Re: MR. V.B.SEHGAL's Vs. IIISLA CASE IN HON'BLE DELHI HIGH COURT AT NEW DELHI

146 views
Skip to first unread message

Chand Bhatia

unread,
Jul 6, 2017, 4:29:40 AM7/6/17
to VINOD KUMAR INDORA, DILEEP WANGOO, ajaykis...@yahoo.co.in, M S Sainani, Sukanta Ku. Das, Manoj Pattnaik, Orissa Insurance Surveyors group, Saroj Kumar Sahoo JPR, kpsbr...@gmail.com, Insurance...@googlegroups.com, asho...@live.com, Sushil Sonthalia, surendr...@rediffmail.com, naveench...@gmail.com, Nihar Dash, Himanhu Parida, Jajati Keshari Patnaik, saik...@yahoo.com, Ashim K. Rath, Ravi Dhar, Swayambhu Mohanty, sayyads...@yahoo.co.in, Mohinder.Kumar Sharma, rajkumar...@yahoo.com, electi...@iiisla.co.in, pban...@yahoo.com, Orissa Insurance Surveyors Welfare Scociety, arvind....@rediffmail.com, ashok...@rediffmail.com, maachin...@gmail.com, Manoj Das, Rajesh C Malhotra, V B sehgal, ray...@rediffmail.com, sks...@sify.com, Saroj Kumar Sahoo, JITENDRA PRASAD SINGH, dav...@rediffmail.com, sks...@aol.com, anil....@hotmail.com, Bani P. Mohanty, razend...@sify.com, umshin...@yahoo.co.in, ijk...@gmail.com, Sudhir Kataria, shibap@rediffmail.co m, SUNIL J. VORA & ASSOCIATES, chai...@irda.gov.in, saroj....@rediffmail.com, Sitansu Sekhar Padhi, k.sent...@gmail.com, Kshirod K. Behera, surveyor_jps, facebook, rkthen...@gmail.com, Ashok Das, GADADHAR SWAIN, raven...@gmail.com, Sanjeeb Mohanty, Prasanna Ku. Tripathy, Tanmoy Sarkar, Tapan ku. Mohanty, ,ersnm1@sify.com, manojku...@rediffmail.com, pramod....@yahoo.com, vipin_sh...@yahoo.co.in, Sourjya Prakash Mohapatra, Shiba Padhi, akpo...@rediffmail.com, Ramesh Ch. Indoria, Upinder Sachdeva, BIBHU DATTA SWAIN, Manoranjan Lenka, DILEEP WANGOO, manaskuma...@gmail.com, Smruti ranjan Sarangi, Pramod Sahoo, Satyanarayan Gharai, manmatha...@gmail.com, Sarat Ch. Senapati, Chitta R. Shaw, Byomokesh Pujari, santo...@yahoo.com, Satyabrata Choudhury, Govind Hota, binod...@gmail.com, subas...@gmail.com, sant_...@yahoo.co.in, usins...@nic.in, Narendra Ku. Sahoo, prashant...@gmail.com, er.manoj...@yahoo.co.in, mhsathis...@gmail.com, njdes...@hotmail.com, srinivasa...@gmail.com, IIISLA CHENNAI UNIT, Nihar Ranjan Mishra, tvnsu...@gmail.com, manas...@yo.com, rsp...@hotmail.com, Sadipta Ku. Behera, subash sabat, ar.me...@sansad.nic.in, sn.nayak200 8@rediffmail.com, Prakash Chandra Nayak, sans...@yahoo.com, Balakrushna Patra, AMAR KANT JHA, mrinal...@sify.com, Rabindra K. Sahoo, dev...@sify.com, PRASANTA KUMAR Mishra, adit...@live.com, Suvendu Naik, sunil vora, sbrsan...@yahoo.com, satyesh prusty, sanjay_d...@hotmail.com, shashi bhushan, raven...@yahoo.co.in, ,illiyas_survey@re diffmail.com, Satya Mo. Mohapatra, Manas Mohanty, pks1...@gmail.com, insurance adjuster, AMIYA BEHURIA, borakh...@gmail.com, Akshaya Kumar Misra, santosh...@gmail.com, pra...@satyam.net.in, punjabsurveyors, Amarendra Dash, S. Anoop Kumar, rajiv budhiraja, Aswini Ku. Mohanty, pktrip...