On 6/15/2012 5:59 PM, Larry in AZ wrote:
> Waiving the right to remain silent,
j...@kamens.brookline.ma.us
> (Jonathan Kamens) said:
>> The new Filelink feature in the new Thunderbird release,
>> which automatically converts large attachments into YouSendIt
>> links, is totally freakin' awesome.
> More awesome would be to decode and save attachments
> to a separate directory as Eudora did.
As much as I admire (and use) Eudora,
for all its under-appreciated gifts,
I have to say that automatic "detaching" has many faults:
o Detaching may become permanent, even when not so desired.
o Deletion of some attachments causes incorrect associations
to form between messages and other attachments, or attaches
some files to newer messages instead of to the correct originals.
o Moving message stores, even to a new computer (e.g. XP -> Win7)
weakens the ability to work with the attachments of older messages
(in some Mac computers it even destroys it).
o Trying to combine message stores leads to
attachment file name collisions, each of which
causes dissociation of at least one attachment.
o Eudora can not save and forward an original "source" message
(e.g. "Content-Type: message/rfc822") because of the very fact
that it has "ripped apart the original and discarded various parts,"
particularly headers of some MIME parts and entire "alternative" parts,
nor can it, for the same reason, ever reconstruct, re-send,
or properly forward the original message.
o TB's mail storage is in the sole format that all internet email systems
understand completely, because it's exactly as it was fetched from servers
to begin with, while Eudora's is not conducive to being transplanted
to any new location, nor to "the cloud."
For those who want TB to split off attachments anyway,
either automatically or manually,
there was an "attachment extractor" plugin. However, it also
reveals a fundamental instability of the entire software model,
in that it has not kept up with new TB versions, it's original author
apparently got tired of maintaining and updating it,
it had bugs and deficiencies, etc.
Having become dependent on certain of your add-ons,
all it now takes is an innocent "check for updates"
to cause a 500 pound alligator, despite all your attempts
to keep it at bay with an "ask me before downloading/installing" fence,
to come crashing right through that fence and involuntarily update you,
potentially leaving you wounded and unable to keep a vital add-on working.
Eudora is the solid old car with heavy steel bumpers that lasts forever;
Thunderbird is made of plastic and foam that crushes if even tapped on,
but who cares -- you replace it with a new model every few weeks anyway,
even if only because this week it added more cup holders.
--