Review Bank in Belize

[Viannie]

Please help me in approving a bank in Belize.  Greatly appreciated.   http://www.google.com/mapmaker?iwloc=0_0&gw=55&editids=uSKW9wweAOmbTWCS9z&dtab=overview&ll=30.045619,30.957584&spn=0.075486,0.146599&t=h&z=13&lyrs=4,5&lyt=large_map&hyaw=263.99300131883825

Viannie

[rjhintz]

Hi,

  Maybe it's just me, but this link doesn't seem right.  How did you get it?

--

Rich

[Viannie]

Hi,

I mistakenly uploaded the wrong link.   Please find the link here: http://goo.gl/fC9EC 

Kindly help me in reviewing so that I may get this published. 

Thank you for your help

Viannie

[rjhintz]

Link is here.

I'd normally approve this, but I'm concerned that the Anonymous approvals are by accounts the mapper may have created for the purpose of approving this feature.  We just had a big problem with this in Antigua and, if this is the case, I don't want to reward this behavior.

--

Rich

[Flash]

I am actually in the middle of writing some comments on this one; there are some concerns that prevent it's approval.

[rjhintz]

I have to admit that I didn't do any due diligence (since I didn't plan to approve once I saw the Anonymous approvals), so I can well understand that the feature may be hinky in other ways.

--

Rich

[Flash]

For one, the address is "2nd Floor" of a building, so it cannot have a boundary.  The only way to fix it will be to undo and start over; so those approvals will end up going away.

[Josh Manchester]

Also it is a PO Box which can’t be mapped either.

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Review Requests" group.
To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msg/map-moderating/-/cgZFE86F4tMJ.
To post to this group, send email to map-mod...@googlegroups.com.
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to map-moderatin...@googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/map-moderating?hl=en.

[rjhintz]

By the way, this feature, it's creation and the review process that we're fooling around with, is a good example of what we're discussing in objecting to Google's top contributor survey conclusions.  I could go into detail, but won't bother since it's a waste of time.

--

Rich

[Flash]

On Saturday, 16 June 2012 11:30:50 UTC-7, Josh Manchester wrote:

Also it is a PO Box which can’t be mapped either.

Yes, that is in my comments also.  Also needs the Local tag.

Viannie, please check the comments I have left you.  I will warn you though, while we can help you prepare this so it meets the guidelines; I am not sure there is an RER in Belize.  I am an RER just north of you, but my powers do not extend down.  Once you have this fixed up, we can put approvals on that show we checked it over, but you will likely then have to wait for a Google employee to put the final approval on it.

[Viannie]

Hello Everyone,

Thank you for your comments.  I am new to google map maker and I got involved really because it was a coworker of mines that created the mapping.   It was a personnel from the bank that is also new to google map maker made the mapping.  After she did it, we realized that it needed others to approve it, so I went into it to try and approve it.  I believe thats why it shows anonymous.  After seeing that the approvals were still pending we did some more research and I found this group where we can ask others to help us approve.  That is why I posted this recently.  I now realize that logging in and trying to approve it without any experience might have been a big mistake.  I wish we had done sufficient research before we mapped it.  

However, I appreciate all your comments and we will work on editing it so that it may be approved.  I read in one of the comments that it might have to be deleted.  Do you suggest that we delete and restart all over again with the correct information?

Thank You

Viannie

[Flash]

That was my comment.  There is no choice I am afraid; you could make all the other corrections without deleting; but you cannot remove the polygon that was drawn and so the only choice is to undo and start over.

What I would suggest, since the listing is almost correct, is to create the new one first.  Copy the information in the old one, making the changes I suggested in my comments (and not drawing a shape).  Once the new one is ready, which should only take 5 minutes, then undo the first attempt.