Hello... I appreciate the alert... Now that Roundup is linked to cancer it deeply distresses me that this is continuing... We are smarter than this! Please keep me updated... I am helping lead a march against Monsanto on May 23/.. Why is it over 60 countries won't use herbicides and yet we still do? Thanks for sharing... I am envisioning us finding a collective voice that stops this... Thanks...
An update on fruit tree policy would be helpful as well. Thanks!
By the way, I'll have plenty of free tomato starts soon for anyone who wants to connect with me for those. Will also soon have extra eggplant. Likely some leeks, cabbage and kohlrabi as well. Oh, and some basil and milkweed seed!
-sk
David Dude...
I am amazed that an ad in strative policy wouldn't be up for a review after being implicated as a cause of cancer... On school grounds? Meanwhile bees across this country ate dying from herbicides... Very difficult for me to understand...
I appreciate your response... I think its time to reevaluate our priorities...
Good afternoon,
We’re always open to reconsidering past decisions. Please feel free to send me pertinent information and we will review accordingly.
Thanks,
David
David Dude, Ph.D. – Chief Operating Officer/Chief Technology Officer – Iowa City Community School District – Mobile: 319.481-3833 – Office: 319.688.1289 – Fax: 319.688.1009 – Email: Dude....@IowaCitySchools.org – Twitter: @ICCSD_Dude – Educational Services Center: 1725 N. Dodge St., Iowa City, IA 52245-9589
Need help with a technology problem? Contact our Help Desk at Help...@IowaCitySchools.org or call extension HELP (4357).
Questions or concerns? Please feel free to contact me or my supervisor, Stephen Murley, Superintendent, Murley....@IowaCitySchools.org.
Good afternoon,
We’re always open to reconsidering past decisions. Please feel free to send me pertinent information and we will review accordingly.
Thanks,
David
.688.1009 – Email: Dude....@IowaCitySchools.org – Twitter: @ICCSD_Dude – Educational Services Center: 1725 N. Dodge St., Iowa City, IA 52245-9589
Thanks, Meg! We will look this over.
I did a quick search on the topic and was surprised to find several other pieces appearing to discredit this one. I share those links as resources to include in the conversation, with no judgment as to their accuracy.
http://www.sci-phy.com/detecting-bogus-scientific-journals/
http://skeptoid.com/blog/2013/05/04/roundup-and-gut-bacteria/
Thanks,
David
David Dude, Ph.D. – Chief Operating Officer/Chief Technology Officer – Iowa City Community School District – Mobile: 319.481-3833 – Office: 319.688.1289 – Fax: 319.688.1009 – Email: Dude....@IowaCitySchools.org – Twitter: @ICCSD_Dude – Educational Services Center: 1725 N. Dodge St., Iowa City, IA 52245-9589
Need help with a technology problem? Contact our Help Desk at Help...@IowaCitySchools.org or call extension HELP (4357).
Questions or concerns? Please feel free to contact me or my supervisor, Stephen Murley, Superintendent, Murley....@IowaCitySchools.org.
As the school reviews policies for use of pesticides, I would encourage them to remember that at one time in the not so distance past, DDT was considered safe. When I took my Master Gardener training, we were shown a video of parents spraying their children with DDT to keep them ‘safe’. Now we know how harmful and misguided that was. But at that time the experts said that was okay…until we learned more.
I worked for over 30 years for Iowa State University. I can tell you that large agribusiness and chemical companies contribute huge amounts of money to universities and influence what is researched and what is reported. There is a lot of pressure to suppress research and information that would harm the profits of the huge companies that benefit from use of pesticides, synthetic fertilizers and other chemicals. We need to be cautious about what we read.
A respected local physician, Dr. Terry Wahls, has done extensive research on the harm done to human health by pesticides like Roundup and many others. You can check her facebook page for references. She strongly recommends that we eat organic foods and avoid contact with toxins such as Roundup. This includes our lawns. She cites research to back up her statement. Here is one example: http://www.naturalnews.com/040482_glyphosate_monsanto_detoxification.html# I would encourage the school district personnel to contact Dr. Wahls for her input on the topic of pesticide use on school property.
