Now a second computer stopped working. It was fine yesterday.
I did a full uninstall/reinstall of ID on all machines. I even replaced the GigE hub they're all wired to. Turned off WiFi on the clients, set the preferred network interface as suggested. No active VPNs anywhere.
ID will see the machine listed when scanning for new systems, but the machine never responds and I don't get a popup asking for permission. Manually adding the main machine to control the client doesn't help either.
There's one Win11 machine that connects reliably (so far), but the other two are dead.
This is really disappointing.