Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

(Dialog) Truncate multiple %newsgroups%

1 view
Skip to first unread message

Lars Anders

unread,
Jan 24, 2022, 10:58:25 PM1/24/22
to
Is there commands to list easy only a _first_ newsgroup in a followup?

Assume Dialog is set to following setting.
Follow-ups to post: On %date%, %from% wrote in %newsgroups%:\n
Date format: d mmm yyyy

If three newsgroups are exist, the result is long too much.
On 24 Jan 2022, A B <a...@gmail.com> wrote in
alt.newsgroup.one,alt.newsgroup.two,alt.newsgroup.three:

I ask for only _first_ newsgroup listing, as in the example next.
On 24 Jan 2022, A B <a...@gmail.com> wrote in alt.newsgroup.one:

Is there a _easy_ way to get Dialog to auto-truncate newsgroups?

Bernd Rose

unread,
Jan 25, 2022, 12:38:56 AM1/25/22
to
I only can think of parsing and altering the content of the reply in an
OnBeforeSendingMessage event script.

Moreover, you probably wouldn't want the /first/ group, anyway, but the
group you directly wrote the reply in. (To indicate the newsgroup, you
are most likely to read any follow-ups in, if you send your answer to
multiple groups, as well...)

In most groups most messages are dedicated ones and not cross-posts.
In each such message mentioning the originating newsgroup in the intro
attribution line is (IMHO) pointless, because the readers of the OP as
well as the readers of your reply /do/ know, which group they currently
reading.

And in cases of crossposts, the leading group (if any) should be denoted by
setting an appropriate follow-up header. This /should/ also be mentioned
somewhere in the answer, itself. (Usually directly above the signature.)
Because there's no way to know, which group you'll regard as main target
(possibly not the one you are writing the answer in), this can not really
be automated.

Therefore, I suggest you leave the %newsgroups% list from attribution,
altogether, and only add such information manually in cases, where this
seems appropriate or even necessary.

HTH.
Bernd

Lars Anders

unread,
Jan 25, 2022, 2:05:16 AM1/25/22
to
On 25 Jan 2022, Bernd Rose <b.rose...@arcor.de> wrote in
news.software.readers:

> Therefore, I suggest you leave the %newsgroups% list from attribution,
> altogether, and only add such information manually in cases, where this
> seems appropriate or even necessary.

Thank you for your kind help.
I understand every point you maked.
The OnBeforeSendingMessage is not easy for me.
That is OK.
I will remove the %newsgroup% after this reply to you.
Bernd, Thank you!
0 new messages