Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.

Dismiss

RFD: comp.sys.mac.programmer.games

2 views

Skip to first unread message

Jason Newquist

unread,

Sep 5, 1995, 3:00:00 AM9/5/95

REQUEST FOR DISCUSSION (RFD)
unmoderated group comp.sys.mac.programmer.games

Newsgroup Line:
comp.sys.mac.programmer.games Discussion of Macintosh Game Programming

An RFD is a Request For the Discussion of the creation of a new Usenet
newsgroup. Discussion of the formation of this group is restricted to
news.groups and should not bleed over into other groups. All
followups are (should be) set to news.groups.

SUMMARY:

Proposal for comp.sys.mac.programmer.games, a group for the discussion
of Macintosh programming issues of interest to game developers.

RATIONALE: comp.sys.mac.programmer.games

comp.sys.mac.programmer.games needs to be created because there is a
significant volume of posts throughout the comp.sys.mac.programmer.*
hierarchy and other games-related groups (such as rec.games.design
and rec.games programmer) which deal with the very specific problems
of Macintosh game developers. Game developers on the c.s.m.programmer
groups agree that a specific forum for the growing number of Macintosh
game developers would provide much-welcomed support and increase the
over-all quality of Macintosh games and entertainment products by
providing a unified forum to focus appropriate discourse.

It has been agreed that placing the group in the c.s.m.programmer.*
hierarchy is most appropriate for the content that the group will
generate. The comp.sys.mac.games.* hierarchy is also not suitable for
programming discourse. Games programming has much more to do
programming than with gaming, hence the decision to place the group in
the c.s.m.programmer.* hierarchy.

Since there is no easy way to determine the precise amount of traffic
that occurs about Macintosh games programming, people have been forced
to use imprecise means of ascertaining the amount of volume that such
a group as this would generate. It is clear that the number of topics
that would be appropriate are many (please see the Charter's list
of appropriate topics). What's more, all such traffic is currently
split among several groups: several in the c.s.m.programmer.* hierarchy,
rec.games.programmer and even some others. Counting the number of
appropriate posts and threads in all these groups together as well as
the other posts that will doubtless be encouraged by the forum's
existence in the first place will, we argue, make for more than enough
traffic to justify this group's existence.

There are no email lists handling traffic of this nature currently.

Archival of posts to this proposed group has not been arranged.

FAQs and other group-related materials will be made available on the
World Wide Web at the site of one of the proponents (Jason Newquist
has offered space) and via FTP at the usual Usenet and Macintosh FTP
sites (rtfm, info-mac, umich, etc.).

CHARTER: comp.sys.mac.programmer.games

comp.sys.mac.programmer.games is for the discussion of programming and
development issues important to Macintosh game programmers. Its purpose
is to focus discussion of Macintosh game development in a single forum.

Postings which would be considered appropriate would consist of: use
of graphics and animations, sound and music in games, game interface
issues, using the latest Apple technologies in games, game performance
issues, game AI and other algorithms, PowerPC/68k game programming/
optimization techniques, porting to and from other platforms, and
issues particular to Macintosh game design. In general, issues and
problems of Macintosh game programming and development as well as
intimately-related informational postings.

Advertisement is limited to programming and development products,
servies and events that bear reasonably on the topic of the group.

Postings which would be considered inappropriate would possibly
contain discussions about issues not directly related to game
programming. Discussions about programming issues are appropriate,
but such discussions that are not related to Macintosh game design or
programming are inappropriate.

Tangential discussions about the philosophy of computing, and general
game philosophy should be taken to more appropriate groups, such as
rec.games.programmer, which is for multi-platform game programming,
and rec.games.design which is suitable for game design issues.

More inappropriate discussions include discussions about discussions
about discussions, and any other topic than programming Macintosh
games. Finally, the posting of binaries is not suitable for this
group, being more appropriate in other locales.

END CHARTER.

PROCEDURE:

This post is being cross-posted to several groups, but follow-ups are
set to news.groups where all discussion is to take place. Discussion
will last for 30 days. Discussion of all sorts is welcomed.

At the end of this 30 day discussion period, assuming reasonable support
for the group is heard, any adjustments to the Rationale and Charter will
be made and the Call For Votes or CFV will be issued. The voting period
will last another 31 days. Details on voting will be made available in
the CFV itself.

DISTRIBUTION:

Distribution of the RFD, the CFV, several reminders of the CFV during
the voting period, and the results of the CFV will be posted to the
following groups:

comp.sys.mac.programmer.misc, comp.sys.mac.programmer.info,
comp.sys.mac.games.announce, comp.sys.mac.announce,
rec.games.programmer, news.announce.newgroups, and news.groups.

Please feel free to repost this RFD (in full, and not edited please) to
relevant mailing lists and other distribution nodes that you feel are
appropriate.

Name of Proponent: Jason Newquist <jrnew...@ucdavis.edu>
--
newq...@maxwell.ucdavis.edu http://maxwell.ucdavis.edu/~newquist
-. .-. .-. .-. .-. .-. .-. .-. .-. .-
\ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ / \ /
`-' `-' `-' `-' `-' `-' `-' `-' `-'

Bill Aten

unread,

Oct 2, 1995, 3:00:00 AM10/2/95

FIRST CALL FOR VOTES (of 2)
unmoderated group comp.sys.mac.programmer.games

Newsgroups line:
comp.sys.mac.programmer.games Macintosh game programming.

