Byron Crawford
unread,Jul 6, 2006, 11:20:47 AM7/6/06Sign in to reply to author
Sign in to forward
You do not have permission to delete messages in this group
Either email addresses are anonymous for this group or you need the view member email addresses permission to view the original message
to minds...@googlegroups.com
I don't usually write for print publications, but the EIC of Rime Magazine invited me to write a 500 word piece on why I'm in favor of H.R. 4437. How could I resist?
It would be cool to publish something like this in XXL, but I don't think they're really into politics like that.
I'm not sure when (or if) this will be published in Rime, but here it is for your reading pleasure. Don't republish it anywhere yet.
Why I'm in Favor of H.R. 4437
By Byron Crawford
For far too long now the United States' border zones have been one big
free for all. I'm in favor of H.R. 4437 because finally someone's
attempting to do something about it.
In
an ideal world, there'd be no need for borders between nations. We
wouldn't have to worry about violent rapists, crazed Arab terrorists,
and pro-life Catholics sneaking into the US, because there'd be no such
thing as violent rapists, crazed Arab terrorists, or pro-life Catholics
in the first place. Ah, wishful thinking.
Meanwhile, those are
about the only people who would even need to break into the US. The
delicious irony of illegal immigration, to witness the so-called
immigrants rights protests, is that basically all of the people
breaking into our country are people the government decided they don't
want here. These people aren't risking life and limb jumping over
barbed wire fences and running through hot, arid deserts because they
need the exercise, after all.
Indeed our government already
provides avenues to safe, legal immigration for people it feels would
be an asset. In an age when our economy is becoming increasingly
information-based, would it not follow that our country would want to
import people - human resources, if you will - with skills that lie in
these areas? Inviting this kind of people into our country would make
us that much more competitive on a global level.
The average illegal immigrant, meanwhile, is primarily an asset to
himself, his home country, and possibly Allah. While it's true that
many, if not most illegal immigrants come here to work, the vast
majority of them come here to work jobs that require little or no skill
and pay very little. In a country that already has such staggering
levels of poverty and income inequality, what sense does it make to
import yet another lower class?
Would it not make more sense to try to bring the lower class that we
already have up by providing them with the same opportunities that were
once offered their grandparent? It's the middle class, after all, that
makes the US the great nation that it is. According to the US Labor
Department, illegal immigrants depress wages for US workers by as much
as $200 billion a year. A meat-packing job that paid $19 in 1980 only
pays about $9 today.
Illegal immigration also places a tremendous burden on social services
such as schools and hospitals. Schools in California, according to
reports, are beginning to resemble... um, prisons in California,
complete with brown-on-black, Jim Morrison-style races wars. Hospitals
that have been forced to treat uninsured illegal immigrants, meanwhile,
have been thrust into financial turmoil. Many have even been forced to
close down.
As such, I can only be glad to see the government finally do something
about this. Illegal immigration is already, as its name would suggest,
illegal. Hopefully, H.R. 4437 will provide those charged with this task the strength necessary to actually enforce this law.