Google Groups no longer supports new Usenet posts or subscriptions. Historical content remains viewable.
Dismiss

Can't Import Opera Bookmarks to Firefox

52 views
Skip to first unread message

Bob

unread,
Sep 17, 2006, 5:56:08 PM9/17/06
to
I'd like to import my Opera bookmarks to Firefox. But when I
open Firefox and then File | Import, Internet Explorer is
the only "choice." I have both Opera 8 and Opera 9 installed
on the same drive as Firefox, but nother related to Opera
appears on the import list.

Any idea why Opera isn't showing up? Is there some other way
to import Opera bookmarks than the way I'm trying?

Thanks.
--

Bob

Nir

unread,
Sep 17, 2006, 6:57:04 PM9/17/06
to

Chris Ilias

unread,
Sep 17, 2006, 6:58:36 PM9/17/06
to
_Bob_ spoke thusly on 17/09/2006 5:56 PM:

Opera shows up here; so I assume it's something in the way Firefox is
trying to detect other installed apps. (registry key?)
In Opera, go to File-->Import and export-->Export bookmarks as HTML.
You should then be able to import that HTML file.
--
Chris Ilias
mozilla.test.multimedia moderator
Mozilla links <http://ilias.ca>
(Please do not email me tech support questions)

Bob

unread,
Sep 17, 2006, 7:14:59 PM9/17/06
to
Nir <nir...@hotmail.com> wrote:

That link suggests a pay program, which I don't reject out
of hand, but I'd first like to see if there's a free way of
making this work.

Thanks.
--

Bob

Nir

unread,
Sep 17, 2006, 7:17:27 PM9/17/06
to

See Chris's Post

Bob

unread,
Sep 17, 2006, 7:17:34 PM9/17/06
to
Chris Ilias <n...@ilias.ca> wrote:

> Opera shows up here; so I assume it's something in the way
> Firefox is trying to detect other installed apps.
> (registry key?) In Opera, go to File-->Import and export-->
> Export bookmarks as HTML. You should then be able to import
> that HTML file.

When I click File | Import, the only choice is import from
Internet Explorer. If I then click next, it goes on to
import from IE; I'm never given the choice to browse for the
html file.

How can I do that?

Thanks.
--

Bob

Chris Ilias

unread,
Sep 17, 2006, 7:30:28 PM9/17/06
to
_Bob_ spoke thusly on 17/09/2006 7:17 PM:

> Chris Ilias <n...@ilias.ca> wrote:
>
>> You should then be able to import
>> that HTML file.
>
> When I click File | Import, the only choice is import from
> Internet Explorer. If I then click next, it goes on to
> import from IE; I'm never given the choice to browse for the
> html file.

Bookmarks-->Manage Bookmarks.
Then, in the Bookmarks Manager, File-->Import.

Bob

unread,
Sep 17, 2006, 7:57:59 PM9/17/06
to
Chris Ilias <n...@ilias.ca> wrote:

> Bookmarks-->Manage Bookmarks.
> Then, in the Bookmarks Manager, File-->Import.

I'm wondering whether something is screwy in my
installation.

I just tried the bookmarks manager, and out of over 9000
bookmarks it imported only the 10 or 15 that were in the
trash folder.

I tried it again by first emptying the trash folder in
Opera, exporting to html again, and this time Firefox
imported only the bookmark in the first subfolder of the
first folder. It didn't important the folder or subfolder
itself.

I'm guessing that to get this to work, I have to delete all
(sub)folders from the html, and in such case it's not going
to be imported in any sort of an organized fashion.

Is that common, or is this at least a known problem? In
other words, any way to deal with it?

Thanks.
--

Bob

Nir

unread,
Sep 17, 2006, 8:15:44 PM9/17/06
to

also see this link :
http://kb.mozillazine.org/Import_bookmarks#External_links
I think softwares listed here are freeware

Bob

unread,
Sep 17, 2006, 8:58:56 PM9/17/06
to
Nir <nir...@hotmail.com> wrote:

> also see this link :
> http://kb.mozillazine.org/Import_bookmarks#External_links
> I think softwares listed here are freeware

Right you are. I'll give one or a couple a try and report
back. (Probably tomorrow).

