Sent from my iPhone
Opti does not make the charger. (at least for the 850). I can get one for $50 on line, $160 from opti.
> I doubt the charging profile from the charger will make much of a difference in battery life.
Opti's old charger ran at a reduced voltage, thereby slowing the (voltage dependent) permanent capacity loss that lithium ion batteries experience with time. Mil spec li-ion systems use the same strategy to get extended service life. I don't know whether the new chargers operate at custom voltages (mine says 40V, compared to the 40.4+/-2V for the stock charger you found), but I highly recommend confirming this before possibly compromising battery life and voiding the warranty.
I don't see any problem with this, but your charger will take significantly longer than Opti's due to its lower current limit. Also I can't rule out the possibility that changing the charger may interfere with cell balancing.
> It is a standard lithium charger. They all run at a lower current, not voltage!, near the end of the cycle.
> Its a poor man's technique for blind balancing. The lower current will prevent fully charged cells from rupturing while still providing some charge to the slower cells.
That is absolutely false. Trickle charging is great for lead acid cells, and is commonly used on nickel batteries, but it absolutely won't work on Opti's batteries. Lithium ion batteries like Opti uses must be balanced actively - during the constant voltage phase of the CC/CV charge cycle. They do not have the ability to lose charge internally and would be destroyed if trickle charged.
It sounds like you don't know what you are talking about. I know enough about the care and feeding of these batteries to question your advice (I don't know that it is harmful, but it might be), and recommend that other Optibike owners make darn sure they have the correct charger before connecting it to their $2000+ battery.
> Not sure but I don't think Raul mentioned "trickle charging". He did say that lithium chargers run at a lower current near the end of the charge cycle. Having observed OptiLink, I can confirm that this is the case...it drops increasingly to under 0.5A from memory. I DO agree that you should definitely be very sure before trying an off-the-shelf charger.
I don't know what else he could have been referring to when he wrote about "a poor man's technique for blind balancing." Suggesting that "blind balancing" is somehow related to the drop in current as the constant voltage charge phase progresses is nonsensical. Opti has done a lot orR&D to get to where they are battery system wise. I'm just saying check with before taking the word of our friend Raul as solid advice.
> I'm still sure the opti charger is off-the-shelf.
You do understand that Opti has a history of ordering custom programmed chargers from this company, right? A CC/CV charger has at least three parameters: CC current, CV voltage, and CV cutoff current. You've check that two agree according to the label, I recommend verifying the chargers are compatible.
Tikit | ![]() ![]() |
Sent from my iPad
On Dec 31, 2011, at 11:44, Tikit <mb.t...@gmail.com> wrote:
> So... Opti had overnighted the new charger...
>
> ... and...
>
> ...wait for it...
>
>
>
>
>
> It works perfectly! Thank you everyone for all the great input and
> teaching! Thank you Nicholas for the quick vacation turnaround, and
> finding the one carrier who would overnight the package on New
> Year's! What a great group!