Dong Chul Oh
Eng.101, Sec. #0495
November 8th, 2008
Essay 2
In his sensational, sharply-analyzing book ‘Are We Rome?: The Fall of
an Empire and the Fate of America’ published in year 2007, Cullen
Murphy asserts that America resembles Rome in six ways. In chapter 1
of the book, The Capitals, Cullen Murphy describes the ‘Inside the
Beltway Mindset’ and claims that overweening importance and self-
centeredness of America’s capital, Washington D.C. parallel, and
furthermore, surpasses Rome. Rather than providing judgments whether
the similarities between Rome and America are failure or success,
Murphy plainly offers his opinions to readers, allowing them to think
for themselves. This evokes and allows the readers to decide for
themselves. Despite his objective-sounded comparisons, what Murphy
tries to assert is clear: that America is dangerously close to what
Rome was even from its foundation. Many Americans, particularly
politicians, must take notice on Murphy’s assertions on the capital’s
attitudes, as they provide significant warning that America resembles
Rome from its start, therefore America could follow the very same path
Rome went through, despite the fact that America would never become an
empirical state.
Throughout the chapter 1, Murphy points out American capital’s view of
self, which can be summarized as self-importance of the capital, or
inside the beltway mindset. Even from its founding, America was doomed
to follow Rome’s path, as America’s Founding Fathers found their
models from republican Rome. Benjamin Franklin, George Washington, and
Thomas Jefferson all inquired into Rome to find the best suitable
answers for the newly born nation. Their ideas were to found a
democratic, republic nation freed from the idea of empire – that of
the British Empire and the Roman Empire. This was perhaps the reason
why George Washington refused to accept the permanent position of
President – the position very similar to what Julius Caesar held and
died for - Dictator Perpetuo (dictator in perpetuity), and returned to
his hometown to spend the rest of his life in farming. He must have
known too well that some day, his nation could follow the very same
steps Rome took – from a republic to an empire, then the fall. Thus,
he showed a role example by himself of not repeating the same mistake
that Julius Caesar went through.
The ideas of the Founding Fathers won’t be too problematic as long as
they are well followed, as the ideas focus and emphasize on democracy
that balance the power of the capital and prevent too much power to be
given to the president. But in recent years, the ideas have been
disobeyed, as we witness the coming of emperor in a disguised form –
the president. Murphy’s claim that too much weight being shifted to
the capital, particularly the president of the U.S. is significant
evidence that America is heading toward its own version of empire.
Ever since the Korean War, which was approved by the U.N. Security
Council, all wars carried out by America have been solely approved by
the president, instead of the Congress, which are violations of the
Constitution. As too much weight has been shifted and given to the
president, the president of the U.S. now acts almost like an emperor.
What is even worse is that the capital’s groupthink (a term used by
Irving I. Janis) hasn’t attempted to stop the president’s excessive
use of power. After 9/11, America completely lost rationality to view
the issue in clear, objective views, and consequently committed an
error of put all its focuses and efforts in the war on terrorism by
invading Afghanistan and Iraq, which has resulted in a catastrophic
financial crisis that has swamped not only the U.S. but the world into
economic crisis. Rome, in its history, experienced huge downfalls
during periods of some tyrannical emperors like Nero and Caligula. In
the modern history, it is very likely that America would go through
similar experiences, as a result of overpowered presidency that has no
limit in its power. America was founded based on democracy Rome
practiced in the republican era, which the Founding Fathers of America
sought after. However, unfortunately, in less than 300 years, America
is heading towards empirical state, an empirical state with no true
emperor, but with a figure that resembles an emperor – the President.
This is perhaps clear when it comes to the current President George W.
