[JIRA] [core] (JENKINS-27565) Nodes can be removed as idle before the assigned tasks have started

[jyri.ilama@eficode.com (JIRA)]

Jyri Ilama edited a comment on JENKINS-27565

Re: Nodes can be removed as idle before the assigned tasks have started Any chance that this fix prevents builds  from  finishing, if e.g. azure slave clean task thread is running? This thread might take pretty long sometimes.  I just updated from 1.606 to 1.612 and found this issue. All builds freeze in the end before triggering a downstream job. The funny part is that the builds don't even show to be running anymore in the project view, but when you open console output, you'll find the build hanging. But, when checking from Jenkins main page, you can see them still running. When the clean task thread finishes, the builds finish too. Add Comment

This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA (v6.4.2#64017-sha1:e244265)

[jyri.ilama@eficode.com (JIRA)]

Jyri Ilama commented on JENKINS-27565

Re: Nodes can be removed as idle before the assigned tasks have started

Any chance that this fix prevents builds finishing, if e.g. azure slave clean task thread is running? This thread might take pretty long sometimes.

I just updated from 1.606 to 1.612 and found this issue. All builds freeze in the end before triggering a downstream job. The funny part is that the builds don't even show to be running anymore in the project view, but when you open console output, you'll find the build hanging. But, when checking from Jenkins main page, you can see them still running. When the clean task thread finishes, the builds finish too.

Add Comment

[peter.huang@practiceevolve.com.au (JIRA)]

Peter Huang commented on JENKINS-27565

Re: Nodes can be removed as idle before the assigned tasks have started

I have come across the same problem.

Add Comment

[stephenconnolly@java.net (JIRA)]

stephenconnolly commented on JENKINS-27565

Re: Nodes can be removed as idle before the assigned tasks have started

I have taken a look at the Azure cloud implementation... why did I do that? I knew what I was going to find before I looked... oh yes yet another completely borked cloud implementation which does everything hacky wrong ways because nobody actually knows the correct way to implement a cloud provider in Jenkins. I would not be surprised if the AzureSlaveCleanTaskThread causes issues, it seems to be doing lots of things it shouldn't... I really need to get the time to implement a clean cloud provisioning API so that people will stop using the current completely broken one (and just so that people who have tried to implement the Cloud API feel better, I have not seen any cloud implementation that is 100% correct... largely because the existing API is so woefully underspecified)

Add Comment

[stephenconnolly@java.net (JIRA)]

stephenconnolly closed an issue as Fixed

Jenkins / JENKINS-27565

Nodes can be removed as idle before the assigned tasks have started

Change By: stephenconnolly Status: Resolved Closed

Add Comment

This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA (v7.1.7#71011-sha1:2526d7c)

[root@junwuhui.cn (JIRA)]

runze xia edited a comment on JENKINS-27565

Re: Nodes can be removed as idle before the assigned tasks have started [~stephenconnolly] Do you know which version is included in this fix? I also encountered this problem using jenkins core v.2176.2   with kubernetes plugin

Add Comment

This message was sent by Atlassian Jira (v7.13.6#713006-sha1:cc4451f)

[root@junwuhui.cn (JIRA)]

runze xia commented on JENKINS-27565

Re: Nodes can be removed as idle before the assigned tasks have started

Stephen Connolly Do you know which version is included in this fix? I also encountered this problem using jenkins core v.2176.2

Add Comment