Votes must be received by 23:59:59 UTC, 23 Oct 1995.

This vote is being conducted by a neutral third party. Questions about
the proposed group should be directed to the proponent.

Proponent: Jason Newquist <newq...@maxwell.ucdavis.edu>
Mentor: Richard H. Miller <ri...@bcm.tmc.edu>
Votetaker: Bill Aten <bi...@netagw.com>

RATIONALE: comp.sys.mac.programmer.games

programming discourse. Games programming has much more to do with

programming than with gaming, hence the decision to place the group in
the c.s.m.programmer.* hierarchy.

rec.games.programmer, and even some others. Counting the number of
appropriate posts and threads in all these groups together, as well as

the other posts that will doubtless be encouraged by the forum's

existence in the first place, will, we argue, make for more than enough

traffic to justify this group's existence.

There are no email lists handling traffic of this nature currently.

Archival of posts to this proposed group has not been arranged.

CHARTER: comp.sys.mac.programmer.games

Advertisement is limited to programming and development products,

surveys and events that bear reasonably on the topic of the group.

END CHARTER.

HOW TO VOTE:

Extract the ballot from the CFV by deleting everything before and after
the "BEGINNING OF BALLOT" and "END OF BALLOT" lines. Don't worry about
the spacing of the columns or any quote characters (">") that your
reply inserts.

PLEASE, do not send the entire CFV back to me as this mail is archived.

Mark the ballot and then MAIL it to: <games...@netagw.com>
Just "replying" to this message should work, but check the "To:" line.

In order to properly record your vote, please provide your REAL NAME and
indicate your desired vote in the appropriate locations inside the ballot.

Examples of how to properly indicate your vote:

[ YES ] example.yes.vote
[ NO ] example.no.vote
[ ABSTAIN ] example.abstention
[ CANCEL ] example.cancellation

*** PLEASE ***
DO NOT alter, modify, or delete any other information in this ballot!
If you do, the voting software will probably reject your vote.

===== BEGINNING OF BALLOT: Delete everything BEFORE this line =====
-------------------------------------------------------------------
comp.sys.mac.programmer.games Ballot
<CSMPG-0001> (Do not remove this marker!)
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Voter name:
(If you do not give your real name, your vote may be rejected)
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Insert YES, NO, ABSTAIN, or CANCEL inside the brackets for each
newsgroup listed below (do not delete the newsgroup name):

Your Vote Newsgroup
--------- ---------
[ ] comp.sys.mac.programmer.games
-------------------------------------------------------------------
===== END OF BALLOT: Delete everything AFTER this line ============

IMPORTANT VOTING PROCEDURE NOTES:

Standard Guidelines for voting apply. Only one vote per person, no
more than one vote per account. Votes must be mailed directly from
the voter to the votetaker. Anonymous, forwarded, or proxy votes
are not valid. Votes mailed by WWW/HTML/CGI forms are considered
to be anonymous votes.

Vote counting is automated. Failure to follow these directions may
mean that your vote does not get counted. If you do not receive an
acknowledgment of your vote within three days, contact the votetaker
about the problem. It's your responsibility to make sure your vote
is registered correctly. Duplicate votes are resolved in favor of
the most recent valid vote. Addresses and votes of all voters will
be published in the final voting results post.

DO NOT redistribute this CFV in any manner whatsoever. The purpose of
a Usenet vote is to determine the genuine interest of persons who would
read a proposed newsgroup. Soliciting votes from disinterested parties
defeats this purpose. Only the votetaker, the news.announce.newgroups
moderator, and the proponent (if specifically authorized by the votetaker)
are permitted to distribute copies of this CFV.

Distribution of pre-marked or otherwise modified copies of this CFV is
generally considered voting fraud and should be reported immediately to
the votetaker or the UVV <con...@uuv.org>. In cases where voting fraud
is determined to have occurred, it is standard operating procedure to
delete ALL votes submitted by the violator. When in doubt, ask the
votetaker.

DISTRIBUTION:

The only official sources for copies of this CFV are the locations listed
below and the votetaker's e-mail CFV server which can be reached at
<games-cf...@netagw.com>.

This CFV has been cross-posted to:
news.announce.newgroups, news.groups, comp.sys.mac.announce,
comp.sys.mac.programmer.info, rec.games.design, rec.games.programmer

Bill Aten

unread,

Oct 12, 1995, 3:00:00 AM10/12/95

LAST CALL FOR VOTES (of 2)
unmoderated group comp.sys.mac.programmer.games

RATIONALE: comp.sys.mac.programmer.games

CHARTER: comp.sys.mac.programmer.games

END CHARTER.

HOW TO VOTE:

<CSMPG-0002> (Do not remove this marker!)

IMPORTANT VOTING PROCEDURE NOTES:

DISTRIBUTION:

comp.sys.mac.programmer.games Bounce List
(No need to revote)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
harp...@execpc.cpom Sean Harper
rja...@austlcm.sps.mot.com Rodney Jacks

Bill Aten

unread,

Oct 24, 1995, 3:00:00 AM10/24/95

RESULT
unmoderated group comp.sys.mac.programmer.games passes 485:20

Voting closed at 23:59:59 UTC, 23 Oct 1995.

This vote was conducted by a neutral third party. Questions about the

proposed group should be directed to the proponent.

Proponent: Jason Newquist <newq...@maxwell.ucdavis.edu>
Mentor: Richard H. Miller <ri...@bcm.tmc.edu>
Votetaker: Bill Aten <bi...@netagw.com>

There were 505 valid votes submitted during the voting period. Each proposed
newsgroup, in order to pass, must have at least 2/3 YES votes and at least
100 more YES than NO votes. The results are as follows:

comp.sys.mac.programmer.games results - 505 valid votes

Yes No : 2/3? >100? : Pass? : Group
---- ---- : ---- ----- : ----- : -------------------------------------------
485 20 : Yes Yes : Yes : comp.sys.mac.programmer.games
3 abstaining votes and 6 invalid votes

The proposal passed.

There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted. If no
serious and significant allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the
moderator of news.announce.newgroups will create the newsgroups shortly
thereafter.

The remainder of the RESULT contains:
Newsgroups Line
Rationale
Charter
Final Voting Acknowledgements

NEWSGROUPS LINE:

comp.sys.mac.programmer.games Macintosh game programming.

RATIONALE: comp.sys.mac.programmer.games

CHARTER: comp.sys.mac.programmer.games

END CHARTER.

FINAL VOTING ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS:

