Dear Aristotle,
DPOTRF computes the Cholesky factorization of a real symmetric
positive definite matrix.
My best guess is that some matrix in the MCSCF procedure which should always be positive definite, does not satisfy that condition.
The first recommendation I can give is to check again your wavefunction, occupation, symmetry, etc. specifications and to check the output carefully for any mismatches between your expectations and the output (before the error).
If the input is sure to be correct, you could probably try looking for MCSCF options that influence orthogonalization.
Best regards,
Tibor Győri