Groups keyboard shortcuts have been updated
Dismiss
See shortcuts

NA values in standard errors after removing one variable from the model

421 views
Skip to first unread message

Tatiana Logvinenko

unread,
Sep 23, 2019, 9:53:00 AM9/23/19
to lavaan
I am using lavaan for SEM analysis of the dataset with test performance measures. I have 5 latent variables constructed from observed variables that were either subtests of one test, or were subtests of different tests measuring similar ability. 

After fitting the model, several problems occurred: 

1) NAs were introduced in CFI and TLI 

  Comparative Fit Index (CFI)                       NA
  Tucker-Lewis Index (TLI)                          NA

2) There is a warning, that  some observed variances are (at least) a factor 1000 times larger than others (use varTable(fit) to investigate); however the data was fitted, BUT after removing one exogenous variable from the regression expression NAs are introduced in the standard errors OR new warning occurs:  lavaan WARNING: the optimizer warns that a solution has NOT been found!

The variable I want to exclude from predictors was 'sex' variable (this variable is not causing anything else in my model): it could be either 1 or 2. 

I don't have any specific questions, but I will be happy to hear any thought why this error message occurs (or in some instance lavaan finds the solution but there are NAs in the standard errors) and how I can improve my model. It might be important, that when I knit my RMarkdown file to HTML I have different warning, that some variances are negative, but after fixing the variances the problem with 'sex' variable is still present. I also thought that  I shouldn't have specified in the var/covar parameter, that residuals of the variables that constitutes the same latent variable should correlate, but clearing it up haven't helped.


The lavaan syntax is as follows: 

sem <- '
# measurement model
word_id_time =~ psw_t + rw_t + ld_irrw + ld_nw + ld_regw
word_id_acc =~ word_id_total + pw_id_total
naming_acc =~ ran_c + ran_o + ran_l + ran_n + sn1e + sn2e +sw1e + sw2e
naming_speed =~ ran_ct + ran_ot + ran_lt + ran_nt + sn1t + sn2t + sw1t +sw2t
phon =~ pa + pseudo_a

# regressions
ab_com ~ word_id_time + word_id_acc + naming_acc + naming_speed + phon +age.tidy + sex
word_id_time ~ naming_speed
word_id_acc ~ naming_acc + phon

#this specifies a variance/covariance parameter
psw_t ~~ rw_t
ld_regw  ~~ ld_nw  + ld_irrw
psw_t ~~ pw_id_total
rw_t ~~ word_id_total
ran_c ~~   ran_ct + ran_o
ran_o ~~   ran_ot
ran_l ~~   ran_lt + ran_n
ran_n ~~   ran_nt
ran_ct ~~   ran_ot
ran_lt ~~   ran_nt
sn1t ~~     sn2t + sn1e + sn2e
sw1t ~~     sw2t +sw1e + sw2e
'

sem_test <- lavaan::sem(sem_model, data=data, estimator = "ML", missing="fiml", std.lv=TRUE)


I am using for this SEM 25 observed variables in total, among which there are transformed (sqrt) count variables (e.g. number of correct answers or number of errors), continuous right-skewed variables (e.g. time in seconds), and variables in z-scores (i.e. ab_com, pa, pseudo_a), however no categorical variable (except 'sex', but it is coded as integer and I want to exclude it). The total number of observations is 414 with some missing data, for which I've used (missing="fiml") option. 

I will appreciate any help on that, because I am very new to lavaan and I am not a proficient R-user. 




Nickname

unread,
Sep 25, 2019, 7:58:57 AM9/25/19
to lavaan
Tatiana,
  As a general strategy, focus on the first error/warning first because solving the first problem will often impact later ones.

  Scaling your variables is a standard step in data preparation for SEM analysis.  Multiply your variables by various powers of 10 to get them all to have variances that differ from one another by a ratio less than 1:10.  This should be discussed in more detail in any good introductory text book.

Keith
------------------------
Keith A. Markus
John Jay College of Criminal Justice, CUNY
http://jjcweb.jjay.cuny.edu/kmarkus
Frontiers of Test Validity Theory: Measurement, Causation and Meaning.
http://www.routledge.com/books/details/9781841692203/




Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages