I find myself wondering how it would respond to my approach.
Gordon
I find myself wondering how it would respond to my approach.
--
Please stop being hateful about Lydia Kavina and now also Andrei Smirnov. For me it poisons the atmosphere here at Levnet.....
PS. Moderators, this might be against policy, so feel free to kick me off the board.
Gordon
This group enjoys a wide "attitude latitude" so as to accomodate the strange group of people attracted to this crazy instrument.
No amount of begging, cajoling, threatening or imploring is going to stop him from attacking those evil Nesturkh
What is "fact" to you, is only a splatter of hate to us.
It is entirely possible that Lev Termen strongly disapproved of Lydia Kavina, but if he did (and I say IF......) none of it came from Lev. He was being manipulated by his daughter (Peter Theremin's grandmama) Natasha. You have only to mention the name of L.K., and Natasha will go magnificently and totally ballistic!
As for Lev, I do not believe he ever hated anyone in his entire life (with the possible exception of Joseph Vissarionovich). From everything I have understood about Lev Sergeievitch, envy, jealousy and hate were simply not part of his nature. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for some of the other members of his family.
---
Alle Postfächer an einem Ort. Jetzt wechseln und E-Mail-Adresse mitnehmen! http://email.freenet.de/produkte/basic/index.html
--
As for Lev, I do not believe he ever hated anyone in his entire life (with the possible exception of Joseph Vissarionovich).
Hate is the kind of poison that poisons the poisoner much more than the object of their obsession.
--
I don't want any hatred or enemy stuff. And I don't want to treat Peter Theremin as a joke. He is a young adult and I hope wisdom will come soon, or at least over the years.
... The road to loneliness and darkness is a long one, especially when you have sheltered yourself from everyone around you by your actions and harsh words. I wish you well in your self inflicted destructive journey. Farewell Peter!
... Are you saying that you are teaching the theremin? Really?
Hmmmm ok ... Maybe I should start teaching too then :)
Hmmmm ok ... Maybe I should start teaching too then :)
The wonderful thing about the theremin is that, unlike traditional instruments, there is no internationally accepted standard of excellence in performance, and no universally agreed upon method for playing it. Consequently, anybody and everybody who wants to set him or her self up as a legitimate theremin teacher can do so with impunity.
And believe me - THEY DO!
The theremin has proved to be the vehicle 'par excellence' for the fulfillment of the artistic ambitions of a surprising number of people who would be unable to get to musical first base on any traditional instrument (including voice), and who demonstrate not one iota of musical talent or aptitude.
Since there is no repertoire for their instrument, thereminists are in a unique position. Unlike cellists, who might be expected to "show their stuff" by dashing off a couple of movements from a Bach Suite for unaccompanied cello, or violinists who might be asked if they can play the Beethoven Violin Concerto (or some other standard work by which their accomplishment could be judged), thereminists can get away with knowing nothing at all except maybe a couple of recognizable bars of IT HAPPENED IN MONTEREY, or MOSCOW NIGHTS.
Several years ago, when Peter Theremin first appeared in the international theremin community, I wrote to him personally and told him what I thought he should be doing, and actually offered to help him do it. I believed at the time that he should diligently work at his English, and put together a talk on the history and development of the theremin, which he could present in a lecture tour of music schools, conservatories and university campuses across North America. I know people who organize tours of this kind, and who could easily have put together a very profitable itinerary for the great grandson of Leon Theremin. He could probably have made himself several thousand dollars a week (after commissions and expenses) while on tour, but Peter was not receptive to the idea.
This was something he could have done, and done with some genuine authority. Teaching the theremin is something he should probably not be doing because he is not a good thereminist.
But what the hell......that hasn't stopped anybody else!
Jess can't laugh a P.T., but I gotta say I'm still giggling over "master class with crook"! ROTFLMAO
You think I will be teaching the theremin? I don't even feel that I am good enough to do that! At least not any time soon.
Several years ago, when Peter Theremin first appeared in the international theremin community, I wrote to him personally and told him what I thought he should be doing, and actually offered to help him do it. I believed at the time that he should diligently work at his English, and put together a talk on the history and development of the theremin, which he could present in a lecture tour of music schools, conservatories and university campuses across North America. I know people who organize tours of this kind, and who could easily have put together a very profitable itinerary for the great grandson of Leon Theremin. He could probably have made himself several thousand dollars a week (after commissions and expenses) while on tour, but Peter was not receptive to the idea.