Bush’s arrogant and self-centered attitude with no respect to others’
opinions: “I’m the commander – see, I don’t need to explain.. I don’t
feel like I owe anybody an explanation.” (p. 43)
In many ways, Washington D.C. is just like the capital Rome – despite
the fact that it is the capital of the U.S., it does not produce
anything concrete, but only consumes. It is filled with numerous
government officials, lawyers, lobbyists, and more – who don’t really
produce anything at all. In other words, Washington D.C. is
economically meaningless city that only live off tax – lots of it. As
the proverb says, ‘All roads lead to Rome,’ every goods and service
head towards Washington D.C. and are wasted. Such phases make people
in Washington D.C. to view themselves as the most important figures in
the nation, and as the U.S. is undoubtedly the most powerful nation in
the world, they make the leader of Washington D.C. and the U.S. – the
President as the most important person in the world. Murphy
demonstrates this idea by stating, “Now that there is no longer an
unfree world, at least officially, the president is simply “the most
important man in the most important city in the world.” (P. 50)
The idea that the capital of the U.S. is the center of the world has
been inherited from Rome – as the Founding Fathers of the U.S.
inherited the founding ideas of the U.S. from Rome. Murphy asserts
this idea as ‘The Omphalos Syndrome,’ a term describes the tendency of
people who “believe themselves to be divinely appointed to the centre
of the universe,” as one geographer explains, to place themselves in
the middle of the maps they draw(P. 44). This is the most important
trait the capitals share, and Washington D.C. is no free from the
syndrome. He views that such attitudes of America’s capital hinder the
central government to see the reality as it is. Despite the fact that
America still hasn’t won wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, $20 million has
been set aside for an eventual “Day of Celebration” marking American
victory in Iraq and Afghanistan. This attitude is no different from
that of Rome, when its west empire had fallen by a warrior named
Odoacer, the Roman Senate ordered new coins to be made, with the
legend “Roma Invica” – “Rome Un-conquered.”
In 1997 film “The Devil’s Advocate,” John Milton, played by Al Pacino
delivers the last line of the film as he reveal himself at the end –
‘Vanity, definitely my favorite sin.’ Vanity and arrogance are the
first weapons a devil uses when targeting man. The U.S.’s capital has
fallen into the trap – being arrogant, surrounded by abundance, and
vain – and they prevent the capital from seeing the reality as it is.
The U.S. is now heading to a path that the Founding Fathers,
particularly George Washington wanted to avoid so much – to an
empirical state. Although many Americans would not see America as an
empirical state, how Washington D.C. works and acts resemble very much
like the capital Rome in the days of empirical era. Unless Washington
D.C. and perhaps the President of the U.S. abandon the idea that the
capital is the center of the world, the U.S. won’t be able to avoid
the very same path Rome had taken. The U.S. is on the blink of
inheriting the mistake that Rome made – the fall followed by removing
its republic government and shifting to an empirical state. Although
it will be very unlike that the U.S. will ever become an empirical
state like Rome, its overpowering presidency could make the U.S. very
much like Rome in many ways. The U.S. must construe what Richard Nixon
said: “When the great civilizations of the past became prosperous,
then they lost the will to go on living and make prosperous, they fell
victims to decadence, which in the long run destroy a culture. The
Unites States is now entering this phase.” (p. 32)
References
Sheila, J. L. Rep. 2007, October, 17. H.R.4020. To recognize the
extraordinary performance of the Armed Forces in achieving the
military objectives of the United States in Iraq, to encourage the
President to issue a proclamation calling upon the people of the
United States to observe a national day of celebration commemorating
military success in Iraq, and for other purposes. US House of
Representatives. Retrieved from:
http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/D?c110:2:./temp/~c110fRLk2C::
Kopelson, A. (Producer), & Hackford, T. (Director). (1997). Devil’s
Advocate. [Motion Picture]. United States: Warner Bros.
Dong Chul Oh
Eng.101, Sec. #0495
November 8th, 2008
Short Story
James Marshal is a handsome, rich man in his early 30s. Inherited
billions of dollar as the sole heir from his parents, who passed away
10 years ago, he enjoys a life of abundance, vanity, and extravagance.
Unlike many of those ‘old-money’ people who are reluctant to display
their wealth, James is eager to show off his wealth, due to influences
from his immature, vain friends he has had since childhood. He spends
most of his time at the beau monde, looking for women he could spent
time with. He has never had any serious relationship with a woman, and
he is not willing to do so. To him, women are just subjects of
enjoyment, pride, and sex. Although he is educated at a prestige
university, Yale University, majoring Business Administration,
schooling is only a title that allowed him to be in the beau monde.
