RFD: soc.culture.punjab.moderated moderated

[Afzal Upal]

REQUEST FOR DISCUSSION (RFD)
moderated group soc.culture.punjab.moderated

This is a formal Request For Discussion for the creation of the
moderated newsgroup soc.culture.punjab.moderated. This is not a Call
For Votes (CFV). Note that this is a proposal for a NEW newsgroup,
and does not affect the change the working of newsgroup
soc.culture.punjab in any way.

Newsgroup line:
soc.culture.punjab.moderated About Punjab, Punjabi and Punjabiat. (Moderated)

RATIONALE: soc.culture.punjab.moderated

The Punjabi community worldwide numbers more than 110 million. There
is a strong need on the usenet to have a newsgroup devoted to
discussing issues of interest to Punjabis everywhere. An unmoderated
newsgroup soc.culture.punjab (SCP) exists but ever since its creation
in September 1994, signal to noise ratio on SCP has been hopelessly
bad. soc.culture.punjab has been infested by reckless cross-posting
from almost all newsgroups related to South Asia, and occasional
crossposting from numerous other newsgroups.

Moderating soc.culture.punjab will result in unmanageable load of
heated debates upon moderators. Therefore, a new newsgroup
soc.culture.punjab.moderated is proposed.

Moderated newsgroup soc.culture.punjab.moderated is envisioned as a
newsgroup devoted to serious and informative discussions about Punjab
and its cultural heritage. It is hoped that with a panel of
moderators, the newsgroup quality will be better than that of
soc.culture.punjab.

CHARTER: soc.culture.punjab.moderated

soc.culture.punjab.moderated is intended to provide a forum for
disussing issues relevant to Punjab, its culture, its language, its
people and its history in a moderated environment. Political
discussions about Punjab as a part of India or Pakistan will be
discouraged given the availability of more relevant newsgroups
soc.culture.pakistan, soc.culture.indian and soc.culture.punjab. The
postings to be carried by soc.culture.punjab.moderated must be of
interest to both Indian and Pakistani Punjabis. Moreover, debates
about religion will also be discouraged, given the presence of
soc.religion.hinduism, soc.religion.islam, soc.religion.sikhism and
other soc.religion.* newsgroups. However, serious, flame-free
discussions about development of religion in Punjab will be
acceptable. Articles and discussions about the Punjabi diaspora and
informative articles about Punjabi culture around the globe will be
accepted.

Moderation Policy:

It is the moderators' responsibility to ensure that postings are
free from verbal abuse and personal attacks. Article content will be
the sole criterion of judgement. Authorship will not be a criterion
for any decisions.

Articles for soc.culture.punjab.moderated must be:

1. Relevant to the newsgroup Charter.
2. Written in non-abusive language.

There will be no other criteria for moderation decisions.

END CHARTER.

MODERATOR INFO: soc.culture.punjab.moderated

Newsgroup Forwarding Site: punja...@acpub.duke.edu
Moderator Contact Address: punja...@acpub.duke.edu

Moderator: Muhammed Afzal Upal <up...@cs.ualberta.ca>

Afzal is Doctoral candidate in computer science at University
of Alberta, Canada.

Moderator: S.V. Jagannath <ja...@ctr.columbia.edu>

Jagan is a recent PhD graduate from Columbia University and works
as a research engineer in BayNetworks Inc. in Billerica, MA, USA.

Moderator: Mandeep Singh Sandhu <san...@lucent.com>

Mandeep is a software engineer with Lucent Technologies - Bell Labs
in New Jersey, USA.

END MODERATOR INFO.

PROCEDURE:

This is a request for discussion, not a call for votes. In this phase
of the process, any potential problems with the proposed newsgroup
should be raised and resolved. The discussion period will continue
for a minimum of 21 days (starting from when the first RFD for this
proposal is posted to news.announce.newgroups), after which a Call For
Votes (CFV) may be posted by a neutral vote taker if the discussion
warrants it. Please do not attempt to vote until this happens.

All discussion of this proposal should be posted to news.groups. This
RFD attempts to comply fully with the Usenet newsgroup creation
guidelines outlined in "How to Create a New Usenet Newsgroup" and "How
to Format and Submit a New Group Proposal". Please refer to these
documents (available in news.announce.newgroups) if you have any
questions about the process.

DISTRIBUTION:

This RFD is being posted to the following newsgroups:
news.announce.newgroups, news.groups, soc.culture.punjab,
soc.culture.pakistan, soc.culture.indian, soc.culture.indian.info
(moderated) bit.listserv.pns-l (moderated),
soc.religion.sikhism (moderated)

In addition, it is being posted on the following two (2) mailing lists:

u...@cs.usask.ca [United Punjab Club]
pakp...@mit.edu [Discussion of issues related to Pakistani
Piunjab]

Proponent: Muhammad Afzal Upal <up...@cs.ualberta.ca>

[Christopher B. Stone]

In article <8511254...@uunet.uu.net>,
Afzal Upal <up...@cs.ualberta.ca> wrote:

> REQUEST FOR DISCUSSION (RFD)
> moderated group soc.culture.punjab.moderated

Looks good; I'll be voting for the group.
--
Chris Stone * cbs...@princeton.edu * http://www.princeton.edu/~cbstone
"In the long history of the world, only a few generations have been
granted the role of defending freedom in its hour of maximum danger.
I do not shrink from this responsibility. I welcome it." -JFK

[Rajinder Nijjhar]

In message <8511254...@uunet.uu.net>
Afzal Upal <up...@cs.ualberta.ca> writes:

> <up...@cs.ualberta.ca>

Yes. I support such a group and those who incite people in the name
of religion should be barred. People like Rajwinder Singh, who is
the noderator of the Soc. SIKHISM speaks non-sense and full of the
sectarian tune whereas in his own NG, he would not tolerate people
like me who try to rectify their views in humbleness. Most importnat
is this that this Rajwinder Singh claims to be a Jat of high class,
but what comes out of his mouth is all KAMINAA not worthy of a Jat.

We should if possible form a Jat NG that should cover all Jats from
the United Panjab but that will not be tolerated by the Lalas. Never
mind, but keep your surnames at the end of names for identification a
I and you do.
--
Chaudhry Rajinder Nijjhar M.Sc.,
A Jat of Pandori Nijjhran, the Panjab,
Retired Senior Lecturer in Metallurgy,
Mussallman of Pir Nanak Shah, INSHALLAH.
DUNIA MARAE YA JEEVAE; SUTHHRA GHOL PITASAE PEEWAE:
gno...@zetnet.co.uk

The gnostics are the living christs(satgurus) of the Living God, PAAR
BRAHM. Say ALLAH HOO AKBAR.

They go by the holy spirit, SURTTI, and they do not follow the
"letters" of the Holy Books blindly. They themselves being solitary
and FREE in spirit, do not take any body for his words but rather
discuss "Logo" through "logical" reasoning, VICHAAR. Their motto is
ASK, SEEK AND KNOCK.

"HOLY SPIRIT SHATTERS THE FETTERS OF THE LETTERS"

[Robert Craig Harman]

Afzal Upal wrote:
>
> REQUEST FOR DISCUSSION (RFD)
> moderated group soc.culture.punjab.moderated

This group has my support.

--
Robert Craig Harman En France, appelez 01 39 76 68 84 pour
BYU Chemical Engineering recevoir un Livre de Mormon gratuit...
Master's Candidate
LDS France Paris Mission http://www.et.byu.edu/~harmanr/mission.html

[Joe Bernstein]

In article <8511254...@uunet.uu.net>, Afzal Upal <up...@cs.ualberta.ca>

wrote (and I snip without further notice):

>MODERATOR INFO: soc.culture.punjab.moderated

>
>Moderator: Muhammed Afzal Upal <up...@cs.ualberta.ca>
>

>Moderator: S.V. Jagannath <ja...@ctr.columbia.edu>

>
>Moderator: Mandeep Singh Sandhu <san...@lucent.com>
>

>END MODERATOR INFO.

