Intent to package amiwm; DFSG ramblings
Chris Lawrence
I'm planning on packaging the amiwm window manager. It's an AmigaOS
lookalike WM, with multiple workspaces and a customizable tools menu
(but
it doesn't support submenus as yet, so menu package support will have
to wait
for this upgrade).
Anyway, it looks like it's going to have to be in non-free. I
contacted the author on the copyright, and this is what he said:
---Marcus Comstedt <mar...@lysator.liu.se> wrote:
> I'm aware that the copyright statement is very fuzzy and I'll try to
> supply a better one in future distributions (if any). Anyway, the
license
> for amiwm does _not_ contain a generic license to produce derived
works
> using my source code. I'll probably grant licenses to specific
derived
> works should someone ask me, but no such license is given implicitly
with
> the software. I'll allow distribution of patches in the form of diffs
> though. My filosofy here is that I don't want people to confuse bugs
> written by other people with the bugs written by me. ;)
Since there's no implicit derived works license, my understanding is
that this contravenes DFSG section #4, which requires an explicit
license (and it would have to be a non-exclusive one).
Anyway, perhaps we need to look at providing a section between
"contrib" and "non-free" that allows for software that is
redistributable without restrictions but is not DFSG-free (i.e. stuff
that people can stick on CD-ROMs without wandering through every
copyright file in non-free), or at least a convention for tagging
non-free packages as CD-ROMable. This would be consistent with our
goal of making it "easy for people to produce CD-ROMs of our system
without violating any licenses, import/export restrictions, or any
other laws" (per Policy) and would not compromise the ideological
purity of the DFSG.
Chris
==
Chris Lawrence Email: qua...@ix.netcom.com
Senior Political Science Major
University of Memphis Contract Programmer
Memphis, Tennessee, USA FedEx - Operations Research
_________________________________________________________
DO YOU YAHOO!?
Get your free @yahoo.com address at http://mail.yahoo.com
--
TO UNSUBSCRIBE FROM THIS MAILING LIST: e-mail the word "unsubscribe" to
debian-dev...@lists.debian.org .
Trouble? e-mail to tem...@bucknell.edu .
Christian Schwarz
On Mon, 5 Jan 1998, Chris Lawrence wrote:
[snip]
> Anyway, perhaps we need to look at providing a section between
> "contrib" and "non-free" that allows for software that is
> redistributable without restrictions but is not DFSG-free (i.e. stuff
> that people can stick on CD-ROMs without wandering through every
> copyright file in non-free), or at least a convention for tagging
> non-free packages as CD-ROMable. This would be consistent with our
> goal of making it "easy for people to produce CD-ROMs of our system
> without violating any licenses, import/export restrictions, or any
> other laws" (per Policy) and would not compromise the ideological
> purity of the DFSG.
This has been discussed some time ago when we decided to make "contrib"
packages also DFSG free.
We didn't choose this option (to split non-free into
non-free-but-freely-dist and really-non-free-stuff) since (a) we don't
want to give guidelines for non-DFSG software (this would be against our
project goals) and (b) what's `freely-dist' differs very much from vendor
to vendor (depending on how much they charge, what else is on the CD,
etc.).
Sorry, but I think the amiwm package has to go into "non-free" for now.
Thanks,
Chris
-- _,, Christian Schwarz
/ o \__ sch...@monet.m.isar.de, sch...@schwarz-online.com,
! ___; sch...@debian.org, sch...@mathematik.tu-muenchen.de
\ /
\\\______/ ! PGP-fp: 8F 61 EB 6D CF 23 CA D7 34 05 14 5C C8 DC 22 BA
\ / http://fatman.mathematik.tu-muenchen.de/~schwarz/
-.-.,---,-,-..---,-,-.,----.-.-
"DIE ENTE BLEIBT DRAUSSEN!"