JMS CIS Digest: 14-Dec-99 00:03 through 14-Dec-99 00:03 (2 msgs)
John D. Hardin
J. Michael Straczynski <71016...@compuserve.com>
14-Dec-99 00:03 through 14-Dec-99 00:03 (2 messages)
WARNING: This digest may contain information about shows
you haven't seen yet ("spoilers"). Proceed with caution.
Subjects in digest:
B5 versus ST:TNG
Administrivia:
South Park fans may wish to visit:
http://www.infinicorp.com/babylonpark/
Well, everybody, thanks to your kind letters (and a new job)
I'm reconsidering my decision to discontinue the Digest. Stay
tuned for the final word...
The administrivia for this digest may be read at
http://www.wolfenet.com/~jhardin/JMS-Digest-Administrivia.txt
It was last updated Sat Feb 13 10:21:30 1999
Replies to this digest go to John Hardin.
obSpoiler-space...
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
v
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Date: 12 Dec 1999 23:08:00 -0700
From: Carolyn Dodson <76337...@compuserve.com>
To: Michael Beemer <71551...@compuserve.com>
Subject: B5 versus ST:TNG
Message-ID: <forum.baby...@compuserve.com>
References: <forum.baby...@compuserve.com>
Message text written by Michael Beemer
> "They didn't want to corrupt the timeline, so they only went back to
> the most recent event they could effectively change."
No No No - if they are concerned with corrupting the timeline then you
can't go back at all - you always change something. I mean a whole
planet just blew up and the Enterprise just went pifta into the planet -
that's a big thing your changing. No I say if you are going to do
something do it big - besides they always seem to go back to the
beginning in Voyager. <g> Where's the consistency?
In all fairness I will admit to one problem I have in B5 plotdom and I
would like to know if this bothers anybody else? Why doesn't Sheridan
remember that Londo has a freakin Keeper. How can you go forward in
time and remember that Delenn says "do not go to Z'ha'dum" but you
forget that a one-eyed, ugly, creepy looking sucker is sticking out of
someone's neck. I mean I don't think that is something I would forget.
I mean Franklin found a Keeper on Mars and I assume he put it in a
report which I assume Sheridan read - he should be able to put 2 and 2
together. Has anyone ever raised this issue or read an explanation from
JMS on this - Mr. Straczynski, are you out there - what's the deal? Is
this going to be elaborated on in the "Legions of Fire" series? Just
wonderin'
cjd
------------------------------
Date: 14 Dec 1999 00:03:08 -0700
From: J. Michael Straczynski <71016...@compuserve.com>
To: Carolyn Dodson <76337...@compuserve.com>
Subject: B5 versus ST:TNG
Message-ID: <forum.baby...@compuserve.com>
References: <forum.baby...@compuserve.com>
"In all fairness I will admit to one problem I have in B5 plotdom and
I would like to know if this bothers anybody else? Why doesn't Sheridan
remember that Londo has a freakin Keeper. How can you go forward in
time and remember that Delenn says "do not go to Z'ha'dum" but you
forget that a one-eyed, ugly, creepy looking sucker is sticking out of
someone's neck. I mean I don't think that is something I would forget.
I mean Franklin found a Keeper on Mars and I assume he put it in a
report which I assume Sheridan read - he should be able to put 2 and 2
together. Has anyone ever raised this issue or read an explanation from
JMS on this - Mr. Straczynski, are you out there - what's the deal? Is
this going to be elaborated on in the "Legions of Fire" series? Just
wonderin'"
It's real simple. That vision was almost 20 years in the
future.
At what point should Sheridan assume the Keeper landed on Londo?
For all he knows, it got there a week before. Nothing in Londo's
behavior in the present B5 storyline says "keeper." People start wars
all the time without the necessity of having keepers. Londo has
certainly had his changes and swings in mood prior to having a Keeper.
WE know this because we have privileged information which Sheridan does
not.
If Londo had said "I got this thing in x-year," then that's one
thing, but absent that...there's no way for Sheridan to know that he
didn't get it 10 or 15 years down the line...and, equally, no way to
know what future events he might change -- possibly for the worse -- by
trying to warn Londo. (And, in fact, if he did try to tell Londo about
this, the Drakh would realize that Londo had been compromised, and they
would probably simply kill him and bring someone else into that
role...so Sheridan's right in that respect.)
jms
------------------------------
End of JMS CIS Digest 14-Dec-99 00:03 through 14-Dec-99 00:03
*************************************************************
Support the anti-Spam bill - join at http://www.cauce.org
rec.arts.sf.tv.babylon5.info <*> Submissions: b5-...@plage.stanford.edu
Another fine service of ISN Mars Comments: b5-info...@plage.stanford.edu