An interesting idea for Diplomacy: A nuclear weapon trade-off to end the war in Ukraine

2 views
Skip to first unread message

Ellen Thomas

unread,
Jul 22, 2022, 7:51:03 AM7/22/22
to NucNews
PNND Update
Read this in your browser
In this update:
  • US Congressional Letter: Diplomatic solution to the Russia/Ukraine war.
  • A Bold Idea: A nuclear weapons trade-off to end the war?
  • Reminder: Abolition 2000 Annual Meeting, Saturday January 23.

Dear Ellen Thomas,

On July 19, United States Congressmember Pramila Jayapal released an Open letter to President Biden on Support for Diplomacy to end the Ukraine war!, and circulated it to other Members of Congress to sign on. The letter condemns Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, expresses concerns about the conflict potentially escalating and risking the use of nuclear weapons, and urges the Biden administration to pursue all possible diplomatic avenues to support Ukraine in achieving a peaceful, negotiated settlement to this war and avoiding an open-ended conflict.

Washington Physicians for Social Responsibility have set up an action page for US citizens to encourage their congressional representatives to endorse the Open Letter.


A bold idea: A nuclear weapons trade-off to end the war

On July 19, The Hill published Nuclear strategy and ending the war in Ukraine, a very interesting article by Oscar Arias, Nobel Peace Laureate and former President of Costa Rica; and Jonathan Granoff, PNND Council Member and President of the Global Security Institute.

Mr Arias and Mr Granoff propose that the United States and NATO "plan and prepare for withdrawal of all U.S. nuclear warheads from Europe and Turkey" as a way to "get Putin’s attention and bring him to the negotiating table" and possibly agree to end the war.

It's a very interesting and bold proposal that could possibly work. It would allow Putin a way to end the invasion by claiming domestically (to Russians) that he had scored a victory - the elimination of US nuclear weapons in Europe. At the same time it would not diminish the security of NATO countries wihch ascribe to nuclear deterrence, as such deterrence does not rely on the US nuclear weapons being based in Europe.

According to the two authors "NATO’s nuclear arsenal failed to deter Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and has almost no utility as a weapon of war. But NATO’s nuclear weapons can still be put to good use, not by threatening to launch them and escalate the war, but by withdrawing them to make room for new negotiations and eventual peace."
Jonathan Granoff and Oscar Arias, authors of Nuclear strategy and ending the war in Ukraine, in which they propose a trade-off of removing US nuclear weapons in Europe as part of negotiations to persuade President Putin to end the invasion of Ukraine.

Abolition 2000 Annual Meeting: July 23

Nuclear disarmament in the wake of the Russia/Ukraine war

We cordially remind you of the annual meeting on Saturday July 23 of Abolition 2000, the global civil society network to eliminate nuclear weapons (and end war). PNND and Abolition 2000 are affiliated networks, cooperating on a number of projects. (See PNND Report to the Abolition 2000 Annual Meeting).

Everyone is invited to attend. The Annual Meeting will include:
  • campaign updates and reports;
  • a strategy discussion focusing on how the Russia/Ukraine war effects peace and nuclear disarmament work;
  • movement building.
It will be held in multiple sessions at different times to enable your participation regardless of where you reside and in which time-zone you will be on Saturday.
 
Register for the Abolition 2000 Annual meeting

Yours sincerely
Alyn Ware
PNND Global Coordinator
On behalf of the PNND Coordinating Team

Parliamentarians for Nuclear Non-Proliferation and Disarmament (PNND) is a global network of legislators working on a range of initiatives to prevent nuclear proliferation and to achieve a nuclear weapons free world.

www.pnnd.org
www.facebook.com/pnndglobal
in...@pnnd.org


 You are receiving this email as a partner, cooperating organisation or friend of PNND.

Parliamentarians for Nuclear Non-Proliferation and Disarmament (PNND)
PNND Head Office - Basel Peace Office
University of Basel, Petersgraben 27
Basel 4051
Switzerland
PNND Head office
PragueVision Institute
Lipsanka 4, 130 00 Prague
Czech Republic
Phone: +420 773 638 867

Prague Europe Office
Basel Peace Office
c/o Seminar für Soziologie
Petersgraben 27
CH-4051 Basel, Switzerland
Phone: +41 788 912-156
 
PNND United Nations Office
220 East 49th Street, Suire 1B
New York, NY 10017, USA
Phone: +1 646 289-5170
Fax: +1 646 289-5171
 

Virus-free. www.avg.com
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages