The marginal identities (individual atma-vigraha's who always have
the choice between the higher bodily self or the lower dream self) have
an eternal bodily individual form as already explained. It must be
emphasized the living entities in their original form in
Goloka-Vrindavan and the Vaikuntha's are not individual sparks of
insignificant light as some Vaishnava scholars propagate. Only in the
sub-conscious dream can ones fallen consciousness appear that way due
to the dreaming projected 'thoughts', called the transmitted
jiva-bhutah or jiva-nikaya consciousness. However, both are only an
illusion facilitated by the sleeping Maha-Vishnu.
This lower self-consciousness firsts manifests as the jiva-bhutah and
then may change to the jiva-nikaya dreamless state if one refuses to
accept the authority of Krishna and keep denying their higher
personified atma-vigraha conscious source. If one refuses to accept the
existence of their Krishna Conscious atma-vigraha body, they will
become fed-up with the impermanent material energy and progress through
a transformation and attain the transmitted jiva-nikaya 'crudely
enlightened' stage of being 'impersonally' liberated into the
Brahma-sayujya (A condition of inactive consciousness). The Mayavadis,
Impersonalists Yogis, Jains and Buddhists hanker after this Impersonal
inactive state of consciousness, who view the self as jiva spark or an
atoms of effulgence merged into the Impersonal Brahmajyoti or, more in
line with their beliefs, they imagine they are only individuals while
embodied and when free from Karma and the cycle of birth and death,
they again merge back into the whole like the air in a sealed container
merges with the all-pervasive air around the pot when it is broken.
There understanding however comes from within the sub-conscious
illusionary realm emanating as delusional dreams from those who forget
Krishna and their own atma-vigraha body. All this illusion is
facilitated by the dreaming Maha-Vishnu because Krishna has empowered
Him to fulfil all of the bizarre desires of those who choose to forget
Krishna. His incredible dreams are also the dreams of the jiva-bhutah
consciousness and their 'conscious' transformation into the
jiva-nikaya Impersonal consciousness that either merges into
Maha-Vishnu's body or the Impersonal effulgence (the causal ocean)
that surrounds it. The glorious of Maha-Vishnu fills volumes of books
and He is only the facilitator of the material universe and the
Impersonal Brahmajyoti. Only in the Universe facilitated by Maha-Vishnu
can one's consciousness 'appear' as an individual atomic spark,
or where one can imagine their consciousness to be all-pervasive and
one with everything. Both conditions are an illusion. These conditions
of deluded states of consciousness is Impersonalism and has nothing to
do with Goloka-Vrindavan reality of Personalism and Perpetual form that
is way, way, way beyond the dream universe over-seen and facilitated by
Maha-Vishnu. We forget the Vedas mostly only deal with the creation of
Maha-Vishnu.
When Srila Prabhupada refers to spiritual sparks, he is referring to
the conditions within the creation of Maha-Vishnu after first appearing
in his creation (specially set up by Krishna to satisfy the mistaken
desires of those who choose to 'consciously' leave/forget their
Krishna Conscious atma-vigraha body (only in a dream state) and
manifest the jiva-bhutah 'material active' conscious state,
followed by jiva-nikaya (Impersonally liberated condition) entering the
condition of no-thought, desires or dreams. All this happens after
sub-consciously leaving (in a dream state) one's atma-vigraha body in
Goloka-Vrindavan. It is very important to understand this. This is an
important realization.
It must be made clear that Srila Prabhpada is referring to Maha-Vishnu
when discussing the creator of the universe that he refers to as the
'cosmic' manifestation.
The Goloka-Vrindavan realm and Vaikuntha planets have no beginning or
end and one can only exist there as a person. Srila Prabhupada
therefore is mostly referring to the material creation and its
Impersonal Brahma-sayujya escape when he says one can appear to exist
as an atomic spark. In reality this condition is an inert state of
consciousness that is also temporary just like the material universe.
Both conditions of consciousness, Personal and Impersonal within and
without the material universe (within the creation of Maha-Vishnu) is
the transmitted consciousness emanating from one real and eternal form
in Goloka-Vrindavan, outside the realm of Maha-Vishnu's jurisdiction
that was long, long, long ago forgotten. Maybe forgotten, but the
connection to who we really are, always exist and can never disappear.
The Vedic texts such as the Srimad Bhagavatam describe that God in His
form of the Primeval 'Maha-Vishnu' lies on the 'causal ocean' and as he
exhales, countless numbers of universes are created from the pores in
His skin. Then as He inhales, they are brought back into His body and
become unmanifest again until the time of His next outward breath. Each
breath is equivalent to many billions of years according to our
calculation.
The first living being created in each universe is called 'Brahma' and
is given the task of creating a diversity of life and environments
within that particular universe. According to people's karma from the
last universe they are put into appropriate bodies in the new one,
anything from being Brahma themselves to being a small ant, and the
cycle continues for infinity. More purified souls are given the task of
stewardship over the existence in a similar fashion to Brahma, and are
known as 'devas' but none have his specific powers.
Maha-Vishnu originates from The Supreme Person (Krishna) - whose abode
is beyond this material world. It is said that the material universes
exist in a small space of an infinite and eternal 'spiritual sky',
known as Vaikuntha. The spiritual sky, Vaikuntha, is beyond our
material conceptions being filled with eternity, knowledge and bliss.
In Vaikuntha it is said that "time is conspicuous by its absence" and
thus there is no creation or dissolution. It is not destroyed when the
material universes become unmanifest, but stays as it is.
In the Sri Caitanya Caritamrita in the Madhya chapter 6, Srila
Prabhupada mainly discuses the activities in the material universe (the
cosmic manifestation) in relation to Maha-Vishnu and Krishna's Lila
within Maha-Vishnu's jurisdiction, Lord Caitanya and His devotees who
'appear' to come to the material universe to help the fallen, it is
all Lila for them because the choice to leave Goloka-Vrindavan is a
conscious choice made by the living entities who want to exist
independent from Krishna. When they again desire to be Krishna
conscious, Krishna sends His devotees to fill the role that facilitates
their desire to again begin to remember their 'old original
consciousness' in the mood of loving reciprocation with Krishna, Lord
Caitanya and His dear devotees (one never leaves physically Krishna
Lila) This is very difficult to understand if one is not Krishna
Conscious.
Achintya-bhedabheda-chintya set of guidelines: - Lord Caitanya*
disproved all kinds of non-spiritual and non-Vaishnavite system of
belief and established the crucial philosophy of Vedic Religion through
His spiritual principle known as 'Achintya Bhedabheda', which
explains that, - Krishna and the individual atma-vigraha's or
atma-jivas are quantitatively distinct and qualitatively
indistinguishable with each other. Krishna is infinite, atma-vigraha's
are infinitesimals, this is the principal distinction between the two.
In the matters of identity, they both are spiritual in nature with
eternal form and personality. Lord Caitanya established that, the
individual atma-vigraha's are the eternal servitors of Krishna.
Forgetfulness of the Lord transforms their awareness down to the jiva-
bhutah consciousness undergoing worldly sufferings through repeated
births and deaths. Lord Caitanya propagated Sri Krishna Nama Sankirtan
(congregational chanting) as the Yuga-Dharma for the present age
Kaliyuga, which when adopted in holy association and good conduct,
shall bestow 'Divine Love' which is the highest summum bonum for
the trapped jiva-bhutahs. Lord Caitanya generously distributed this
exceptional treasure of divine love to one and all without any
discrimination. The generosity of Lord Caitanya knows no bound,
therefore He is known as the all-benevolent Lord. Everyone who came
across the Lord became influenced and marvelled. Those who desire to
achieve the highest well being of human life and reawaken their old and
original Krishna Consciousness should whole-heartedly follow the
instructions of Lord Caitanya and adore Him through Krishna Nama
Sankirtana in close association with the pure devotees of Lord Sri
Caitanya Mahaprabhu.