Hi Peter,
I find your disclosures about the history of your family extremely interesting. And yes, I can see how you may have reason for some annoyance / anger about “the situation”. You have an “involvement” and “insight” to which we are all outsiders.
Untruth by documentary makers or journalists etc is an accepted part of our western culture – I hate it, but I don’t think many people feel passionate about the matter – they accept that the truth is “bent” to turn a complex tale into a simple and entertaining one.. I so doing, they often create a new “reality” – craft a story – Because, quite simply, if they didn’t do this nobody (or only extremely few) would be interested –
The above process has knock-on effects.. look, I am not saying that I subscribe to your version of events or that I reject it – It is good enough for me that you believe it is the truth.. I am sure you have evidence to back up at least a large chunk of the history and details you expound..
But, whatever happened, and whoever was in the “right” or in the “wrong” , and whatever issues of “honor” are involved, the fact is that the story has been established.. And this story, regardless of how much “truth” or “fiction” is embedded in it, has influenced the lives of many people.
I have met Lydia many times, have spent time with her and George, have been taught theremin basics by her and had long technical discussions with her and George.. I really like both of these people, a lot! – I am saying this up-front so that you know my position before you read what follows.
Let us say that your story is true – “He called Lydia Kavina in the movie great-niece of Leon Theremin that was and is lie.” – If (and I do not think you would say it if it wasn’t true, or certainly, I believe that you believe it to be true, and that you are most likely correct – but I have no evidence either way – and to me, I actually don’t care if Lydia was the great-niece of Adolf Hitler – Or what claims she or anyone else make for her lineage – To me, it is utterly irrelevant) Lydia was wrongly cast in this “role” – whether she went along with it or not – the result of this “claim” being made public would have had a knock-on effect on Lydia’s life..
There is a statement which goes “what a person pretends to be, they become” – And I think there is sometimes truth in this.. But one thing I believe to be true is that we are never the same “person” from one moment to the next .. Do you REALLY know who you are? – I am not talking here about your lineage or whatever – I am talking about the “real you” …If You can honestly and without any uncertainty declare “Yes” to that question, you are doing a lot better than me! ;-)
There is another thing – I have found that my encounters with the theremin has changed me profoundly .. Years ago, I started my “theremin journey” as an electronics consultant (with specialization in capacitive sensing) looking to make money – I saw a trough of useless theremin “toys” selling for high prices, and thought “I can get in there, make a cheap digital theremin which knocks the s**t out of this market” – But in the process of R+D, and actually playing a few real theremins, and being invited to one of Lydia’s private get-togethers and hearing the theremin being played by Lydia and others accompanied by some of the most inspiring musicians playing breathtakingly, I lost my focus – and fell in love with this instrument.. It has cost me dearly (all love costs dearly, it would seem … But I still think its less expensive than hate..)
So, to me, it matters not one iota whether Lydia started out as a “crook” or not – I will “judge” people for what they are now. As for Bob Moog, the use of theremin technology even if “with out permission of Leon Theremin” is entirely permissible – The theremin patent has lapsed, and the whole purpose of the patent system is disclosure of an invention and the advancing of technology because, once a patent has lapsed, anyone is free to use the technology without licence and even without acknowledgment… But, apart from this, the 91A uses a completely different, non-heterodyning technology, which was not Lev’s invention and would not have been covered by Levs patent.
The truth, Peter, is that (regardless of their “rights” or “wrongs”) without Bob Moog, Your grandfather would not be nearly as well known or revered as he is today. Likewise, without thereminists like Lydia, Precision theremin playing may well have gone to the grave with Clara.
And NOBODY in this whole “drama” is the same person that they were even 10 years ago .. Any reasons for anger or bitterness have been washed away by time.
I envy you.. Leon had some truly remarkable qualities – You WILL have inherited at least some of those qualities.