comp.sys.mac.programmer.games Final Vote Ack

comp.sys.mac.programmer.games ---+
|
100...@2221.compuserve.com Kurt Sutter Y
10062...@compuserve.com Stuart Ball Y
650...@ucsbuxa.ucsb.edu Mason Thomas Y
7342...@compuserve.com Garry Roseman Y
78...@FHD-Stuttgart.DE Andy Lietz Y
a...@pine.cse.nau.edu Aric Friesen Y
ab...@kenlaw.com Abie Flaxman Y
abrow...@ea.com Andrew Brownsword Y
a...@nilenet.com Andy Sandoval Y
ad...@informatik.tu-muenchen.de Martin Adler Y
adr...@wimsey.com Adrian C Ruigrok Y
adv...@ub4b.eunet.be Jos Potargent Y
aear...@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu Alan D. Earhart Y
afa...@us.itd.umich.edu Andrew Fabbro Y
ahs...@unixg.ubc.ca Adam Slim Y
a...@rmit.edu.au Andrew van der Stock Y
akli...@wyoming.com Aaron Klingaman Y
al...@bones.demon.co.uk Alan Staniforth Y
alec_...@taligent.com Alec Plumb Y
al...@brown.edu Alex Gottschalk -
alle...@ucdavis.edu Alan Lehman Y
alle...@prairienet.org Mark Allender Y
al...@isy.liu.se Anders Lundqvist Y
am...@acs.bu.edu Bryce Ambo Y
Ambro...@aol.com John Haley Y
Ambro...@aol.com David Richard Y
andr...@cs.auckland.ac.nz Andrew Luxton Y
and...@lion.hsc.edu Andrew McClintock Y
and...@communique.net Andrew Oliver Y
ane...@magnet.at Andreas Netzer Y
Ap...@graphex.com Sean McKibben Y
ar...@ven.net Isaac Arias Y
a...@scumby.com Art Kerns Y
asout...@VNET.IBM.COM Andrew R. Southwick Y
aud...@alien.slip.umd.edu Damian Audley Y
ava...@indirect.com Avalon Trust Y
a...@chevron.com Alan V. Hardin Y
awhi...@cats.ucsc.edu Doug Whitmore Y
b.ko...@frw.ruu.nl Barend Kobben Y
bar...@tcst.com Christopher Barkley Y
ba...@ensisun.imag.fr Cedric Barra Y
ba...@tubular.ie Barry Byrne Y
bar...@netcom.com Barry Nathan Y
bast...@netcom.com Gregory J. Weston Y
bcol...@itsmail1.hamilton.edu Brian Collett Y
bc...@sikorsky.com Brian Cyr Y
be...@freenet.carleton.ca Henry Smith Y
bea...@lairware.com Leon McNeill Y
Benjami...@hmc.edu Benjamin Elgin Y
bern...@mathp6.jussieu.fr Dominique Bernardi Y
bf...@ACM.ORG Brian P. Fitzgerald Y
bhi...@sdcc13.ucsd.edu Ben Hines Y
bi...@NovaEngr.COM Bill Walburg Y
Bo.Lun...@ki.ericsson.se Bo Lundqvist Y
bo...@cruzio.com Ethan Phelps-Goodman Y
boon...@ultranet.com Bob Boonstra Y
boo...@sics.se Kent Boortz Y
bor...@kappa.sil.org Randy Boring Y
Bre...@dicomed.com Cris Breece Y
bri...@worldweb.net Brian Stewart Y
bri...@efn.org Britt A. Green Y
broi...@abo.fi Ben Roimola Y
br...@wat.hookup.net Bruce Fletcher Y
bry...@informatik.tu-muenchen.de Till Brychcy Y
bryn...@cybernet.co.nz Brynley Blake Y
bsey...@halcyon.com Brooks Seymore Y
bub...@lmis.loral.com Jason L. Buberel Y
b...@tiac.net Bruce Wyman Y
ca...@laserpoint.com Cary Farrier Y
cata...@aol.com Bill M Catambay Y
cat...@netcom.com Mark Kupferman Y
CCON...@pinc.com Carl B. Constantine Y
cda...@bnlux1.bnl.gov chris davis Y
cecc...@server.tdnet.it Paolo Cecchetti Y
c...@cyberpuppy.com Christopher Haupt Y
cfl...@infi.net Casey Fleser Y
cha...@mcs.com Chris Hanson Y
ch...@kaleida.com Chih Chao Lam Y
CHEN...@urvax.urich.edu Andrew Shi-hwa Chen Y
cheu...@ha.org.hk Ngai Tseung Cheung Y
chn...@cs.cuhk.hk Ngai Chi-ho Y
Christia...@eikon.e-technik.tu-muenchen.de Christian Doenges Y
c...@acsu.buffalo.edu John C. Chu N
c...@best.com Chris Thomas Y
cla...@csc.canterbury.ac.nz Matt Neuburg Y
cl...@columbia.edu Chris Stamper Y
club...@aol.com Thorpy Inglebird III Y
cne...@gpu.srv.ualberta.ca Chris Neuman Y
coc...@astro.psu.edu Eric J. Cocklin Y
co...@teleport.com Colen Garoutte-Carson Y
co...@adsnet.net Doug Cole Y
con...@fyxx.demon.co.uk Connie Dialeris Y
co...@ozemail.com.au Conor MacNeill Y
coo...@math.miami.edu Brian A. Coomes Y
cordesm...@sni.de Martin Cordsmeier Y
co...@aero.org Ric Cowan Y
cre...@mitre.org Chris Reedy Y
cs03...@cs.uwa.edu.au Barnaby Brown Y
c...@cinetic.de Christoph Sold Y
csa...@urc.tue.nl Michiel Wijers N
csa...@chem.wisc.edu Chris Saari Y
cts...@mail.usask.ca Colin Simmonds Y
d-ga...@ski.mskcc.org Dave Garaffa Y
