My order of interest:
1. East of Eden - Steinbeck is one of my favorites and has yet to
disappoint. Read this one several years ago and enjoyed it but would
like to reread as I've forgotten most of the details.
2. Death of Ivan Ilyich (and other stories?) - In my copy, Death is
about 50 pages but the collection includes "Family Happiness," "The
Kreutzer Sonata" and "Master and Man," altogether about 300 pages.
Read this one but again it's been too long to remember details. LIked
it.
3.Crime and Punishment - I enjoy saying "Raskolnikov." I remember more
details from this one than the others, probably because it left a
strong impression. I think for me this would be the most time-
consuming read of the options.
I think these three are great selections for potential theological
discussion.
4 & 5 - The remaining two are good choices as well. Austen is a
completely different feel from the others. Borges is a recognized
genius. To be honest, his Labyrinths intimidates me because I read
another book of shorts by him (The Aleph and Other Stories) and I
comprehended very few of them. I think I remember being lost mostly
because of many allusions I didn't get and historical references I
didn't know (I think Spanish and Argentinian).
Future considerations for those with interest:
Like you said, Jordan, there are a ton of options in this category.
Just thinking about ones that might be interesting seminary student/
pastor options for anytime, I thought I'd throw four classic titles
out for future reference. Some may have been mentioned already: Cry,
The Beloved Country (Alan Paton), The Power and the Glory (Graham
Greene), The Plague (Albert Camus), and Portrait of the Artist as a
Young Man (James Joyce). I'm sure this is only the tip of a large
iceberg.