These articles are fascinating! That review is just incredible of "You Do Something To Me", were these critics deaf?
This is for all general Lanza-related comments that you feel don't require their own separate thread.
Last weekend I attended a showing of the film by Barney Snow: “Some Day I’ll Find You,” about the search for the person, AJW, responsible for the sketches, as discussed here earlier. It was said that a quarter of a million were placed mainly around the Black Country, over the last forty years. It was a most enjoyable evening with excerpts from Mario Lanza films, with Barney Snow and the ex-policeman, who did the investigating in the film, answering questions at the end. There were also original sketches on beer mats and postcards etc. we were allowed to handle. I was unable to obtain any, but the entrance ticket, with a Mario beer mat as a jig-saw, I thought was attractive and collectable, reflecting Snow’s artistic training. I suppose these sketches would be easy for someone with artistic bent to fake, but blank beer mats were supplied with marker pens and a contest to see who could make the best copy; of the twenty or thirty submitted none were very convincing.
I was going to give some background about the Black Country and, to put it politely, the “rivalry” between the Black Country and Birmingham (UK) concerning the showing referred to here earlier, but I do tend to bore people. Also I am not sure I should go into detail about the film at the risk of spoiling it for others who may want to see it. It was said that AJW was around nineteen years old when he started and was about sixty-five when the film was made. There was film of his hands making a sketch forty years ago on a news programme and again when the film was made. The hands were grimy, typical of someone working in engineering, and that is what the Black Country was famous for. Both times he left a gap between the “L” and the “A” in Lanza, an indication that the sketches are genuine.
I was amused on several occasions; a woman in the audience asked Snow if AJW is a Black Countryman, “I mean is he one of us?” highlighting the identity Black Country people embrace. One of the sketches had: “At the end of his life Picasso painted little blue circles in the corner of his pictures; there was a simple explanation for this: The man was crackers.” Two people said they had come across sketches in the past and never thought to pick them up.
Hi Norma: With Derek out of action for a few days I’ll answer your question about Marcheta.
As far as I know he recorded the song only once for his Coca Cola Radio program in March, 1952.
The song is on the CD Mario Lanza –When Day is Done, which is available on Amazon on the following link:
Cheers,
Armando
I understand that Mario sang Marcheta twice-once on the coca cola show and once live. On which radio programme did he sing it live and is it on a CD? Thanks to everyone. Norma.
Hi Norma: I don’t use Spotify, but from what you are saying it sounds to me as if the supposedly multiple versions are simply the same one taken from different pirated CDs and downloaded at different speeds. This would account for the higher sounding voice on the particular one you are referring to. Believe me, Lanza made only one recording of Marcheta- the Coca Cola one.
Cheers,
Armando
“A RARE TREAT.”
I just wanted to tell you that Johanna von Koczian was among the guests in a Late Night Show (“Markus Lanz”) here on German TV tonight. She did talk very little about her career (time is limited anyway when there are several guest to be interviewed within an hour – and consequently the comments are more or less general).
One focus was on a song (Schlager) which she sang in 1977 and which was very popular here and with which she – after so many years - is still associated by more than only one generation, “Das bisschen Haushalt.”
She mentioned her father (she was from his 4th marriage) and how wonderful a man (and a very good looking, too!) he was, but also remarked that he did not want her to become an actress. She responded by telling him that she would become an actress in any case by the time of reaching her legal age, and that his “refusal” would only delay the start of her career, so her father eventually gave in to her wish. She made her stage debut at about 1952.
Johanna did not talk about any movies or TV films she appeared in in the past, neither did she speak about any future plans.
It was gratifying to hear that she’s in excellent health and goes to the gym three times a week. She turned 81 last October. She was very natural in her looks, no make-up hiding her age (her blonde hair was pinned up loosely – and no “grande dame allures” at all).
When she speaks (she has still the same soft voice) and smiles (those smiling eyes!) one can still see this lovely young girl that co-starred with Mario in his last film, “For the First Time.”
Just recently Johanna gave a lecture at a German theatre, reading short stories written by herself and other authors. As you can see, she’s still “in business” – no one of Mario’s leading ladies could surpass her in this! – and she can look back to a career spanning more than sixty years!
Seeing her “live” on TV was a real rarity!