Given that this proposal concerns a moderated soc.culture.* group for a
South Asian region, there's next to no chance that the debate won't focus
on this section of the RFD. I don't know the net presence of these three
individuals, but note the pleasant surprises their surnames offer.

That said, it would be desirable to have an explicit provision for the
replacement of moderators, partly because such a provision would establish
clearly whether or not this diversity of the panel is expected to last.

This is *very* pleasingly blunt. The only thing I'm not crazy about is
that it doesn't explicitly address cross-posting. However, *if* the
moderators in fact enforce the charter with care, that won't matter much.

On the whole, this RFD has previous soc.culture.* RFDs I've read whupped
for sheer competence, with the notable exception of the current proposal
for soc.culture.african.american.moderated. I look forward to this debate.

Joe Bernstein
--
Joe Bernstein, writer, banker, bookseller j...@sfbooks.com
speaking for myself alone http://www.tezcat.com/~josephb/
But...co-proponent for soc.history.ancient, now back under
discussion in news.groups!

[bill...@primenet.com]

LAST CALL FOR VOTES (of 2)
moderated group soc.culture.punjab.moderated

Newsgroup line:
soc.culture.punjab.moderated About Punjab, Punjabi and Punjabiat. (Moderated)

Votes must be received by 23:59:59 UTC, 11 Mar 1997.

This vote is being conducted by a neutral third party. Questions about
the proposed group should be directed to the proponent(s).

Proponent: Muhammad Afzal Upal <up...@cs.ualberta.ca>

Mentor: none
Votetaker: Jeremy Billones <bill...@primenet.com>

RATIONALE: soc.culture.punjab.moderated

The Punjabi community worldwide numbers more than 110 million.
There is a strong need on the usenet to have a newsgroup devoted to
discussing issues of interest to Punjabis everywhere. An unmoderated
newsgroup soc.culture.punjab (SCP) exists but ever since its creation
in September 1994, signal to noise ratio on SCP has been hopelessly
bad. soc.culture.punjab has been infested by reckless cross-posting
from almost all newsgroups related to South Asia, and occasional
crossposting from numerous other newsgroups.

Moderating soc.culture.punjab will result in unmanageable load of
heated debates upon moderators. Therefore, a new newsgroup
soc.culture.punjab.moderated is proposed.

Moderated newsgroup soc.culture.punjab.moderated is envisioned as a
newsgroup devoted to serious and informative discussions about Punjab
and its cultural heritage. It is hoped that with a panel of moderators,
the newsgroup quality will be better than that of soc.culture.punjab.

CHARTER: soc.culture.punjab.moderated

Soc.culture.punjab.moderated is intended to provide a forum for

disussing issues relevant to Punjab, its culture, its language, its
people and its history in a moderated environment. Political
discussions about Punjab as a part of India or Pakistan will be
discouraged given the availability of more relevant newsgroups
soc.culture.pakistan, soc.culture.indian and soc.culture.punjab. The
postings to be carried by soc.culture.punjab.moderated must be of
interest to both Indian and Pakistani Punjabis. Moreover, debates
about religion will also be discouraged, given the presence of
soc.religion.hinduism, soc.religion.islam, soc.religion.sikhism and
other soc.religion.* newsgroups. However, serious, flame-free
discussions about development of religion in Punjab will be
acceptable. Articles and discussions about the Punjabi diaspora and
informative articles about Punjabi culture around the globe will be
accepted.

* MODERATION POLICY:

It is the moderators' responsibility to ensure that postings are
free from verbal abuse and personal attacks. Article content will be
the sole criterion of judgement. Authorship will not be a criterion
for any decisions.

Articles for soc.culture.punjab.moderated must be:

1. Relevant to the newsgroup Charter.
2. Written in non-abusive language.

There will be no other criteria for moderation decisions.

END CHARTER.

MODERATOR INFO: soc.culture.punjab.moderated

Moderator: Muhammad Afzal Upal <up...@cs.ualberta.ca>

Moderator: "S.V. Jagannath" <ja...@ctr.columbia.edu>
Moderator: Mandeep Singh Sandhu <san...@lucent.com>

Administrative contact address: punja...@acpub.duke.edu
Article submission address: punja...@acpub.duke.edu

END MODERATOR INFO.

HOW TO VOTE

Erase everything above the top "-=-=-=-" line and erase everything
below the bottom "-=-=-=-" line. Do not erase anything between these
lines and do not change the group names.

For each group, place a YES or NO in the brackets next to it to vote for
or against it. If you don't want to vote on a particular group, just leave
the space blank. Don't worry about spacing of the columns or any quote
characters (">") that your reply inserts.

Send MAIL to: vot...@clark.net
Just Replying should work if you are not reading this on a mailing list.

-=-=-=-=-=- Don't Delete Anything Between These Lines =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
soc.culture.punjab.moderated Ballot <SCPM-0002> (Don't remove this marker)

Give your real name here:

[Your Vote] Group
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
[ ] soc.culture.punjab.moderated
-=-=-=-=-=- Don't Delete Anything Between These Lines =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-

You may also ABSTAIN in place of YES/NO - this will not affect the outcome.
Anything else may be rejected by the automatic vote counting program. The
votetaker will respond to your received ballots with a personal acknowledge-
ment by mail - if you do not receive one within several days, try again.
It's your responsibility to make sure your vote is registered correctly.

One vote counted per person, no more than one per account. Addresses and
votes of all voters will be published in the final voting results list.

VOTING PROCEDURE NOTES:

Standard Guidelines for voting apply. One person, one vote.
Votes must be mailed directly from the voter to the votetaker.
Anonymous, forwarded or proxy votes are not valid; this includes
votes generated by WWW/HTML/CGI forms.

Vote counting is automated. Failure to follow these directions will
mean that your vote does not get counted. Duplicate votes are
resolved in favor of the most recent valid vote. Addresses and votes
of all voters will be published in the final voting results post.

The purpose of a Usenet vote is to determine the genuine interest of
persons who would read a proposed newsgroup. Soliciting votes from
disinterested parties defeats this purpose. Please do not
redistribute this CFV. If you must, direct people to the official CFV
as posted to news.announce.newgroups. Distributing pre-marked or
otherwise edited copies of this CFV will result in those votes being
cancelled. When in doubt, ask the votetaker.

Common errors include quoting the entire article and sending your vote
to the vote-takers personal address. Either of these two could result
in your vote not being counted.

DISTRIBUTION:

This CFV has been posted to the following newsgroups:

Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups
soc.culture.indian
soc.culture.indian.info
soc.culture.pakistan
soc.culture.punjab
soc.religion.sikhism

This CFV has also been forwarded to the following mailing lists:

Mailing list name: United Punjab Club
Submission address: u...@cs.usask.ca

Mailing list name: Pakistan Punjab Discussion Forum
Submission address: pakp...@mit.edu

soc.culture.punjab.moderated Bounce List - No need to revote
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
a...@draziw.com Ryan
G.D....@dundee.ac.uk Dr. G.D. Singh
kdha...@coewl.uiuc.edu Kanwar Dhaliwal
sh...@emanon.net Dan Birchall
tjas...@kibo.us.oracle.com Tom Jaskiewicz

[bill...@primenet.com]

RESULT
moderated group soc.culture.punjab.moderated fails 113:70

There were 113 YES votes and 70 NO votes, for a total of 183 valid votes.
There was 1 abstain and 73 invalid ballots.

For group passage, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid (YES and NO)
votes. There also must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO votes.

There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted.
Unless serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the group may
not be voted on again for six months.

Newsgroup line:
soc.culture.punjab.moderated About Punjab, Punjabi and Punjabiat. (Moderated)

Proponent: Muhammad Afzal Upal <up...@cs.ualberta.ca>

RATIONALE: soc.culture.punjab.moderated

CHARTER: soc.culture.punjab.moderated

* MODERATION POLICY:

END CHARTER.

MODERATOR INFO: soc.culture.punjab.moderated

END MODERATOR INFO.

soc.culture.punjab.moderated Final Vote Ack

Voted Yes
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3a...@qlink.queensu.ca Andy Lehrer
4h...@qlink.queensu.ca Harjinder Sahdra
aca...@paknet1.ptc.pk Zahid Hussein
A...@infonet.tufts.edu Toni Passano
akg...@plg.uwaterloo.ca anil k goel
akha...@worldbank.org A. Khawaja
al...@micro.lucent.com Irfan Ahmed
ana...@rpi.edu Harpreet Singh
ap...@mail.wdn.com Mahmood Raza Tariq
aps...@calum.csclub.uwaterloo.ca Amrit Singh
ari...@taronga.com Stephanie da Silva
az...@lafn.org B. Thober
bain...@unbc.edu Deepinder Kaur Bains
ba...@yallara.cs.rmit.edu.au Jaspreet Singh Bains
ba...@pender.ee.upenn.edu Azhar Basit
b...@herbison.com B.J. Herbison
bop...@students.uiuc.edu Sanji Boparai
bor...@nortel.ca BORIS SLOBODKIN.
bri...@nortel.ca Brindarjit Gill
br...@kenosis.com Bruce Baugh
bs...@cs.virginia.edu Bhupinder Singh Sethi
cbs...@phoenix.Princeton.EDU Chris Stone
chau...@epix.net Nazeer A. Chaudhry
cro...@eno.Princeton.EDU Scott Cromar
c...@sitar.jazz.att.com Charan bhatia
cwi...@CapAccess.org Carl Wilson
daljee...@tempe.vlsi.com Daljeet Sidhu
DEEPINDER...@nt.com Deepinder Singh
dhal...@student.umass.edu DHANJIT SINGH DHALLIWAL
dh...@hq.ctr.vt.edu dhruv nanda
DPAIAC9%WAD...@ADMIN.WMICH.EDU Imtiaz Chaudhary
eut...@siam.muc.de Ekkehard Uthke
G.D....@dundee.ac.uk Dr. G.D. Singh
G.S....@lboro.ac.uk G.S.Samra
Gagande...@ualberta.ca Gagan deep Singh
gma...@mcs.dundee.ac.uk George Mathai
gov...@cfm.brown.edu Govind Menon
gsi...@ford.com Gurinder Pal Singh
gs...@stern.nyu.edu Gurpreet Singh
gsm...@is2.nyu.edu JuNgLisT
gur...@pacbell.net Gurdip Singh Sekhon
gur...@cs.wisc.edu Gurmit Singh Kaleka
ha...@gharib.demon.co.uk Gharib Hanif
he...@ichips.intel.com Heminder Singh
hgr...@leland.Stanford.EDU Harpreet Singh Grewal
hl...@hsc.unt.edu Harbans Lal
hlmi...@acs.ucalgary.ca Heather Michaud
hol...@punjab.bu.edu NARESH SHARMA
ICeK...@aol.com Sundeep Singh
ir...@punjab.bu.edu Irfan Malik
Jagjit.Bas...@nt.com JAGJIT SINGH
jas...@punjab.bu.edu Jasmine Khurana
jas...@punjab.bu.edu Jaspal Singh
j...@rahul.net John David Galt
jiti...@nortel.ca Jitinder Singh
kdha...@coewl.uiuc.edu Kanwar Dhaliwal
koc...@psu.edu Rohit Kochhar
ksi...@chem.bu.edu Kuljeet Singh
mah...@mstf.org Khalid N. Mahmood
mal...@begv.beg.utexas.edu Mohammad A. Malik
mani...@Glue.umd.edu Manish Agarwal
man...@merle.acns.nwu.edu Manjit Singh Mundi
man...@nortel.ca Manjote Sandhu Haworth
ma...@nortel.ca Rajvinder Mann
man...@cisco.com Manveen Kalyanpur
me...@CapAccess.org Manzur Ejaz
mh...@raven.phs.com Mike Hatz
mi...@mnsinc.com Amir Tuteja
mi...@bu.edu Mira Misra
m...@surfer.amc.bell-labs.com Mandeep S Sandhu
na...@mips.pfalz.de Christian Weisgerber
nam...@admin.mcc.mass.edu Marzieh Namazi
nma...@fco-link.columbus.dfas.mil Naseem Majeed
p.k...@utoronto.ca Palvinder Kaur
pam.s...@apics8-haml.org Pam Somers
pa...@byu.edu Robert Craig Harman
pau...@astro.ocis.temple.edu Pam Austin
pa...@cancom.net Trevor Tymchuk
per...@cyberspace.org M. Permar
phe...@MIT.EDU Bilal A. Bhutta
pj...@leicester.ac.uk Pete Humble
pri...@viman.engr.sgi.com Prince Kohli
qa...@goofy.med.uth.tmc.edu Usman Qazi
raj...@sindhu.pp.sci.fi Niranjan Rajani
ra...@bu.edu Rajwinder Singh
ran...@alpo.casc.com Ravdeep S. Anand
ri...@bcm.tmc.edu Richard Miller
ri...@sparc.isl.net CSRihal
ro...@newton.ruph.cornell.edu Rohan Oberoi
sa...@Glue.umd.edu Simarjeet Saini
sara...@ecn.purdue.edu Sarabjit Singh
sba...@fyi.net Sandeep Singh Bajwa
S...@tifrvax.tifr.res.in Sanjay C. Panchal
sha...@access.digex.net Shafqat Khan
sh...@emanon.net Dan Birchall
si...@interlog.com Ontario Sikh Students Association
si...@pyro.ugcs.caltech.edu singh
si...@xraylith.wisc.edu Sangeet Singh
ska...@lsil.com Shekhar Kapoor
sou...@Synopsys.COM Sourabh
sra...@ix.netcom.com Safir H. Rammah
srin...@cs.ualberta.ca Srinivas Padmanabhuni
stephen...@unh.edu Stephen Dunhom
stu...@cosc.canterbury.ac.nz stuart yeates
su48...@uscolo.edu Mohammad Shoaib Sultan
tin...@panix.com Bruce Tindall
to...@null.net Tony Basoglu
up...@cs.ualberta.ca Muhammad Afzal Upal
vik...@hclind.hclc-ggn.hcla.com Vikas Wadhawan
viv...@india.hp.com Vivek Chopra
W.As...@datasci.co.uk Asghar Waseef (MS Mail Dir Sync)
wahe...@osu.edu mian
whi...@MIT.EDU Rajiv Suri