It is said the Brahma-sayujya or Impersonal Brahmajyoti is on the edge
of the material universe and one attains that condition by merging into
the outer bodily effulgence of Maha-Vishnu. Krishna's transcendental
body (vigraha) is eternal, full of knowledge and bliss. Sat means ever
existing for all time and in all places; in other words, all-pervading
in time and space. Cit means full of knowledge. Krishna has nothing to
learn from anyone, he is the knower of everyone. He is independently
full of all knowledge. Ananda means the reservoir of all pleasure and
vigraha means eternal bodily form. The impersonalists are seeking to
merge into the Impersonal Brahman effulgence of eternity and knowledge,
but they avoid the major portion of the absolute pleasure, which is in
Krishna. One can enjoy the transcendental blissfulness of merging into
the Impersonal Brahman effulgence after being freed from the
contamination of material illusion, false identification, attachment,
detachment and material absorption. These are the preliminary
qualifications of a person who can realize Brahman. It is stated in
Bhagavad-gita that one has to become full of joyfulness; this is not
exactly joyfulness, but a sense of freedom from all anxieties. Freedom
from all anxieties may be the first principle of joyfulness, but it is
not actual joyfulness. Those who realize the self, or become
brahma-bhuta, are only preparing themselves for the platform of
joyfulness. That joyfulness can be actually achieved only when one
comes into contact with Krishna. Krishna consciousness is so complete
that it includes the transcendental pleasure derived from impersonal
Brahman realization. Even the impersonalist will become attracted to
the personal form of Krishna, known as Syamasundara.It is confirmed by
the statement of Brahma-samhita that the Brahman effulgence is the
bodily ray of Krishna; the Brahman effulgence is simply an exhibition
of the vigour of Krishna. Krishna is the source of the Brahman
effulgence, as He Himself confirms in Bhagavad-gita. From this we can
conclude that the impersonal feature of the Absolute Truth is not the
ultimate end; Krishna is the ultimate end of the Absolute Truth. The
members of the Vaishnava schools therefore never try to merge into the
Impersonal Brahman effulgence in their pursuit of spiritual perfection
nor do they believe they originated from there. They accept Krishna as
the ultimate goal of self-realization. Therefore Krishna is called
Parambrahman (the Supreme Brahman) or Paramesvara (the supreme
controller). Sri Yamunacarya has prayed as follows: "My dear Lord
Krishna, your Maha-Vishnu creates the cosmic manifestation, I know that
the gigantic universe and gigantic space and time within the universe
are covered by the ten layers of the material elements, each layer ten
times larger than the previous one. The three material modes of nature,
the Garbhodakasayi Vishnu, the Kshirodakasayi Vishnu, the Maha-Vishnu,
and beyond them the spiritual sky and its spiritual planets, known as
Vaikunthas, and the Brahman effulgence in that spiritual sky - all of
these taken together are nothing but a small exhibition of Your
potency".
"Those who attain 'brahma-sayujya' liberation cannot gain entrance into
Vaikuntha; their residence is outside the Vaikuntha planets." (Caitanya
Caritamrta Adi Lila 5:31.).
"Outside the Vaikuntha planets are the atmosphere of the glowing
effulgence, which consists of the supremely bright rays of the body of
Lord Krona." (Caitanya Caritamrta Adi Lila 5:32.)
"That region is called Siddhaloka, and it is beyond material nature.
Its essence is spiritual, but it does not have spiritual
varieties."(Caitanya Caritamrta Adi Lila 5:33.)
"It is like the homogeneous effulgence around the sun. But inside the
sun are the chariots, horses and other opulence's of the sun-god."
(Caitanya Caritamrta Adi Lila 5:34.)
Srila Prabhupada: - "Outside of Vaikuntha, the abode of Krishna, which
is called 'paravyoma', is the glaring effulgence of Krishna's bodily
rays. This is called the 'brahmajyoti'. The transcendental region of
that effulgence is called Siddhaloka or Brahmaloka. When impersonalists
achieve liberation, they merge in that Brahmaloka effulgence. This
transcendental region is undoubtedly spiritual, but it contains no
manifestations of spiritual activities or variegated ness. It is
compared to the glow of the sun. Within the sun's glow is the sphere of
the sun, where one can experience all sorts of varieties."(Caitanya
Caritamrta Adi Lila 5:34.
To further make this clearer, it is not the same Brahmajyoti-Personal
effulgence of Krishna where the Vaikuntha planets exist that surround
Goloka-Vrindavan that is mostly talked about in the various Vedic
scripts. The Brahmajyoti talked about in The Nector of Devotion and the
Madhya Chapter of the Caitanya Caritamrita is the bodily glare of
Maha-Vishnu Personal form. This is confirmed by Srila Prabhupada: -
"According to the Brahma-Samhita, there are infinite numbers of
planets, all these infinite universes with their infinite planets
within are floating on and are produced from the Brahman effulgence
emanating from the transcendental Maha-Vishnu, who is worshiped by
Brahma, the presiding deity of the universe in which we are
residing". (How this happens is explained on page 148).
In this way, one can enter this Brahmajyoti effulgence emanating from
Maha-Vishnu or even merge ones consciousness (jiva-nikaya) into His
body, not by leaving or renouncing the material universe, but by rather
changing ones material addicted consciousness, to a non-creative
dormant Impersonal inactive consciousness. It is this Impersonal
consciousness that Srila Prabhupada sometimes refers to as
'individual atomic spiritual sparks' however as Srila Prabhupada
said: -
"Because he (the living entity) falls down from Brahma-sayujya, he
thinks that may be his origin, but he does not remember that long,
long, long, long before that even he was with Krishna".
