Seemingly rediculous answers to edits

[Patrick Shanahan]

msg #1

Your change has been denied by Google Reviewer Manjula, a trusted reviewer but will
be looked at by other reviewers.

Reason: Other
Comments:
Hi,Please resubmit the feature with the supportive information to validate the
changes made.Unfortunately, the edit cannot be approved.Thanks !
Reply

This change has total 0 approvals and 1 denials

Previous comments:

Hi, we are unable to confirm the changes made can you please provide us some
supportive information in this regard. Thank you
This is a personal residence This is NOT BLP Laser Engraving (by you)

Enable display of images to see the map.




msg #2
Dear paka


Your change has been denied by Google Reviewer Manjula, a trusted reviewer but will
be looked at by other reviewers.

Reason: Other
Comments:
Hi,Please resubmit the feature with the supportive information to validate the
changes made.Unfortunately, the edit cannot be approved.This link will help you in
understanding in editing features in Map maker http://goo.gl/k4yXA.Thanks !
Reply

This change has total 0 approvals and 1 denials

Previous comments:

Hi, we are unable to confirm the changes made can you please provide us some
supportive information in this regard. Thank you
This is a personal residence This is NOT BLP Laser Engraving (by you)

Enable display of images to see the map.


msg #3

Dear paka


Your change has been denied by Google Reviewer Barkha, a trusted reviewer.

Reason: Other
Comments:
.
Reply

This change has total 0 approvals and 1 denials

Previous comments:

Hi,Please resubmit the feature with the supportive information to validate the
changes made.Unfortunately, the edit cannot be approved.This link will help you in
understanding in editing features in Map maker http://goo.gl/k4yXA.Thanks !
Hi, we are unable to confirm the changes made can you please provide us some
supportive information in this regard. Thank you
This is a personal residence This is NOT BLP Laser Engraving (by you)

Enable display of images to see the map.



msg #4


Dear paka


Your change has been commented on by Google Reviewer Barkha, a trusted reviewer.

Comments:
Hi, Thanks for the edit. As per our resources we are not able to verify the changes
made please provide supportive details so that we can publish this edit. Personal
information is not allowed on maps, please confirm if the business exists or never
existed at this location, so that we can publish this edit. This link will help you
in understanding in editing features in Map maker http://goo.gl/k4yXA, Thanks!
Reply

This change has total 0 approvals and 0 denials

Previous comments:

This is MY house, I live here. It is not a business, BLP Laser Engraving. It is:
2929 Woodside Drive Plainfield, Indiana 46168-3003 It doesn't even look like a
business. (by you)
Previous reported inaccuracy not corrected accurately (by you)

Enable display of images to see the map.



msg #5

Dear paka


Your change has been denied by Google Reviewer Charan, a trusted reviewer.

Reason: Other
Comments:
.
Reply

This change has total 0 approvals and 1 denials

Previous comments:

Hi,as per our resources we are unable to verify the changes made to this feature at
this address location.Please provide supportive information or an official website
if any for verifying the same.Thanks!
Hi, Thanks for the edit. As per our resources we are not able to verify the changes
made please provide supportive details so that we can publish this edit. Personal
information is not allowed on maps, please confirm if the business exists or never
existed at this location, so that we can publish this edit. This link will help you
in understanding in editing features in Map maker http://goo.gl/k4yXA, Thanks!
This is MY house, I live here. It is not a business, BLP Laser Engraving. It is:
2929 Woodside Drive Plainfield, Indiana 46168-3003 It doesn't even look like a
business. (by you)
Previous reported inaccuracy not corrected accurately (by you)

Enable display of images to see the map.



msg #6

Dear paka


Your change has been denied by Google Reviewer Shirley, a trusted reviewer but will
be looked at by other reviewers.

Reason: Other
Comments:
Hi,as per our resources we are unable to verify the changes made to this feature at
this address location.Please provide supportive information or an official website
if any for verifying the same.Thanks!
Reply

This change has total 0 approvals and 1 denials

Previous comments:

Hi, Thanks for the edit. As per our resources we are not able to verify the changes
made please provide supportive details so that we can publish this edit. Personal
information is not allowed on maps, please confirm if the business exists or never
existed at this location, so that we can publish this edit. This link will help you
in understanding in editing features in Map maker http://goo.gl/k4yXA, Thanks!
This is MY house, I live here. It is not a business, BLP Laser Engraving. It is:
2929 Woodside Drive Plainfield, Indiana 46168-3003 It doesn't even look like a
business. (by you)
Previous reported inaccuracy not corrected accurately (by you)

Enable display of images to see the map.




I see little/no need to attempt corrections to googlemaps if this is standard!