Voted No
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
a...@whq.csar.com Abhijit Dutta
a...@draziw.com Ryan
afa...@brokenarrow.us.itd.umich.edu Andrew Fabbro
agho...@aol.com A. Ghosh Publisher
an...@cadence.com Anand Bemra
Arun.K...@MCI.Com Arun Kankani
ash...@giasbm01.vsnl.net.in Ashok Chowgule
AT...@neu.edu Atul Nagras
aus...@nmu.edu A. Syed
bo...@datasync.com Martin H. Booda
BV_Mura...@3mail.3com.com
dbal...@cs.com Don Ballard
d...@panix.com David W. Crawford
d...@eclipse.keithley.com Keshav Dev
df...@sunset.backbone.olemiss.edu Rajiv Varma
dn...@columbia.edu Dilip Deodhar
dx...@psu.edu Dinesh Agrawal
el...@corinth.alphalink.com Rick Ellis
gan...@hotmail.com S. Chandramouli
g...@cypress.com Gaurang R. Desai / Staff Test Engineer
Ha...@aol.com HAAW
har...@infogain.com Harish P. Hiriyannaiah
hindu...@aol.com Indrasen Sharma
india...@aol.com India Watch
ind...@iastate.edu Indira Shukla
jaga...@us.ibm.com Jagadeesh Chilakapati
je...@intercable.net Jesus Eugenio Sanchez
ki...@netcom.com Kim DeVaughn
kpr...@lsil.com Prasad Kuppa
l...@zk3.dec.com Larry Smith
list-...@dream.hb.north.de Martin Schr"oder
Mano...@MCI.Com Manoj V. Das
mar...@pacbell.net Aaron Marquez
matu...@marlin.navsea.navy.mil Alex Matulich
me...@telconet.com Melvin C. Etheridge
mi...@cactus.org Milan Patel
mi...@churchill.ColumbiaSC.NCR.COM Milan J. Patel
Mo...@aol.com
mvsh...@gsbpop.uchicago.edu Vishal Sharma
nag...@wallop.com Nagaraj Patil
na...@San-Jose.ate.slb.com Ganesh Nayak
ni...@informix.com Nihar Mehta
niha...@ix.netcom.com Ramana Murthy
nti...@ptc.com Nachiketa Tiwari
pa...@lcs.mit.edu Patrick J. LoPresti
pjo...@informix.com Parag Joshi
Raj.Bh...@UC.Edu Raj Bhatnagar
ra...@umevoice.com Narayanan Raju
RAM...@aardvark.ucs.ou.edu Ramdas Vaidyanathan
rich...@vcn.bc.ca Richard Songhurst
rvai...@ATOKA.RE.uokhsc.edu Vaidyanathan Ram
sara...@ix.netcom.com Gopal Saraswat
sch...@andrew.cmu.edu Sandeep Chand
Sh...@Quicklogic.com Shyam Gokalgandhi
spi...@informix.com Santosh Pillai
spi...@zeus.netset.com Suchand Pingli
srinivas....@ccmail.bsis.com Srinivas
srin...@rahul.net B. Srinivas
stai...@bga.com Dwight Brown
sta...@stamper.com Chris Stamper
ste...@magenta.com STella
Subbarao....@Eng.Sun.COM Subbarao Jagannatha
Suresh....@wellsfargo.com Deopura, Suresh
tjas...@kibo.us.oracle.com Tom Jaskiewicz
vembar...@mail.amsinc.com Vembar S. Gopal
vi...@ciocc.arc.nasa.gov V. Narayan
vksh...@acs.ucalgary.ca Vijay Kumar Shrivastava
vs...@VNET.IBM.COM V.Sardesai
z...@cjnetworks.com Ned Fleming
z...@ampersand.com Mark Atwood

Abstained
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dayadee...@ualberta.ca Dayadeep Singh Monder

Votes in error
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
agu...@uceng.uc.edu Amit Gupta
! No vote statement in message
chah...@cps.msu.edu Rajbir Singh Chahal
! No vote statement in message
chau...@students.wisc.edu CHAUDHRI, RAUF, ABDUL
! No ballot
eey...@ftp.netgate.net harmeet Sobti
! No vote statement in message
mah...@worldbank.org Masood Ahmad - SA1AN
! No ballot
oga...@cork.cig.mot.com Jayant Ogale(TCSI)
! No ballot
punee...@ST.COM Puneet Goel
! No vote statement in message
pun...@ix.netcom.com Puneet Bhalla
! No ballot
Shalini...@mackenzie.usask.ca Shalini Mahajan
! No vote statement in message

Votes invalidated due to email campaigning
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ah...@server1.mail.virginia.edu Aisha Hussain
an...@sabretooth-23.Eng.Sun.COM Anil Rai
au...@robinhood.engg.uregina.ca Ahsan Upal
bin...@pop.jaring.my Harbinder Singh
BSMu...@efaches.navfac.navy.mil Balwant Singh Multani
cha...@tfn.com Jasmin Chanana
cha...@ima.umn.edu Sanjay Chawla
ci...@freenet.toronto.on.ca Abdul Jabbar
cks...@is5.nyu.edu Chamanjeet k Sidhu
cs...@informix.com siva nandan
cxw...@s2.cxwms.ac.uk Perbinderpal Singh Grewal
Dayadee...@ualberta.ca Dayadeep Singh Monder
dha...@oitunix.oit.umass.edu Kanwalroop K. Dhanda
dhe...@cs.ualberta.ca Dheeraj Madadi
dhi...@numbat.cs.rmit.edu.au Gurvinder Singh Dhillon
dmat...@mail.chardikalaa.com Dalvinder Singh Matharu
d...@neu.edu Durga P. Choudhury
gko...@us.ibm.com Gurpreet Kaur Koura
gs...@is5.nyu.edu Gurpreet Singh
ha...@madmats.esd.sgi.com Madhsudan Hans
hgi...@widow.aracnet.net Gurmeet Singh
imudi...@otb.com
Info...@aol.com Nagaraj Patil
iza...@pass.wayne.edu Imrana Zaman
j...@netcom.com jai bannur
Jay_Sharma/CDR/BSM/MCI.M...@notes.MCI.Com Jay Sharma
Krishnamurth...@Ebay.Sun.COM Krishnamurthy Woonnimani
ksi...@juno.com Kuljeet Singh Tuteja
ku...@cimar.me.ufl.edu Ramakrishna Kuppa
mah...@worldbank.org Manzur Ejaz
mgan...@UNRAVEL.com Mahes Ram Ganesan
MKVu...@os.varian.com Manoj Kumar Vuriti
msa...@informix.com Mahabala Sastry
msg...@amp.com MANMEET SINGH___________
Muthukumar_Venkatachalam/CDR/BSM/MCI.M...@notes.MCI.Com Muthukumar Venkat
na...@pacbell.net Nachiketa Sharma
p.k...@utoronto.ca Palvinder Kaur
Prakash...@dgii.com Prakash Kamath
psr...@is5.nyu.edu pimpdaddy
R.S...@newcastle.ac.uk R. Singh
RAD...@aol.com Jayshree Radia
ram...@cisco.com Ramesh Srinivasan
Rao...@MCI.Com Darbhamulla K Rao
RDHO...@us.oracle.com Rakesh Dhoopar
re...@orion.neca.com Madhusudan Reddy
Rishi...@ems.prc.com Sher Jung Bahadur Singh Rishi
rsm...@is2.nyu.edu Rajinder Singh Malhotra
S4C...@msg.PacBell.COM Sadashiv C khole
san...@sikhs.org Sandeep Singh Brar
s...@cs.usask.ca Bharadwaj Yadavalli
si...@dakota-75.Eng.Sun.COM Surinder Singh__________
sing...@pilot.msu.edu Deepinder Singh
Sreedhara_Kabam/CDR/BSM/MCI.M...@notes.MCI.Com Sreedhara Kabam
Sridhar_Royaprollu/CDR/BSM/MCI.M...@notes.MCI.Com Sridhar.Royaprollu
ssi...@mb.sympatico.ca Sarbjeet Singh
sza...@hsph.harvard.edu Shella Zaidi
tmah...@gpu.srv.ualberta.ca Tariq Mahmood
vee...@faslab.com Veena Sastry
Venkat...@MCI.Com Venkata Rami Reddy Pindi
vinod_bal...@Claris.COM Vinod Balakrishnan
vso...@husc.harvard.edu Vikaas_Singh_Sohal_
vs...@VNET.IBM.COM V.Sardesai
wah...@indiana.edu Waseem Ahmad
wsi...@sfu.ca Winty Singh

[Ash Nallawalla]

In <8582089...@isc.org> bill...@primenet.com writes:

>Voted No
>------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>vs...@VNET.IBM.COM V.Sardesai

>Votes invalidated due to email campaigning
>------------------------------------------------------------------------------

>vs...@VNET.IBM.COM V.Sardesai

I am not interested in the newsgroup or the usual voting controversies -- but
is there an anomaly above? (I did not check every name on the invalidated
list against the other categories -- this name caught my attention as I
know someone of that name.)

--
PC User Group Leader? See http://www.apcug.org

[Jeremy Billones]

In article <WH-JzAj...@home.melbpc.org.au>,

Ash Nallawalla <a...@melbpc.org.au> wrote:
>I am not interested in the newsgroup or the usual voting controversies -- but
>is there an anomaly above? (I did not check every name on the invalidated
>list against the other categories -- this name caught my attention as I
>know someone of that name.)