I suppose that the show will be available as a “re-play” at the beginning of next week and you should be able then to watch it even if you do not live in Germany. I will let you know then.
Steff
Good to know that Johanna is still very active, Steff, and thank you for the update.
I wonder what happened to that autobiography she was supposedly writing!
Armando
She has aged gracefully without resorting to face lifts or plastic surgery which make many celebrities simply look ridiculous!
Hi, Steff: That’s an interesting subject you brought up. Firstly, it’s essential to distinguish nasality from nasal resonance. Nasality implies singing almost entirely through the nose and that’s a no-no! It’s a sign of lack of technique and such a singer would have a very short career, if any.
Domingo is a case in point. He does sound nasal, mostly in his mid- range, but, although the sound is not particularly beautiful at times, it is nasal resonance and not nasality as such, or Domingo would have stopped singing a long time ago.
Mr. Blizzart is mistaken in attributing to both Wunderlich and Lanza nasality used in beautiful ways. What it is, instead, is the most beautiful of nasal resonance.
Cheers,
Armando
It is nice to see that Mario Lanza is not forgotten. There was a history book published just recently (December 2015), titled “Scranton – The First 150 Years 1866-2016” which celebrates Scranton’s 150th anniversary. Among the approximately 250 photos there’s one of Mario visiting (with Sam Weiler) a local record store (1951):
“I submitted two photos taken inside the Globe Store during the mid-1950s. One included in the publication was a photo of Mario Lanza’s visit to the Globe record department prior to a performance at the former Catholic Youth Center, which appeared on page 87 in the publication.” (As told by Helen Gohsler, a former Globe Store employee who provided the photo of Mario for the book) (source: http://thetimes-tribune.com/opinion/letters/your-opinion-1.2004021)
For more information about the book please follow the link below:
The photo of Mario is different to the one that Armando has included in the first (also second?) edition of his book “Mario Lanza – An American Tragedy” (photo no.113) Mario is blowing kisses to his many fans. Sam Weiler is not with Mario “on the stage” on this photo but can be spotted among the enthusiastic crowd, on Mario’s right.
Steff--
You received this message because you are subscribed to a topic in the Google Groups "Mario Lanza, Tenor" group.
To unsubscribe from this topic, visit https://groups.google.com/d/topic/mariolanza/XrE3gHV3v7c/unsubscribe.
To unsubscribe from this group and all its topics, send an email to mariolanza+...@googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.
Carreras’s parents didn’t go to the opera when he was growing up, but as a child he did happen to see Mario Lanza in the film The Great Caruso, and it changed his life. “I was six and I wanted to be him, so I would spend hours singing 'le donna e mobile’ in the bathroom.”
Does he wonder what might have become of his life if he hadn’t by chance seen that film? “I don’t know, I think I would still have been drawn to the arts. I don’t think I would have been a footballer, though I have always been passionate about it.”
Wonderful! Glad to see Mario in the NY Times.
Ciao!
Tony
Thanks for the post Steff!
Tony
Tony Partington
--
Charles W. Harrison - Tenor
Amazing, what beautiful sound a voice can still produce in its mid-70s!
Watch out for the American tenor Charles W. Harrison (1878 – 1965), one of the first recording artists – and without doubt one of the busiest and most industrious ones - of the acoustic era. He made his first recordings in 1911 and his last ones in 1954! Apparently he never followed a career on the opera stage, so similar to Mario Lanza he was a tenor “in a category of his own,” so to speak.
In May 1954 – a few months before Harrison turned 76 - his LP album was released titled “Charles Harrison Sings Again” containing 8 songs, among them, interestingly, 4 songs that Mario Lanza also recorded. Here they are, and I think they are just beautifully sung (at the piano: George Blake) which can especially be said about his rendition of D’Hardelot’s “Because.” Harrison still has a very good voice control. A voice which was taken good care of for many decades, I’d say.
Steff
“Because” - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xh4NYIIVN3I
“Somewhere a Voice is Calling” - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XlmKrTwDD34
“Song of Songs” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SCwnlNUSlYM
“For You Alone” - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wUDmEZjKg6k
Here’s an excerpt from the book “The Twilight of Belcanto” written by Leonardo Ciampa
(Act II “Journey – Interludio: Other Rosati Students – Mario Lanza)
I think this book was never mentioned here before, but I noticed that Ciampa’s opinion about Mario Lanza’s “Mattinata” was included years ago on two other threads of this forum.
