VAT query

[Gaurav mehrotra]

Hello All

Builder is distributing the VAT letters today with deadline of 25th October . Please let all know how we should collaborate and approach the builder regarding this

Regards

Gaurav

A-601

[tarun sharma]

Dear All,

Greetings!

The VAT submission deadline(31st Oct 2012) is for the builders and not the consumers. The builder is supposed to deposit VAT by 31st Oct and can collect the same from the flat owners by giving a notice of three months. The final verdict of VAT is still pending at the supreme court of India, which will be rolled out after 31st Oct. Please make a collective stand.

Regards

Dr. Tarun Sharma

A-308

[Gaurav mehrotra]

Pasting another thread regarding same issue and copying other interested parties in KP

rom:	himanshu shah <him...@gmail.com>
To:	Himanshu SHAH/HSDI/HSBC@HSBC03
Date:	10/23/2012 12:11 PM
Subject:	Fwd: VAT NOTICE FOR PAYMENT BY 25.10.2012 - SOCIETY STAND ON THIS SUBJECT.

---

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: himanshu shah <him...@gmail.com>
Date: Tue, Oct 23, 2012 at 12:12 PM
Subject: Re: VAT NOTICE FOR PAYMENT BY 25.10.2012 - SOCIETY STAND ON THIS SUBJECT.
To: Dilip Hotpeti <hotp...@inoxap.com>
Cc: Naresh Panchal <pna...@suzlon.com>, Ghanashyam Bhavsar <ghanas...@hotmail.com>, ashuto...@dargroup.com, heta...@gmail.com, iyer...@gmail.com, bhavesh....@gmail.com, che...@amdocs.com, Brajesh Palsaniya <pbra...@suzlon.com>, Narendra C Savalia <snar...@suzlon.com>, navde...@gmail.com, Rajesh Dhrangadharia <dra...@suzlon.com>, goya...@gmail.com, nitin...@yahoo.co.in, sanjaych...@gmail.com, soni.j...@gmail.com, Kaushik Vagadia <vkau...@suzlon.com>, Rajiv Parikh <pra...@suzlon.com>, Shivlal Vekaria <vshi...@suzlon.com>, gan...@gmail.com, aukha...@gmail.com, Manish Jain <jma...@suzlon.com>, amit...@gmail.com, vikas....@gmail.com, rphul...@yahoo.in, meh...@gmail.com, bhatt...@rediffmail.com, hari_...@hotmail.com, sth...@synteltelecom.com, Sanjay Chandrani <csa...@suzlon.com>, arc...@gmail.com, arvind...@bharatforge.com, vishalp...@gmail.com, prashant...@synefra.com, puneet....@gmail.com, ravir...@gmail.com, ghanashya...@honeywell.com, aparna...@hotmail.com, aparna....@autodesk.com, priyanka shah <priyank...@gmail.com>


Yes i completely agree with you Dilip as we need to understand some points here
 
1) How builder calculated the amount ? Is it merely based on the registration amount * 2 or 2.5 % ?
2) Is above calculation got confirmation from court or is it some different calculation as well ?
3) If yes then do we require to pay beforehand to the builder as we have got deadline of only 1 day (by considering notice has been given today or yesterday) as by 25th we need to pay. I was under the consideration that builder will be first paying to the authority and then will recover from the flat owners but here its happening in the other way
(Currently Not all builders are asking money from flat owners)
4) As we have to pay only to the builder, then shall we not consider our pending amount (to be recovered from builder...eg. Gas pipeline amount) and pay remaining amount to builder
 
It would be better if we all agree, decide and then make payment instead of going individually and make the payment to builder
I agree that we have to pay but need to understand the correct amount and correct time based on everyones decision (and not based on one letter from builder)
 
Thanks,
Himanshu Shah


 
On Tue, Oct 23, 2012 at 11:28 AM, Dilip Hotpeti <hotp...@inoxap.com> wrote:
Dear All,

 

As you are aware that Builder has issued a demand letter on yesterday for payment of VAT before 25.10.2012. Since the matter is having substantial financial impact & the matter is pending for final disposal in Supreme Court, we need to discuss collectively & act accordingly.

 

Can we have the views from all society members for mutual decision.