[Craig Hartel]

Patrick,

Can you post a link? Maybe a bunch of us can add our voices to the edit.

[Patrick Shanahan]

thanks, here it be  :^)

https://sites.google.com/site/mapyourworldcommunity/discuss?place=topic/map-moderating/rbR5mrYXlRg&pli=1

[Craig Hartel]

Sorry for the confusion, Patrick. I meant a link to the feature you are trying to change in Map Maker. We can review the edits and either agree with the previous reviewers or agree with you! :^)

[Patrick Shanahan]

I am not really trying to change a "feature".  I tried to note that a Commercial Business who's address appears to be my *home* did/does not exist and that my home address was incorrectly positioned on the map.

I showed the correct location for my home and was asked to provide a "Category" so I indicated "Personal Residence" which I had to write in as it does not exist.

I really don't care about the "feature" but the incorrect address and the business which "is not there"!

I have attached a screen capture of the pertinent data.

Please advise.  I am feeling that this is not work the effort.

The business listed does not exist at my home.

If the attached screen capture does not appear, it can be seen at:

   http://wahoo.no-ip.org/~pat/googlemap.png

tks for your concern

[Patrick Shanahan]

looking for email

[canada_mapmaker]

@Patrick - could you post a link to the actual edit? The link provided is to another part of the Google Mapmaker forums.

[Patrick Shanahan]

http://goo.gl/k4yXA

http://www.google.com/mapmaker?gw=55&editids=1R6ScoRtOWal4BzLNG&iwloc=0_0&t=h&dtab=overview

is this what you want?

tks

[Patrick Shanahan]

[canada_mapmaker]

The second link, yes.

I think your best bet is to simply delete the item in question. Once you have done that post that you've done so and I'll have a look at it.

[Patrick Shanahan]

be glad to but do not see a way.  Instruction welcome.

appears to be a monumental *mess*.

[canada_mapmaker]

I just applied to have it deleted for you, and I provided a link to this forum thread. What I did:

- Clicked on Edit, then Select a Place

- Clicked on map in area of location in question

- BLP Laser Engraving appeared in the left pane; I clicked on Edit

- Clicked on Delete This

Now that I have applied for deletion, you can review the edit. Go to the area and click on the Review Edits button. My edit should come up (my username on MM is different than on the forum).

Post here if you're unsure how to review an edit.

Good luck!

[Patrick Shanahan]

I think I have approved your edit.  I hope this works now.

You might want to review my edit.

Thanks much

[canada_mapmaker]

You're still adding "Personal Residence" as a category for the location plus your personal phone numbers, which seem to be partially what was causing the denials previously.

[Patrick Shanahan]

Ok, didn't really understand.

I have removed "Personal Residence" and the phone numbers and email addr.

tks,

[Patrick Shanahan]

Maybe I am figuring it out  :^)

I have deleted the business and corrected the address

left off phone numbers, .....

tks,

[canada_mapmaker]

You've deleted the name but the marker is still there. There should be no point of interest there.

What I'm going to do is deny the latest edit, only so that there is only one pending edit in the queue for this location, which is the deletion I initiated that you have approved.

[IndianaRed]

For a start, I would ignore the marker location. Google doesn't know exactly where the addresses are in this case. Is there a residence at 2903? This business provided laser-engraved gifts and could well be a home based business.

See their original website: http://web.archive.org/web/20100123083400/http://blplaserengraving.com/

The current version says the business closed, Aug 1st [2010]: http://blplaserengraving.com/

The POI should be deleted as This place is closed, and perhaps moved over the residence at 2903.

[Patrick Shanahan]

On Thursday, December 15, 2011 12:58:41 AM UTC-5, IndianaRed wrote:

For a start, I would ignore the marker location. Google doesn't know exactly where the addresses are in this case. Is there a residence at 2903? This business provided laser-engraved gifts and could well be a home based business.

yes, but new owners in the last six months.

 

See their original website: http://web.archive.org/web/20100123083400/http://blplaserengraving.com/

not there now

 

The current version says the business closed, Aug 1st [2010]: http://blplaserengraving.com/

The POI should be deleted as This place is closed, and perhaps moved over the residence at 2903.

Agreed, should be deleted.

And searching for my address "2929 Woodside Drive" points to the "red" marker at 2903 Woodside Drive

tks 

[Patrick Shanahan]

On Wednesday, December 14, 2011 9:37:28 PM UTC-5, canada_mapmaker wrote:

You've deleted the name but the marker is still there. There should be no point of interest there.

 

agreed.

What I'm going to do is deny the latest edit, only so that there is only one pending edit in the queue for this location, which is the deletion I initiated that you have approved.

thanks.