“[…] Lanza’s forays into classical music were „a mixed bag.“ Among the less successful examples are his butchering of ‘Mattinata’: wrong notes, and a diction that can barely be called Italian.
But a staggering example of Lanza’s classical potential can be heard in his recordings of Scenes 2 & 3 from Act III of ‘Otello,’ with the great Licia Albanese. If you think I am crazy, listen for yourself. You won’t believe it. The richness of the middle voice! Fearless, spinning high notes! The perfectly placed ‘declamati!’ The overflowing Italian warmth! The almost animalistic quality of Otello’s character! I don’t know how he got all that in there, but he did. (Albanese certainly had the Italian approach in spades; she could have helped at least with that. But the rest?)
Whatever you do, do not disparage the natural voice that God gave to Lanza, because it was one of the century’s greatest. There was not one teacher, critic, or colleague who disagreed on this point. Rosati, though immensely frustrated by Lanza’s drunkenness, whoring, and distaste for work, admitted that Lanza’s was THE best tenor voice he encounted since Gigli’s […].”
As a side note: The author Ciampa says the following about the Russian tenor Vladimir Atlantov: “Now you want to know a tenor that, had he managed to slip through the Russian beaurocracy, would have put a dent in the incomes of Corelli, Tucker, and several others? His name was Vladimir Atlantov. Never heard of him? Nor has most anybody. The few difficult-to-locate records of this Russian phenomenon confirm that his was one of the greatest tenor instruments of his time, or at any time. Imagine the young Carreras, only with a healthy technique and Mario Lanza’s passion.
Steff
As I was writing my yesterday’s post about the book “The Twilight of Belcanto” I was reminded of another book which also singled out Mario Lanza’s outstanding Otello recording with Licia Albanese for the movie “Serenade.”
The title of this German book is „Grosse Stimmen – Von Enrico Caruso bis Jessy Norman" (Great Voices – From Enrico Caruso to Jessye Norman) by Jens Malte Fischer.
It seems that Mario’s interpretation of Otello is one of those rare recordings that have equally impressed his devotees and his unbelievers/detractors. A true ‘breathtaker’ – Simply unsurpassed!
Here are two excerpts from the book (Translation by Steff Walzinger):
From the chapter “First Intermezzo: The Highlight of Italian Dramatic Singing: Otello, the Role and Its Singer:”
There’s a recording probably from the mid-fifties of the scene “Dio ti giocondi.” One could even lead clever voice experts up the garden path with it because only very few would recognize this impressive, beautifully timbred tenor voice, as being that of Mario Lanza (1921-1959) who was an unfortunate victim of Hollywood and of his own unsteady personality. This recording (with a somewhat more than mature Licia Albanese as Desdemona) belies all those who claim over and over that Lanza’s voice would have been unsuitable for the stage. Opportunities to manipulate [recordings] were relatively small in those days and it cannot be denied that here can be heard an extraordinarily beautiful tenor voice of a virile timbre whose placement and technique were quite steady. Why should this voice not have been able to fill a theatre? Lanza’s voice was not exceedingly big but possessed quite a sufficient middle volume. It would have been necessary to refine the singer’s intelligence and musicality considerably, but, in this regard, even more famous colleagues would have needed some coaching as well.
It might well be that I am all alone with my opinion, but I regard Lanza as an extraordinary vocal talent for which a great opera career would have been possible if it had gotten the chance to mature.
From the chapter “Third Intermezzo: The Peculiar [Singers] and the Outsiders, the Underestimated and the Unknown [Singers]:”
The question is if Lanza was, like many opera lovers in his time thought and many still think nowadays, only one talent among a dozen others and artificially hyped by Hollywood or if he was a truly great talent. I strongly tend to the latter opinion. If one watches the Caruso movie or listens to his not so many opera recordings nowadays, it can be noticed that he was not a particularly cultivated al fresco singer and that his voice did not even have an overly great resemblance to Caruso’s. However, the vocal material, the richness and abundance of this tenor was so great that, in those days as well as today, a truly great opera career would have been indeed possible had he gotten the right instructions.