As each vote was invalidated, I sent an email to that address informing
them of the reason, and requesting that they obtain a legitimate copy
of the CFV and vote again. Some did so. I should have deleted each
multiple occurence of names (that is, once under Yes or No and once
under invalid), but I did miss (at least) one duplicate.

Jeremy Billones, UVV
bill...@primenet.com

[ukko...@cc.memphis.edu]

In article <8582089...@isc.org>, bill...@primenet.com writes:
> RESULT
> moderated group soc.culture.punjab.moderated fails 113:70

> hindu...@aol.com Indrasen Sharma
> india...@aol.com India Watch

> Mo...@aol.com

What kind of a name is "India Watch" or " "?
I hope votetakers are aware that it is very easy for one to obtain multiple
screen names with a single aol account.

Shelly

[Martin H. Booda]

In article <1997Mar1...@msuvx2.memphis.edu>,

<ukko...@cc.memphis.edu> wrote:
>
>What kind of a name is "India Watch" or " "?

I can vouch for Mr. Watch. His sister, Swiss, is very dependable.
--
Usenet is essentially a HUGE group of people passing notes in class. --R. Kadel
I have been designated by Warren Lavallee to represent 166.57 s.c.i.j-k voters.

[Kulbir Singh]

bill...@primenet.com wrote:
: RESULT

: moderated group soc.culture.punjab.moderated fails 113:70

: There were 113 YES votes and 70 NO votes, for a total of 183 valid votes.
: There was 1 abstain and 73 invalid ballots.

I wanted to vote yes but missed the deadline by one day. Sorry about that.
Can somebody explain to me how the votes are invalidated ? How did they
decide which votes to invalidate ?

Thanks.

regards,

kulbir singh

[Jeremy Billones]

(Followups set to news.groups only.)

In article <5ga2nu$h...@morgoth.sfu.ca>, Kulbir Singh <kbh...@sfu.ca> wrote:
>
>Can somebody explain to me how the votes are invalidated ? How did they
>decide which votes to invalidate ?

Some votes are invalidated for technical reasons - they forgot to
actually put in their vote, or they deleted something the vote tabulating
software needed to count their vote. In those cases, the software
sends an error mesage to the voter, telling them the error and asking
them to vote again, but if they don't then their vote is invalid.

The other class of invalid votes deals with email solicitation. The
CFV is supposed to be obtained by the voter from Usenet, from the votetaker,
or from the votetaker's posting to a mailing list. Unfortunately, it is a
regular occurence that individuals on either side of a vote will email the
CFV (or sometimes just the ballot portion) to a bunch of people they want
to have help them stuff the ballot box. This is not allowed. Any vote
that is based on such an emailed CFV (or portion thereof) is thrown out,
and a note sent to the voter asking them to get a legitimate copy of the CFV
and vote again. (Some do, and those votes are counted normally.)

Jeremy Billones, UVV

[icek...@aol.com]

In article <8582089...@isc.org>, bill...@primenet.com writes:

wow did even one sardar or khalistani vote for no moderation?....it seems like every khalistani and sikh wanted moderation....how many deshibigots are from the above list of no moderation?

Sundeep Singh

[bill...@primenet.com]

RESULT
moderated group soc.culture.galiza passes 380:22

There were 380 YES votes and 22 NO votes, for a total of 402 valid votes.
There were 13 invalid ballots.

For group passage, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid (YES and NO)
votes. There also must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO votes.

There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted. If no
serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the moderator of
news.announce.newgroups will create the group shortly thereafter.

Newsgroups line:
soc.culture.galiza Galicia, on the Iberian Peninsula. (Moderated)

This vote was being conducted by a neutral third party. Questions about

the proposed group should be directed to the proponent(s).

Proponent: Luis A. Perez Carrasco <la...@stir.ac.uk>
Proponent: Xose Manuel Dieguez Perez <jo...@fib.upc.es>
Proponent: Manuel Carro <mca...@fi.upm.es>
Proponent: Xabier Boullon-Agrelo <jjb...@is.nyu.edu>
Proponent: Anxo Sanchez <an...@dulcinea.uc3m.es>
Proponent: Xurxo Duran Laguna <xu...@ires.ucl.ac.be>
Mentor: Mark James <jam...@dialogic.com>
Votetaker: Jeremy Billones <bill...@primenet.com>

RATIONALE: soc.culture.galiza

There is a strong feeling in the Galician community spread all over the
world for the need of a forum where they, and other people, can exchange
information about Galicia, her culture, and the future development of the
country. Although there are presently some mailing lists which have as
discussion topics the Galician language and culture, there is currently no
newsgroup with which Galicians abroad can keep a link with their homeland
for discussing Galician topics in a broad sense. Those discussions would
not be appropriate in a general newsgroup, such as soc.culture.spain,
especially if they are made using Galician, which most Spaniards will not
fully understand. Discussions would take place mainly in Galician,
resorting to Portuguese, English or Spanish if this is needed for a
complete understanding.

A note on the name: "Galiza" was chosen in preference to "Galicia", after
extensive consultations with group-advice and group-mentors, in order to
avoid confusion with the Galicia in Poland.

CHARTER: soc.culture.galiza

The newsgroup soc.culture.galiza is intended for discussion of topics
related to Galicia, Iberian Peninsula: history, current affairs,
future political and economic development, culture and traditions,
language, and relationships with other countries.

Moderation Policy:

Soc.culture.galiza will only employ robomoderation. Human moderation
is NOT included.

1. The robomoderator will screen every article submitted to
soc.culture.galiza. It will unequivocally reject any article
crossposted to four or more newsgroups other than soc.culture.galiza.

2. The robomoderator, when rejecting a submission, shall send the
submission's author a copy of the moderation policy statement and an
explanation as to why the submission was not posted.

3. In case of technical difficulties with the software used for
moderation (see Moderator Info), the contact person will be
Ramon Flores Seija <fa2r...@usc.es>

Amending This Charter:

For the readers of soc.culture.galiza to change or amend this Charter
or moderation policy, a formal RFD followed by a CFV must be posted to
soc.culture.galiza and news.groups. The procedure must follow the
standard guidelines for a newsgroup status change as described in the
news.groups FAQ.

END CHARTER.

MODERATOR INFO: soc.culture.galiza

Moderator: STUMP program <s...@usc.es>
Administrative contact address: scg...@usc.es
Article submission address: s...@usc.es

Robomoderation will be accomplished using the program STUMP, written
by Igor Chudov <ich...@algebra.com>. Information about this program
can be seen at:

http://www.algebra.com/~ichudov/usenet/scrm/robomod/robomod.html

END MODERATOR INFO.

DISTRIBUTION:

These results have been posted to the following newsgroups:

Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,
soc.culture.asturies
soc.culture.basque
soc.culture.catalan
soc.culture.celtic
soc.culture.latin-america
soc.culture.portuguese
soc.culture.spain

This CFV has also been forwarded to the following mailing lists:

