It is important for me to know how frequently you were watering these
plants and how you did it (soaking in a bucket, pouring a little water from a
watering can, taking it to the sink and so on. It is also important to know what
size pot the plants were put in and if the potting mix was changed.
Mushy dropping leaves is generally indicative of a bacterial or fungal
disease, which may or may not have anything to do with what your sister (or
you) did; though using old (used and dirty) pots, or bruising the plant (especially if your hands
are dirty from other garden tasks) could have introduced infection. It may well
have picked up a pathogen at the store from which you bought it, especially "big
box stores". Generally there is no remedy for this sort of thing, but an
understanding of how you cared for the plant may help me to assure it does not
happen again.
Sincerely,
Dennis