As an experiment just play one of Lanza’s opera recordings (for example the scene Otello/Desdemona “Dio ti giocondi”) without mentioning his name and compare them with more famous opera voices. You will notice the excitement of all listeners who usually would express strong reservations knowing that it is Lanza, the tragic figure in musical history which on its part would have deserved a realistic-critical film titled “The Talented but Unfortunate Lanza” [RCA]. (Translation by Steff Walzinger).
Steff
Whenever I read the article below which I came across many years ago I am amazed about the myriad of great artists that Mario met.
The event took place 10 days after Mario Lanza’s and Dorothy Kirsten’s St. Rafael concert (27 June 1948) and about two weeks before Mario Lanza’s second appearance at the Hollywood Bowl (24th July 1948, “Symphonies under the Stars”).
Music Group Honors Widow of Composer
A noted assemblage of composers, conductors and well-known musical artists attended the dinner given by Eugene Ormandy and the Hollywood Bowl Association in honor of Mme. Alma Mahler-Werfel, in the Crystal Room of Beverly Hills Hotel last night. Mme. Mahler-Werfel is the widow of the famous Austrian composer and conductor, Gustav Mahler, whose Eighth Symphony, “The Symphony of a Thousand,” will be presented in Hollywood Bowl under Ormandy’s direction on July 29. The work is dedicated to Mme. Mahler-Werfel.
Noted composers attending the dinner were Igor Stravinsky, Arnold Schoenberg, Italo Montemezzi, Erich Wolfgang Korngold, George Antheil, Louis Gruenberg, Ernst Toch, Arthur Bergh, Miklos Rozsa, William Grant Still, Richard Hageman, and Eugene Zador.
Conductors present besides Mr. Ormandy were Bruno Walter, Ivan Boutnikoff, Franz Waxman, Frederick Zweig, Robert Zeller, Leith Stevens and Richard Lert. Other well-known musicians attending were Joseph Szigeti, Dorothy Kirsten, Eula Beal, Mario Lanza, Amparo Iturbi, Olive Mae Beach, Maurice Zam, Andres de Segurola, Susanna Foster and Lester Donahue.
Other guests included Thomas Mann, famous novelist; Fr. Gustave Arlt of UCLA; Ida Koverman, chairman of Mayor Bowron’s advisory committee for music and member of the art commission; C. E. Toberman, president of the Hollywood Bowl Association; George Pike, chairman of the associated board, Hollywood Bowl Association; Ralph Yambert, member of the associate board; J. Arthur Lewis, coordinator, Los Angeles Bureau of Music, and Mrs. Joseph J. Levy, chairman, Hollywood Bowl hospitality committee.(From the Los Angeles Times, 8 July 1948)
Side note: The German novelist Thomas Mann and his family lived at Pacific Pallisades between 1942 – 1952, so, if only for a short time, they were ‘neighbours’ of Mario Lanza’s parents – If I am not mistaken Toni and Maria Cocozza moved to Pacific Pallisades around 1950.
Attached is a photo of that event, showing (from left to right: Bruno Walter, Alma Mahler-Werfel, Eugene Ormandy, Dorothy Kirsten and Igor Strawinsky (photo taken from www.alma-mahler.at)
Steff
This is what José Carreras said this month, June 2016, in an interview for the German newspaper “Welt am Sonntag:”
Den Film, der ihn zum Singen brachte, sieht er sich immer wieder mal an: "Der große Caruso" mit Mario Lanza in der Hauptrolle.
"Der Film ist jetzt 65 Jahre alt, ich habe ihn natürlich auf DVD. Wann immer ich ihn mir anschaue, genieße ich ihn noch genauso wie damals, als ich ihn zum ersten Mal sah."
He [Carreras] watches the film that got him to become a singer again and again: It is ‘The Great Caruso’ with Mario Lanza in the title role:
“The film now is 65 years old, and of course I have it on DVD. Whenever I watch it, I still enjoy it as much as I did at the time I saw it for the very first time.”
Steff
--
Zsa Zsa Gabor, one of Mario’s great co-stars, passed away yesterday, 18th December 2016, at the (estimated) age of 99. R.I.P.
