What did you think of this week?

[brenda]

top to bottom
1. Lee(I still think he is the best with his Dave Matthews voice)
2. Crystal(It was a great job but it is her personality i don't care
for)
3. Casey( I liked it alot)
4. Siobhan(I didn't like her as much this week but she is a good
singer)
5. Mike (He has kindof gotten old to me for some reason as he tries
to appeal to the ladies too much)
6. Tim (I really don't know why but i think he is not that bad at
all and i like him alot better than Aaron)
7. DiDi (It was better than they said it was but she is not sure of
herself enough)
8. Andrew (The boy takes alot of abuse doesn't he?)
9. Aaron(He is the most overrated one and please don't try to sing a
Steven Tyler song because your voice is not that good) I would rate
him last but that would not be right i guess. HIs Angie version was
horrible.
10. Katie (Play this one back and you will see how out of tune it
was)
11. Paige (It was so bad and i love this song)

Ps....back to Tim. I was just talking to my husband and we both agree
that it is because he doesn't seem to care what the judges say and
comes out every week and tries to do his best. I like Casey and Lee
because they are always on pitch it seems. Katie sings sharp all the
time. As far as the song that Crystal sang,,,I like the guy that wrote
it singing it better than Joplin and that is kris kristofferson.

[Mike]

Good analysis Brenda. I thought Crystal was the best but like you
something about her personality just rubs me the wrong way. I'd rank
Siobhan next even though I really don't like her screeches (same
problem I had with Adam last season), and then probably Casey even
though I could hear Huey Lewis in his voice really well. As for Mike,
he actually surprised me this week and I didn't think I'd like it but
I did. Lee did well all things considered but I didn't think the song
fit his style at all. Katie did well with song choice but yeah she was
sharp throughout a lot of the performance. I really used to like
Andrew but he's been letting me down so much lately that I was
surprised he didn't make the bottom three. Didi was alright,
definitely didn't deserve the criticism Simon gave her, and Aaron was
overrated I would agree with that. I don't think Tim is as bad as
people are making him out to be but among Tuesday's performances I'd
rank him just ahead of Paige. And Paige was a complete disaster. I
think that's everyone haha. All I can say is I hope next week is
better!