SyedMdAsadullah
unread,Feb 4, 2009, 10:52:34 AM2/4/09Sign in to reply to author
Sign in to forward
You do not have permission to delete messages in this group
Either email addresses are anonymous for this group or you need the view member email addresses permission to view the original message
to 3alm...@googlegroups.com, AbuSam...@googlegroups.com, aim...@googlegroups.com, AK...@googlegroups.com, ala...@googlegroups.com, aman-birad...@googlegroups.com, aman-birad...@googlegroups.com, AMC_Pa...@googlegroups.com, anti-corruption...@googlegroups.com, assu...@yahoogroups.com, banglades...@googlegroups.com, chainf...@googlegroups.com, dine...@googlegroups.com, emribi...@googlegroups.com, focuso...@googlegroups.com, friends-of-a...@googlegroups.com, future-of-t...@googlegroups.com, hasans...@googlegroups.com, hotmail...@googlegroups.com, humanright...@googlegroups.com, India-Pakistan-...@googlegroups.com, india-...@googlegroups.com, islamandch...@googlegroups.com, islamand...@googlegroups.com, Islamict...@googlegroups.com, la...@googlegroups.com, mediamu...@googlegroups.com, moh...@googlegroups.com, muslimsw...@googlegroups.com, Myanmar...@googlegroups.com, nps_...@googlegroups.com, ofm...@googlegroups.com, Pakista...@googlegroups.com, Pakistan...@googlegroups.com, paks...@googlegroups.com, paks...@googlegroups.com, PressP...@googlegroups.com, proud-pa...@googlegroups.com, RAJP...@googlegroups.com, repor...@googlegroups.com, sagar_...@hotmail.com, shiast...@googlegroups.com, sri-lankan...@googlegroups.com, sufi-h...@googlegroups.com, swtis...@googlegroups.com, syedmda...@googlegroups.com, theislam...@googlegroups.com, Urdu-Hai-J...@googlegroups.com, you...@googlegroups.com, trueis...@googlegroups.com
Islamic World News
Libya's Gaddafi Chosen to Lead African Union
2. Africa summit debates Gaddafi's unity plan
3. Indian Women cross rise against terror
4. India's 'Taliban' ban Girls from madrasas
5. Turkey's Turn From the West
6. Man gets 30 lashes for smoking on Saudi plane
7. Three women abduct, rape man in Karachi
8. Palestine-Israel: The One State Solution
9. 'Pak may become failed state with nuclear arsenal'
10. To stanch spread of radical Islam, Saudis woo detainees
11. INDONESIA: SHARIA LAWS CREEP IN
12. Two soldiers beheaded in Muslim southern Thailand
13. Islamabad ponders 'Agenda - Islam and West'
14. New Somali president faces a difficult task
15. Demonstrators Baidoa oppose new Somali president
16. Sinners, Saints and Stocks: Guided by Faith
17. KUWAIT BILL ASKS GOVERNMENT TO BUY DEBT
18. Obama showing "respect" for the Muslim world from first day
19. OIC calls for measures against rising vandalism in Crimea
Morehttp://
www.newageislam.com/NewAgeIslamArticleDetail.aspx?ArticleID=1171
Islam and Pluralism
Darul Harb versus Darul Aman: Can Pakistan or Saudi Arabia be considered a Land of peace for Muslims?
Pakistani blogger Mr. Aamir Mughal has raised a very important issue in
a comment posted in relation to the article below: Demolish Kafir/
Mushrik/ Munafiq-manufacturing factories, says Sultan Shahin, defending
New Age Islam against Talibani onslaught
http://newageislam.com/NewAgeIslamArticleDetail.aspx?ArticleID=1143
which needs to be debated threadbare- that of Darul Harb and Darul
Aman. I live in India. Suppose I were to consider it a Darul Hrab -
which of course, I don't - on the basis of the mere fact of it being a
non-Muslim majority country - though it would appear that only
so-called Darul Harbs are Darul Amans, lands of peace, in today's world
- which Darul Aman, a Muslim country, would accept me as a full-fledged
citizen, that India accepts me as? Pakistan will not even give me a
visit visa, perhaps, unless I give it a host of false and forged
documents. Saudi Arabia and all other Arab or Muslim countries, I can
live and work there, if I find a job, for hundreds of years, but I
would never get any citizenship rights. Only countries that I can think
of which can give me full citizenship rights as India does would be
countries of the West, like the UK, USA, Canada, Australia, other
European countries. It won't be easy but it is doable. However,
according to Mr. Aamir Mughal's definition, these are all Darul-Harbs,
so what would be the point of shifting from one Darul Harb to another?
What kind of Islam and what kind of Darul Harbs and Darul Amans are you
talking about Mr. Aamir Mughal? Do you consider Pakistan a Darul Aman
for Muslims, where Muslims are killed routinely during prayers in
mosques, and where even the Muslims for whom this country was created
do not get even visit visas?
Sultan Shahin, editor, New Age Islam
111Comments More..
http://www.newageislam.com/NewAgeIslamArticleDetail.aspx?ArticleID=1161
Ijtihad, Rethinking Islam
Demolish Kafir/ Mushrik/ Munafiq-manufacturing factories, says Sultan Shahin, defending New Age Islam against Talibani onslaught
... As a community we are more reactionary and obscurantist that
positive and progressive. We live in fear and denial. There is noting
wrong with us; it's all Jewish conspiracy, Hindu conspiracy, Western
imperialist conspiracy, etc. etc. We love living in the past, in the
land of pointlessness. So our discussions too are not so much about
issues of today as about the bygone past. We revel in discussing ad
infinitum the dirty politics of seventh century Arabia and taking sides
with one or the other party. We have no present and no plans for the
future. As a community, that is. Some individuals, of course, do have
plans for themselves as well as for the community and a vision of
regeneration for Islam and the Muslim community. But they are reviled
for thinking of this word rather than the other world where 72 houris
are waiting for them impatiently in a land of milk and honey and of
course, plenty of liquor. (In the case of poor women, of course, only
their husbands, if any, would be waiting there, and yet some of them
become suicide bombers, for some reason.)
------ Sultan Shahin, editor, New Age Islam
112 Comments More...
http://www.newageislam.com/NewAgeIslamArticleDetail.aspx?ArticleID=1143
--
Syed Md Asadullah
--
Syed Md Asadullah