 

 

 

Regards,

Dilip Hotpeti

A-302, Kumar Picasso.

Hadapsar, Pune

Cell 94235 75570

---

From: tarun sharma <taru...@yahoo.com>
To: "gaurav....@yahoo.com" <gaurav....@yahoo.com>; Kumar Picasso Hadapsar Pune <kumar-picasso...@googlegroups.com>
Sent: Tuesday, 23 October 2012 9:01 AM
Subject: Re: VAT query

[tarun sharma]

Dear All,

As I currently stay at Delhi. Can someone kindly inform me about the following issues:

1. Has the society been formed and builder has handed over( I guess its more than two years now?)

2. Do we get the PMC water now. (As this main point)

3. Has he given the completion certificate from PMC or Gram Sabha?

Regards

Dr. Tarun Sharma

A-308

09312477723

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: himanshu shah <him...@gmail.com>
Date: Tue, Oct 23, 2012 at 12:12 PM
Subject: Re: VAT NOTICE FOR PAYMENT BY 25.10.2012 - SOCIETY STAND ON THIS SUBJECT.
To: Dilip Hotpeti <hotp...@inoxap.com>
Cc: Naresh Panchal <pna...@suzlon.com>, Ghanashyam Bhavsar <ghanas...@hotmail.com>, ashuto...@dargroup.com, heta...@gmail.com, iyer...@gmail.com, bhavesh....@gmail.com, che...@amdocs.com, Brajesh Palsaniya <pbra...@suzlon.com>, Narendra C Savalia <snar...@suzlon.com>, navde...@gmail.com, Rajesh Dhrangadharia <dra...@suzlon.com>, goya...@gmail.com, nitin...@yahoo.co.in, sanjaych...@gmail.com, soni.j...@gmail.com, Kaushik Vagadia <vkau...@suzlon.com>, Rajiv Parikh <pra...@suzlon.com>, Shivlal Vekaria <vshi...@suzlon.com>, gan...@gmail.com, aukha...@gmail.com, Manish Jain <jma...@suzlon.com>, amit...@gmail.com, vikas....@gmail.com, rphul...@yahoo.in, meh...@gmail.com, bhatt...@rediffmail.com, hari_...@hotmail.com, sth...@synteltelecom.com, Sanjay Chandrani <csa...@suzlon.com>, arc...@gmail.com, arvind...@bharatforge.com, vishalp...@gmail.com, prashant...@synefra.com, puneet....@gmail.com, ravir...@gmail.com, ghanashya...@honeywell.com, aparna...@hotmail.com, aparna....@autodesk.com, priyanka shah <priyank...@gmail.com>

Yes i completely agree with you Dilip as we need to understand some points here   1) How builder calculated the amount ? Is it merely based on the registration amount * 2 or 2.5 % ? 2) Is above calculation got confirmation from court or is it some different calculation as well ? 3) If yes then do we require to pay beforehand to the builder as we have got deadline of only 1 day (by considering notice has been given today or yesterday) as by 25th we need to pay. I was under the consideration that builder will be first paying to the authority and then will recover from the flat owners but here its happening in the other way (Currently Not all builders are asking money from flat owners) 4) As we have to pay only to the builder, then shall we not consider our pending amount (to be recovered from builder...eg. Gas pipeline amount) and pay remaining amount to builder   It would be better if we all agree, decide and then make payment instead of going individually and make the payment to builder I agree that we have to pay but need to understand the correct amount and correct time based on everyones decision (and not based on one letter from builder)   Thanks,
Himanshu Shah

  On Tue, Oct 23, 2012 at 11:28 AM, Dilip Hotpeti <hotp...@inoxap.com> wrote: Dear All,

 

As you are aware that Builder has issued a demand letter on yesterday for payment of VAT before 25.10.2012. Since the matter is having substantial financial impact & the matter is pending for final disposal in Supreme Court, we need to discuss collectively & act accordingly.

 

Can we have the views from all society members for mutual decision.

 

 

 

Regards,

Dilip Hotpeti

A-302, Kumar Picasso.

Hadapsar, Pune

Cell 94235 75570

[Vishal Kulkarni]

Hello All,

Some more information on VAT .. please read the document attached.

However I agree with all, we need more details from Builder

Thanks

Vishal