Issue with REDEFINES AND OCCURS together

[Athul prasanna Venkatesh]

Hi Fady,

I have the following block in my copybook

009700     05  SPF-BUCKET-TABLE REDEFINES SPF-RECORD-DATA               00970000

009800                                          OCCURS 3 TIMES                                       00980000

009900                                 INDEXED BY SPF-INDX.                                        00990000

and the following schema gets generated

<choice>

                <element name="spfRecordData" type="tns:SpfRecordData">

                    <annotation>

                        <appinfo>

                            <cb:cobolElement cobolName="SPF-RECORD-DATA" isRedefined="true" levelNumber="5" srceLine="80" type="GROUP_ITEM"                     unmarshalChoiceStrategyClassName="com.bony.csr.copybook.legstar.positionrecord.choice.spfRecordDataChoice"/>

                        </appinfo>

                    </annotation>

                </element>

                <element maxOccurs="3" minOccurs="3" name="spfBucketTable" type="tns:SpfBucketTable">

                    <annotation>

                        <appinfo>

                            <cb:cobolElement cobolName="SPF-BUCKET-TABLE" levelNumber="5" maxOccurs="3" minOccurs="3" redefines="SPF-RECORD-DATA" srceLine="98" type="GROUP_ITEM"/>

                        </appinfo>

                    </annotation>

                </element>

            </choice>

JAXB runs successfully and having issue only with COXBgen. The below is the compilation error I get,

[javac] C:\Dev\CorpTrust\Common\tools\legstar-distribution-1.5.2\BNY\src\com\bony\csr\copybook\legstar\positionrecord\bind\SpfRecordDataChoiceBinding.java:65: cannot find symbol

[javac] symbol  : variable _spfBucketTableWrapperItem

[javac] location: class com.bony.csr.copybook.legstar.positionrecord.bind.SpfRecordDataChoiceBinding

[javac]         _spfBucketTableWrapperItem = new SpfBucketTableBinding("SpfBucketTableWrapperItem",

[javac]         ^

[javac] C:\Dev\CorpTrust\Common\tools\legstar-distribution-1.5.2\BNY\src\com\bony\csr\copybook\legstar\positionrecord\bind\SpfRecordDataChoiceBinding.java:68: cannot find symbol

[javac] symbol  : variable _spfBucketTableWrapperItem

[javac] location: class com.bony.csr.copybook.legstar.positionrecord.bind.SpfRecordDataChoiceBinding

[javac]                "SpfBucketTable", getParentBinding(), _spfBucketTableWrapperItem);

The SpfRecordDataChoiceBinding java class generates this _spfBucketTableWrapperItem variable but not declared within the class,

public class SpfRecordDataChoiceBinding 

             extends CChoiceBinding {

    /** Alternative bound bound to value object property SpfRecordData(SpfRecordData). */

    public ICobolComplexBinding _spfRecordData;

    /** Alternative bound bound to value object property SpfBucketTable(SpfBucketTable). */

    public ICobolArrayComplexBinding _spfBucketTableWrapper;

    

    /**

     * Constructor for a Choice element.

     * 

     * @param bindingName the identifier for this binding

     * @param parentBinding a reference to the parent binding

     */

  

    /** Creates a binding property for each alternative. */

    private void initAlternatives() {

        if (_log.isDebugEnabled()) {

            _log.debug("Initializing started");

        }

        /* Create binding alternatives instances */

        _spfRecordData = new SpfRecordDataBinding("SpfRecordData",

               "SpfRecordData", getParentBinding(), null);

        _spfRecordData.setCobolName("SPF-RECORD-DATA");

        _spfRecordData.setByteLength(30);

        _spfBucketTableWrapperItem = new SpfBucketTableBinding("SpfBucketTableWrapperItem",

               "SpfBucketTable", getParentBinding(), null);

        _spfBucketTableWrapper = new SpfBucketTableWrapperBinding("SpfBucketTableWrapper",

               "SpfBucketTable", getParentBinding(), _spfBucketTableWrapperItem);