I STRONGLY urge the school to use the precautionary principle!! The precautionary principle states: The precautionary principle or precautionary approach to risk management states that if an action or policy has a suspected risk of causing harm to the public or to the environment, in the absence of scientific consensus that the action or policy is not harmful, the burden of proof that it is not harmful falls on those taking an action.
The principle is used by policy makers to justify discretionary decisions in situations where there is the possibility of harm from making a certain decision (e.g. taking a particular course of action) when extensive scientific knowledge on the matter is lacking. The principle implies that there is a social responsibility to protect the public from exposure to harm, when scientific investigation has found a plausible risk. These protections can be relaxed only if further scientific findings emerge that provide sound evidence that no harm will result.
In some legal systems, as in the law of the European Union, the application of the precautionary principle has been made a statutory requirement in some areas of law.
I believe that the issue of spraying the school ground with pesticides violates the precautionary principle. Our children are being exposed unnecessarily to poisons (that’s what pesticides are). Let’s stop adding to the health risks our children face!!
Good morning,
Thank you all for sharing this information. It’s very helpful. If you have additional resources to share, please don’t hesitate to do so. As I’ve been looking into these things, I found some additional resources I thought I’d share:
http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanonc/article/PIIS1470-2045%2815%2970134-8/fulltext
http://www.epa.gov/oppsrrd1/reregistration/glyphosate/
I really like the concept of the precautionary principle that Mary shared and look forward to giving that more thought. My initial thought in reading it was how to measure “harmful.” For instance, I think there is solid evidence that a 65 mph interstate speed limit causes more deaths than a 55 mph limit, but many states allow it (and higher limits) in some sort of “cost-benefit” reasoning (I presume). (Note that even this, naturally, has contradictory perspectives. See this and this, for example.) For a more local example, if harm is any injury, then allowing students to play on a playground has a suspected risk of causing harm. I’m not aware of scientific consensus that allowing students to play on the playground is not harmful, therefore this principle would require us to discontinue allowing children to play on the playground. I share these examples as food for thought as I process the concepts myself.
Regarding the impact Monsanto has on research, research universities, and government agencies, I’m not clear how our school district is in a position to evaluate that. For instance, when I read pieces that refer to glyphosate as “that sinister chemical,” I’m not inclined to believe that the author is objectively, scientifically evaluating the evidence, but those pieces are being shared as evidence that the US EPA is negligent in their protection of US citizens. I appreciate Blair’s perspective that “we are being duped,” but would appreciate suggestions as to how the school district should evaluate contradictory information between the WHO and the EPA, for instance. Since many of you have strong beliefs regarding glyphosate, I encourage you to reach out to your legislators and get the state to update Iowa code to reflect how glyphosate should or should not be used. You can look them up here: https://www.legis.iowa.gov/legislators.
Looking forward to continued conversation on this topic.
David
David Dude, Ph.D. – Chief Operating Officer/Chief Technology Officer – Iowa City Community School District – Mobile: 319.481-3833 – Office: 319.688.1289 – Fax: 319.688.1009 – Email: Dude....@IowaCitySchools.org – Twitter: @ICCSD_Dude – Educational Services Center: 1725 N. Dodge St., Iowa City, IA 52245-9589
Need help with a technology problem? Contact our Help Desk at Help...@IowaCitySchools.org or call extension HELP (4357).
Questions or concerns? Please feel free to contact me or my supervisor, Stephen Murley, Superintendent, Murley....@IowaCitySchools.org.
Great exchange, all. Very healthy and long overdue as we continue to build bridges. I'd just add that if we acknowledge that playgrounds shouldn't be banned because someone might get hurt, that same logic should apply to plants. Should apple trees be banned because a kid might throw an apple? Of course not. ANYthing is a potential projectile. Should we ban pollinators (most of which all garden plants are, by the way) because a kid might get stung and have an allergic reaction? Of course not. Provide more Epi Pens on site. Should we ban all plants over a few feet tall because a preditor might be hiding behind a tomato cage? Of course not. But these are legit questions to wrestle with. And I'd suggest turning to a myriad of resources in other school districts, many of which I'm in in the corridor, where these concerns have been dealt with (not to mention formally priortized in budgets and common core curricula): http://www.lifelab.org Edible landscapes and outdoor classrooms are the future.
I have yet to see any evidence that apples are dangerous (we might want to change the logo of ICCSD if that's the case :), but plenty of evidence that glyphosate is extremely harmful, even in minute doses. There are plenty of MUCH safer alternatives: http://www.omri.org (Organic Management Research Institute) A fundamental tenet of my teaching is the direct, causal link between Biodiversity and Balance. Glyphosate greatly diminishes microbial diversity essential for nutrient cycling (not to mention its negative impact on water quality). And more vibrant, robust ecosystems with a deliberately biodiverse botany, including a variety of vegetables, fruit, nuts, flowers & herbs, are abSOILutely essential (sorry, couldn't resist) for enhancing beneficial insects (not to mention life skills): http://www.xerces.org
Happy spring. Let's grow soil, grow food and grow lifelong learners!
-sk
p.s. Great suggestion to contact your public officials at the statehouse, by the way. But let's also start right here with our local folks -- school board, city council ... There are many of us who will continue to lobby for this stuff, again, to be prioritized in policy and budget cycles.
Good afternoon,
I’m definitely going to try to find a way to use “abSOILutely” in conversation in the future. Better trademark that, Scott! ;-) Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this. Again, very helpful.
In case you or others aren’t aware, Iowa schools have been prevented from “stocking” epinephrine auto-injectors (such as EpiPens). There is a bill in the legislature (HF200, SF462) to address this. It appears it unanimously passed the house yesterday and the senate today.
http://thegazette.com/subject/news/bill-would-allow-more-epipen-use-in-schools-20150329
https://www.legis.iowa.gov/publications/search/document?fq=id:645706
https://www.legis.iowa.gov/publications/search/document?fq=id:632926
David
David Dude, Ph.D. – Chief Operating Officer/Chief Technology Officer – Iowa City Community School District – Mobile: 319.481-3833 – Office: 319.688.1289 – Fax: 319.688.1009 – Email: Dude....@IowaCitySchools.org – Twitter: @ICCSD_Dude – Educational Services Center: 1725 N. Dodge St., Iowa City, IA 52245-9589
Need help with a technology problem? Contact our Help Desk at Help...@IowaCitySchools.org or call extension HELP (4357).
Questions or concerns? Please feel free to contact me or my supervisor, Stephen Murley, Superintendent, Murley....@IowaCitySchools.org.
Good afternoon,
Thanks for your patience while we pulled together the information to answer Jenni’s questions about fertilizer use, particularly at Shimek. We’re working to develop a system where details for each location can be shared on the website so anyone who wants to review can, but that’s going to take some time.
Primary fertilizer for Shimek: 35-0-10 180 day slow release
• Summer of 2013--no applications
• Summer of 2014--one low application at .5 lbs/1,000 sf was applied
· Application was timed with seeding
· Recommended labeled rates are 5.7 lbs-8.6 lbs/1,000 sf
• Summer of 2015--A low application is planned for a renovation project on the soccer field
• To date only the 35-0-10 has been used at Shimek
Other products used district wide:
• 35-0-10 180 day slow release
• 14-14-14 slow release
• 34-0-9 95% 90 day slow release
• 21-0-21 75% RXN
• 18-12-12 starter mix
• 18-0-7 50% RXN
• 13-13-13
• We’re also looking into a mix that includes micronutrients, but have not yet identified a supplier
David
David Dude, Ph.D. – Chief Operating Officer/Chief Technology Officer – Iowa City Community School District – Mobile: 319.481-3833 – Office: 319.688.1289 – Fax: 319.688.1009 – Email: Dude....@IowaCitySchools.org – Twitter: @ICCSD_Dude – Educational Services Center: 1725 N. Dodge St., Iowa City, IA 52245-9589
Need help with a technology problem? Contact our Help Desk at Help...@IowaCitySchools.org or call extension HELP (4357).
Questions or concerns? Please feel free to contact me or my supervisor, Stephen Murley, Superintendent, Murley....@IowaCitySchools.org.