ILO-Studie zeigt negative Auswirkungen von TTIP auf EU auf

[Erwin Leitner [mehr demokratie!]]

 

From: recoveryhuma...@socpro.list.ilo.org [mailto:recoveryhuma...@socpro.list.ilo.org] On Behalf Of Capaldo, Jeronim
Sent: 29 October 2014 12:29
To: recovery...@socpro.list.ilo.org
Subject: [recovery_human_face] Study indicates EU-US trade deal (TTIP) would have negative effects in Europe

 

Dear Colleagues,

 

The EU and the US are currently negotiating the Trans-Atlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (or TTIP), an agreement aimed at boosting trade by eliminating differences in commercial regulations.  Official studies of TTIP project benefits in terms of GDP and household income while they are less clear about employment and income distribution.

 

Unfortunately, recent literature has shown that the main existing studies of TTIP rely on inadequate economic models (of the CGE type). Following this lead, in a Tufts University working paper I have analyzed TTIP with a different model -- the United Nations Global Policy Model -- and found dramatically different results. Here's a summary for the European Union:

• TTIP would lead to losses in terms of net exports after a decade, compared to the baseline scenario. Northern European Economies would suffer the largest losses (2.07% of GDP) followed by France (1.9%), Germany (1.14%) and United Kingdom (0.95%).

• TTIP would lead to net losses in terms of GDP. Consistent with figures for net exports, Northern European Economies would suffer the largest GDP reduction (-0.50%) followed by France (-0.48%) and Germany (-0.29%).

• TTIP would lead to a loss of labor income. France would be the worst hit with a loss of 5,500 Euros per worker, followed by Northern European Countries (-4,800 Euros per worker), United Kingdom (-4,200 Euros per worker) and Germany (-3,400 Euros per worker).

• TTIP would lead to job losses. We calculate that approximately 600,000 jobs would be lost in the EU. Northern European countries would be the most affected (-223,000 jobs), followed by Germany (-134,000 jobs), France (- 130,000 jobs) and Southern European countries (-90,000).

• TTIP would lead to a reduction of the labor share (the share of total income accruing to workers), reinforcing a trend that has contributed to the current stagnation. The flipside of its projected decrease is an increase in the share of profits and rents, indicating that proportionally there would be a transfer of income from labor to capital. The largest transfers will take place in UK (7% of GDP transferred from labor to profit income), France (8%), Germany and Northern Europe (4%).

• TTIP would lead to a loss of government revenue. The surplus of indirect taxes (such as sales taxes or value-added taxes) over subsidies will decrease in all EU countries, with France suffering the largest loss (0.64% of GDP). Government deficits would also increase as a percentage of GDP in every EU country, pushing public finances closer or beyond the Maastricht limits.

• TTIP would lead to higher financial instability and accumulation of imbalances. With export revenues, wage shares and government revenues decreasing, demand would have to be sustained by profits and investment. But with flagging consumption growth, profits cannot be expected to come from growing sales. A more realistic assumption is that profits and investment (mostly in financial assets) will be sustained by growing asset prices. The potential for macroeconomic instability of this growth strategy is well known after the recent financial crisis.

These results point to a general conclusion: seeking a higher trade volume is not a sustainable growth strategy for the EU. In the current context of austerity, high unemployment and low growth, increasing the pressure on labor incomes would further harm economic activity. On the contrary, any viable strategy to rekindle economic growth in Europe would have to build on a strong policy effort in support of labor incomes.

 

Best,

 

Jeronim Capaldo

Econometrics and Data Specialist

Social Protection Department

International Labour Organization

4 route des Morillons
CH-1211 Genève 22
Switzerland

Tel. +41-(0)22-799-6729

 

Please share your inputs by e-mailing: recovery...@socpro.list.ilo.org    To join or leave this e-discussion, send an email with subscribe or unsubscribe in the subject field. To see all messages http://www.recoveryhumanface.org/    This e-discussion is intended to facilitate the exchange of knowledge and ideas; the views expressed by contributors do not reflect the policies of ILO.  The moderator of the e-discussion is Isabel Ortiz, contact: ort...@ilo.org

-----------------------------------------
This electronic message may contain confidential, proprietary or privileged information intended solely for the use of the named recipient. The ILO is not liable for any error or virus connected with this transmission.
-----------------------------------------
Ce message électronique peut contenir des informations confidentielles, ou spécialement protégées, à la seule intention du destinataire. L'OIT ne peut être tenue responsable des erreurs ou des virus qui s'y trouveraient.
-----------------------------------------
Este mensaje electrónico puede contener información confidencial o especialmente protegida para el uso exclusivo del destinatario indicado. La OIT no se responsabiliza en caso de error o virus.
-----------------------------------------