Thanks so much for all the feedback, both specific to The Collagist and that which is more generally just about the challenges of reading online. I think I've done so much reading online over the past few years, that it's become almost second nature to do so: I just finished reading over a thousand nominations for this year's
Best of the Web book, and that's in addition to the PDF review copies, the hundreds of submissions recently for the magazine, the book and journal editing I'm doing on-screen. Every day I use some combination of printed books and magazines and printouts, iPad/Kindle/smartphone, and desktop and laptop to do all these things, on top of my own writing, which is 90% done on the computer. It adds up to-on a normal day--ten to twelve hours of computer time, so I don't think I have the same resistance to reading on the screen as people who maybe don't do as much of it as I do. It's just part of life now.
That said, I think reading at the computer can be distracting, both for layout reasons--some of which are at least partially unavoidable, because websites, unlike books, need navigational links and buttons and so on, and some of which are just bad design--and also because the computer itself is incredibly distracting. Right now, I've got five Firefox tabs open across two monitors, plus a menu bar and a dock on the top and bottom of the screen both capable--and all to willing--to deliver popups and badges and sounds and so on. It's to concentrate at the computer, without a doubt.
I've found the iPad and other similar technologies to be a pretty ideal way to experience web journals, at least for me-- its easier to sit back and enjoy, there's less immediate distractions because of the full-screen nature of the device, and it's easier to make the text bigger, which is good on my eyes and for my comprehension. Clearly, that's not something everyone has access to, but I think as that technology and others like it spread some of our irritations with reading online are likely to fade.
Best,
Matt
www.mdbell.comHow They Were FoundP.S. This is a great conversation, and I'll try to participate as I can, but I'm actually still working too, and might not get back in a timely fashion. Thanks for all your great contributions so far!