, which normally takes 30 yeas and few dozen exams and interviews.
A senior journalist received a phone call from Zia Shahid asking to work for his English newspaper ‘The Post’ in London. His son late Ednan Shahid send him a contract with a condition that, ‘Pakistani labour laws would be applicable while he would be working and living in London. He wanted him to function under Pakistani laws and not British in London. The worst of all is they did not pay the agreed amount at all.
Wajahat Ali Khan current acting President of Pakistan journalists Association United Kingdom left GEO Television due to non payments of salary for many months. His section in charge Iftikhar Qaisar was reassuring him that one day you will be paid. I am not sure if he himself is getting paid as probably he himself is not regular employee of the company? In this age of emails and fax his case for payments is under consideration for months and his dues have not been cleared yet. These so called media giants are the worst perpetrators of the rights of the media and journalists. Pakistani journalists based abroad must be provided full support like many other countries. No doubt what these journalists are doing money can’t buy but it is an essential for the survival in the most expansive cities in the world so they could focus on media activities?
Huma Ali a senior journalist based in Islamabad told me that ‘some media groups are hiring/sub contracting journalists through third companies for years to avoid labour laws and are depriving them from their legal rights’.
We have to find a solution of the problem and support each other. Media in Pakistan has been hijacked by organised mafia gangs who are using it for their protection? It is difficult to differentiate between true journalists, pen pushers and fakes since they have joined the ranks. Now any one can become a journalist by self certifying but it does not work in practice?
Those groups avoiding labour laws by issuing short term contract letters for years should be told to stop that practice and legislation should be introduced to protect rights of journalists. There should be a clear and transparent policy of internship for the training and education of young journalists to avoid future suicides and exploitations.
Government of Pakistan should ask for the complete list of full time and temporary employees, their duration of service, of all print and electronic media groups. Ministry of Information can easily do that and should accredit only if a legal contract from the employers represented and company hired is the same.
When I asked President Musharraf in London to do something for the rights of the journalists. He said, ‘they should come on the road’. He said, ‘journalists in Pakistan are getting Rs50,000. per month’. The real question is how many are getting Rs.50,000 a month? Though some are getting paid in US$ but others are not getting paid at all.
(Dr Shahid Qureshi is award wining journalist and writer on foreign policy & security based in London)
| |
| |
|
|
|
| |
| |
|
|
|
India Acquiring Israeli Airborne Early Warning System
By Nissan Ratzlav-Katz
IsraelNN.com) India is to take delivery of the first of three Israeli airborne early warning command and control (AWAC) systems on Sunday.
With the integration of the Israel Aircraft Industries (IAI) Phalcon system, the Indian air force will become the first in South Asia with advanced AWAC aircraft.
Considered the most advanced AWAC system, the Phalcon provides tactical surveillance of airborne and surface targets, and the gathering of signal intelligence.
It is capable of tracking fighter planes, missiles and ground forces from up to 400 kilometers away, in any weather conditions.
The system can identify all types of aircraft and was programmed to differentiate between friend and foe.
The delivery of the long-range, high-performance and multi-sensor Phalcon system is part of a 1.1 billion dollar deal signed between India, Russia and Israel in January 2004.
As part of the delivery, IAI mounted the Phalcon systems on IL-76 aircraft supplied by Russia. Delivery of the last two Phalcon systems to India is slated for 2010.
Ahead of the negotiations for the sale of the Phalcons to India, Israel obtained a green light from the United States for the transfer of incorporated American technology.
Israeli caution was borne of bitter experience, after a previous deal with China for the purchase of the Phalcon systems was nixed by the U.S. As a result, Israel-China
relations suffered a harsh blow and Israel was forced to compensate China to the tune of 375 million dollars.
Over the past several years, Israel has sold more than 1 billion dollars worth of defense systems to India on an annual basis. This has made India Israel’s leading customer in the global military supply market.