PLEASE – For the sake of the memory of your Grandfather, and for the future of his invention, DON’T waste what you have by focusing your energy on fighting ghosts from the past – They are ghosts! – The people you see as your enemies, those who you feel are bringing Leon Theremins name and invention into disrepute, they are not “real” – When you see them, you are seeing YOUR ghosts.. Those ghosts died a long time ago, these people are not them! … The ghosts are only in your mind… At one time they were probably real – your “cause” was real – But that time has long passed.
Fred.
-----Original Message-----
From: lev...@googlegroups.com
[mailto:lev...@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of
Peter Theremin
Sent: 25 January 2013 08:28
To: lev...@googlegroups.com
Cc: j.hu...@jeshum.com
Subject: Re: Thierry Plays The
Terpsitone
--
Amethyste,What unkind words I was saying about the people on the forum?
I think she means that you used the forum to spread unkind words, not that the unkind words were about people on the forum.
--PK
--
Peter,
I have no argument about your beliefs on this matter, but lets take a “feet on the ground” look at each issue:
1. Legal (but not the public until the court decision is issued)
There is no legal basis for anything to be done..
I know this will come as a shock to many, and I find it outrageous – But, as I discovered when I had my “identity” stolen some years ago (someone took my name, and set up Ebay and other accounts using this, and I ended up getting hounded by irate buyers and sellers) there is no legal framework which one can prevent someone saying they are whoever they want to call themselves, or declaring themselves to be the grand-whatever of whoever… The only action I was able to take (and it was difficult and costly) is to prove that I was not guilty of the financial frauds – and when I did this, the victims took action against the fraudster.. But there was no legal action I could take against someone calling themselves by my name!
2. Ethics (all that I have written - the truth and I am prepared to confirm - with documents and witnesses. And how will assess it each individual person - it's not for me to decide.)
Ethics are situation dependent, they are probably different for every individual on this planet – they are part of our grand delusion about free-will and responsibility.. They are as unreal as the phantoms in our dreams… What you see as ethical (your pursuit of your targets) others see as completely unethical – Both parties are “right” from their perspective – both cannot comprehend the others perspective.. And to both, the issues are really important..
And almost every atrocity ever committed, and every wasteful or pointless act, has been done because the parties involved really believed they were in the right, that they were being “ethical”. And one can never know, no matter how sure one is, that ones actions are REALLY “ethical” because the whole idea of “ethics” is based on our delusory social structure – the idea is there as an evolutionary developed structure essential to our predominance - but like all delusory mechanisms, it is extremely fallible!
3. actual
There is no such thing as “actual”.
Nobody cares, Peter! -
And what reason do you have to care? – Stop and think about it! … So, you are entirely “right” .. What does it matter? – 100 years from now nothing of what you are saying will be remembered by anyone – if anything is remembered it will be the story in Glinsky’s book… Leon and Clara will probably be remembered in this framework – Clara’s recordings may still be listened to, as might a handful of thereminists of today.. The only way you are likely to be remembered is if you make some major CONTRIBUTION .. certainly not because you were defaming (justifiably or unjustifiably) people like Lydia!
I know the “prognosis” for OCD – I know that what Peter Pringle says is “textbook true”.. But I refuse to believe that anyone is absolutely trapped by their psychosis.. To me, the whole “script” is written – but I do not know my script – and my “matrix” forces me to try to “bump” things onto a “different” course..
I just feel that, as a Theremin, you must have some strong “stuff” in your genes – Stuff which must surely be strong enough to overcome your destructive obsession – Yeah – I know you don’t see it as an obsession – But whatever it is, its not going to take you anywhere..
Whereas focusing on what you have might take us all somewhere positive.
Kind regards,
Fred.
-----Original Message-----
From: lev...@googlegroups.com
[mailto:lev...@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of
Peter Theremin
Sent: 25 January 2013 20:27
To: lev...@googlegroups.com
Subject: Re: Thierry Plays The
Terpsitone
Thank you, Fred.
--
Thanks Peter,
I wish you well.
Fred.
-----Original Message-----
From: lev...@googlegroups.com
[mailto:lev...@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of
Peter Theremin
Sent: 25 January 2013 22:01
To: lev...@googlegroups.com
Subject: Re: Thierry Plays The
Terpsitone
Fred, thank you for what you wrote.