D.Bi...@regy.canterbury.ac.nz Denis Birnie Y
da...@CoLi.Uni-SB.DE Daniel Bobbert Y
D...@Dartmouth.EDU David T. Santoro Y
Damien...@fundp.ac.be Damien Andre Y
d...@rhino.harvard.edu Dan Crevier Y
daniel...@tts.lth.se Daniel Sobirk Y
dan...@hardy.ocs.mq.edu.au Duncan Anker Y
dar...@teleport.com Darryl L. Smith Y
da...@synopsys.com Dave Schreiber Y
David....@adelaide.on.net David Wareing Y
david...@aol.com David Hill Y
daws...@UCBEH.SAN.UC.EDU Drew J. Dawson Y
dd...@cornell.edu David Irwin Y
d...@aretha.jax.org Mark Harrison Y
dew...@image.Kodak.COM Thomas DeWeese Y
d...@watershed.com Dirk Fromhein Y
di...@cs.Stanford.EDU Doug Ihde Y
dkkr...@artsci.wustl.edu Jerry Adlersfluegel Y
dk...@nwu.edu David Kwok Y
dlac...@crim.ca Denis Lacasse Y
dloe...@astro.ocis.temple.edu David R. Loebell Y
dlre...@mindspring.com David Lane Reynolds Y
dmcg...@MIT.EDU Dan McGuire Y
dmd...@engr.ucdavis.edu Daniel Deal Y
dneb...@mtc.iitri.com David E. Nebiker Y
doc...@doctor.nl2k.edmonton.ab.ca Dave Shariff Yadallee Y
dr...@altorsys.com David Rees Y
ds...@li.net Bob Snider Y
dse...@glenayre.com Dale Semchishen Y
ds...@hops.cs.jhu.edu David Shaw Y
dun...@nw.pensee.com David Dunham Y
du...@grad.csee.usf.edu Walter Duque de Estrada Y
dw...@andrew.cmu.edu Duane T. Williams Y
dwa...@acy.digex.net Dave Warker Y
dwoo...@aol.com DWoodall Y
dxcl...@ucdavis.edu David Clancy Y
dy...@cs.washington.edu Dylan McNamee Y
e019...@brookes.ac.uk Nigel Brown Y
e332...@student.uq.edu.au Anthony Wilkinson Y
efre...@cdmi.com Eric A. Freeman Y
ei...@netmarket.com Eiji Hirai Y
ell...@mpi-muelheim.mpg.de Dr Mark Elliott Y
emu...@actcom.co.il Tal Rotbart Y
eng...@primenet.com Lawson English Y
era...@iway.fr Emmanuel Rayzal Y
er...@ra.nilenet.com Eric A. Drumbor Y
er...@ensuing.com erik kraft Y
erky...@CMU.EDU Andrew Plotkin N
ev...@cornell.edu Erik Schwiebert Y
e...@uiah.fi Samu Mielonen Y
F.Dij...@fys.ruu.nl Freek Dijkstra Y
f9...@matfys.lth.se Per Persson Y
f94...@efd.lth.se Markus Andreasson Y
f...@miles.de Florian -FDj- Dejako Y
fel...@lsesun12.epfl.ch Pascal Felber Y
femi...@eskimo.com William Affleck-Asch Y
fe...@wyn.hq.org Chris Patti Y
figu...@galaxie.int-evry.fr Hubert Figuiere Y
fir...@cae.wisc.edu James Firmiss Y
fla...@tikkabik.com Peter A. Cohen Y
fla...@is.tokushima-u.ac.jp Andrew Flavell Y
flis...@cs.wisc.edu Shaun Flisakowski Y
forr...@ameritel.net James Daryl Forrest Y
for...@vlsi.polymtl.ca guillaume fortin Y
fpre...@engin.umich.edu Matt Slot Y
ft...@acpub.duke.edu Fletcher Thompson Penney Y
gam...@microweb.com Gary Arnold Y
gar...@IRO.UMontreal.CA Eric Garneau Y
ga...@magna.com.au Gary Makin Y
ga...@magna.com.au Gavan Schneider Y
g...@tiac.net Gustave A. Zeissig Y
gbr...@ccm.tdsnet.com Gary J. Brooks Y
ge...@nwu.edu Joey Gray Y
geo...@netcom.com geoff george Y
geo...@ifi.uio.no Georg Lundesgaard Y
giam...@snowhite.eeap.cwru.edu Jude Giampaolo N
g...@acpub.duke.edu Gavin Kistner Y
gkri...@unlgrad1.unl.edu Gary Krichau Y
Glenn_...@avid.com Glenn McElhoe Y
gles...@phy.ulaval.ca Guillaume Lessard Y
gli...@cs.washington.edu Greg Linden Y
gneu...@ccs.carleton.ca Grant Neufeld Y
gpio...@motown.ge.com George A. Piotrowski Jr. Y
Guy.Mo...@InfotecSA.Com Guy Moreillon Y
h950...@hkusua.hku.hk Lee Chun Kwok Y
h...@cs.hut.fi Hannu Aronsson Y
ha...@mti.com Robert W. Hahn Y
ha...@netcom.com Steve Hales Y
han...@cs.stanford.edu Michael Hanson Y
harp...@execpc.cpom Sean Harper Y
har...@hale.yerkes.uchicago.edu Evan Harper Y
harp...@eelab.newpaltz.edu Doug Harple N
has...@dragon.achilles.net Hassan Farisi Y
has...@inet.uni-c.dk Henrik A. Steen N
hch...@coil.com Harold Cheney Y
he...@gizmo.uchicago.edu Dion L. Heinz Y
her...@access.digex.net Michael Herveus M.J. Houghton Y
hild...@bnr.ca robert (r.) hildinger Y
hi...@sensors.Stanford.EDU Matthew Hills Y
h...@netcom.com Scott Szretter Y
hmue...@maxsolns.com Harry Mueller Y
hoep...@intr.net Patrick Hoepfner Y
hsh...@denim.ultranet.com Howard S Shubs Y
h...@dove.mtx.net.au Henry Penninkilampi Y
