I'm good getting Shady. I'm concerned the Treehouse doesn't have enough beds, so I think we need to nix that one, anyway. Black Mtn is a pretty sweet (tho fancy) town. There's a sick coffee shop (Dripolator). And from that place we can ride up Mt. Mitchell (highest point in NC and east of Mississippi R.).
I know this area quite well, and the trade-offs as I see them are clear:
-Shady Grove looks way nicer of a property; it's newer, more common space, bigger kitchen, etc. It's pretty far from town, Black Mtn or Asheville, and it's a gated mountainside community, so when back at the house, we stay in the house. The ride options are probably a bit more epic with Mt. Mitchell close by.
-The one in Pisgah is not as nice or new, and the common space is not as big or open. But the place is literally IN the national forest, with endless miles of trails right out the door for non-cycling SOs to walk/hike/run, or any of us to explore on foot or bike; it's also way closer to town.
I do think we are gonna ride ourselves into the ground, and we'll be sitting around the house the rest of the time. I suspect not all of us are gonna have bikes compatible with trails/gravel. In either case, we'll need to drive to town. But I wanted to paint a picture in case others see the options differently.
That's it.
NP