Mailing list name: Galicia-L
Submission address: GALI...@LISTSERV.REDIRIS.ES

soc.culture.galiza Final Vote Ack

Voted Yes
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
10074...@CompuServe.COM Antonio Fernandez Lera
7477...@CompuServe.COM Carmen Cibiera
@azca:jmcolina@azca1 Jose Manuel Colina Garea
abr...@cableinet.co.uk PETER ANDERSON
ac...@gnofn.org Alberto Colmeiro
acar...@est-econ.uc3m.es Maria Angeles Carnero Fernandez
ad...@valbuena.fis.ucm.es Francisco Dominguez-Adame
add...@on.the.signature Javier Ramirez
afo...@arrakis.es Anxo Forxan
agt...@pitt.edu Antonio Teixeira
aill...@alum.uax.es Aitor Illarramendi Amilibia.
aja...@arrakis.es =?ISO-8859-1?Q?A._Javier_Fern=E1ndez_Garc=EDa?=
al00...@llevant.uji.es Antonio Adega Salgado
al00...@llevant.uji.es Cristobal Alvarino Galdo
Alain....@nessie.mcc.ac.uk Alain Deckers
alberto...@stud.uni-hannover.de Alberto
alex_...@redestb.es Alejandro LOPEZ NADAL
alex_...@redestb.es Alejandro L. Nadal
all...@readysoft.es Antonio LLanos Alonso
all...@terabyte-sl.es allegue
alm...@mail.telepac.pt Paulo Almeida
alo...@finisterrae.dc.fi.udc.es Miguel A. Alonso Pardo
alo...@rockvax.rockefeller.edu Jose Manuel Alonso Lopez
amlou...@redestb.es Antonio Mantiñán Loureiro
ana.mor...@strath.ac.uk Ana Morandeira Lopez
and...@uvigo.es Nuria Andion Rodriguez
ant...@hpisrhw.cup.hp.com Antoni Drudis
an...@dulcinea.uc3m.es Angel (Anxo) Sanchez
arme...@laas.fr Joaquim Armengol Llobet
asar...@letras.up.pt Maria da Assun=E7=E3o Ara=FAjo
ass.ge...@mail.telepac.pt Manuel Miguez Garcia
at...@redestb.es Xulio López Pérez
ava...@ibm.net Alejandro Varela Sanchez
avel...@unico.udc.es Alberto Veleiro Vidal
Avendan...@msn.com Alberto Avendano
aven...@dataweb.nl Albert Ventura i Amat
az...@lafn.org B. Thober
aze...@scs.leeds.ac.uk Mario Azevedo
ba...@clip.dia.fi.upm.es Daniel Cabeza-Gras
bas...@unico.udc.es Basilio Bernardo Fraguela Rodriguez
bas...@gte.net Maria Rosa Elliott
bau9...@ccsun.strath.ac.uk David.Sanin-leira
ber...@mx0.redestb.es Afonso X. Canosa
bigl...@uvigo.es Jorge Vila Biglieri
bio...@ua.pt Carlos Moreira
bla...@laas.fr Gil Blanch
bo...@pizarro.dia.fi.upm.es Manuel Carro
bre...@arrakis.es breixo
br...@seneca.fis.ucm.es Ricardo Brito
ca...@redestb.es Carlos
cam...@arrakis.es Camilo Regueiro
ca...@tsc.uvigo.es Nicanor Gil Troitino
car...@utu.fi Carlos Amado Losa
carb...@unico.udc.es Marcelino Ladra Gonzalez
carlos...@redestb.es Carlos Lamas Seco
carlos....@stir.ac.uk CARLOS MAZORRA DE QUERO
Carlos.Pin...@cern.ch CArlos.P-P
Carlos...@3mail.3com.com
carm...@sas.upenn.edu Carmen Rio-Rey
ca...@unico.udc.es Carlos Pi#eiro Sanchez
casd...@encomix.es Manuel Casal Lodeiro
cast...@juno.com Alfonso R Castelao
castro...@redestb.es XOAN MIGUEL CASTRO VICENTE
c...@lix.intercom.es Cristina G=F3mez i Morell
ch...@is2.nyu.edu Joseph Chan
ch...@arrakis.es RAMON COLADAS
c...@pobox.com Carlos Hermida
cibe...@unico.udc.es Bertha Guijarro Berdinhas
Clann...@ameritech.net Michael Horan
com...@boats4u.com =?ISO-8859-1?Q?Paco_Comesa=F1a?=
cor...@enxebre.com IVAN ROCHA FREIRE
cpva...@secuslugo.lugo.usc.es Carlos Pérez Varela
cr...@scot.demon.co.uk Craig Cockburn
cr...@iponet.es cris
cse...@donau.boku.ac.at CarlosSEQUEIRAJOSE'
ct...@mail.telepac.pt Maria da Concei=E7=E3o Coelho Tom=E9
cue...@dulcinea.uc3m.es Rodolfo Cuerno
cue...@dulcinea.uc3m.es Jose Antonio Cuesta Ruiz
cur...@tsc.uvigo.es M. Carmen Curras Francos
curs...@sarenet.es Iker Durán
cva...@satlink.com Cesar Varela
dab...@llevant.uji.es Vicent Tarrazona i Rubio
dan...@sol.des.fi.udc.es Daniel I. Iglesia Iglesias
des...@empireone.net Cesar Amicarella
dfde...@alum.uax.es Diego Fernandez Dominguez
d...@asturies.org David Guardado
dra...@worldcom.ch Diego RAMOS
dro...@iaga.com Daniel Antonio Romero Rodríguez
dtal...@usc.es Alba Nogueira Lopez
E.A...@UCG.IE Elena Ayaso
eagl...@usc.es Oscar Rodil
eaxv...@usc.es xavier vence
eco6...@EAST-01.NOVELL.LEEDS.AC.UK Maria Isabel Andrade
ECO...@lucs-01.novell.leeds.ac.uk Eliana Terezinha Pereira Senna
eco...@lucs-01.novell.leeds.ac.uk Francisco Barros Castro
ed...@compuserve.com ENRIQUE DANS
edm...@redestb.es Edmundo Fraga Lopez
edu...@unico.udc.es Eduardo Mosqueira Rey
egim...@uvigo.es EDUARDO L. GIMENEZ FERNANDEZ
ela...@usc.es Francisco Xabier Gsmez Sanz
elbr...@usc.es Javier Diaz Bruguera
elbu...@usc.es Alberto J. Bugarin Diz
elca...@usc.es Carlos Vazquez Regueiro
elc...@usc.es Xose Maria Varela Casal
elcu...@usc.es Carlos Luis Garcia Cuntin
elf...@elf.chalmers.se Manolo Quiroga-Teixeiro
elfx...@usc.es Xulio Fondado Fondado
elju...@usc.es Juan Jose Pombo Garcia
elma...@usc.es Maria Sordo Touza
elp...@usc.es Jose M. Pardo Lopez
elp...@usc.es Pedro Jose Saco Lopez
elt...@usc.es Tomas F. Pena
eme...@rioja.ericsson.se Modesto Garrido
enu...@pescanova.com eduardo
eori...@redestb.es Emiliano Orizales
esca...@mci2000.com Manuel Escand=F3n Bassetti
eso...@unico.udc.es Emilio Saavedra Otero
est...@redestb.es Estanis
est...@arrakis.es =?ISO-8859-1?Q?Estela_Gonz=E1lez?=
est...@papaguena.upc.es Esteve Miralles
es...@redestb.es federico gutiérrez estoa
et...@tid.es Inaki Diaz de Etura
eu.ale...@redestb.es =?iso-8859-1?Q?Mi=F1oca?=
eu...@arrakis.es eueg
eut...@siam.muc.de Ekkehard Uthke
evar...@morfeo.upc.es Evaristo de Frutos Arranz
e...@ppp.nasionet.net Manuel Matalobos y Otero
fa2r...@usc.es Ramon Flores Seijas
faca...@usc.es Carlos Pombo Vidal
fae...@usc.es M. Elena Lopez Lago
fag...@usc.es Eva Acosta Plaza
fago...@usc.es Salvador Bara Vinas
fag...@ix.netcom.com FRANCISCO
faj...@usc.es Jose Ramon Salgueiro
falo...@usc.es M. Dolores Mouriz Cereijo
falo...@usc.es Carlos Montero
falo...@usc.es Raul de la Fuente
fam...@usc.es Humberto Michinel
fan...@usc.es Nicol=E1s V=E1zquez Iglesias
faon...@usc.es Ignacio Rodriguez Martinez
far...@usc.es Carlos Alberto Rega Liste
fasu...@usc.es Susana Rios Rodriguez
fax...@usc.es Jesus Prieto Blanco
fax...@usc.es Xerardo Prieto Estivez
fax...@usc.es Jose Ramon Fernandez Vidal
fca...@apolo.nauta.es Francisco Casal
fca...@fep3.fep.up.pt Francisco Barros Castro
fe...@medicina.ub.es Pedro Feliz Pereira
ffvi...@usc.es Rosa Villar Cordoves
