Sreepalan VC
unread,Jan 29, 2009, 9:34:39 PM1/29/09Sign in to reply to author
Sign in to forward
You do not have permission to delete messages in this group
Either email addresses are anonymous for this group or you need the view member email addresses permission to view the original message
to peacethr...@googlegroups.com, jain...@yahoogroups.com, quest4ete...@yahoogroups.com, jain...@yahoogroups.com, jains...@yahoo.co.uk, kund...@yahoogroups.com, tamil...@yahoogroups.co.in, jain...@yahoogroups.com, jain...@gmail.com, Sum...@yahoo.com, csmahe...@yahoo.com, sat...@yahoo.com, Maha...@telus.net, jai...@hotmail.com, rkeer...@yahoo.com, swar...@singnet.com.sg, jayasr...@yahoo.com, rameshbh...@gmail.com, rames...@hotmail.com, csp...@hotmail.com, esams...@suryaconsulting.net, madhukara...@yahoo.co.in, ajith...@gmail.com, asoma...@gmail.com, raju...@rediffmail.com, madh...@hotmail.com
Samyak Darshan
Dear Shri Sanjay Jian,
Let soul secure Samyakthva.
‘Vathu Sahaavo Dhammo’ – Veer Vaani - 'Nature of substance is Dharma'.
Ask thou, thou shall be given; knock thou and thou shall be heard.
‘Know thyself and be thyself’ – Achaarya Shri Kund Kund Dev.
Sub: Art of Living
Ref: Thursday, January 22, 2009 8:30 PM
Quite an analysis, it is that helps to understand the realities of living and pursue the path of liberation.
Well, on the concept of nischaya and vyavahaar there appears to be some cloud of confusion, it is opined.
Nischaya and vyavahaar are two sides of a coin, any doubt?
Absence of nischaya there is no independent vyavhaaar.
Only when nischaya is finalized vyavhaar follows suit. If one wishes to go to ‘Shri Sammed Sikar’ that one has to climb the hill, right. The nischaya is the top of the hill and vyavahaar is steps that start from the bottom of the hill to the top. If there is no wish to go to top of the hill, then there is no need for climbing steps. And if one has to go to top of the bill, climbing the steps is a must, right.
If one feels that but for the steps, that one cannot reach the top of the hill and stays in the steps themselves, then he cannot reach the top of the hill, right. Therefore, necessarily one has to leave the steps, if that one has to enter into the top of the hill.
Steps are part and parcel of the hill trip. They are not made just for that individual but as a pilgrimage centre the steps form part and parcel of the hill. Both the top of the bill and the steps neither invite any one nor obstruct any. They are passive substances functioning ceaselessly.
After reaching the top of the hill there is neither nischaya nor vyavahaar, any doubt.
Vyavahaar is ever changing and temporary whereas nischyaa is permanent and never changing. That which is changing from the truth point of view is untrue or false.
Now your valued statement:
Quote: I say..everythin here is said from vyvhaar view-point only. But whentaking the nischay to consideration.. the vyvhaar stands false. So maybe we should understand the nischay view-point...because by that only our vyvhaar would be said to be true.. otherwise they are false only. unquote.
Analysis:
From the brief information stated herein above, if acceptable or otherwise too, vyavahaar is always impermanent and changing one and hence untrue and false. Vyavhaar is passing or fleeting one and it a tool only to understand the nischaya. Its birth is simultaneous but known or understood only immediately after nischaya.
Vyavahaar is paryaaya – momentary expression or modification - and may be true for that fleeting moment as change is incessant.
Barring the above mentioned point of difference, the write up is well thought out and rendered for the benefit of the valued participants.
Learned Dr Shri C Devakumar Jain in his mail has given importance to the known phenomenon i.e., moha – delusion, raaga – likes and dhvesha – dislikes which are to be distanced by the aspirant to reach the goal of ending the cycle of birth and death. Such an attempt by him is for those who have not entered into the portals of passionless Jina Dharma and are unfamiliar to it; besides carrying passionate concepts as worship worthy. By and large the mundane souls are passionate and hence Dr. has preferred to present it in that fashion.
Thanks for providing an opportunity to dwell in Dharma Dhyaan and of course, it is also a cause for inflow of karma as it is shubha bhaava.
Attempt made to present the best known and it is likely that it may be falling short of one’s expectation and information. It is earnest and sincere request to bring out the defects and insufficiencies thereby help understanding better.
Welcome for any further clarification.
Truth is of Kevalin and the rest are mine.
Wishing you all the best for the early dawn of Samykathva.
Now, it is, for the participants to come up.
Yours brotherly,
Sreepalan
--- On Thu, 1/22/09, sj <
jain...@gmail.com> wrote: