--- Original Message -----
From:
Mark G.
To:
SArjuna
Sent:
Friday, February 20, 2009 5:56 PM
Subject:
Re: Brussels' new EMR standard: 3 volts per sq. meter
Thanks Shivani!
Does anyone have a
current chart showing the different limits/standards in different
countries in V/m for Microwave Radiation and also a chart for
Electromagnetic Fields???
-----
Original Message -----
From:
SArjuna
Sent:
Friday, February 20, 2009 8:47 PM
Subject:
Brussels' new EMR standard: 3 volts per sq. meter
The Brussels shock wave
The suit of the phone companies and the federal government
has been dismissed and the Brussels standards validated; a definite
step forward in protecting health from radiation.
Three volts per metre: that's now the only valid standard for exposure
to electromagnetic microwaves in force. In its decision published this
Thursday the Constitutional Court confirmed this statutory limit, due
to come into force in the Brussels Region on 15th March next.
The outcome was by no means a foregone conclusion for the
Brussels government. In their appeal to have the motion brought by the
MP Dominique Braeckman (Ecologist) quashed, the phone companies
Belgacom, Mobistar and Base, as well as the federal government,
considered that only the federal authority had the power to legislate
on standards aimed ultimately at protecting human health.
The Constitutional Court swept aside these arguments and
judged a contrario that "the Regions have
the authority to prevent and to combat different types of environmental
pollution, and that this authority confers the right to take measures
to prevent and to limit risks (…), including limiting people's exposure
to the risks from these types of radiation."
The Court goes even further and judges that on the basis of
its redefined competence, "the federal authority no longer
has the power to set statutory exposure levels. (…) The
choice made by the regional legislature (…) to apply the principle of
precaution falls within the right of this legislative body to make its
own assessment and cannot be rejected simply because there are no
stricter international standards in force."
And what about freedom for business and industry? "This
cannot be held to be total freedom," the Court declared.
"The plaintiffs have not demonstrated that it is
technically or financially impossible to meet the standards set out in
the motion."
Needless to say the Brussels Environment Minister Evelyne
Huytebroeck (Ecologist) is delighted: "The Region has
just won a fundamental battle to preserve the quality of life of the
population in spite of the appeals by the federal minister at the time
(Ed: Rudy Demotte, Socialist, now the Walloon minister-president) and
by the phone companies," she said. "In the absence
of a scientific consensus, the principle of precaution dictates that we
should take measures to avoid the risk of irreversible damage to the
environment and to health."
The office of the federal Minister of Health Laurette
Onkelinx (Socialist) prefers to remain silent on the subject. At the
end of 2008 Laurette Onkelinx had made it known that she would follow
the recommendation of the Higher Council of Health, which has always
favoured the 3 V/m limit, even while the federal standard remained 20.6
V/m.
By coincidence, the Committee for Federal-Regional Concertation is due
to consider the question this coming Friday. In view of the content of
the Court's decision, it's unlikely that the reluctance of the Minister
of the Economy Vincent van Quickenborne (Walloon Liberal Democrats)
with regard to the 3 V/m level will have much influence.
: 3
In the Walloon region the Minister for Regional Development,
André Antoine (Humanist Democratic Centre), sent out a circular to the
local authorities at the beginning of the week, which also imposes the
3 V/m: "The decision of the Constitutional Court
is good news and closes the file on the subject," said
the minister. "So much so that, with my colleague
of the Environment Benoît Lutgen, I am presenting a bill to confirm the
3 V/m standard. It will be voted during this term."