Michael,
I know what I’m about to say will run contrary to the way some (many?) look at this but as a mostly coastal sailor and believer in the KISS principal of engineering, I’ve taken a different approach with our electrical. We have a lowly 60A (near) stock alternator. Same mounts, same belts. Works great for what we need. Let me explain a bit.
I’ve kept the electrical system as close to stock as possible (it has near zero leakage!) BUT: we have upgraded to four 90Ah 980CCA X2 deep cycle AGMs. Constant updates on primary cables and wiring (but still far from all new), all lights converted with LED bulbs in stock fixtures, an old fridge that’s draws 4-5a (so do the new ones) and all new B&G NAV, AIS, Cell booster, 2500w inverter for 115v etc. All wires and connections have liberal use of dielectric grease.
So as I’ve said, it’s been great for what we do. Live on a mooring so no dock charging. Sail a few times weekly where the engine is only used for 10-15min at a time. We cruise for few weeks a season. More than a few days of sailing without running the engine is rare. We never feel we’re lacking in power or need to run the engine much more than the typical harbor transit, low wind motoring etc.
—the only things we’re still considering are a few deck mounted walkable 100w solar panels. Which could let us run the fridge more but we don’t need that most of the time—
So on the charging:
1. Battery capacity and depth of discharge
• The batteries are 12 V, 90 Ah.
• At 25% discharge, which is a lot, that means about 22 Ah needs to be replaced in each batttery.
2. Alternator rating
• The alternator is rated at 60 A at 12 V.
• In practice, alternators rarely deliver their full rated current continuously — heat, rpm, regulator behavior, and battery acceptance all reduce it. A safe assumption is ~50–70% of rating on average during recharge. Let’s assume 40 A average after further reducing for running equipment (which is what I see on my gauge) actually goes into the battery.
3. Ideal recharge time
• Energy to replace = 45 Ah.
• At 60 A continuous (perfect case): 2hr 16min
4. Absorption phase reality
Battery (Lead-acid or AGM) charging isn’t linear and they can only absorb so much at a time. Most notably, as the battery approaches ~80% state of charge (which is much of the time in most cases), current acceptance drops and the alternator output tapers. The last 20% may take just as long as the first 80%.
• To reach 80% charged (≈72 Ah): ~45–70 minutes.
• To reach nearly full (≈100%): often 2.5–3 hours total, even with a 60 A alternator. SO, at this point alternator size becomes much less important for the longer part of the change cycle.
Sam
Cahoots
J/4O #44
⸻