Fwd: How has the CES helped you? (Levies to be charged)

3 views
Skip to first unread message

Chris Caston

unread,
Aug 10, 2010, 10:01:37 PM8/10/10
to perth-e...@googlegroups.com
Hello,

I got the following from the CES mailing list.

Any have any thoughts? I did suggest a fund raising for their server but it didn't end up happening.

best regards,

Chris

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Community Exchange Network <ad...@community-exchange.org>
Date: Tue, Aug 10, 2010 at 10:32 PM
Subject: How has the CES helped you? (Levies to be charged)
To: pc...@community-exchange.org


Community Exchange Network Update
10 August 2010

This Update is an occasional letter from the Administrator of the Community Exchange Network

Dear Perth Community Exchange,

How has the CES helped you?

Dear administrators and users of the exchange,

Just over 6 years ago a friend introduced me to the Talent Exchange and I went along to my first market bearing herb cuttings from my garden.  I was impressed by the expected honesty in the hall.  Everyones' wares laid out, a trading sheet on the table and you just wandered up, filled in your account number and a description of the goods you had helped yourself to.  It felt free and easy and happy, lots of love and laughter, a brand new way of doing money.

Since then I have become the biggest earner and spender on the exchange.  I make it work for me.  I have a disability, so shopping and getting out and about have been difficult.  I can still drive, so now I can shop with real people from my car or at a market day.  I can pay people to help me rather than having to take advantage of my friends.  I have made a huge new circle of friends.  I have become exceedingly generous, as CES credits are so easy to earn and have to be spent.  I no longer have to listen to my father's voice in my head talking about 'hard-earned money' and 'save for a rainy day', and 'money doesn't grow on trees'.  This is heart money.  The more you give the more you get back in return.

When I needed a wheelchair, one came on offer on the exchange. When I needed an electric disability scooter, one came on offer on the exchange.  When I got my new service dog and wanted to reward my trainers and the staff at the training centre (they were not allowed to accept money) I gave them gift vouchers for a treatment at the local spa, which accepts CES credits.   The Community exchange has enriched my life, has led me into the poorest of the poor and the richest of the rich areas and everywhere in between.

I have subsequently become a board member of the CES, I am the steward of the Cape Town exchange and administrator of most of the South African exchanges.  I have now become aware of the vast amount of resources that have been put into this system by a very few individuals.  I really do feel it is time that everyone contributes.

In order to maintain the system, monthly expenditures and large once off expenses still need to be paid for.  We have ongoing expenses in the form of banking fees, internet bandwidth, web-hosting and we need to raise money for a new computer server.  In South Africa a portion of our levies goes to the central exchange GLOG0000.  This has up to now been on a donation basis.  There is a donation button on the front page of the web site.  A huge thank you to those individuals and exchanges that have been contributing.

It was decided a while back, in January 2009, that all exchanges around the world should contribute via levies.  This is now finally going to be implemented from the end of September 2010.  1% of your trade will need to be paid over to the CES.  This can either be paid in your local currency (CES credits) from levies or, if you do not have levies, in your fiat (national) currency, or you may elect to do a mixture of the two.

Should you decide to make payment in fiat (national) currency you will need to do so physically at a bank and make a foreign exchange payment to:

Bank: Nedbank
Branch: Rondebosch
Branch address:
Shop 2, 2nd Floor, Rondebosch Village, 51-58 Main Rd, Rondebosch, 7700, South Africa
Branch tel no: +27 21 658 4160
Branch code: 10480911
Swift code: NEDSZAJJ
Account number: 1048086712
Type: Nedbank Current Account

The Directors
Community Exchange Systems
B8 Linden Park
Liesbeek Road
Rosebank
7700
South Africa

Let's enrich our own lives and the lives of everyone around us through our use and maintenance of 'heart' money.

Sincerely,
Dawn Pilatowicz
Board Member - Community Exchange Systems
da...@ces.org.za


__
To stop receiving these updates please log into your account here, check 'Stop Updates' and press the [Update Record] button.