hu...@deltanet.com Tim Hume Y
hu...@husc.harvard.edu Tim Hunt Y
i...@hci.npl.co.uk Ian Curson Y
ia...@ipdsys.com Ian Florance Y
iceb...@eskimo.com Bob Hall Y
Ig...@cass.demon.co.uk Ian Richards Y
isb...@ai.mit.edu Charles Isbell Y
j-ja...@uchicago.edu Jerome Jahnke N
jac...@eyes.uab.edu Gregory Jackson Y
jac...@AZStarNet.com John S. Jacobs Anderson Y
jad...@eng.umd.edu Josh Adams Y
jae...@WPI.EDU Jae Hyuk Lee Y
ja...@netcom.com Marcu Jager Y
ja...@uclink.berkeley.edu Joseph Churchill Y
ja...@bronze.lcs.mit.edu Jamal Hannah Y
jam...@cc.gatech.edu Josue E. Amaro Y
James....@Dartmouth.EDU Douglas Buskey Y
ja...@crocker.com Jason Linhart Y
jas...@eniac.seas.upenn.edu Jason Pareti Y
JasonT...@mail.utexas.edu Jason Townsend Y
jaso...@postoffice.utas.edu.au Jason Anderson Y
j...@usa1.com Jay Hennessey Y
jbu...@acm.org Joe Buczek Y
je...@ee.pdx.edu Jeff Heinen Y
je...@amanda.dorsai.org Jeffrey Posnick Y
j...@magic.fr J.F. Bustarret Y
jh...@columbia.edu Jonathan H Chapman Y
jhu...@alinc.com Jeff Hughes Y
jimg...@caprica.com James Gagne Y
Jim_Gfess...@email.mot.com Jim Gfesser Y
jjca...@engin.umich.edu Josh Carpenter Y
jje...@telalink.net Jeff Jetton Y
jkle...@pobox.com Joel Klecker Y
j...@freenet.grfn.org Joel M. Mawhorter Y
jmu...@beta.hut.fi Juri Munkki Y
jo...@datadesign.se Joar Nilsson Y
joef...@phoenix.Princeton.EDU Joe Faber Y
jo...@itg.ti.com Joel Quejada Y
jo...@Tempest.NET.HK John W. Blackburne Y
john...@iconz.co.nz Ching-Yi (John) Tsai Y
jon...@io.org Trevor Tymchuk Y
jon...@netcom.com Jon Pugh Y
j...@miamisci.org Joe Block Y
jre...@qualcomm.com Jason Regier Y
j...@globalvillag.com John R. MacWilliamson N
jr...@cornell.edu Jonathan Rynd Y
js...@cs.adelaide.edu.au Sam Bushell Y
jsho...@MIT.EDU John S. Holmes Y
js...@cornell.edu James Margaris Y
jth...@netcom.com Jim Hill Y
jtr...@REAL.com.au Jonathan Trott Y
julia...@stonebow.otago.ac.nz Julian Cox Y
jul...@waikato.ac.nz Julian Melville Y
junk...@halcyon.com James Hague N
jviz...@csus.edu John M. Vizcarra Y
jwco...@MIT.EDU Jamie Coffin Y
j...@ai.polymtl.ca Jean-Yves Herve' Y
k...@medialab.ericsson.se Kaj Nygren Y
ka...@mail.utexas.edu Kevin Armstrong Y
k...@mindspring.com Kristopher Johnson Y
ke...@mail.med.cornell.edu Chris Kelch Y
Kenneth...@msn.fullfeed.com Kenneth Heitke Y
ke...@banyo.nmrfam.wisc.edu Ken Prehoda Y
kev...@attachmate.com Kevin Purcell Y
KHA...@Kilcom1.UCIS.Dal.Ca Kevin Hayes Y
k...@kjbmac.demon.co.uk Keith Bromley Y
kmit...@direct.ca Kevin Mitchell N
kn...@pharos.com Knee, Jeff Y
kni...@world.std.com Chris Knight Y
koco...@tpd.tno.nl Peter Kocourek Y
ko...@crd.GE.COM Mark A. Kolb Y
kri...@husc.harvard.edu David Krinsky Y
kr...@mips2.phy.queensu.ca Keith Rose Y
kupi...@noise.bsd.uchicago.edu Matthew Alan Kupinski Y
la...@bard.edu Luis Alcazar-Roman Y
lan...@cats.ucsc.edu Lance Chun Y
lau...@planon.qc.ca Laurent Daudelin Y
l...@cs.duke.edu Lyman Green Y
le...@sparc.ipgp.jussieu.fr Eric LEWIN Y
li...@ils.nwu.edu Jeff Lind Y
list-...@dream.hb.north.de Martin Schr"oder Y
lorin...@attws.com Lorin Rowe Y
lo...@capcom.apana.org.au Lorin O'Brien Y
lo...@iar.se Lars-Ove Karlsson Y
l...@cray.com Larry Rolison Y
lue...@media.mit.edu Luette Bourne Y
lun...@cs.wisc.edu Peter Bierman Y
lur...@tiac.net Pete Lurie Y
mage...@infinet.com Mark Middleton Y
marc....@crpht.lu Funck Marc Y
ma...@fyxx.demon.co.uk Mark Hobba Y
Markus...@maushh2.hh.provi.de Markus Fritze Y
marm...@conch.aa.msen.com Dave Walker Y
Marsha...@brown.edu Marshall Vale Y
mat...@vaxc.hofstra.edu Steven R. Costenoble Y
ma...@sol.med.jhu.edu Matthew A. Rubin Y
mb...@aloha.com Mike Bradshaw Y
mbr...@extro.ucc.su.OZ.AU Michael Bradshaw Y
mbu...@falcon.cc.ukans.edu Matt Burch Y
mcca...@scf.usc.edu Kelly M. McCarthy Y
mcc...@minerva.cis.yale.edu Meredith McClurg Y
mch...@ici.net Mike McHugh Y
McMa...@mediasoft.net Chuck McMath Y
mdc...@halcyon.com Martin Cahn Y
mdu...@freenet.columbus.oh.us Matthew Dunbar Y
me...@virginia.edu Andrew Meggs Y
