Friends,
I am struggling to understand how this will benefit the community. I'm seeing nothing but downside.
First, a little personal background: I am second-generation American, my grandparents having immigrated. I know how this sounds but...many of my friends are immigrants--from Brazil, Greece, Sri Lanka, Lebanon, etc. My uncle married a Japanese war bride. So do not misconstrue my comments.
Through a Roman Catholic ministry I volunteer for--St. Vincent De Paul--I see, every week, people in Buffalo who live in poverty. Some of these clients are immigrants. I know this is anecdotal but I am 100% certain that our community cannot now meet all the needs of the people living in poverty who live in Western New York. St. Vincent De Paul is referred clients who can no longer be helped by Erie County's DSS and by Catholic Chairities and other organizations. And our resources are inadequate.
The majority of the immigrants and refugees who come to WNY now need help of one kind or more. there are exceptions of course, such as almost all of my friends that I mention above but these people needed no special invitation/accomodations from our community to come--they are teachers, professionals, or self-employed who, in most cases, married a WNY native. Please consider this against the backdrop of the third-poorest city in the country. We cannot help all our residents now. why bring in more people who need help?
Your invite mentions Buffalo's history vis-a-vis immigrant contributions but society and the economy were different then. My Dad worked with 'DPs' in the fluor mills who had no high school education and couldn't speak English very well. you could show up at the gates of steel mills or fluor mills and get a job that day. That's not gonna work in today's economy. And America was growing then. It is not now. It's not like we need workers--the situation is that workers already here need work. Currently there are 48,700 unemployed adults in WNY, a rate of 8.37%. Why would we want to attract more people looking for jobs?
And then there's the issue of anti-immigrant sentiment. I don't know about your social networks but in mine there are a lot of unemployed/underemployed who resent the government programs to help immigrants and aliens. I have family in California, one of them of Mexican descent, who are very opposed to more immigration. And it's not xenophobia or racism; it's a shrinking economy and that makes job opportunities and demands for social services more competitive.
The problem in WNY is that people are leaving. We have a higher birth rate than death rate and still our population declines. We don't need replacements from the outside, we need to keep the naitves here. i think that should be the priority.
Larry Brooks