DE really depends on what you like, but it seems gnome 3 is highly
rejected by it's old users. I think this reason would be a very good one
to simply copy windows 's DE, if we want to have more users (but do we
really want that? I'm still unsure, there are good pros and cons),
because it would allow new users to keep their habits in a first time.
Then, when the first time is passed, they could try other stuff... or
not. On my side, I've more or less always used command line tools, since
my childhood, so it is not so surprising that I now mostly use it, with
only few softwares.
I do not know what kind of interface your are accustomed to, but you
could try XFCE or LXDE.
In fact, you could also install more than one, and try them from time
to time, in the login manager, you can often choose the DE when you
installed more than one. That's a convenient feature for people who like
to try different things, and when you have build your opinion, just
remove DE you do not like is really easy.
In short, just take the DE which fit your needs. I would say that the
Big Two, Gnome and KDE, are made for users which have very few time to
invest in their system, and do not want to even install new softwares.
They are near the complete OS, IMHO.
In second, you have desktops like XFCE and LXDE, which are more like
what you have with a vanilla windows: you have everything you need to
simply use a computer, but not softwares to do real tasks.
At last, you have "mad guys", which are proud to be so, which build
their environment from scratch, like me. We do not compile things by
ourselves (well... some do that, too) or learn programming, we just
accept to read documentations and software descriptions.
For that kind of people, aptitude (without arguments, the ncurses
GUI)is a powerful tool IMHO, because it is easy to use it to have a
description of installed or needed softwares. Just, install debtags
first, because it will give you some very nice hints.
OT:
I am thinking that creating a guide to select softwares people really
needs, aka, building and configuring their own "desktop environment",
understandable by people without great knowledge of computer sciences,
could be interesting.
I have noticed that there are many quality tools outside usual DEs
which interact well between them, and sounds easy enough to use when you
are accustomed to only one of them.
The problem is that I do not know where on the vast Internet such a
guide should take place, and I could not write it alone...
Archive:
http://lists.debian.org/2e4339e71f2c919a...@neutralite.org