Hey Teeb,
OK, I think I deserved that. Firstly, all I can do is apologise for not doing the right thing by you all and I'm sorry that you feel let down and even a bit angry. Let me try to explain in a bit more detail so you can see what happened and basically how I fucked up.
* We asked for the community to submit designs for the site which lots of you did and I'm genuinely grateful for. In my defence, when I asked for submissions I said that the layout is not fixed and you are free to change it. See the post on 9th May: "Here are the wireframes for the homepage. These are just guides regarding what needs to be on the page, feel free to change the layout if you think you have a better solution..."
* I sent all of these designs to Adam to look at and feedback on
* One of the designers I work with was interested in helping too after she heard me talking about it. She isn't a LagTV fan but wanted to help me out. I gave her the same information as you guys, but thinking about it now, she did have an unfair advantage as we could discuss it verbally which is more convenient than a google group. We should have kept our conversions on the group so you could all see it (not that we discussed that much really anyway). That is totally my fault, it was just easy to chat face to face. I should have also uploaded the design she did at the time as well. This was a honest mistake on my part. Again, all I can do is say sorry for that. I meant to do it at the time but just didn't get round to it.
* As she was working on the designs I did post a few times that she was working on a design and I wanted Adam to see that too before a decision was made and that was the reason to the delay. See my post on Aug 1st for example. So it wasn't a secret that she was working on a design, I just didn't post her submission or what we discussed about it. I spoke to Adam about the delay and he was happy to wait for her submission.
So in summary, I should have updated you all more often than I did and made sure that the whole thing was transparent and for that I am sorry. I'm not an evil villan trying to hatch a plan to piss you all off. I'm just a fan like you trying to do the right thing and get the guys a site they can finally use. I've tried to do the best I can to keep everyone happy but I haven't done a great job here obviously. Like you all here, my only motivation is to help Adam and Jeff and ultimately the community as a whole. Trying to spec the project, manage the community, build the site and make sure Adam is updated isn't an insignificant amount of work for me during my free time so while I agree I should have done better for you all I would ask that you could cut me a little slack? I've reflected back on the above and I can totally understand the reaction and how it looks but it has been a genuinely honest mistake on my part.
What can I do you make it up to you all? Let me know and I'll try my very best to make you happy and get everyone back on board. Also I just want to reiterate that this is in no way anyone else's fault but my own. So please don't hate on Adam, Jeff or my designer friend. They are in no way to blame for any of this.
I hope you can accept my apology and understand how it happened, I just forgot to put the design to the group. If not, please let me know and I'll be happy to discuss it further with you.
Thanks
Andy