Re: Second Al-Fatimiyah Season

[klei...@astound.net]

AlMujtaba Home Page wrote:

Probably automatically - but why complain. This is a good example of
someone's ideas about Islamic origins. That that someone is doubtless
Shi'ite is never mentioned.

> *Second Al-Fatimiyah Season*

> *Martyrdom Anniversary of Sayeda Fatimah Al-Zahra (AS)*

It is a far stretch on the martyr to say that Fatima was a martyr.

> who was martyred according to a narration on *13. Jamadi Al-Awwal 11 A.H.
> (632 A.D)*, and according to another narration on *8** **Rabi Al-Thani 11
> A.H. (632 A.D)*, and according a third narration on *3, Jamadi Al-Thani 11
> A.H. (632 A.D)*.

This is a deplorable way to present data. Whose narrations and found
where? Ibn Sa'd, who should be the most dependable source, quotes
several first-class sources as saying she lived six months after
Muhammad. Tabari quotes Ibn Ishaq as saying Muhammad died on 12 Rabi
Al-Awwal and six months later would be in Ramadan. Ibn Sa'd quotes
Waqidi as saying she died on 7 Ramadan.

> *On this sad and tragic event, AlMujtaba Islamic Network Team have
> established a special season commemorating Hazrat Fatimah Al-Zahra (AS)*
>
> *To view this season...Please visit http://www.almujtaba.com*
>
> Please don't forget us from your prayers

My prayers will be devoted to their improving thei act.