--
Peter,
I just noticed something which MIGHT convince you.. (I am being an optimist now ;-)
You say below :
“And you think that after 100 years will be remembered Lydia Kavina and Glinsky,”
But I never said that at all ! - What I said was:
“if anything is remembered it will be the story in Glinsky’s book… Leon and Clara will probably be remembered in this framework – Clara’s recordings may still be listened to, as might a handful of thereminists of today..”
I never mentioned Lydia! I do not actually believe that Lydia is significant enough to be remembered much in terms of this “story” –
But you read it as : “you think that after 100 years will be remembered Lydia Kavina and Glinsky,”
PETER! – LOOK AT IT!! YOUR OBSESSION IS STARING AT YOU FROM THE WORDS YOU HAVE WRITTEN! – IT IS SHOUTING AT YOU, MOCKING YOU!
You are seeing Lydia where she isn’t present – I was not sure about PPs diagnosis of OCD with you, but I now know he is right.. I just hope he is not right about the idea that you will forever be under the control of this obsession – Talk about “sad facts” – well, there could hardly be a sadder tale than for a descendent of Lev to be lost in this way.
Enough said – You have my email sent yesterday, and I am happy to chat, but no more in public!
I am also really interested in your life and the “behind the scenes” – I am fascinated by your Grandfather, particularly since I started really exploring his designs and realized just how special they are, and how they have been misunderstood and misinterpreted for decades. I had a Russian grandfather (who I never met) so perhaps I have some hereditary connection with you (LOL – not that it matters – we are all connected far more than we could ever imagine! ;-)
Fred.
-----Original Message-----
From: lev...@googlegroups.com
[mailto:lev...@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of
Peter Theremin
Sent: 25 January 2013 22:01
To: lev...@googlegroups.com
Subject: Re: Thierry Plays The
Terpsitone
Fred, thank you for what you wrote.
--
"I decide , in addition to the main work studio, to create express method for people who want to learn to play the theremin."
Peter, I have no desire to learn melodic theremin playing, but I would like to understand more about your express method, because I believe that it must take a long time and require a great deal of practice to play conventional music well on a theremin.
Can you explain some of your method?
Thank you,
Gordon
Peter, I have no desire to learn melodic theremin playing, but I would like to understand more about your express method, because I believe that it must take a long time and require a great deal of practice to play conventional music well on a theremin.
Can you explain some of your method?
Design better players, lol.
LPKaster
http://lpkaster.com
Sorry Peter, I never meant to be offensive.
“sick” is a harsh word –
As you know, I have some strange ideas about life.. And to me, recognition of our imperfections is actually (usually) of benefit.. It is by recognizing “symptoms” that we can take action to cure the problem – and when I say “symptoms” this doesn’t always mean “bad” – If we didn’t feel thirst, we wouldn’t know that we needed to drink.. And sometimes we don’t recognize a problem until it becomes difficult to fix.
If “Because her family was actively involved in the distortion of the truth about Leon Theremin” is the truth, then it’s the truth.. But Lydia was caught and moved by the forces of her family in the same way that you have been caught and moved by the forces of your family..
No one is “guilty” and no one is “bad” - Its just the script we must follow… And some “themes” in this script are predominant… fighting these “themes” is not going to have the effect you hope for.
I have watched video of your grandfather, and Natasha, and you, and Lydia, and Clara … And the only thing in these videos which doesn’t show the passing of time much, is the theremin! - Young people playing who are now old people, or dead.
We are here for a brief moment.. All our fights are futile.. I am saying this to myself more than to you!
Fred.
-----Original Message-----
From: lev...@googlegroups.com
[mailto:lev...@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of
Peter Theremin
Sent: 25 January 2013 23:26
To: lev...@googlegroups.com
Subject: Re: Thierry Plays The
Terpsitone
Fred,
--
Now I'm still in development and watch my students, but I hope that in September I officially present my method, it will be called "Theremin in 24 hours"
--
Sorry... Did you mean 24 _years_?
On Jan 25, 2013, at 5:44 PM, Peter Theremin said:
--
Peter, I do understand the nature of the obsessive/compulsive. I am even schooled to give them music therapy :
LPKaster wrote:Sorry... Did you mean 24 _years_?
Dear Lawrence,No, I mean "24 hours"
--I am not working as a music therapist anymore. But for some clients it would be very nice to hear "It's not you, it's just a crazy instrument!" :D
--
“and what quality of theremin it have.”