        _spfBucketTableWrapper.setCobolName("SPF-BUCKET-TABLE");

        _spfBucketTableWrapper.setByteLength(30);

        _spfBucketTableWrapper.setItemByteLength(10);

        _spfBucketTableWrapper.setMinOccurs(3);

        _spfBucketTableWrapper.setMaxOccurs(3);

        _spfBucketTableWrapper.setRedefines("SPF-RECORD-DATA");

        /* Add alternatives to alternatives list */

        addAlternative(_spfRecordData);

        addAlternative(_spfBucketTableWrapper);

 

        if (_log.isDebugEnabled()) {

            _log.debug("Initializing successful");

        }

    }

}

Your help is very much appreciated.

Thanks,

Athul

[Fady]

Hello Athul

I confirm this is a bug. I have opened https://code.google.com/p/legstar/issues/detail?id=177 to follow up on this.

You can work around the issue by manually adding the missing variable declaration in SpfRecordDataChoiceBinding:

public SpfBucketTableBinding _spfBucketTableWrapperItem;

Thanks for raising this.

Fady

[Athul prasanna Venkatesh]

Fady,

Thanks for your response.

Athul

[Mike West]

I'm having the identical problem on a large copybook. However I'm using later versions of legsem and expected that the fix would be present.

My errors 

oft-copybook-temp\m1_fwg07200_full\src\com\parasoft\soavirt\copybook\m1_fwg07200_full\bind\OccurrenceCodesDatesM1ChoiceBinding.java:65: error: cannot find symbol

        _occurCodesDatesTableM1WrapperItem = new OccurCodesDatesTableM1Binding("OccurCodesDatesTableM1WrapperItem",

        ^

  symbol:   variable _occurCodesDatesTableM1WrapperItem

  location: class OccurrenceCodesDatesM1ChoiceBinding

C:\Users\MWEST~1.PAR\AppData\Local\Temp\parasoft-copybook-temp\m1_fwg07200_full\src\com\parasoft\soavirt\copybook\m1_fwg07200_full\bind\OccurrenceCodesDatesM1ChoiceBinding.java:68: error: cannot find symbol

               "OccurCodesDatesTableM1", getParentBinding(), _occurCodesDatesTableM1WrapperItem);

                                                             ^

  symbol:   variable _occurCodesDatesTableM1WrapperItem

  location: class OccurrenceCodesDatesM1ChoiceBinding

C:\Users\MWEST~1.PAR\AppData\Local\Temp\parasoft-copybook-temp\m1_fwg07200_full\src\com\parasoft\soavirt\copybook\m1_fwg07200_full\bind\PcSavingsDataM1ChoiceBinding.java:65: error: cannot find symbol

        _pcSavingsTableM1WrapperItem = new PcSavingsTableM1Binding("PcSavingsTableM1WrapperItem",

... many more like this

This is the portion of the POM that shows the dependencies I'm using

<dependency>

<groupId>com.legsem.legstar</groupId>

<artifactId>legstar-cobcgen</artifactId>

<version>1.6.0</version>

</dependency>

<dependency>

<groupId>com.legsem.legstar</groupId>

<artifactId>legstar-codegen</artifactId>

<version>1.6.0</version>

</dependency>

<dependency>

<groupId>com.legsem.legstar</groupId>

<artifactId>legstar-coxbapi</artifactId>

<version>1.6.0</version>

</dependency>

<dependency>

<groupId>com.legsem.legstar</groupId>

<artifactId>legstar-coxbgen</artifactId>

<version>1.6.0</version>

</dependency>

<dependency>

<groupId>com.legsem.legstar</groupId>

<artifactId>legstar-coxbrt</artifactId>

<version>1.6.0</version>

</dependency>

<dependency>

<groupId>com.legsem.legstar</groupId>

<artifactId>legstar-jaxbgen</artifactId>

<version>1.6.0</version>

</dependency>

<dependency>

<groupId>com.legsem.legstar</groupId>

<artifactId>legstar-cob2trans</artifactId>

<version>1.5.3</version>

</dependency>

Any help would be appreciated.