[JIRA] (JENKINS-61605) Files with SpotBugs warnings are copied to the build folder but files with FindBugs warnings are not found

[me@basilcrow.com (JIRA)]

Basil Crow created an issue

Jenkins / JENKINS-61605 Files with SpotBugs warnings are copied to the build folder but files with FindBugs warnings are not found Issue Type: Bug Assignee: Ulli Hafner Components: warnings-ng-plugin Created: 2020-03-20 19:36 Environment: warnings-ng 8.1.0 analysis-core 1.96 analysis-model-api 8.0.1 Priority: Minor Reporter: Basil Crow Overview When using Gradle and the Warnings Next Generation Plugin, files with SpotBugs warnings are copied to the build folder but files with FindBugs warnings are not found. Steps to Reproduce I have created a minimal reproducible example (MRE) at basil/warnings-ng-reproducer. Run the Jenkinsfile there to reproduce the issue. Expected Results This is a bare-bones Gradle build with two subprojects: findbugs and spotbugs. Each subproject has a single Java file with warnings. The findbugs subproject has the Gradle FindBugs plugin enabled, while the spotbugs subproject has the Gradle SpotBugs plugin enabled. Gradle detects the same warnings in both subprojects. The expected results are for the Warnings Next Generation Plugin to copy the files with issues in both subprojects to the build folder. Actual Results When recording issues with the Warnings Next Generation Plugin, the following occurs: […] [FindBugs] Copying affected files to Jenkins' build folder '/var/jenkins_home/jobs/test/builds/1/files-with-issues' [FindBugs] -> 0 copied, 0 not in workspace, 3 not-found, 0 with I/O error […] [SpotBugs] Copying affected files to Jenkins' build folder '/var/jenkins_home/jobs/test/builds/1/files-with-issues' [SpotBugs] -> 1 copied, 0 not in workspace, 0 not-found, 0 with I/O error […] Note that for FindBugs there are "3 not-found" issues, while for SpotBugs there are "0 not-found" issues. In the Jenkins UI, files from the findbugs subproject are not viewable, but files from the spotbugs subproject are. I have attached a screenshot showing this. Add Comment

This message was sent by Atlassian Jira (v7.13.12#713012-sha1:6e07c38)

[me@basilcrow.com (JIRA)]

Basil Crow updated an issue

Jenkins / JENKINS-61605 Files with SpotBugs warnings are copied to the build folder but files with FindBugs warnings are not found

Change By: Basil Crow Attachment: findbugs-spotbugs.png

Add Comment

[ullrich.hafner@gmail.com (JIRA)]

Ulli Hafner edited a comment on JENKINS-61605

Re: Files with SpotBugs warnings are copied to the build folder but files with FindBugs warnings are not found Can you create a diff of the two different XML files . ? I doubt that this is a problem in my plugin, as the same parser is used for both warnings. BTW: why are you using using both tools? FIndBugs is end-of-life and has been replaced by SpotBugs.

Add Comment

[ullrich.hafner@gmail.com (JIRA)]

Ulli Hafner edited a comment on JENKINS-61605

Re: Files with SpotBugs warnings are copied to the build folder but files with FindBugs warnings are not found

Can you make create a diff of the two different XML files. I doubt that this is a problem in my plugin, as the same parser is used for both warnings. BTW: why are you using using both tools? FIndBugs is end-of-life and has been replaced by SpotBugs.

Add Comment

[ullrich.hafner@gmail.com (JIRA)]

Ulli Hafner commented on JENKINS-61605

Re: Files with SpotBugs warnings are copied to the build folder but files with FindBugs warnings are not found

Can you make a diff of the two different XML files. I doubt that this is a problem in my plugin, as the same parser is used for both warnings. BTW: why are you using using both tools? FIndBugs is end-of-life and has been replaced by SpotBugs.

Add Comment

[me@basilcrow.com (JIRA)]

Basil Crow commented on JENKINS-61605

Re: Files with SpotBugs warnings are copied to the build folder but files with FindBugs warnings are not found

Thank you for the quick reply! Can you create a diff of the two different XML files? Sorry, I don't have the time to investigate this further at present. But you should be able to easily reproduce the problem following the instructions I listed under "Steps to Reproduce", after which you should be able to compare the two different XML files. Let me know if I can provide any additional context.

BTW: why are you using using both tools? FIndBugs is end-of-life and has been replaced by SpotBugs.

Yes, I am aware that FindBugs is EOL. I used both tools in the example merely to illustrate that the problem is only reproducible when using FindBugs. I am maintaining a Jenkins setup that runs an application build that I don't maintain, and that build still uses FindBugs, so unfortunately I still need to be able to use Jenkins with FindBugs.

Add Comment