Sorry Peter – but the theremin is utterly irrelevant – its “quality” affects such a miniscule number of people that it is of absolutely no importance by ANY statistical standard .. The theremin does not reflect the state of the world anymore than one butterfly being responsible for our climate change crisis.
But, an individual descendent of Leon Theremin could be reflecting the state of the world.
With kindness,
Fred.
-----Original Message-----
From: lev...@googlegroups.com
[mailto:lev...@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of
Peter Theremin
Sent: 26 January 2013 06:50
To: lev...@googlegroups.com
Subject: Re: Thierry Plays The
Terpsitone
Thank you, Fred.
--
Dear Fred,I did not mean that in every country keeps track of statistics on theremin.I have listed the criteria which allow us to assess the country quickly, I think that's right.The fact that for most of people of the world theremin has no value, it's absolutely true.However, Japan is highly developed theremin-culture.
Is it one 24 hour session, or is there a break -or several time-outs, say perhaps a year or 4 each?
--
Two weeks? Still no break?Or is it like we say, "dog years"? Since dogs, especially the larger breeds don't live so long, we say "what's that in dog years?" So 14 days for a dog might be 14 years for someone listening to theremin. Or is it like what we have; a "Rush Hour" when we sit in traffic and it seems like an eternity?(Maybe there's another meaning for "Dog Days"!
Hi Peter,
I find your disclosures about the history of your family extremely interesting. And yes, I can see how you may have reason for some annoyance / anger about “the situation”. You have an “involvement” and “insight” to which we are all outsiders.
Untruth by documentary makers or journalists etc is an accepted part of our western culture – I hate it, but I don’t think many people feel passionate about the matter – they accept that the truth is “bent” to turn a complex tale into a simple and entertaining one.. I so doing, they often create a new “reality” – craft a story – Because, quite simply, if they didn’t do this nobody (or only extremely few) would be interested –
The above process has knock-on effects.. look, I am not saying that I subscribe to your version of events or that I reject it – It is good enough for me that you believe it is the truth.. I am sure you have evidence to back up at least a large chunk of the history and details you expound..
But, whatever happened, and whoever was in the “right” or in the “wrong” , and whatever issues of “honor” are involved, the fact is that the story has been established.. And this story, regardless of how much “truth” or “fiction” is embedded in it, has influenced the lives of many people.
I have met Lydia many times, have spent time with her and George, have been taught theremin basics by her and had long technical discussions with her and George.. I really like both of these people, a lot! – I am saying this up-front so that you know my position before you read what follows.
Let us say that your story is true – “He called Lydia Kavina in the movie great-niece of Leon Theremin that was and is lie.” – If (and I do not think you would say it if it wasn’t true, or certainly, I believe that you believe it to be true, and that you are most likely correct – but I have no evidence either way – and to me, I actually don’t care if Lydia was the great-niece of Adolf Hitler – Or what claims she or anyone else make for her lineage – To me, it is utterly irrelevant) Lydia was wrongly cast in this “role” – whether she went along with it or not – the result of this “claim” being made public would have had a knock-on effect on Lydia’s life..
There is a statement which goes “what a person pretends to be, they become” – And I think there is sometimes truth in this.. But one thing I believe to be true is that we are never the same “person” from one moment to the next .. Do you REALLY know who you are? – I am not talking here about your lineage or whatever – I am talking about the “real you” …If You can honestly and without any uncertainty declare “Yes” to that question, you are doing a lot better than me! ;-)
There is another thing – I have found that my encounters with the theremin has changed me profoundly .. Years ago, I started my “theremin journey” as an electronics consultant (with specialization in capacitive sensing) looking to make money – I saw a trough of useless theremin “toys” selling for high prices, and thought “I can get in there, make a cheap digital theremin which knocks the s**t out of this market” – But in the process of R+D, and actually playing a few real theremins, and being invited to one of Lydia’s private get-togethers and hearing the theremin being played by Lydia and others accompanied by some of the most inspiring musicians playing breathtakingly, I lost my focus – and fell in love with this instrument.. It has cost me dearly (all love costs dearly, it would seem … But I still think its less expensive than hate..)