Sales have included hardware and software, missiles for the Indian navy, as well as anti-aircraft and anti-missile systems based on the Green Pine radar.
“Green Pine”, designed by Israel Aerospace Industries, is a transportable radar system designed to track dozens of ballistic missiles from long-ranges, and in all weather conditions.
In addition to the Phalcon sale, Israel’s military industry firm has announced it will establish five factories in India for the production of artillery shells. The project is said to be worth 240 million dollars.
In other fields related to defense, Israel and India have collaborated in military and aerospace research and development.
In January 2008, for example, the Israel Space Agency and India’s Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) successfully launched an Israeli-made spy satellite from the Satish Dhawan Space Centre at
Sriharikota in southeastern India.
Pakistan's Treacherous Regime & US Game Plan | |
| |
|
|
|
Diplomatic Begging and British Pakistanis | |
| |
|
|
|
| |
| |
|
|
|
Who are USA’s High Value Pakistani Assets? The London Post | |
US officials and politicians are most of the times so much convinced with their own policies that they seems like megalomaniacs, hypnotised and robotic. This inflexible attitude has caused deaths and destruction to millions in Iraq, Afghanistan and now in Pakistan. Probably for that very reason US invest in recruiting agents then making true friends from the masses. Nicholas Burns, US Assistant Secretary of State was in the same trance when I asked him at (IISS) International Institute of Strategic Studies in London in 2008, something like, ‘what moral lessons you have for the people resisting occupations (under International Law) of two occupied countries’? He asked me which two countries and I replied ‘Iraq and Afghanistan’ sir. Ambassador Burns gave a response backed with UN resolutions which some people call ‘dodgy justifications’. He and others defended the US official policy almost religiously”. | |
On the other hands Pakistani policy makers mostly believe in ‘pay as you go’ or ‘I will always scratch your back even if you are not itching especially if you are from USA’. It is due to the deep roots of US obliged corrupt elite. Pakistan always had a significant role in the strategic designs of the USA in the region. Pakistan’s political, civil, military establishment and influential organised minority groups like Shias, Ismailis, Parsis, and Qadiyanis have always been entwined with foreign agenda for various reasons perhaps their own |
In 43 years 710 Pakistanis visited USA was from 1964-2008, but numbers shot up in 2007-2008 when 207, Pakistanis have visited US under Fulbright scholarship? |
vulnerabilities? According to a US based senior analyst, ‘Zardari regime is a classic example of smooth ‘shia Muslim minority’, rule without even 95% of the people knowing what actually is going on? Get press, media, finance and law in your control and whole state is in your hand. That suits the foreign players including India.” The corrupt regime of Asif Zardari is full of criminals and out laws that is why Pakistan does not have a law minister for the past three months. Why? Farooq Naik was his family lawyer who was first promoted as law minister then chairman of upper house (Senate). Few weeks ago I told him in the House of Lords in London to introduce another NRO so people like his boss can bring their black money back into the country. He said, ‘OK’. Countries where leaders have vision, promote rule of law, invest in education, especially in research and development from bird watching to space travel. Research is an expansive business but some times money can’t buy everything? The best source developed countries can get from developing countries is human resource. Britain is one of the richest countries in research, human resource development, and retaining human resources for generations. That is why a country size of Pakistan is being run by the officials’ rank of a director general or joint secretary? No wonder London is known as junk yard of Pakistani politicians and officials. Public opinion is not in favour of the US policies as religiously followed and adopted by the corrupt elite. US has always had a place in the hearts and minds of the people of Pakistan until after tragic events of 9/11 in which approximately 3000 people died and subsequent killings of millions of people with destruction and displacement in Afghanistan, Iraq and Pakistan. Ironically Pakistani governments and the establishment have always facilitated the US policies? US enjoy this advantage because it has an elaborate plan to ensure its grip on the governing infrastructure of Pakistan. Amongst a number of ostensibly