Beside, his grades in the university were far below average, as his
only interest in his schooling period was to date women. His garage is
filled with expensive, super cars – from Lamborghini to Ferrari,
Porsche, Maserati, etc – each car costs a normal person’s entire
salaries of lifetime. He owns numerous houses and cottages all around
the country – from Beverly Hills, Palm Beach and Upstate New York to
Hawaii, the Caribbean Sea, etc. He has a company of his own – a
financial firm called JM Finances, which is one of the top financial
firms in the world. However, he has never been really involved in
managing the company, as the company is operated by executives whose
only interests are seeing how the wind blows on James and making money
by his side.
Even with all his wealth, he is literally a child on his own – he
cannot cook, send an E-mail, or even wash his own clothes. He is
surrounded by people who are only there to assist and help his living,
from butler to cleaning lady, gardener, etc. Deep inside their heart,
they detest James, as he is an arrogant, ill-natured, and detestable
man with no respect for others around him. Only reason they stay
around him is because of his wealth. At least, James’ huge fortune
allows him to pay them well – far better than any other job can offer.
Despite his child-like characters, James is he is literally a king in
his own world. Everyone around him obeys his words, and no one ask a
question. He can do nearly anything he wants, and there is no one who
would criticize or interrupt him whatsoever. To simply put it, he
can’t imagine a universe that doesn’t revolve around him. That’s how
he grew up, and that’s how he has lived his life.
Then one day, came a financial crisis and a burst of real estate
bubble that have bankrupted many financial firms and crushed real
estate businesses. James’ firm and fortune cannot escape the crises.
His share value starts to fall rapidly, and his firm soon faces
bankruptcy. Only to realize the seriousness of the situation too late,
he tries to do anything to revive his company. However, he has no
knowledge on how to manage the firm, and his efforts only make things
worse. In his desperate attempts, he starts to sell his real estates,
which value 50% lower compared to prior to the burst of real estate
bubble. With his desperate attempt, he somewhat manages to avoid
bankruptcy. But the situation hasn’t really improved, as the measure
is only a stopgap. Soon, his firm goes bankrupt, resulted in losing
more than 80% of his wealth. As he has most of his fortune, everyone
around him starts to leave him. First his girlfriend leaves him as he
can no longer provide her with the luxuries she wants. Then, his
friends in the beau monde turn their back on him, as they also have
their own problems and are reluctant to provide him any help to him –
they know too well that James is incapable to do any business own his
own, and they are too busy to save their own asses. Finally, all those
people who have babysat him, his butler, cleaning lady, cook,
gardener, etc leave him. What makes things worse is his arrogance and
ill-natured personality that are hard to endure if it weren’t for his
money, make people around him to abandon him, without remorse.
Realizing how immature and wrong he has been, he regrets what he has
been and tries to better himself, only realizing it is too late. Being
completely left alone, he now has to live by himself, and only things
left to him are a house in Beverley Hills, an Aston Martin, and 2
million dollar in his bank account. Though he is determined to change,
he cannot easily let go of his life in vanity and leave the glory of
the past behind him, which he has enjoyed for more than 30 years in
his life. With no one to cook for him, he always dines out, ending up
eating expensive foods he is used to. No one to clean or take care of,
his last house started to turn into a dumping ground. As there is no
gardener to take care of his garden, his once beautiful garden soon
turns into a jungle. Despite these decadences that are so obvious,
James still can’t make changes that require him to live off his last
remaining money. Despaired for left all by himself, with no one next
him, he soon falls into the temptation of drug and alcohol. Surely,
doing drug was nothing strange for him when he was rich, but this
time, it has gotten much worse. Within a short period time, he becomes
a heavy drug addict and alcoholic. Once a beautiful house that boasted
its stunning view of LA area, has now turned into a crumbling house
that no one cared to see. Spending most of his money on drugs,
alcohols, and luxuries, James soon becomes a penniless, and lives off
on fast-foods. For months, he does not leave his house, and when fire
fighters and paramedics finally break into his house a few months
later by his neighbors’ call, James have long been dead, heavily
decomposed, with a heroine needle on his forearm.
Just like that, one rich young man who once enjoyed a life of vanity
and abundance has passed away. Only a few people attend his funeral.
No one really cries for him, nor is saddened by his death. His last
house is now deconstructed, as it is impossible for anyone to live in,
and his last loving car, Aston Martin will soon be sold at public
auction. He was born rich with everything one could ask for on his
side, but died with only a crumbling house, an Aston Martin, and
loneliness on his side.