fi...@simpson.tsc.uvigo.es Fidel Pita Sande
f...@tsc.uvigo.es Felix Valado Pomarinho
fjl...@eco.uc3m.es Fuco Xavier Lores
fml...@usc.es Luis Miguel Varela Cabo
fmma...@usc.es Martin Perez
fr...@ucla.edu Frank Henriquez
friv...@arrakis.es Fernando Riveiro Lopez
fs...@usc.es Gonzalo Iglesias
g.ji...@m.landata.es GONZALO JIMENEZ
gabi...@xunta.es Gabinete de Comunicacion da Xunta de Galicia
gabr...@dulcinea.uc3m.es Gabriela Sansigre Vidal
gal...@ksu.edu Pedro L. Muiño
galiz...@juno.com Oneto de Vinhal
gar...@inta.es Jose Garea Loureiro
gazt...@sarenet.es Alejandro Durán
gb...@tsc.uvigo.es Guillermo Briz Blanco
gd3...@glo.be Ruben Van Parys
gmor...@emerald.tufts.edu Gabriel Moralejo Cacheiro
go...@et.ruhr-uni-bochum.de Jose Gomez Dans
Goulven....@ens.insa-rennes.fr Largouët Goulven
gri...@asturies.org CONSTANTINO ALVAREZ-LAFUENTE DELGADO
her...@lords.com Manolo
her...@ctv.es hermida
hlor...@unico.udc.es Henrique Lorenzo Cimadevila
h...@ksu.edu Hema Viswanathan
hol...@usc.es Coqui R. Holguin
hsch...@tiac.net sayra surucu
iage...@usc.es Xerardo Fernandez Alvarez
iam...@usc.es Mario Cal Varela
ian...@usc.es M. Nila Vazquez Gonzalez
IBM3...@globalnet.es Iago Soto
ich...@algebra.com Igor Chudov
IF...@nmsua.nmsu.edu Jonathan E. Davis <if...@nmsua.nmsu.edu>
ipe...@unico.udc.es JOSE ANDRES DIZ ALONSO
ism...@arnal.es Ismael
its...@ksu.edu CHRIS RAUSCH
j-l...@redestb.es Jose-Luis Gonzalez
J...@etsiig.uniovi.es Jose A. Corrales
jag...@CS.UCLA.EDU Juan Carlos Sanchez Agrelo
jal...@ns.inter.edu Jose Alberto Lopes da Silva
jama...@visa.com Martinez, Jose Antonio
jav...@ctr.columbia.edu Javier Zamora
jaze...@individual.EUnet.pt Joao Azevedo
jba...@jet.es Javier Barros Guerton
jbo...@legendnet.net Javier
j...@smd.pt Jose' Bernardo B. R. Silva
jca...@asturies.org Jose Carlos Fernandez Gancedo
j...@rahul.net John David Galt
je...@intercable.net Jesus Eugenio Sanchez
jfr...@iies.es Xavier Franco Sabaris
jhj...@is4.nyu.edu Joseph Jarrin
jim...@cais.com James B. MacGregor
jjb...@is.nyu.edu Xabier X. Boullon Agrelo
jjca...@mail.telepac.pt JOAO CARDOSO
jlva...@arrakis.es =?ISO-8859-1?Q?Jos=E9_Luis_Varela_Tasende?=
jmp...@elrond.uc3m.es Jose M. Sanchez-Pena
jnav...@redestb.es Javier Naveiro
Joao...@mail.telepac.pt Joao Pena
jon...@redestb.es VÍCTOR _ALONSO_RODRIGUEZ
jorg...@satlink.com Jorge Send=F3n<br>If you do =
jose...@arrakis.es Jose Dacal
jose...@zfis.usc.es Vidal Farinha Jose Luis
jo...@fib.upc.es Xose Manuel Dieguez Perez
jose...@arrakis.es Jose M. Rodriguez
josepu...@redestb.es JOSE PUENTES RAMOS
jos...@unico.udc.es Jose Rodrigo Sanjurjo Amado
jpa...@cs.nmsu.edu Jose Ramon Parama
jr...@arrakis.es Moncho Díaz Lombardía
Ju...@casal.demon.co.uk Juan Pampin Casal
j_fer...@breogan.cif.es José Ricardo Rodríguez Ferreira
k...@surfing.net.com Jesús López
karen...@strath.ac.uk David Sanin Leira
k...@CSUA.Berkeley.EDU Kenneth Liao
knoch...@org.chem.ethz.ch Richard Knochenmuss
kqw...@is4.nyu.edu Karen E.Weiner
lal...@zmat.usc.es Leo Alonso
la...@olympus.net Fernando E. Lamas
lan...@tsc.uvigo.es Luis Landesa Porras [ANT]
la...@stir.ac.uk Luis Perez Carrasco
lb...@tsc.uvigo.es Luis Bou
lbo...@redestb.es Luis Bouza-Brey
lca...@simpson.tsc.uvigo.es Luis Canton Blanco
lea...@tsc.uvigo.es Leandro Rodriguez Linhares [GTS]
le...@jet.es Alberto de las Fuentes
le...@psc.edu Juan Leon
lins...@concentric.net Linda K. Sherman
lmir...@brisco.telogy.com Luis Mirantes
lo...@odyssee.net Mel Lopes
lorena...@redestb.es Lorena LOPEZ NADAL
LTor...@Proel.es Luis Felipe Torrente
lu...@fep.up.pt Luis Delfim Santos
lur...@eucmos.sim.ucm.es Lourdes Araujo
lxal...@unico.udc.es Celso Alvarez Caccamo
mab...@columbia.edu Miguel A. Gabian
ma...@morfeo.upc.es MANEL RODERO
mant...@lander.es Domingo Mantilla
manue...@dragonet.es Manuel Gato Pena
man...@poligal.es Manuel Ogando
manu...@uax.es MANUEL MATA PASTOR
ma...@arrakis.es Miguel Anxo Otero Landin
ma...@mail.telepac.pt Mario Oliveira
mar...@vents.uji.es GLORIA MARTINEZ VIDAL
mc1...@ci.uminho.pt Joao Mario Ferradais Fernandes
MCARR...@nexo.es Miguel Angel Carrasco
mca...@mpsnet.com.mx Marilu Casal Vieitez
mca...@fep.up.pt Luis Mota de Castro
mc...@ctv.es MCFA
mco...@tid.es Miguel Conde de Simon
med...@sialpha1.usc.es Julio Balado Lopez
Mercedes_Vidal/BCN/Lo...@lotus.com Maria Mercedes Vidal Sanz
me...@laas.fr Jose Luis Mesas Laserna
mes...@ibm.net Mariano Escayo =?iso-8859-1?Q?Ca=F1edo?=
mgo...@HK.Super.NET Miguel Mario Gonzalez
mgro...@valhall.esrin.esa.it Manuel Vicente Garcia Rodriguez
migl...@iponet.es =?iso-8859-1?Q?M=EDguez?= & Iglesia
mig...@simpson.tsc.uvigo.es Miguel Perez Iglesias
migue...@overnet.com.ar Miguel Angel Fernandez
MJ...@neumann.teleco.ulpgc.es Manuel Jos=E9 Rodr=EDguez Hern=E1ndez
mlp...@arrakis.es Miguel Lopez
mme...@fep.up.pt Maria Margarida Malheiro Queiroz de Mello
mm...@u.washington.edu Manuel M. Paz
moli...@stanford.edu Pablo Molinero Fernandez
mqy...@is2.nyu.edu Mikiko Yamashita
mrm...@usc.es Margarita Taracido Trunk
mrma...@usc.es RAIMUNDO MATEOS ALVAREZ
mrmo...@usc.es Agustin Montes
ms...@dayhoff.med.virginia.edu Maria S. Santisteban
mur...@axturies.tid.es Jesus Murias
mz...@nbnet.nb.ca Monique Zeilinger
nac...@arnal.es Ignacio M=FAgica Fanjul
nda...@interlog.com Nigel David Allen
nfor...@fep3.fep.up.pt Natercia da Silva Fortuna
ni...@uv.es Nilo Casares
n...@ksu.edu Nathan Havercroft
no...@unico.udc.es Xosé Manuel Martínez Filgueira
nop0...@mail.telepac.pt Antonio Belo Nunes
nop0...@mail.telepac.pt Victor
nop1...@mail.telepac.pt Alvaro Augusto Fernandes
np8...@pt.lu Luis Franco
oac...@usc.es Cristina Prieto
ocon...@juno.com Penny M. O'Connor
oct...@secuslugo.lugo.usc.es Octavio Vazquez Sotelo
octa...@peabody.jhu.edu Octavio Vazquez-Rodriguez
ogu...@skyway.usask.ca Oguocha Ike
ol...@ccat.sas.upenn.edu Marta de Olano Vela
ole...@juno.com Alfredo M. Muinho
ore...@samedi.arnal.es Oscar Reixa
oub...@netcom.es Jose Manuel Vaamonde Oubiña
ova...@ctv.es Ovalle - Jose Antonio Rodriguez
pa...@des.fi.udc.es Xoan C. Pardo Martinez
pa...@byu.edu Robert Craig Harman
patoc...@juno.com Patricia O'Connor
paulop...@mail.telepac.pt Paulo Jorge Henriques Pereira

pau...@astro.ocis.temple.edu Pam Austin
pa...@cancom.net Trevor Tymchuk

pbl...@mail2.cti.unav.es BLANCO ARIAS, Patricia
pco...@fep3.fep.up.pt Pedro Cosme da Costa Vieira
pcpb...@usc.es Fernando Diaz Fernandez
pc...@stir.ac.uk Philip C. Scott
phu...@mail.cosapidata.com.pe Patricia Phumpiu
pictoric...@net64.es xesus oscar fernandez gomez
pin0...@pophost.ping.be STEPHANE DOHET
P...@neumann.teleco.ulpgc.es Pedro Manso Carballo
pm...@mat.uc.pt Paulo Melo
psan...@mail.med.upenn.edu PATRICIA V SANCHEZ
psc...@ksu.edu Peter J. Schebler
py...@swansea.ac.uk Esperanza Gomez Martinez
qfj...@usc.es Jose A. S. Moreira
qom...@usc.es Marta Teijeira Bautista
r2005...@abonados.cplus.es Kike Benlloch
rafa...@hotmail.com Rafael Sanmartin
rami...@redestb.es RAMIRO RODRIGUEZ SUAREZ
rayp...@cruzio.com Ray Price
rd...@raza.giga.com ROGELIO DIZ RUBIANES
re...@ibm.net Juan Manuel Rey
rich...@vcn.bc.ca Richard Songhurst
rig...@mpsnet.com.mx Miguel Rivera
rlov...@eco.uc3m.es Rosa Maria Loveira Pazo
rmr...@acs.tamu.edu Ricardo Rodr=EDguez-Iglesias
rob...@xures.ei.uvigo.es José Carlos González Pérez
ro...@royal.net Roberto Loxo Pérez
ro...@ma1.upc.es Agusti Roig
ro...@arrakis.es Rafael Ojea
ro...@fib.upc.es ROSA-MARIA MARTIN
ro...@maptel.es Ricardo Rozas Abella
rse...@pinar1.csic.es Rosalia Serna
ru...@uamca2.fmc.uam.es Ruben Perez Perez
RUB...@eucmax.sim.ucm.es Garcia Diaz,Ruben
r...@ctv.es Ricardo Viñas Cué
s.alv...@m.landata.es Sergio Alvarino Primo
Santg...@aol.com
santia...@geocities.com Santiago Fco. Lopez-Ponte
savi...@uvigo.es Mar Gonzalez Savignat
savill...@ucdavis.edu Sergio A. Villalobos
SEI...@sixecon.usc.es Enrique Giron
si...@mbcrr.harvard.edu Antonio J. da Silva
sit...@pi.net Leslie Sitek
Slow...@aol.com Ed Smith
sm...@cortex.med.harvard.edu Susana Martinez-Conde
soe...@nbnet.nb.ca Elizabeth Soeler
sol...@Umoncton.CA Francois Soeler
sra...@spyglass.com Scott Rains
sran...@usc.es Antonio Perez Casas
sru...@tsc.uvigo.es Simon Ruibal Menduinha (GTS)
st...@ksu.edu Tod Story
sus...@dmae.upm.es SUSANA GILARDI
sys...@pobox.com Ana Hermida Ruibal
tab...@ccr.jussieu.fr Juan-Jose TABOADA-MIDALGO
tbru...@panther.netmania.co.uk Theo Brueton
tin...@panix.com Bruce Tindall
ton...@cot.es José Antonio González Silva
torm...@unico.udc.es Maria Araceli Torres Mino
uch...@earth.oscs.montana.edu Richard Hughes
uop...@secrel.com.br francisco de assis costa aderaldo
vce...@netpar.com.br Valmir Cesar Nogueira
vdcab...@redestb.es Victoria Diaz Cabanela
vent...@inta.es ANDRES VENTAS PEREZ
w960...@uea.ac.uk Iago Mosquera Sanchez
xab...@iaga.com A. X. Canosa Rodriguez
xi...@arrakis.es xiada
xi...@pratique.fr Christian TANGUY
xld...@redestb.es Javier L. Doce
xmar...@usc.es Xurxo
XMe...@Proel.ES Xabier Meilan
xos...@arrakis.es Xos=E9 Ronquete Paz
xriv...@arrakis.es F. Xavier Riveiro Lopez
xsal...@tsc.uvigo.es Xavier Fernandez Salgado
xuan.g...@bcn.servicom.es
xu...@ires.ucl.ac.be Jorge Duran
xu...@ctv.es Pablo Justo Sanmartín
ZUR...@etsiig.uniovi.es Ruben Zurita Hevia

Voted No
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
afa...@brokenarrow.us.itd.umich.edu Andrew Fabbro
bo...@datasync.com Martin H. Booda
C.PR...@lse.ac.uk Xunto 'o nome do grupo, escrebe o teu

dbal...@cs.com Don Ballard
d...@panix.com David W. Crawford

fin...@pop.uni-dortmund.de Thomas Adams
gail...@panix.com Ed Gaillard
g...@wolves.durham.nc.us Gregory G. Woodbury
gpr9...@uconnvm.uconn.edu G.P. Ryan
jim...@pipeline.com Jim Riley
jkra...@swarthmore.edu Joshua Kramer
jo...@world.std.com Fred Cherry
ki...@netcom.com Kim DeVaughn
l...@zk3.dec.com Larry Smith
ni...@cimio.co.uk Nick Waterman - Hates Long Ballots
ram...@ecf.toronto.edu gopal g
ri...@bcm.tmc.edu Richard Miller
rosm...@pinkinc.com H Albert Rosman

stai...@bga.com Dwight Brown
sta...@stamper.com Chris Stamper

tla...@amug.org Todd C. Lawson
z...@cjnetworks.com Ned Fleming

Votes in error
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ch...@bpe.es Rufino Contreras
! No ballot
dir...@ctv.es Diego Rueda Losada
! No ballot
dome...@redestb.es Domenec Benaiges Monreal
! No ballot
fgan...@usc.es Ana I. Boullon Agrelo

! No vote statement in message

jl...@ctv.es Manager
! No ballot
labe...@mail.med.upenn.edu Monique Laberge
! No ballot
mon...@satlink.com Esther Moncarz
! No ballot
MTT...@aol.com

! No vote statement in message

ni...@ctv.es Nico
! No ballot
pmo...@pacbell.net
! No ballot
sic...@lix.intercom.es
! No ballot
teje...@arrakis.es Bernardo Tejeda
! No ballot
wir...@aol.com WirbelW
! No ballot