@gmail.com, Manmohan Mishra, Umesh Chandra Patnaik, spsingh...@yahoo.com, Amar nath Taneja, S N NAYAK, sunil.m...@yahoo.com, paraz...@vsnl.net, Gaurishankar Dalai, Sanjeeb Kumar Mohanty, akjen...@rediffmail.com, saipr...@gmail.com, shankarkr...@gmail.com, Radhe Shyam Garg, Kawaljit Ahluwalia, Goutam Das, Arjun Ram Meghwal, rkgsu...@yahoo.com, jsin...@nic.in, Chitta Ranjan Mohapatra, Diganta Keshari, shivashan...@yahoo.co.in, Manas Singh, uba...@yahoo.com, Debadatta Mohapatra, binayak das, manoj hota, Saroj kumar Panda, Bharat Ku. Dhal, Shreemanta Tarai, b...@vsnl.com, Jagat Krushna Pattnaik, ed...@irda.gov.in, Himansu sekhar Dash, shajujosephc...@gnail.com, prad...@sancharnet.in, op_sh...@yahoo.com, Dr. M.K.Nanda, Harvinder Pal Singh Mokha, deepakm...@yahoo.com, IIISLA ODISHA, Satyasiba Pattnaik, iiisla...@gmail.com, Ashraff Tim, hnag...@hotmail.com, vivek...@gmail.com, Satyajit R. Das, Sangram K. Mishra, Pravat Pradhan, ,ranajitpanda99@yahoo.com, saritd...@yahoo.co.in, skg_su...@sify.com, kishor...@hotmail.com, Rakhal Chandra Behera, prk...@gmail.com, Jagdish Parmar-Zonal Chairman IIISLA & IISA Secy., Hrushikesh Mohanty, dea.o...@gmail.com, www.p...@yahoo.co.in, akm...@dataone.in, Bibhudutta Roy, NARAYAN CHANDRA NAYAK, Chitta R. Das, shyama sankar Mishra, skn...@gmail.com, ir...@irda.gov.in, Ashok Singh, G P Mishra, Akshaya K. Swain, skmoh naty@indiatime.com, kpbalakrish...@gmail.com, Cc: Amarbar Khatua, asant...@gmail.com, Bijoy Ku. Mohapatra, Srikant Brahma, mithil...@rediffmail.com, Amar Das, panchanan mishra, raman...@yahoo.com, dro-iii.ad...@nic.co.in, skgi...@yahoo.in, keep-in-touch-su...@googlegroups.com, sitansu_se...@yahoo.co.in, satyanarayan mohanty, kavish malhotra, nirmal....@rediffmail.com, ese...@live.in, Bipin Bihari Patra, Rajesh Zawar, sms...@yahoo.com, faridaba...@googlegroups.com, Dillip K. Mohanty, Bibhu P. Das, S ANTOSH DASH, gaura...@yahoo.co.in, Rakesh Bajaj, Yashobant N. Mohanty, patilsu...@yahoo.com, ,sushil.sarkar15@yahoo.com, Arunaudayaeswar Das, Bijan Bihari Mohanty, bhargava...@gmail.com, nares...@rediffmail.com, nira...@esenden.in, Salila Satapahty, ippr...@gmail.com, Manas R. Mohanty, Dhirendra Dash, rrmoha...@rediffmail.com, b_b_p...@yahoo.co.in, ,rbhuyan03@gmail.com, Dinesh Acharaya, Sunil Dhawan, lalit gupta, Sudam Charan Panda, Rakesh Agarwal, rakes...@relianceada.com, Byomokesh Pujari, f...@nic.in, crkof...@yahoo.com, mukunda sahu, Raghunath Bal, Bibhudutta Roy, pinak...@rediffmail.com, Sushant K. Mohapatra, SANJAY KUMAR NEURA, smco....@gmail.com, sn.nayak...@gmail.com, iiisla...@googlegroups.com, ,bipin_patra2005@yahoo.com, Suvendu K Jena, singhdhan...@gmail.com, Ramakanta Swain
Dear Mr. Indora

The penalty of Rs. 50000.00 is not imposed that the petition was not maintainable, but court found that some material facts were not disclosed by the petitioner. This is what is the information given to me.