There’s a terrific photo (see attachment) of Zsa Zsa Gabor (AP, photo by Mario Torrisi) – it belongs to a series of photos that also show her with Mario and the film team - which was taken on 2 October 1958 during a reception at the “Incom” movie studios in Rome to celebrate the beginning of the filming of Mario’s last film “For the First Time.” The photo is featured in the article: “Before Kim Kardashian, Zsa Zsa Gabor was the ultimate socialite:”
In browsing some you-tube videos today I noticed that Zsa Zsa Gabor presented the “Oscar” 1952 in the category “Costume Designs (Black and White):”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ts9I7HF4To&list=PLJ8RjvesnvDPtmlakNWASv3xXgAEBrKD5&index=5
It was the same Academy Award Ceremony in which “The Great Caruso” was nominated in three categories:
Sound Recording: MGM Studio Sound Department, Douglas Shearer, Sound Director
Music (Scoring of a Musical Picture): Peter Herman Adler, Johnny Green
Costume Design (Color): Helen Rose, Gile Steele
As we know “The Great Caruso” eventually won the Academy Award in the category “Best Achievement by Studio Sound Department.” The American actress and dancer Cyd Charisse presented the award to sound director Douglas Shearer:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=39cMy-Nh1uw&list=PLJ8RjvesnvDPtmlakNWASv3xXgAEBrKD5&index=9
Steff
--
The articles are of special importance as they contain some interesting new information:
They mention three songs that we were not aware Mario had them in his repertoire. These are "Auf Wiedersehn" by Sigmund Romberg, "I Love Life" by Manna-Zucca and "Perfect Day" by Carrie Jacobs Bond (Please note that the latter two were composed by women - remember that Mario's repertoire hardly contains any songs composed by women!). Mario sang these songs (and "One Alone" by Sigmund Romberg) with the chorus, which is special, as he usually only did solo numbers (or rather duets, for example with his "Bel Canto Trio" colleagues) during his concert appearances. Mario's accompanist for the two concerts was, as so often, Josef Blatt, the chorus' accompanist Merrill Lewis and the musical director the chorus founder himself, J. A. Breese.
Incidentally, one of the rewiews, which I am sure Derek McGovern, will soon add to the press section of www.mariolanzatenor.com, mentioned: "One new number was added to Wednesday's program. Following rendition of 'La donna e mobile' from Verdi's 'Rigoletto' in Italian, Mr. Lanza sang the same number in English, singing both to the chorus and to the audience." Do you all remember what Mario did years later at the Royal Albert Hall: "May I sing one half of the aria to the people behind me?" It seems that Mario revived this idea in London.
Of the three "new" songs I mentioned above some nice renditions can be found on you-tube.
Steff
--
Apart
from the concerts I unearthed the other day (Oshkosh, Wisconsin) and which I
posted about yesterday, I came across another "goody."
I am not sure if it was already known that the US-American actor Bradley Cooper (born 1975 in Philadelphia) is a fan of Mario Lanza. In some recent interviews which Cooper gave on the occasion of his directorial debut in the film “A Star is Born” (co-starring Lady Gaga) he mentions that he grew up with Mario’s recordings. As you may notice in the attached excerpts of some interviews with Bradley he mentions that he played Mario Lanza “on the red carpet.” In fact this was on 31 August 2018 and the occasion was the 75th Venice Film Festival (Biennale Cinema 2018).
And here is the proof:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kzk9quQ5f2o
Just start the video at 2:22. One of Mario’s recordings of “E lucevan le stelle” is played while Cooper walks the red carpet. Maybe some of our experts here can even identify the recording?
Steff
After a friend had pointed out to me recently that he also seemed to have recognized excerpts from the song "Marechiare" by Tosti I re-watched the complete video several times yesterday. And, indeed, after the aria "E lucevan le stelle" from Puccini's "Tosca" (about minute 2:00) Mario's recording of "Marechiare" is played (about minute 4:33).
But there's more to it than that. Tosti's song is followed by "La donna è mobile" from Verdi's "Rigoletto" (about minute 7:40) Besides, right at the beginning of the video, you see the fashion designer Donatella Versace appearing on the red carpet. That's the moment they play Stradella's "Gia il sole dal gange."
It really takes a good hearing combined with headphones to identify any music at all as all the screams of enthusiastic festival fans almost drown out the singing.
As far as I can see all recordings were taken from Mario's Royal Albert Hall recital. Maybe I am wrong but it appears to me that only excerpts of the songs/arias were played, not the complete recordings (maybe due to copyrights?).
Steff