Community Exchange Network Administration
Email: ad...@community-exchange.org
Web: www.community-exchange.org

This web service is provided by the Community Exchange System (CES)


ne...@mail.org

unread,
Aug 12, 2010, 12:05:40 AM8/12/10
to perth-e...@googlegroups.com
Hi,
I don't mind paying a bit, but it may put off new members.
Please let me know and I will make the payment.
Thanks.

Ted Russ

unread,
Aug 12, 2010, 3:23:50 AM8/12/10
to perth-e...@googlegroups.com
As a newer member - I have to say that it's not been wildly successful for me, and any further levies or fees would see me walk.  There isn't much traffic I can see, there's very little new membership uptake, and I've had greater success at commercially-run sites.  I gather there's a levy on our transactions already, and now to be asked to either pay a currency fee or a further levy is just not sound economics.  I imagine that most of us are here because of a need to be frugal and economical, not out of any altruistic desire to support and save a software application.

To date, (about five months if my memory serves me well) CES has given me one purchase (but which was very useful) and one sale. (Which became a barter and so went off the books, leaving me in nett debt.)  In the same timespan, I've sold, traded, bartered, and received - about three dozen transactions in total.  To achieve that I've used only two other free of charge trade / classifieds systems, and the old "back fence" barter method.  It hasn't cost me any fees.  

I consider myself an average user, and if my experience is anything to go by, CES will not get much traction for such fees and levies...

--
ted.
"Paddle faster, I hear banjos!"

angie lyndon

unread,
Aug 12, 2010, 9:19:12 PM8/12/10
to perth-e...@googlegroups.com
Are you sure it is not from NIgeria??  I think all Lets type systems should be autonomous and not have financial ties to anywhere else  Not necessary or customary

 ange

--- On Thu, 12/8/10, ne...@mail.org <ne...@mail.org> wrote:

Chris Caston

unread,
Aug 12, 2010, 10:13:21 PM8/12/10
to perth-e...@googlegroups.com
This is the thread on the ning site that was asking for money for the server:


That is my one worry about CES it could start off as all open and radical but then just become another trade association with cash fees.

I think we need some further clarification from them on this subject. 

At the same time Perth Community Exchange doesn't need to be stuck to CES we can move to different systems. CES is all centralised to South Africa and runs on Windows servers. It's really some quite outdated technology but it does keep
the task of running an exchange that can trade with other exchanges much simpler. 

 We can even setup our own server and install open source LETS software like cclite.


best regards,

Chris

Trevor Holland

unread,
Aug 12, 2010, 11:53:19 PM8/12/10
to perth-e...@googlegroups.com
Ohhhh ... Thank You Chris!  :)
NOW I remember how much your efforts as our system administrator are appreciated.

I've been delaying my reply as I prepared a suggestion to go for an open source alternative and have struggled to find one. At first glance, the CCLite system of Chris's latest message looks good.
In the short term we probably don't need to make the switch .... our trading value is quite low at the moment so the 1% levy of that is virtually nothing.

Longer term, I have difficulty with any closed source system because their ideal start-up ethos tends to get corrupted over time. Open source systems have the BIG advantage that if corruption does show up, members (users) are always able to "fork the code" and begin anew without needing to start from scratch. Very quickly one sees that the most ethically and justly administered systems attract the most trading, and those who have "lost their way" tend to wither and die, but the movement goes on and the zeitgeist remains.

The best thing seems to be to stay focused on the key asset of the trust level that we build with each other rather than worry too much about which accounting system is being used, but steadily move toward the one that works best with this group's core values. To that end, the core of ANY currency system (alternate OR legacy) is trust or credit-worthiness. That gets built quicker with lots of trading, but it can also happen via these frank and open discussions right here.

CES were supposed to be going Open Source but as they chase revenue streams then an Open Source version will get much lower priority, even being seen as a financial threat probably. I for one will be watching closely, happy in the knowledge that we can move to Open Source for our subset of CES when and if we need to.

I'm glad to be part of this group!

best regards
Trev
--
Trev Holland
+61 403 078 661
www.hypertrike.org
LoGo "Courier" # US-051
     .-.
     /v\    L I N U X
    // \\  >Phear the Penguin<
   /(   )\
   ^^-^^

Ted Russ

unread,
Aug 13, 2010, 12:51:21 AM8/13/10
to perth-e...@googlegroups.com
Yayyy Chris!  I didn't realise we could cut adrift like that and still be able to trade with other LETS schemes. 

