On Tuesday, 11 June 2013 17:40:14 UTC+1, Patrick Meier wrote:
... proven workflows that (1) have already been used to support disaster response efforts and (2) have already been directly requested by our humanitarian partners. So this means:
1) Tagging images/videos if they show disaster damage
The workflow that came immediately to mind is that used by
Tomnod (now
acquired by DG): Finite tasks over a limited scope that gamify participation (granting this is different entirely from the sort of "serious gaming" we're discussing here).
2) Tagging tweets if they refer to damage, needs, etc.
The stuff that MapBox has done with Gnip lately, while not tagging individual tweets per se, does give some indication that the geolocation and microblog ingestion is manageable. Also, it's just beautiful stuff. I've thought about the tagging issue, and it seems like tagging might be handled well with a hybrid system, whereby a limited corpus of predetermined selectable tags (e.g. fire, flood, damage, medical) plus a capability to accept free-form tags (#GentianStreet, #NeedMedicine, #NeedWater) from participants. Ideally, being able to iteratively manage available prefab tags based on the evolving nature of the emergency would be a good thing.
So our main questions right now are:
1) How do we integrate these IRL tasks into existing games?
2) How do we convince gaming companies to prototype this?
3) Which companies should we approach first?
I am not much of a gamer, but one of the things did occur was the sort of easter-eggs or mini-games you'll occasionally find in MMORPGs: stopping by the saloon and taking up a game of blackjack with an old prospector, for example. The difference is that the incentive system to encourage participation (win money) would necessarily need to be thought about fairly extensively: is intrinsic motivation sufficient? Do we suggest in-game benefit? If so, how do we encourage a gaming company to offer this sort of thing in a way that doesn't become disruptive (i.e. offering those who participate untoward advantage in the balance of the game)?
I'm principally a remote sensing & GIS/Geovisualization dude, so my inclinations naturally lie in those arenas. I look forward to the rest of the discussions.
best
Chris