merk...@phgrav.phys.lsu.edu Stephen Merkowitz Y
mess...@rohan.sdsu.edu Robin Messerli Y
mglo...@supranet.com Michael Glowacki Y
mh...@cornell.edu Matthew Barr Y
mi...@emf.net Mick Foley Y
mied...@mpipf-muenchen.mpg.de Frank Miedreich Y
mi...@pmafire.inel.gov Mike Caldwell Y
mi...@mit.edu Michael Genrich Y
mil...@cs.rochester.edu Brad Miller N
miw...@davidson.edu Mike Weber Y
mk...@emf.net Marty Kent Y
mkw...@sdcc13.ucsd.edu Myra Wong Y
mmha...@alchemy.cs.ruu.nl Maarten Hazewinkel Y
m...@RedBrick.COM M Mike Taksar -
mo...@teleport.com Charles Vollum Y
mond...@panix.com David Gerald Hill Y
moo...@grimoire.Tymnet.COM Ed Mooring Y
mo...@engc.bu.edu Matt Mick Y
mou...@zercom.net Martin-Gilles Lavoie Y
mpl...@teleport.com Michael Plump Y
mric...@cmi.on.ca Mark Richman Y
mro...@GroupZ.net Mike Calloway Y
msa...@mbox.vol.it Marco Sandri Y
mwda...@students.uiuc.edu Michael W. Daniels Y
mw...@ycc.kodak.com Michael P. Webb Y
my...@terminator.rs.itd.umich.edu Michael Dautermann N
n0...@vax1.mankato.msus.edu Chris Schmelzer Y
na...@owlnet.rice.edu John A. Chapman Y
na...@RDataSys.COM Mark Nagel Y
nahe...@plains.nodak.edu Nathanael Henderson Y
nath...@CSUA.Berkeley.EDU Nathan Sturtevant Y
nd...@cec.wustl.edu Nathaniel D. Brazy Y
nd...@park.uvsc.edu Neil Despain Y
nebu...@rmii.com Adam Schabtach Y
ne...@nharris.demon.co.uk Neil Harris Y
Nelson_...@jhasia.immedia.ca Nelson Gallash Y
newq...@maxwell.ucdavis.edu Jason Newquist Y
ni...@godbout.interax.net Nicolas Godbout Y
ni...@pitt.edu Nick.c DeMello Y
NickP...@vic.sanctuary.com Nick Porcino Y
nie...@MO.NET Jim Niemann Y
nv91...@nada.kth.se Roger Andersson Y
pan...@world.std.com Phillip D. Andrus Y
paqu...@infinity.metrowerks.ca Marc Paquette Y
pa...@bigbang.stanford.edu Brian Park Y
patri...@aol.com Patrick Weigel Y
pau...@astral.magic.ca Paul C. H. Ho Y
pau...@mindspring.com Paul Scheele Y
peri...@hermes.eawag.ch Philippe Perisset -
pe...@peppertree.com Peter Jensen Y
ph...@tartarus.uwa.edu.au Patrick C Hew Y
Philipp...@supaero.fr Philippe Gachon Y
pho...@ermis.demon.co.uk Phoebus Apostolides Y
phu...@bigdog.fred.net Derrick Kent Miller Y
pie...@gdt.com Pierre Houston Y
pino...@vnet.net Susan Pinochet Y
p...@stacken.kth.se Patrik Johansson Y
p...@telepac.pt Kyle Ellrott Y
plu...@bnr.ca David Plumpton Y
pl...@mtek.chalmers.se Pelle Johansson Y
pmag...@tcst.com Patrick Magruder Y
pmo...@facstaff.wisc.edu Andrew Moroz Y
pn...@server.ee.virginia.edu Philip N. Wheeler Y
pp00...@interramp.com Peter H. Jergens Y
pre...@isoquantic.com Patrick L. Reilly Y
pu...@cs.UMD.EDU William Pugh Y
qtx...@garbo.ericsson.se Jakob Cederlund Y
rac...@netcom.com Rachel Bernstein Y
radr...@panix.com Rebecca Drayer N
ra...@MIT.EDU Rajiv Aaron Manglani Y
ram...@hookup.net Dave Smith Y
ra...@cig.mot.com Kris Rande Y
rath...@miles.de Michael Rathmann Y
rave...@eskimo.com Erik C. Thauvin Y
rda...@vnet.net Ron Davis Y
re...@medicine.wustl.edu Thomas Reed Y
re...@nbn.com Reede Stockton Y
Regul...@aol.com Aaron Davidson Y
rel...@ewg.org Frank Schima Y
rgri...@FOX.NSTN.NS.CA Robert Grimshaw Y
rg...@aware.com Ron Gut Y
rh...@vision.net.com Roger Hook Y
ri...@bcm.tmc.edu Richard Miller Y
Rick_...@adbbs.antioch.edu Rick Worley Y
rja...@austlcm.sps.mot.com Rodney Jacks Y
R...@cris.com Ron Nascimento Y
Robert.L...@Dartmouth.EDU Scot Drysdale Y
rob...@keltia.freenix.fr Ollivier Robert N
roge...@nwu.edu Roger Kim Y
root...@teleport.com Tom Phoenix Y
rpo...@yarrow.wt.com.au Remo Ponta Y
rsn...@hns.com Russ Snyder Y
rt...@baker.cnw.com Dan Thies Y
rw...@midway.uchicago.edu Chip Ach Y
RW...@math.otago.ac.nz Roy Ward Y
ry...@grep.cs.fsu.edu JOHN RYAN Y
ry...@gwis2.circ.gwu.edu G. Patrick Ryan N
Sai...@sierra.net Michael Donovon Peters Y
sa...@chardos.connix.com Scott Kenney N
sam...@panix.com Samuel Rosenthal Y
san...@eniac.seas.upenn.edu Erick M. Santos Y
saun...@stripe.Colorado.EDU Alexander Saunders Y
s...@w0x0f.com Steve Fenwick Y
schi...@stars.gsfc.nasa.gov Francis H Schiffer, 3rd Y