So, to me, it matters not one iota whether Lydia started out as a “crook” or not – I will “judge” people for what they are now. As for Bob Moog, the use of theremin technology even if “with out permission of Leon Theremin” is entirely permissible – The theremin patent has lapsed, and the whole purpose of the patent system is disclosure of an invention and the advancing of technology because, once a patent has lapsed, anyone is free to use the technology without licence and even without acknowledgment… But, apart from this, the 91A uses a completely different, non-heterodyning technology, which was not Lev’s invention and would not have been covered by Levs patent.
The truth, Peter, is that (regardless of their “rights” or “wrongs”) without Bob Moog, Your grandfather would not be nearly as well known or revered as he is today. Likewise, without thereminists like Lydia, Precision theremin playing may well have gone to the grave with Clara.
And NOBODY in this whole “drama” is the same person that they were even 10 years ago .. Any reasons for anger or bitterness have been washed away by time.
I envy you.. Leon had some truly remarkable qualities – You WILL have inherited at least some of those qualities.
PLEASE – For the sake of the memory of your Grandfather, and for the future of his invention, DON’T waste what you have by focusing your energy on fighting ghosts from the past – They are ghosts! – The people you see as your enemies, those who you feel are bringing Leon Theremins name and invention into disrepute, they are not “real” – When you see them, you are seeing YOUR ghosts.. Those ghosts died a long time ago, these people are not them! … The ghosts are only in your mind… At one time they were probably real – your “cause” was real – But that time has long passed.
Fred.
-----Original Message-----
From: lev...@googlegroups.com [mailto:lev...@googlegroups.com] On Behalf Of Peter Theremin
Sent: 25 January 2013 08:28
To: lev...@googlegroups.com
Cc: j.hu...@jeshum.com
Subject: Re: Thierry Plays The Terpsitone
пятница, 25 января 2013 г., 0:28:59 UTC+4 пользователь Peter Pringle написал:
As for Lev, I do not believe he ever hated anyone in his entire life (with the possible exception of Joseph Vissarionovich).
Not Joseph Stalin but "propagandists of theremin" taught Leon Theremin to hate.
Peter, Leon Theremin was very kind man and always good to young and always helped when asked for. Leon Theremin hated lies and conflict with Lydia Kavina started from the time when she started to say that she is his granddaughter.
Leon Theremin loved his theremin , and he loved his family.
Before his trip to America in the spring of 1991 after the filing of the Union of Composers for the ride to the Lev Theremin received threats to shoot him and his family.
Come some people. As the result my brother and great-grandson of Leo Theremin was born not in time and died.
After the arrival from America Leon Theremin found that destroyed his laboratory and Leon Theremin, particularly savagely smashed his theremin.
Peter, Steve Martin knew exactly what Natasha provide authentic theremin (tube and new model ) in Russia and abroad from 1989 to 1993, with the approval of Leon Theremin, and refused to show, theremin made by Robert Moog.
Steve Martin was at the last concert of Holland Leon and Natasha Theremin in 1993 in Holland, and there Leon and Natasha had a very hard conflict - with Steve Martin.
However, Steve Martin in his film pretends that Leon Theremin came to the U.S. in 1991 alone, without his family.
He did not film overseas performances of Leon Theremin, or did, but did not include in the film.
Steve Martin included Lydia Kavina,in the film without the consent of Leo Theremin.
He called Lydia Kavina in the movie great-niece of Leon Theremin that was and is lie. (The real great-niece of Leo Theremin, the only granddaughter of Leon Theremin's sister died last year)
the firm of Robert Moog gave to everybody who buys the theremin by Moog the disc with advertising of Lydia Kavina, who plays an instrument of Robert Moog 91a, seemingly repeats the form of exclusive authentic theremins of Leon Theremin with out permission of Leon Theremin.
Andrei Smirnov came to Leon Theremin, and said in October 1993 that he was forced to take the name of Leon Theremin without asking for name of its center, because it is only in this case the promised foreign support.
He said he was not interested in theremin and it's not going to do this and can take the name against the will of Leon Theremin and so Smirnov did .
Andrew said that he did not know Lydia Kavina and is not going to cooperate with her .
All of the above - took place without the consent and against the will of Leon Theremin.
I think this is deliberate hoax directed against individuals and inventions of Leon Theremin.
--
--