 

On Thu, Jul 6, 2017 at 12:37 PM, VINOD KUMAR INDORA <vkin...@gmail.com> wrote:
Respected Wangooji,
Seeking relief on mercy petition is fundamental right but the the matter is held on prima facie ground. If the plaintiff file again he has to deposit 50000 cost as per order. Now it is clear that whoever file petition must accertain first that the matter is maintainable or not. This matter will be decided with IIISLA AOA the court has no jurisdiction to intervien the IIISLA disciplinary matter. However as per my opinion on ground of livelihood the mercy pray to IIISLA will definitely give relief in this matter. The advice given buy you will take time and can not be admired and the result may be adverse and will be upheld as before.
Please resolve issue with President IIISLA or be ready for further 5oooo cost. Court has no power to intervien in like matter. If you want Mersey pettition then IIISLA is your own institutie will  not have to pay any cost the CC + president has power to restore the membership. So far constitutional remedy you may seek direction in any matter after restoration of your work. Only IIISLa can give relief get mandate of cc. No need for litigation sir. Vinod Kumar Indora


On Jul 6, 2017 10:18 AM, "Dileep Wangoo" <surveyors.association@gmail.com> wrote:
Dear Mr. V.B.Sehgal,

You have been my colleague, best friend and active member od SURVEYOR's WELFARE ASSOCIATION (Regd.). I am personally pained that you have become target of IIISLA promoted by IRDAI, Hyderabad thereby your livelyhood has been snatched away by the intimidating acts of omission and commission of C/C 12 members of IIISLA.

I have gone through the order of hon'ble DHC dated 04.07.2017 and would like to give you some legal procedure relief receiving suggestions as under:

01. You must not directly challenge the IIISLA removal from register but challenge the impact of it on your livelyhood i.e. challenge the decision of Insurers to stop your work on the presumption of IIISLA's removal from register.

02. Seek relief from the court to stay the decision of Insurers to stop your work till the disposal of the case related to the removal of your name from IIISLA register which is arbitrary, bad in law above all infringement into your RIGHT TO CARRY ON YOUR PROFESSION FOE EARNING LIVELUHOOD under Article 25 of Constitution of India read with Article 19 0f Constitution of India. 

03. Please make all the correspondence between you and IIISLA annexures to the MERCY PETITION and state all the facts and circumstances in the petition. Your Advocate must contest in the Court to RESTORE your LIVELYHOOD till Disposal of the case.

04. Also you must state in the petition that IIISLA's Act has damaged my sincere, dedicated, hardearned reputation etc; etc; with the Insurers by issuing letters to them and following them personally by the C/C of IIISLA for vengenance.

Hope these points may be helpful to you and you may be able to get relief from the court.

With Best Wishes and Best of Luck.

DILEEP  WANGOO    G.S. SURVEYORS WELFARE ASSOCIATION (Regd.)

9711427980 / 9015342998



--
c k bhatia
09810231248


S. Anoop Kumar

unread,
Jul 6, 2017, 4:59:58 AM7/6/17
to Chand Bhatia, Insurance surveyors, insurance-su...@googlegroups.com, Indian Independent Insurance Surveyor And Loss Assessors Bengal
Dear Mr. CK Bhatia,

Let there be some clarity on the issue.

First, the case of Mr. VB Sehgal is not dismissed, but was withdrawn by the petitioner himself due to certain technicalities.

Second, it is wrong to mention that IIISLA has won the case or Mr. VB Sehgal has lost the case as some people are spreading the message and gloating victory of IIISLA.

Third, the petitioner has the right to file the case afresh with complete documents and the petitioner is sure to do that anytime soon or could have already filed the case.

Fourth, the court penalised the petitioner by way of imposing costs at Rs. 50,000.00 for having filed the case without sufficient supporting documents later leading to self withdrawal of case.  The amount is payable to court for their valuable time and not to be taken as costs awarded to the opposite party, that is IIISLA.

Indian courts are not so swift or fast to deliver judgements at such a speed.  But how I wish we are..