The living entities are also known as jiva-sakti, which also means the
marginal atma-vigraha's however, it must be made clear that Krishna
(the Supreme Atma-Vigraha Lord Krishna) and his marginal living
entities (individual atma-vigraha's) have bodily form eternally that
is naturally Krishna Conscious.
The marginal conditions of the atma-vigraha's means the living
entities can waver or fall (only in a conscious dream condition) from
their higher consciousness (always existing as perpetual form) and
forget their atma-vigraha body, just as one forgets their present body
while dreaming. The real body still exists while the sub-conscious
dream condition only creates illusion after illusion.
In this way, the dreaming consciousness becomes the lower self in
defiance of its higher self's perpetual form that continues to exist
in Goloka-Vrindavan regardless. The lower self therefore is the
transformation of being consciously aware of ones atma-vigraha body, to
forgetting that it exists altogether. Along these lines, one's
existence is never diminished and just continues to exist in that
forgetful consciousness in another dimension within the material
impermanent universe. Ones thoughts have simply changed from thinking
of and serving Krishna, to thinking of satisfying ones self without
Krishna. This is how the jiva-bhutah conscious comes into being. The
words 'transmitted consciousness' is used to separated the real
from the imaginary however, it is only a figure of speech in this
thesis for communicating the separation of consciousness from being
aware of ones Krishna Conscious atma-vigraha body, or forgetting it and
creating the material universal dreams, all facilitated by Maha-Vishnu
and his Vishnu expansions - all expansions of Lord Krishna.
Technically it is all going on in the same space just as ones dreams at
night are all happening within your dreaming body. This is very
difficult to comprehend. As will be explained in detail later, Krishna
in His Personal Goloka-Vrindavan form only rarely has anything to do
with the material universe and its Impersonal escape, which is all a
dream anyway. Krishna leaves all that in the hands of His Maha-Vishnu
expansion. It is therefore Maha-Vishnu who facilitates those who want
to merge their consciousness into an imaginary stage of non-existence.
This can be done in two ways, merging into Maha-Vishnu's bodily
effulgence or into His body however, just like the material universal
dream one is trying to escape from, both methods of Impersonal
liberation are also a dreaming illusion outside the realm of
Goloka-Vrindavan and the Vaikuntha planets.
The material universe is the invented figment of the non-Krishna
Conscious self that is transmitted as thoughts of selfish dreams when
one's consciousness is no longer Krishna Conscious, or aware of their
Krishna Conscious body.
All souls have the choice (known as jiva-samjnitah or jiva-sakti -
marginal living entities) to be Krishna Conscious as their atma-vigraha
bodies serving Krishna, or can drift off into an unconscious dream
state of forgetting Krishna and create their own existence known as the
material universe. Margin can also further mean one can go one-way or
the other, either to remember Krishna and ones eternal body, or forget
Krishna and dream-up unlimited counterfeit bodies. This is again
similar to dreaming at night in your present body, the body goes
nowhere while the imagination fantasizes itself everywhere within the
confines of the material universe that includes that universes
Brahma-sayujya escape.
The Sanskrit word jiva has over 170 different meanings, each describing
a different level of the lower self's sub-conscious dream state while
trapped in the ethereal and biological illusory vessels within the
material dream. Atma-vigraha's are also known as jiva-tattva's which is
a further Sanskrit expression that refers to the original atma-vigraha
body. The atma-vigraha (jiva-tattva) is the true status of the living
entity, which is eternal bodily form, while the transpositional
jiva-sub-conscious illusionary creations and impermanent fantasies are
ones forgetful consciousness that appears in many dream states. All the
following versions of the Sanskrit word jiva are different expressions
of ones sub-conscious illusionary dream state: - jiva-bhutah,
jiva-nikaya, jiva-samjnitah, jiva-kosah, jiva-vinirmukayh jiva-kita,
jiva-sakti, ksudra-jiva, ei-jiva, jiva-adhame, jiva-hana, jiva-rupa,
jiva-paya, vyatha-jiva, mara-ami-jiva, jiva-dehe, brahma-adi-jiva,
ksudra-jiva, ajna-jiva, jiva-abhimana, etc. The universe of both
material and impersonal existence only exists within the confines of
Maha-Vishnu's creation. This is confirmed in the Srimad Bhagavatam
2.5.33
"Thus when all these became assembled by force of the energy of the
Supreme Personality of Godhead, this universe certainly came into being
by accepting both the primary and secondary causes of creation".
Srila Prabhupada: - In this verse it is clearly mentioned that the
Supreme Personality of Godhead exerts His different energies in the
creation; it is not that He Himself is transformed into material
creations. He expands Himself by His different energies, as well as by
His plenary portions. In a corner of the spiritual sky of brahmajyoti a
spiritual cloud sometimes appears, and the covered portion is called
the mahat-tattva. The Lord then, by His plenary portion as Maha-Vishnu,
lies down within the water of the mahat-tattva, and the water is called
the Causal Ocean (Karana-jala). While Maha-Vishnu sleeps within the
Causal Ocean, innumerable universes are generated along with His
breathing. These universes are floating, and they are scattered all
over the Causal Ocean. They stay only during the breathing period of
Maha-Vishnu. In each and every universal globe, the same Maha-Vishnu
enters again as Garbhodakasayi Vishnu and lies there on the serpentlike
Sesha incarnation. From His navel sprouts a lotus stem, and on the
lotus, Brahma, the lord of the universe, is born. Brahma creates all
forms of living beings of different shapes in terms of different
desires within the universe. He also creates the sun, moon and other
demigods.
Therefore the chief engineer of the material creation is the Lord
Himself, as confirmed in the Bhagavad-gita (9.10). It is He only who
directs the material nature to produce all sorts of moving and
nonmoving creations.
There are two modes of material creation: the creation of the
collective universes, as stated above, done by the Maha-Vishnu, and the
creation of the single universe. The Lord does both, and thus the
universal shape, as we can see, takes place.
The meaning of nitya - siddha.
The nitya-siddha personality, identity and form refer to ones original
Krishna Conscious body that is always there in Goloka-Vrindavan (Gods
Kingdom) and can never fall down however, souls fall down into material
existence, how can us conditioned souls (lower conscious self)
understand this apparent paradox of existing in two places at the same
time?
The answer is not simple however, try to understand that it is ones
forgetfulness of Krishna that instantaneously formulates the
altered-state sub-consciousness called the jiva-bhutah which is the
fallen (non-Krishna conscious) state of consciousness, or the lower
self that has the ability to manifest itself as multiple counterfeit
identities through numerous ethereal and biological vessels within the
material universe. These bodies are created by desires and thought and
eventually ones consciousness becomes so entrenched they no longer know
who they really are and loose their independence under the confines of
karma. The sub-conscious dream world is not a free for all; it operates
under strict laws of cause and effect (karma). This is referred to as
the law of nature.
The jiva-bhutah's ethereal and biological consciousness, as well as
its material lifeless surroundings (which is made up of the fossilized
lifeless shells left over from their biological possession establishing
the fact that all inert matter originates from life) comes under the
jurisdiction of Krishna's independent marginal identities, it is
their creations that generate the material universe. Krishna does not
do this directly because He is too busy with His loving devotees in
Goloka-Vrindavan however, because everything is His creational dream,
which is a result of the independence of His marginal individuals,
everything is facilitated by His Maha-Vishnu expansion as already
explained, He allows the phenomenon of the material universe to exist
given that some desire to split 'consciously' from their
atma-vigraha body and go it alone. In that way Krishna does not
interfere with those desires. Further more Krishna does not want to
upset His devotees in Goloka-Vrindavan/Vaikuntha, so he expands Himself
as Maha-Vishnu who's sleeping dreams are the bizarre heavenly and
horrific realities of those who choose to forget Krishna.
Even though ones consciousness can split into Krishna Consciousness or
material consciousness, both originate from the source of their
marginal identity, which is the atma-vigraha body however, one can only
choose to be one or the other. As already explained, marginal means one
is eternally an independent identity from Krishna, that
'independence' further has the ability to choose to be dependant on
Krishna, or forget Krishna altogether and do your own thing. Krishna
does not interfere with that choice, yet is always sending His devotees
into the dreaming dimension in an attempt to remind the fallen souls of
their eternal home and wake up from the dream they have carved out for
themselves.It must be understood the Spiritual Universe is unchanging
and never ending, where everything is alive with individuality,
identity and personality. There is no such thing as a Spiritual atomic
spark in the devotional Spiritual realm of Goloka-Vrindavan or
Vaikuntha because every living entity has an atma-vigraha body.