Thanks much.
--

Bob

gwtc

unread,
Sep 18, 2006, 2:33:15 PM9/18/06
to
I just checked and I had no problems whatsoever. From the bookmark
manager in Opera, File, Import/Export and export the bookmarks to an
html file. Then from FF, open the bookmark manager, and click on
File, Import and import the html file.

--
Pic of the Day: New Campbell's Soup:
http://img85.imageshack.us/my.php?image=creamofspamnx1.jpg

Bob

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 12:16:47 PM9/19/06
to
gwtc <TheNe...@4iVWMRLYahp.U7yjsIFfetn> wrote:

> I just checked and I had no problems whatsoever. From the
> bookmark manager in Opera, File, Import/Export and export
> the bookmarks to an html file. Then from FF, open the
> bookmark manager, and click on File, Import and import the
> html file.

I figured from the responses I've received so far that most
users would find that. Unfortunately, it doesn't appear to
work in my install. In my case it importants only the
bookmarks that appear in the first subfolder of the first
folder in the html that I exported from Opera.

What I'm going to try is opening the html in an editor (Word
should be good enough), and delete all the folders and
subfolders, then also delete all bookmarks I don't want to
import. Maybe that way I'll get somewhere.

Thanks for the suggestion.

--

Bob

gwtc

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 12:30:45 PM9/19/06
to
the other way is to replace the FF bookmarks.html file with the newly
created bookmarks file from Opera. Just rename it to bookmarks.html.
When its replaced, try importing the original FF bookmarks.html
file. [Hmmm, I wonder if that made sense?]

--
There's this fella with a parrot. And this parrot swears like an old
salt, I mean he's a pistol. He can swear for five minutes straight
without repeating himself. Trouble is, the guy who owns him is a
quiet, conservative type, and the bird's foul mouth is driving him
nuts. One day, it just gets to be too much and the guy grabs the bird
by the throat, shakes him really hard, and yells, "QUIT IT!" But this
just makes the bird mad and he swears more than ever. Then the guy
gets angry and says, "OK for you," and locks the bird in a kitchen
cabinet. This really aggravates the bird and he claws and scratches,
and when the guy finally lets him out, the bird cuts loose with a
stream of vulgarities that would make a sailor blush. At that point,
the guy is so mad that he throws the bird into the freezer. For the
first few seconds there is a terrible din. The bird kicks and claws
and thrashes. Then it suddenly gets very quiet. At first the guy just
waits, but then he starts to think that the bird may be hurt. After a
couple of minutes of silence, he's so worried that he opens up the
freezer door. The bird meekly climbs onto the man's outstretched arm
and says, "Awfully sorry about the trouble I gave you. I'll do my best
to improve my vocabulary from now on." The man is astounded and amazed
at the transformation that has come over the parrot. Then the parrot
says, . . . to be continued

Bob

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 2:05:47 PM9/19/06
to
gwtc <TheNe...@4iVWMRLYahp.U7yjsIFfetn> wrote:

> the other way is to replace the FF bookmarks.html file with
> the newly created bookmarks file from Opera. Just rename
> it to bookmarks.html. When its replaced, try importing the
> original FF bookmarks.html file. [Hmmm, I wonder if that
> made sense?]

It makes perfect sense, but I got a bizarre result.

I renamed the original bookmarks.html (in
D:\Firefox\defaults\profile) to something else and then
moved in the html from Opera and named it bookmarks.html.
And yet everything remained *exactly* the same: the
Bookmarks menu still shows everthing that was there from the
original bookmarks.html.

It made no difference that I then moved the old file out of
D:\Firefox\defaults\profile altogether. Firegox obviously is
getting its bookmark info from somewhere other than the
bookmarks.html file.

That makes no sense at all, but that's what happened.

Any idea what that's all about?
--

Bob

gwtc

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 2:47:25 PM9/19/06
to
When you're renaming and moving the files about, you're doing so with
the program closed? Right!?

Bob

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 3:29:48 PM9/19/06
to
gwtc <TheNe...@4iVWMRLYahp.U7yjsIFfetn> wrote:

> When you're renaming and moving the files about, you're
> doing so with the program closed? Right!?

Thinking it over, I can't remember, although I know that's
the way to do it in any browser.

To double check it I did it all over just now -- made sure
both Firefox was closed, new export from Opera, closed
Opera, renamed it bookmarks.html. Deleted the bookmarks.html
that was in Firefox and substituted the renamed file from
Opera. And same result -- the bookmarks menu *still* shows
the bookmarks from the original Firefox file.

Strange. Very Strange.

How can such things be?
--

Bob

gwtc

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 3:55:16 PM9/19/06
to
lets check something. In the address bar type in about:config and
look for this entry:

browser.bookmarks.file

do you have it? If so, then where is it pointing to? If not, then are
you using the correct bookmarks.html file in the correct profile.
Maybe you have more than one profile. Then in the about:config look
for this entry:

browser.cache.disk.parent_directory

this is the location of the cache. It should show the approximate
location of where your profile is. Is that the area you're looking in?

Chris Ilias

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 4:02:07 PM9/19/06
to
_Bob_ spoke thusly on 19/09/2006 12:16 PM:

> What I'm going to try is opening the html in an editor (Word
> should be good enough), and delete all the folders and
> subfolders, then also delete all bookmarks I don't want to
> import. Maybe that way I'll get somewhere.

The Bookmarks Converter Tool has a 30 day trial period. You should be
able to use it without paying.
http://www.magnusbrading.com/bmc/

Bob

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 5:12:21 PM9/19/06
to
gwtc <TheNe...@4iVWMRLYahp.U7yjsIFfetn> wrote:

> lets check something. In the address bar type in about:
> config and look for this entry:

> browser.bookmarks.file

> do you have it? If so, then where is it pointing to?

It's not there.

> If not, then are you using the correct bookmarks.html file
> in the correct profile. Maybe you have more than one
> profile. Then in the about:config look for this entry:

> browser.cache.disk.parent_directory

> this is the location of the cache.

> It should show the approximate location of where your
> profile is. Is that the area you're looking in?

It's not there either! There are only three entries
beginning in browser.cache.disk., and they are capacity;
enable; and cache_sll.

Any idea where to go from here?

Thanks.

--

Bob

Bob

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 5:14:10 PM9/19/06
to
Chris Ilias <n...@ilias.ca> wrote:

>_Bob_ spoke thusly on 19/09/2006 12:16 PM:

> The Bookmarks Converter Tool has a 30 day trial period.


> You should be able to use it without paying.
> http://www.magnusbrading.com/bmc/

That sounds like an idea.

I normally don't like to abuse the privilege of free trials
if I'm not truly considering a purchase (I'm the sort who
always makes donations for donation ware), but if push comes
to shove I've try it.

Thanks very much for the suggestion.
--

Bob

gwtc

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 5:35:44 PM9/19/06
to
in the address bar type in about:cache?device=disk and you should see
where the cache is located in the first 4 lines.

Bob

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 6:34:27 PM9/19/06
to
gwtc <TheNe...@4iVWMRLYahp.U7yjsIFfetn> wrote:

> in the address bar type in about:cache?device=disk
> and you should see where the cache is located in
> the first 4 lines.

OK, I'm getting somewhere. It's in C:\Documents and
Settings\< user name>\Local Settings\Application
Data\Mozilla\Firefox\ Profiles\xnwooot8.default\Cache

Where do I go from here?

Thanks.
--

Bob

gwtc

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 6:59:03 PM9/19/06
to

your bookmarks should be located here: xnwooot8.default. Is that
where you have been looking?