innocent ways to ensure this control two are quite prominent. One is the 'International Visitor Programme and the other is Fulbright Scholarship. Under visit programme, US attracts important / influential members of Pakistani society i.e. politicians, civil/military bureaucrats, journalist, intellectuals etc by offering a visit to US under privileged arrangements. During these visits, required people are spotted and later on engaged to work for both short and long term US interests in Pakistan. It does not end here, later on; these people are also assisted and supported to progress in their fields to reach targeted positions of high value from where they can provide required service to their masters. Every year short listing of the potential individuals is done by the existing sources in respected fields that are duly supervised by US embassy. A complete profile of the short listed individuals is made with special emphasis on strong / weak areas. These areas of the individuals are exploited during their visits / tours to US and they are motivated or forced to work for US interests. Lucrative postings of the armed forces for UN peace missions can be a good networking start for future assets. According to reports, ‘since FATA has become an important area for US, in 2008, five Pakistanis from FATA were selected to go to US where they stayed for almost a month. Baluchistan carries a similar position for US so no wonder US regularly sends short listed Baluch nationalists on these visits. US efforts on Pakistani politicians of the mainstream parties never stop. Currently, more than a dozen sitting MNAs (Members of National Assembly) of leading political parties are on a trip to US. It is interesting to note that most of these MNAs are members of Parliament's Standing Committee for Defence, which indicates that US wants to develop source to keep a closer eye on Pakistan's defence infrastructure including the nuclear asset. According to a senior analyst, “Under Fulbright scholarship, selected students are sent to US under arrangements of The United States Educational Foundation in Pakistan. This programme is funded by U.S. Department of State and offers up to four years of graduate study in the US towards a Ph.D. degree. US provide tuition, books, airfare and a trip back home after two years, a living stipend, and health insurance. In 43 years from 1964 to 2007, total numbers of Pakistanis visited USA was 710 but the numbers shot up in 2007-2008 when 207, Pakistanis have visited US under Fulbright scholarship? These sponsored visits to US cover almost all important fields of Pakistani society which include Armed Forces / civil bureaucracy (both senior and junior levels) religious scholars, politicians, businessmen, media personnel and students”. The beneficiaries of this US patronage, work for their master on long term bases and reach place of strategic value. All the way through, heavy financial rewards and full protection is guaranteed to these individuals in case they are in trouble. One can simply recall a number of journalists, politicians and bureaucrats, who were caught for their wrongdoings but went scot free to the utter surprise of every one. It was known later that US government exerted pressure for such releases. A defence analyst said, “It is quire ironic to note that despite clear service rules and regulations, government departments directly coordinate and process various scholarships and visit programmes. Most of the times no questions are asked before issuing NOCs (no objection certificates) and no debriefings are done on return. It is quite understandable as to why the government does not bother about its officials' visit to US and growing US influence within important government departments as well as society. But if we want to maintain our religious, cultural, social and political integrity, it is very important that Pakistan government should exercise maximum control over the growing US control of the countries”. It would be wise if USA and others connect with the people of Pakistan then recruiting, investing and protecting small ‘chiefs or thieves’. |
|
Congratulation Pakistan
Well done Team
For winning T20 World Cup
For details contact:
Dr Shahid Qureshi
Email: ukcorre...@hotmail.com
Mob: 07764184908b
Old Ravians Association – UK and Europe
Mr. Arshad S. Bokhari (President)
Old Ravians Association UK and Europe
98 Turnpike Link, Park Hill Croydon, CRO 5NY, Surrey, UK
Tel Nos: 0044 (0) 2086803222, 7956819234, 7984453314, 1895850820
E-mails: arshad...@oldravian.com
(Old Ravians are former students of The Government College Lahore (now University) – Pakistan)
for example: Yousaf Raza Gillani, Nawaz Sharif, Zafrullah Jamali, Moeen Qureshi? .....
| |
| |
|
|
|