schn...@ipesgi.e-technik.uni-stuttgart.de Claudius Schn"orr Y
schu...@pitt.edu Christina Schulman Y
sch...@sojourn.com Christopher Schweda Y
sco...@jaguar.visix.com Scott Hofmann Y
sco...@uiuc.edu Eric Scouten Y
sdo...@cis.ksu.edu Steven D. Marcotte Y
sgr...@ncsa.uiuc.edu Steven Greco Y
sha...@students.uiuc.edu Jeffrey Shabel Y
sh...@Dartmouth.EDU Simon.Holmes.a.Court. Y
sh...@one.net Shane Looker Y
sha...@tiac.net Chuck Shavit Y
sher...@pitt.edu Sherman Uitzetter Y
shi...@localnet.com Stanley J. Hiller Y
sie...@luva.lb.bawue.de Achim Siebert Y
simon.b...@jrc.it Simon Brownlee Y
sis...@ictp.trieste.it Daniele Terdina Y
ska...@a.crl.com Seth Kadesh Y
ske...@tartarus.uwa.edu.au Scott Kevill Y
sk...@aerie.dgsys.com Mitchell Skiba Y
skov...@ccgate.acuson.com Scott Kovatch Y
sla...@richmond.infi.net S A Laing Y
sli...@max.tiac.net Scott Lipcon Y
s...@netserv.com Scott M. Hinnrichs Y
sno...@cats.ucsc.edu Daniel Jalkut Y
sn...@netaxs.com Mattias Fornander Y
sophie.s.bawue.de!jue...@nadia.s.bawue.de Juergen Schroth Y
sp...@ruc.dk Peter Speck Y
spt...@uabdpo.dpo.uab.edu Joel Cunningham Y
stai...@bga.com Dwight Brown N
sta...@subasic.sciatl.com Altan J. Stalker Y
st...@the-wire.com Stan Witkowski Y
st...@park.uvsc.edu Steven H. Taylor Y
Stephen....@vuw.ac.nz Stephen Marshall Y
st...@hebb.psych.mcgill.ca Steve Hayduk Y
st...@unet.umn.edu Steve Fletty Y
ste...@accessone.com Steven Carlson Y
steve_bo...@imdgw.chinalake.navy.mil Steve Bollenbaugh Y
st...@escalade.com John Stick Y
st...@ids2.idsonline.com J. Scott Tury Y
sut...@mindvision.com Brian Sutter Y
swe...@adobe.com Sam Weiss Y
swi...@iac.net Shawn M. Witzki Y
tbu...@iadfw.net Thomas J. Bunce Y
tc...@tccn.com Coralie J. Allen Y
t...@cs.utexas.edu Ted Woodward Y
te...@hou.moc.com Andrew J. Testa Y
tes...@xs4all.nl Mark Boon Y
tfr...@cad749.sc.intel.com Tony Freitas Y
t...@oasis.ot.com Theodore F. Vaida Y
tha...@cs.pdx.edu Adam Lang Y
thar...@student.ecel.uwa.edu.au Toby Harrison Y
third...@aol.com Ben Lowers Y
thomas_...@powertalk.apple.com Thomas Weisbach Y
Thorsten...@ms3.maus.westfalen.de Thorsten Kistler Y
tkm...@sdt.com T. Kelly Mower Y
tk...@singnet.com.sg Teow-Khoon Ng Y
tla...@email.develop.american.edu Todd C. Lawson Y
to...@tks-cons.demon.co.uk Tony Jackson Y
t...@muc.de Thomas Tempelmann Y
tw...@sfu.ca Thomas Myles Weir Y
twpi...@midway.uchicago.edu Tim Pierce N
ud3...@sunmail.lrz-muenchen.de Eric Danay Y
udc...@kcl.ac.uk Simon Clifford Y
ulb...@www.unido.org Peter Ulbrich Y
umbe...@cc.UManitoba.CA James A. Best Y
uublip!outlander!ke6...@ccss.com Dennis Allen Carr Y
uzs...@ibm.rhrz.uni-bonn.de Thomas Emmler Y
v.d....@ams.chem.ruu.nl Koen van der Drift Y
vande...@DIMES.TUDelft.NL Arthur van der Harg Y
vc...@bbn.com Volkan F. Can Y
ve...@micronet.fr Jean-Francois Brouillet Y
vfr...@cp10.es.xerox.com Victor Franco Y
vin...@clt50bw.der.edf.fr Vincent LADEUIL Y
vpnet!vpnet!vag...@wwa.com Guy Umbright Y
w...@ardu.dsto.gov.au Warren Denley Y
wal...@zeus.towson.edu Martin Walser Y
wide...@cc.helsinki.fi Risto Widenius N
wil...@virtu.sar.usf.edu Steve Wilder Y
WILL...@miavx1.acs.muohio.edu R.E. Williams, Jr. Y
win...@zeus.via.org Joe Winter Y
w...@pitt.edu William K. Walker Y
wood...@acf2.NYU.EDU Andrew D. Woodard Y
wo...@alumni.caltech.edu William Edward Woody Y
wsel...@mindspring.com walt sellers Y
wth...@omega.uta.edu Billy Harris N
wv...@cornell.edu William Garrison Y
wya...@nwlink.com Wyatt Webb Y
wy...@blue.weeg.uiowa.EDU Wei Chiang Yin Y
z...@spine.med.utoronto.ca Greg Goldthorpe Y
zim...@aur.alcatel.com Mike Zimmerman Y
zi...@chesternet.org Jason H. Pellerin Y

Votes in error
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
jo...@panix.com
! No name given
kre...@apanix.apana.org.au
! No name given
post...@cs.uidaho.edu
! No name given
ro...@flugor.si.sub.de Andreas Franz
! Invalid address
sma...@turing.toronto.edu
! No name given
Sy...@ch.chaven.com
! Invalid address

0 new messages