Bob

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 7:29:31 PM9/19/06
to
gwtc <TheNe...@4iVWMRLYahp.U7yjsIFfetn> wrote:

> your bookmarks should be located here: xnwooot8.default. Is that
> where you have been looking?

There are two things in that folder: the Cache Folder, which
in turns contains a bunch of stuff, though nothing that has
a name similar to bookmarks and a single file named XUL.mfl.

Is that mfl file something that relates to bookmarks?

Thanks.
--

Bob

gwtc

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 7:37:17 PM9/19/06
to

have you not been reading? I said the bookmarks file will be located
in xnwooot8.default. In another post I said the name of the file is
bookmarks.html

Chris Ilias

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 7:54:10 PM9/19/06
to
_Bob_ spoke thusly on 19/09/2006 7:29 PM:

> There are two things in that folder: the Cache Folder, which
> in turns contains a bunch of stuff, though nothing that has
> a name similar to bookmarks and a single file named XUL.mfl.
>
> Is that mfl file something that relates to bookmarks?

Remove \Local Settings\ from the path.
For more on profiles, and their locations, see
<http://www.mozilla.org/support/firefox/profile>

Bob

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 8:13:10 PM9/19/06
to
gwtc <TheNe...@4iVWMRLYahp.U7yjsIFfetn> wrote:

> have you not been reading? I said the bookmarks file will
> be located in xnwooot8.default. In another post I said
> the name of the file is bookmarks.html

There's no reason to be testy.

I have been reading, but that's not going to place the
bookmarks.html file there if it isn't there. If it's not
there, but you tell me that "the bookmarks file" *is* there,
then that file obviously has to be called something other
than bookmarks.html. The next logical step therefore is to
ask whether what's there is in fact a bookmark file. And so
that's what I asked.

From your last response, I guess that what's there isn't a
bookmark file after all.

Got it.
--

Bob

Bob

unread,
Sep 19, 2006, 8:29:09 PM9/19/06
to
Chris Ilias <n...@ilias.ca> wrote:

> Remove \Local Settings\ from the path.
> For more on profiles, and their locations, see
> <http://www.mozilla.org/support/firefox/profile>

And there it is.

I took the next step and re-named that bookmarks.html file
to something else, exported Opera bookmarks, renamed them to
bookmarks.html, and moved them into the folder.

The new file clearly is not recognized in place of the
original one, since the few bookmarks that appeared in
Firefox earlier are now gone, and in their place are
bookmarks from the new file (the one exported from Opera).

Unfortunately, I still have the problem that I had when I
tried to import the Opera file from the Bookmarks Manager --
I can see bookmarks only for the set contained in the first
subfolder of the first folder in the Opera bookmarks.

I then tried one other thing. I opened the Opera bookmarks
file (not the one I renamed and moved into Firefox, but a
different copy) and edited it so as to remove all folder and
subfolder names, so that the file become simply a long list
of links. I then renamed that one bookmarks.html and
substituted it for the bookmarks folder that was already in
Firefox. The result was that no bookmarks whatever appear
when I open Firefox.

Should I be getting the message that my installation of FF
is corrupt, or is there something else I can try?

Thanks.
--

Bob

Chris Ilias

unread,
Sep 20, 2006, 1:44:44 AM9/20/06
to
_Bob_ spoke thusly on 19/09/2006 8:29 PM:

> I took the next step and re-named that bookmarks.html file
> to something else, exported Opera bookmarks, renamed them to
> bookmarks.html, and moved them into the folder.
>
> The new file clearly is not recognized in place of the
> original one, since the few bookmarks that appeared in
> Firefox earlier are now gone, and in their place are
> bookmarks from the new file (the one exported from Opera).

Firefox bookmark files have the DOCTYPE "<!DOCTYPE
NETSCAPE-Bookmark-file-1>". It's not a regular HTML file.

> Should I be getting the message that my installation of FF
> is corrupt, or is there something else I can try?

Try the Bookmarks Converter Tool.

0 new messages