On Thu, Nov 11, 2010 at 1:36 PM, nischmi
<nico.schmi...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Hi.
> I want to ask what is the "Reserve" - function. Is it an actual lock
> which disallows other users from changing things in the tile, or is it
> just a graphical marker which shows other people that someone is
> working on the tile? If yes, can several people reserve the same tile?
The "reserve" function is just a way to show other people in the area
that this tile area is currently being edited (in an OSM editor) by
someone else.
This just helps prevent conflicts (which I always find annoying) and
double work. This can be helpful when running mapping parties for
instance.
There's no lock on the area, either on OSM or on QSM.
> Are there any plans for further developments, aside from the issues
> listed in the google code repository?
Yes, definitely.
I'm just temporarily out of time (var Alice = new Baby({age: "2 months"})).
>Will there be more input
> possibilities, e.g:
> - Method of how something was checked (e.g. on-site check, checked
> against other data source, guessed ...)
> - not clear which aspects have been checked: e.g. was the geometry
> (locational accuracy) or the attributation or the connectivity
> (topology) of the highway network checked?
At the beginning, I wanted to do a very simple app, with only three
basic "survey criteria" (namely: "highways", "buildings" & "landuse").
Then, people asked for more criteria. As a result, I recently added
(nearly) all tag keys.
Now, other people say that it gets difficult to find a key and set it.
So I don't really know for sure in which direction this app should go
: either simplicity or complete framework for evaluation of OSM data.
At the very early beginning of the app, I was thinking of a way to
allow people to create their own "quality map". A "quality map" would
be defined by an extent, a survey tile width (currently roughly 1 sq
km, which is too much for urban areas), a list of criteria, and of
course its own URL.
Me being lazy, and the success of the app not garanteed, I first
wanted to try something easier. That is the reason why there currently
is a single map across Europe.
As multiple expectations for this app are coming to light these days,
I think we should get back to the code, and improve it so that my
first idea comes to life.
As a remnant of this first idea, there's a "map" table in the SQL
schema (http://code.google.com/p/osmqa/source/browse/trunk/sql/osmqa.sql#1),
which currently has a single entry.
> Are you interested in collaboration, contribution in this direction?
I definitely seek collaboration.
The direction needs to be discussed ;-)
> Kind regards
Thanks for your feedback.
I'd be interested to hear about what other people in this list think of this.
F.