What sort of horsepower would a local server require?  Cos I have an (admittedly old) PC tower form factor machine, dual (old, so prolly only 1GHz or so) Xeons server grade motherboard, 1Gb RAM, and SCSI controllers with an auxilliary IDE, works fine except all my SCSI drives I've had have been flogged to within an inch of their lives and I've chucked them all as they started developing huge error rates... 

It used to run VMware on RHEL, with a couple of VMs actually doing the heavy lifting, I used it as my home server, and various dev/test machines as needed.  Also, something like a LETS box can surely be run on Joomla or Xoops these days, I'm sure there are extensions for them? Cos that way, I can help with the admin work a bit.  I worked as a system and network admin for about 12 years before I retired and have managed to install a couple of Mambo and Xoops CMSs to play with since.

I'm happy happy happy to help out if we can push PCEX and get it running successfully, maybe if we do a local server we could consider also putting in an anonymous open membership for anybody at all to trade/swap same way as Gumtree does, then if they want something a member is trading for CX, we can get them into full memberships?  It would at least get traffic up, the classifieds and freebie sites seem to get plenty... 

Rack space, I think if you know anyone at any business in Perth that has a decent link and a server room we should ask them to support LETS by donating a power point and a network port...  We'd be very low bandwidth, after all, and just take up one line in their router tables...  

So if we do decide to do this, I'm happy to help out.  One proviso - I'm hoping to move a bit further out towards Bakers Hill so I'd have to be doing remote work and our coverage area would have to expand a bit so that I can still use it... %)

--
ted.
0409 249 807 mobile
On the 'net:  http://www.zencookbook.com/ http://tedalog.blogspot.com/ http://facebook.com/teddlesruss/
http://www.feedblitz.com/f/f.fbz?Sub=245899 - Go here to subscribe to a newsletter of all my articles!

"Paddle faster, I hear banjos!"


Chris Caston

unread,
Aug 13, 2010, 4:19:06 AM8/13/10
to perth-e...@googlegroups.com
Hi Russ,

If we are going to run cclite we have a few choices for example running it on a physical server a a member house. For example I have Amnet ADSL with a static IP and we could run it from here.
There other choices could be co-location or setting it up on a virtual server for example one of the amazon EC2 solutions. The EC2 solution will still cost us money but will be more reliable e.g. we don't need to worry about having a UPS. 

We could also asking PLUG (Perth Linux User Group) mailing list.

It would be best to use Debian as the cclite packages are .deb files.

best regards,

Chris Caston


Chris Caston

unread,
Aug 13, 2010, 4:19:26 AM8/13/10
to perth-e...@googlegroups.com
Debian or Ubuntu server

angie lyndon

unread,
Aug 13, 2010, 8:56:50 AM8/13/10
to perth-e...@googlegroups.com
the old freo system ran on a programme specially developed by one of the members called unnat [spiritual name]  and it was fine  i have not got his number but i can get it
it worked well for a long time - just they could not get anyone to do the admin when the last person got tired of it...............  i was living interstate when it  closed-   it used to have regular meetings where people got to see and trust each other or not which kept it going


 ange

--- On Fri, 13/8/10, Ted Russ <teddl...@gmail.com> wrote:

Timothy White

unread,
Oct 8, 2010, 6:37:53 AM10/8/10
to perth-e...@googlegroups.com
> We could also asking PLUG (Perth Linux User Group) mailing list.

I would happily run something on my VPS colocated in Perth (same as
one of PLUG's server). As long as it's not a memory hog or anything.
My preference for software on my VPS is PHP based software, as then I
don't need to install anything extra. As long as I can run cclite
through an Apache Vhost, then I've got not problems hosting it.

Even though I've now "left" the Perth CEX, I still wish to be involved
in it in what ever way I can (those not part of PLUG, I have moved to
QLD).

I also don't agree with the fee's being talked about.

Thanks Chris for your hard work.

Tim

Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages