If it's not accepting the default set on the Signup Form page of your MailChimp account, that would suggest something is seeing the browser language as English, and so it's attempting to auto-translate to English. If you'd like me to test it out directly, feel free to email
he...@mailchimp.com with "ATTN: Anna" in the subject line, and I can take a closer look.
As an alternative, if most signups are triggered via the API, disabling the autotranslate option would give you more uniform results.
Glad to hear you may be able to fake the browser language you want, though! Best of luck, for sure!
-- Anna