When reading the Pew Internet article first I was a little skeptical
of the data collected. If one thoroughly reads the article the
research groups were only made up of six focus groups with middle and
high school students in TWO American cities. “These qualitative
results are not representative of the U.S. teen population.” (Part 1,
page 3)
Yet, throughout the article statistics quote American teenagers. The
study did conduct 935 telephone interviews with teen’s ages 12 to 17
years-old and their parents within the United States. The overall
margin of error was plus or minus 3 % points. (See Methodology page
38-45 to analyze research) It is important to remember that sampling
fluctuations are only one possible source of error in a survey
estimate. Other sources, such as respondent selection bias
(interviewees were paid to participate in study) questionnaire wording
and reporting inaccuracy, may influence the results of the study.
Never give a scientist a research paper and not expect the data to be
scrutinized. Having said that, I was surprised by very little in the
article most of the information was prior knowledge for me.
Things that I would share with other parents are effective filters
and monitoring software. Some parents believe that by using the
Internet Tools bar and setting a filter to restricted sites they are
fully protecting their children. What they do not realize is that if
the child opens another Internet browser they can get around the
filter system. In addition, not all monitoring software is equal.
Cyber Patrol from The Learning Company, provides customizable access
controls for multiple users. Aside from installation difficulties,
this is one of the best for families, especially where continuous
supervision is unlikely. Cyber Patrol requires subscription for
regular updates. (
www.superkids.com)
Another great resource is i-SAFE Inc. Founded in 1998 and endorsed by
the U.S. Congress, i-SAFE is a non-profit foundation dedicated to
protecting the online experiences of youth everywhere. i-SAFE
incorporates classroom curriculum with dynamic community outreach to
empower students, teachers, parents, law enforcement, and concerned
adults to make the Internet a safer place. (
www.isafe.org) This is a
great resource for educators and parents.
In conclusion, social networking encompasses so much of what today’s
kids want and love- real-time and fast communication features,
blogging tools, photos, music and video sharing, and the ability to
post original and creative work-all linked to a unique profile that
can be personalized and updated on a regular basis.
The most important questions to ask teens are: “How much information
have you shared? Is it all true? Is your profile private? Do you
live in a small town or a big city? How did you create your network
of online “friends”? How old are you? Do your parents have lots of
rules about Internet use?” (Part 3, page 30)