The NJ Transit train to Port Jervis is out of service due to the hurricane. I took a look, and there is a Coach USA/Shortline bus out of Port Authority that takes you only 5 blocks away from our hotel. Bus times are 10, 2:30, 3:30, 4:35, 5:35, 7, and 11 PM. The bus ride is approximately 1:50 mins from the Port to Port Jervis. Fare is 22.50. There's also a bus from Ridgewood NJ (near Paramus) at 7:32 pm.