Regards,
S Anoop Kumar.

Dileep Wangoo

unread,
Jul 8, 2017, 2:31:31 AM7/8/17
to V B sehgal, ,bipin_patra2005@yahoo.com, ,ersnm1@sify.com, ,rbhuyan03@gmail.com, ,sushil.sarkar15@yahoo.com, Akshaya K. Swain, Akshaya Kumar Misra, Amarendra Dash, Arunaudayaeswar Das, Ashim K. Rath, Ashok Das, ashok...@rediffmail.com, Aswini Ku. Mohanty, b_b_p...@yahoo.co.in, Bani P. Mohanty, Bharat Ku. Dhal, BIBHU DATTA SWAIN, Bibhu P. Das, Bibhudutta Roy, Bijoy Ku. Mohapatra, Byomokesh Pujari, Byomokesh Pujari, Chitta R. Das, Chitta R. Shaw, Chitta Ranjan Mohapatra, crkof...@yahoo.com, dea.o...@gmail.com, Dhirendra Dash, Dinesh Acharaya, Dr. M.K.Nanda, G P Mishra, Govind Hota, Harvinder Pal Singh Mokha, Himansu sekhar Dash, hnag...@hotmail.com, Hrushikesh Mohanty, Jagat Krushna Pattnaik, Jajati Keshari Patnaik, Kawaljit Ahluwalia, Kshirod K. Behera, Manas Mohanty, Manas R. Mohanty, Manas Singh, manaskuma...@gmail.com, manas...@yo.com, Manmohan Mishra, Manoj Das, manoj hota, NARAYAN CHANDRA NAYAK, Narendra Ku. Sahoo, nares...@rediffmail.com, Nihar Dash, pban...@yahoo.com, pks1...@gmail.com, pktrip...@gmail.com, prad...@sancharnet.in, Pramod Sahoo, Prasanna Ku. Tripathy, Raghunath Bal, Rajesh C Malhotra, Rakhal Chandra Behera, Ramesh Ch. Indoria, rrmoha...@rediffmail.com, Satya Mo. Mohapatra, Satyajit R. Das, satyanarayan mohanty, electi...@iiisla.co.in, rakes...@relianceada.com, adit...@live.com, ajaykis...@yahoo.co.in, akjen...@rediffmail.com, AMAR KANT JHA, Amar nath Taneja, Ashok Singh, Ashraff Tim, b...@vsnl.com, Cc: Amarbar Khatua, chai...@irda.gov.in, Chand Bhatia, deepakm...@yahoo.com, DILEEP WANGOO, dro-iii.ad...@nic.co.in, ed...@irda.gov.in, faridaba...@googlegroups.com, ir...@irda.gov.in, Jagdish Parmar-Zonal Chairman IIISLA & IISA Secy., jsin...@nic.in, lalit gupta, M S Sainani, nirmal....@rediffmail.com, paraz...@vsnl.net, patilsu...@yahoo.com, punjabsurveyors, Radhe Shyam Garg, Rajesh Zawar, rajiv budhiraja, rajkumar...@yahoo.com, Rakesh Agarwal, Rakesh Bajaj, Ravi Dhar, S. Anoop Kumar, Saroj kumar Panda, shashi bhushan, Sudhir Kataria, Sunil Dhawan, SUNIL J. VORA & ASSOCIATES, sunil vora, Tanmoy Sarkar, Upinder Sachdeva, usins...@nic.in, vinod indora, anil....@hotmail.com, asant...@gmail.com, binod...@gmail.com, borakh...@gmail.com, dev...@sify.com, gaura...@yahoo.co.in, iiisla...@gmail.com, ijk...@gmail.com, ippr...@gmail.com, kishor...@hotmail.com, kpbalakrish...@gmail.com, kpsbr...@gmail.com, maachin...@gmail.com, manojku...@rediffmail.com, mhsathis...@gmail.com, mithil...@rediffmail.com, naveench...@gmail.com, op_sh...@yahoo.com, pinak...@rediffmail.com, prk...@gmail.com, raven...@gmail.com, raven...@yahoo.co.in, rkgsu...@yahoo.com, rsp...@hotmail.com, sans...@yahoo.com, shajujosephc...@gnail.com, shankarkr...@gmail.com, shivashan...@yahoo.co.in, singhdhan...@gmail.com, skg_su...@sify.com, skn...@gmail.com, smco....@gmail.com, spsingh...@yahoo.com, srinivasa...@gmail.com, tvnsu...@gmail.com, uba...@yahoo.com, vipin_sh...@yahoo.co.in, vivek...@gmail.com, akm...@dataone.in, akpo...@rediffmail.com, arvind....@rediffmail.com, bhargava...@gmail.com, dav...@rediffmail.com, Insurance...@googlegroups.com, k.sent...@gmail.com, Mohinder.Kumar Sharma, mrinal...@sify.com, njdes...@hotmail.com, pra...@satyam.net.in, prashant...@gmail.com, raman...@yahoo.com, razend...@sify.com, rkthen...@gmail.com, saipr...@gmail.com, sanjay_d...@hotmail.com, santosh...@gmail.com, sayyads...@yahoo.co.in, umshin...@yahoo.co.in, www.p...@yahoo.co.in, keep-in-touch-su...@googlegroups.com, ,illiyas_survey@re diffmail.com, ,ranajitpanda99@yahoo.com, Amar Das, AMIYA BEHURIA, asho...@live.com, Balakrushna Patra, Bibhudutta Roy, Bijan Bihari Mohanty, binayak das, Bipin Bihari Patra, Debadatta Mohapatra, Diganta Keshari, Dillip K. Mohanty, er.manoj...@yahoo.co.in, ese...@live.in, facebook, GADADHAR SWAIN, Gaurishankar Dalai, Goutam Das, Himanhu Parida, IIISLA CHENNAI UNIT, IIISLA ODISHA, iiisla...@googlegroups.com, insurance adjuster, JITENDRA PRASAD SINGH, kavish malhotra, manmatha...@gmail.com, Manoj Pattnaik, Manoranjan Lenka, mukunda sahu, Nihar Ranjan Mishra, nira...@esenden.in, Orissa Insurance Surveyors group, Orissa Insurance Surveyors Welfare Scociety, panchanan mishra, Prakash Chandra Nayak, pramod....@yahoo.com, PRASANTA KUMAR Mishra, Pravat Pradhan, Rabindra K. Sahoo, Ramakanta Swain, ray...@rediffmail.com, S ANTOSH DASH, S N NAYAK, Sadipta Ku. Behera, saik...@yahoo.com, Salila Satapahty, Sangram K. Mishra, SANJAY KUMAR NEURA, Sanjeeb Kumar Mohanty, Sanjeeb Mohanty, sant_...@yahoo.co.in, santo...@yahoo.com, Sarat Ch. Senapati, saritd...@yahoo.co.in, Saroj Kumar Sahoo, Saroj Kumar Sahoo JPR, saroj....@rediffmail.com, Satyabrata Choudhury, Satyanarayan Gharai, Satyasiba Pattnaik, satyesh prusty, sbrsan...@yahoo.com, Shiba Padhi, shibap@rediffmail.co m, Shreemanta Tarai, shyama sankar Mishra, Sitansu Sekhar Padhi, sitansu_se...@yahoo.co.in, skgi...@yahoo.in, skmoh naty@indiatime.com, sks...@sify.com, sks...@aol.com, Smruti ranjan Sarangi, sms...@yahoo.com, sn.nayak...@gmail.com, sn.nayak200 8@rediffmail.com, Sourjya Prakash Mohapatra, Srikant Brahma, subash sabat, subas...@gmail.com, Sudam Charan Panda, Sukanta Ku. Das, sunil.m...@yahoo.com, surendr...@rediffmail.com, surveyor_jps, Sushant K. Mohapatra, Sushil Sonthalia, Suvendu K Jena, Suvendu Naik, Swayambhu Mohanty, Tapan ku. Mohanty, Umesh Chandra Patnaik, Yashobant N. Mohanty, Arjun Ram Meghwal, ar.me...@sansad.nic.in, f...@nic.in
DELHI HC ORDER 4.7.2017 ON VB SEHGAL.pdf
Reply all
Reply to author
Forward
0 new messages