The shooting i Minneapolis

[John Williams]

The NY Times has an analysis of the videos of the shooting in Minneapolis.  Here is the transcript:

On Wednesday in Minneapolis, a federal agent fatally shot a motorist, 37-year-old Renee Nicole Good. Trump administration officials said these were “defensive shots” fired because the officer was being run over. But our analysis of bystander footage, filmed from different angles, appears to show the agent was not in the path of the victim’s SUV when he fired three shots at close range. Here’s how events unfolded. Moments before the shooting, the victim’s maroon SUV is stopped in the middle of the street. Multiple unmarked federal vehicles are idling nearby. Secretary Noem alleged the motorist “was blocking the officers in.” Bystanders are blowing whistles and yelling at federal agents. Then, federal vehicles start moving toward the maroon SUV with sirens and lights blaring. A federal agent films the scene on his phone. The driver rolls forward slightly, turning left, then stops and waves for others to go ahead. Two agents exit this silver pickup and walk toward the vehicle. Moments later, shots are fired. Let’s look at the scene again more closely. This is the agent who shoots the driver. He walks around the car filming and disappears from view. Other agents pull up and order the driver to exit her vehicle. One of them grabs at the door handle and reaches inside. The SUV reverses, then turns right, apparently attempting to leave. At the same time, the agent filming crosses toward the left of the vehicle and grabs his gun. He opens fire on the motorist and continues shooting as she drives past. The moment the agent fires, he is standing here to the left of the SUV and the wheels are pointing to the right away from the agent. This appears to conflict with allegations that the SUV was ramming or about to ram the officer. President Trump and others said the federal agent was hit by the SUV, often pointing to another video filmed from a different angle. And it’s true that at this moment, in this grainy, low-resolution footage, it does look like the agent is being struck by the SUV. But when we synchronize it with the first clip, we can see the agent is not being run over. In fact, his feet are positioned away from the SUV. The SUV crashes into a white car parked down the road. A bystander runs toward the collision. The federal agents on scene do not appear to rush to provide emergency medical care. Eventually, the agent who shot the motorist approaches the vehicle. Seconds later, he turns back around and tells his colleagues to call 911. Agents blocked several bystanders who attempt to provide medical care, including one who identifies himself as a physician. At the same time, several agents, including the agent who opened fire, get in their vehicles and drive off, apparently altering the active crime scene.

[Robert Yosha]

Stop with the truthiness, John! Your goals are suspect.

You keep trying to inform folks; informed citizens may create a threat to this nation's goals and that should be clear to you by now. 

Accuracy and truth ruin our country and will likely interfere with President Trump's intent. Our Trumplican friends are going to report you (our nation now has a reporting system for folks insinuating or using words unfavorable to our president) if you persist in your silly, obsolete effort to prevent harm to innocent people by resurrecting our historical, US constitutionally-derived structure.  

You speak as if US citizens should still respect that now thoroughly quashed creed and system of government. Get real! Next, you'll want equality for non-whites and non-fake-Christians. 

You must be old. Get with it. Stop living in the past with your outdated democratic objectives!

 

Downright Un-American of you, John . . .

---

From: mat...@googlegroups.com <mat...@googlegroups.com> on behalf of John Williams <jgw...@frontiernet.net>
Sent: Thursday, January 8, 2026 8:23 AM
To: Mattole Valley Bulletin Board <mat...@googlegroups.com>
Subject: The shooting i Minneapolis

 

The NY Times has an analysis of the videos of the shooting in Minneapolis.  Here is the transcript:

On Wednesday in Minneapolis, a federal agent fatally shot a motorist, 37-year-old Renee Nicole Good. Trump administration officials said these were “defensive shots” fired because the officer was being run over. But our analysis of bystander footage, filmed from different angles, appears to show the agent was not in the path of the victim’s SUV when he fired three shots at close range. Here’s how events unfolded. Moments before the shooting, the victim’s maroon SUV is stopped in the middle of the street. Multiple unmarked federal vehicles are idling nearby. Secretary Noem alleged the motorist “was blocking the officers in.” Bystanders are blowing whistles and yelling at federal agents. Then, federal vehicles start moving toward the maroon SUV with sirens and lights blaring. A federal agent films the scene on his phone. The driver rolls forward slightly, turning left, then stops and waves for others to go ahead. Two agents exit this silver pickup and walk toward the vehicle. Moments later, shots are fired. Let’s look at the scene again more closely. This is the agent who shoots the driver. He walks around the car filming and disappears from view. Other agents pull up and order the driver to exit her vehicle. One of them grabs at the door handle and reaches inside. The SUV reverses, then turns right, apparently attempting to leave. At the same time, the agent filming crosses toward the left of the vehicle and grabs his gun. He opens fire on the motorist and continues shooting as she drives past. The moment the agent fires, he is standing here to the left of the SUV and the wheels are pointing to the right away from the agent. This appears to conflict with allegations that the SUV was ramming or about to ram the officer. President Trump and others said the federal agent was hit by the SUV, often pointing to another video filmed from a different angle. And it’s true that at this moment, in this grainy, low-resolution footage, it does look like the agent is being struck by the SUV. But when we synchronize it with the first clip, we can see the agent is not being run over. In fact, his feet are positioned away from the SUV. The SUV crashes into a white car parked down the road. A bystander runs toward the collision. The federal agents on scene do not appear to rush to provide emergency medical care. Eventually, the agent who shot the motorist approaches the vehicle. Seconds later, he turns back around and tells his colleagues to call 911. Agents blocked several bystanders who attempt to provide medical care, including one who identifies himself as a physician. At the same time, several agents, including the agent who opened fire, get in their vehicles and drive off, apparently altering the active crime scene.

--
How to Google Group:
1. Please sign your posts. Your email address alone isn't enough.
2. No more than two posts per day from each person on any single topic.
3. No personal attacks. Write as though you’re standing on the porch of the general store addressing about 300 of your neighbors.
4. Kindly be clear in your post's Subject line, to respect readers' time.
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Mattole Valley Bulletin Board" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to mattole+u...@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/mattole/c3ff9ad3-0a14-4cf6-8b79-a528347ea8f4n%40googlegroups.com.

[Barbara Christe]

Rob, are you feeling satirical? I hope you are. Sorry i can’t process satire at this point…my bad?

[John Williams]

Alpha News has a new video of the event: https://bsky.app/profile/thetnholler.bsky.social/post/3mbz3va3en22e

This seems to have been from the cell phone or body camera of one of the agents.  It shows Good's partner mouthing off at the agents, but hardly seems consistent with Good trying to hurt the agent.  

It isn't clear how Alpha News got the video, but it does seem to be right-wing:  https://alphanews.org/category/news/mn-news/